5 ms·
GetSatisfaction's open letter to Jason Fried
- run4yourlives 18y agoSo, where is GS's CEO in all of this? Isn't she the "leader"? Why is the CTO/Founder doing the PR campaign? This whole thing leads me to believe that GS operates a little on the shady side. Everything from the poorly worded "box" to the competitor's ads to the clipped logos and trademarks seems designed to stick it to the companies in question in a manner that is borderline extortion. It seems that instead of seeing companies as clients and selling them a service they can use, they're operating a giant defamation board where anything goes, and perpetrating the "us against them" mentality that seems popular these days with consumers. Bad karma begets bad karma, and the whole business case of GS seems to be designed to generate bad karma. Once GS gets big enough to rankle a company with big enough legal pockets, it's going to go the way of the dodo.
- swombat 18y agoAlso worth reading is the article from Garrett Dimon at the end: http://garrettdimon.com/archives/2009/3/31/handling_things/ http://garrettdimon.com/archives/2009/3/31/handling_things/ Makes some good points about what would have been a better way to handle this, including this particularly important truism: Never attribute to malice that which can be explained by ignorance.
- fh 18y ago"Never attribute to malice that which can be explained by ignorance." What if something can't be adequately explained by ignorance?
- rimantas 18y agoI think it takes a malicious amount of ignorance to come up with the text they did. And this is hardly an open letter, reads more like PR spin.
- earl 18y agoPlease. Grabbing someone's logo and making them pay you not to write "[company] has not committed to open conversation about its products and services. Encourage them to join and support the Company-Customer pact" on a very official looking page with your logo on it? I'm sorry, but them's fighting words. At a cursory glance, it isn't entirely obvious that Get Satisfaction is unofficial. Further, particularly for new companies, Get Satisfaction might end up with better PR than the official support forums! While there is value for the consumer in having off site forums that a company can't control, compare this to reseller ratings. On the latter, there is no chance you'll think you're on an official company page. Get Satisfaction seems to me to go to lengths to give that impression.
- spif 18y agoYou don't have to pay. You _do_ need to have at least one 'official' employee participate.
- run4yourlives 18y agoUsually, everything an employee does links directly back to the company's books, by definition.
- tptacek 18y agoHaving an employee tasked with monitoring that site is probably a bigger deal than paying, especially for 37s, which runs a really lean, carefully-designed team.
- tokenadult 18y agoYes, as the two astute replies beforehand have pointed out, you have to have someone on your payroll provide content for someone else's site. Nice work if that other site can get it.
- palish 18y agoGlance more carefully. It is now entirely obvious that Get Satisfaction is unofficial. Check out their page for 37signals: http://getsatisfaction.com/37signals http://getsatisfaction.com/37signals - The title is "Unofficial customer service & support for 37signals on Get Satisfaction". - The wording has been changed from "37signals has not commited to open conversation..." to "No one from 37signals has sponsored, endorsed or joined the conversation on Get Satisfaction yet. Employees may sign up here." - The top of the page has large text that reads "Unofficial Customer Support Community for 37signals" So Get Satisfaction deserves some credit for changing its ways.
- dualogy 18y agoI usually stick to that in day affairs. But for people who are essentially in the business of thinking my intuition and judgment is usually that ignorance is almost as bad as malice. Another way of seeing it is that if you make ignorance "totally OK now", you just make it way too easy for actual malice to get away with more. Grown-up people, and certainly companies, should be held responsible for their actions regardless of their motive or lack of it, so that they act responsibly towards themselves and others.
- tokenadult 18y agoBut for people who are essentially in the business of thinking my intuition and judgment is usually that ignorance is almost as bad as malice. In many legal settings, saying "Oops, I was ignorant," or (today) "April Fools" wouldn't be a defense against various forms of liability. The leaders of a business corporation have to make sure that their employees (their agents, by common law) aren't doing illegal acts.
- sethg 18y agoWhile I agree with the principle "never attribute to malice that which can be explained by ignorance", I think a discussion of how a certain action caused damage, and how to remedy that damage, can be easily sidetracked by a discussion of whether the action was malicious or ignorant.
- Semiapies 18y agoThe "but these are good, smart people!" business verges on outright fanboyism. When people complain about someone publicly criticizing a venue for public criticism, I have to wonder about their thought processes.
- wheels 18y agoIt was a good enough read that I submitted it here too: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=541831 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=541831 Paul also writes in his startup FAQ: "The one book we encourage startup founders to read is Dale Carnegie's How to Win Friends and Influence People. It's critically important for anyone in business." If you read that (or listen to it as an audio book, as I did) you get that one of the central points is: don't put people on the defensive. Guy Kawasaki in Art of the Start has a paragraph labeled "Wait When You Hate": "Although you should always answer e-mail in under twenty-four hours, there is one case where you should wait at least twenty-four hours before responding: when you're angry, offended or argumentative. E-mail written when you're in these moods tends to exacerbate problems, so delay your response." The reason this advice keeps recurring is because it's good advice.
- Semiapies 18y agoI'm puzzled by the suggestion that this was an angry screed Fried tossed off in a rage and immediately posted.
- mechanical_fish 18y agoWhat does malice have to do with it? Here's part of Jason Fried's description of the problem: Can you believe that language? “37signals has not yet committed to open conversations about its products or services.” WHAT?! We haven’t committed to open conversations about our products or services because we haven’t signed Get Satisfaction’s pact on Get Satisfaction’s site which generates Get Satisfaction’s income? That’s awfully close to blackmail (or a shakedown or a mafioso protection scheme). It doesn't matter whether Get Satisfaction wrote the false and insulting phrase about "open conversations" by accident or on purpose. It was insulting, and false, and if Jason's response came off as a bit angry nobody should be the least bit surprised. They asked for it; they got it. It also doesn't matter whether Get Satisfaction was committing a shakedown through "ignorance" or out of "malice". A shakedown is a shakedown. Get Satisfaction created a problem [1], and then asked for something of value to make the problem go away [2]. That's a shakedown. I'm perfectly willing to believe that Get Satisfaction didn't mean to wake up one day and discover themselves in a dubiously ethical line of work. [3] But they did. To their credit, they seem to be reacting with appropriate public displays of horror and remorse. --- [1] The problem: A site that fooled me, and apparently more than a handful of other people, into thinking it was an official 37signals support site. One that was full of questions, but no answers. [2] The value: A public endorsement from 37signals, in the form of a publicly visible signature on a "Company-Customer pact". Endorsements are valuable. (The pact itself seems to be a bunch of legally meaningless pledges, but then again I'm not a lawyer; if it contains any legally actionable language, then the mere act of signing it is a cost.) Also: A public notice, on the Get Satisfaction page, that 37signals employees visit that page -- a notice which, once it is up, will tend to obligate 37signals to devote valuable employee time to answering questions on a third-party support system that's incompatible with their standard support system. The cost of having to do tech support on two -- or three, or four, or seventeen -- different public sites is nontrivial. (Copying and pasting support tickets from site to site is inefficient. Hacking up RSS feeds to integrate trouble reports from n different sites is inefficient. Answering the FAQs 2n times per week, rather than just n times per week, is inefficient.) More importantly, splitting your support effort across multiple venues dilutes your brand, dilutes your customer base, and confuses your customers ("where should I report this problem, again"?), and that's even more costly. [3] I've had the experience of suddenly realizing that I'm working on an unethical project. It's not uncommon -- just ask the people who've been working on Wall Street. It's amazing how such things can sneak up on you.
- quellhorst 18y agoThey still use the 37Signals logo and fail to link to the official 37Signals support channels.
- swombat 18y agoApparently, using someone's public logo to refer to them is fair use. Anyway, that's not the point.
- fizx 18y agoIANAL: Depends on whether it causes marketplace confusion.
- quellhorst 18y agoReally? The way they were using the logo on their page made it look like it was an official 37s service. That isn't fair use.
- astrec 18y agoNot fair use at all: In many jurisdictions it's called passing off.
- tokenadult 18y agofair use The concept of "fair use" applies to copyright law, but it doesn't apply to trademark law at all. And if GetSatisfaction doesn't have anyone on staff who knows the difference between copyright law and trademark law, while they are copying business corporation trademarks to display on their site, they are acting in a seriously unprofessional and legally dangerous manner. The lesson for employees of GetSatisfaction would be to not accept stock options as compensation, and to start sending around resumes to a company that is more legally prudent in its business model.
- tptacek 18y agoYou use the word "apparently" when you really mean "potentially". You can use a non-free image... * ... for purposes of education, criticism, or comment ... * ... noncommercially ... * ... and only by ensuring you don't dilute the mark by causing confusion about whether the owner approved it. It is not at all clear that 37s couldn't lawyer up on GetSatisfaction, even after yesterday's cleanup. Of course, 37s probably won't do that.
- fizx 18y agoI would bet that this is yet another example of a startup pushing things to the edge. For example, Youtube/Scribd/etc. have hosted copyrighted material in their early days. This clearly benefits them while they make baby steps towards compliance. Startups will do what they can get away with, not that I know anything about this.
- olefoo 18y agoI'm willing to bet that most of the people on the GS side didn't realize that someone could see their actions in as sinister a light as Jason Fried obviously did. It's interesting the extent to which emotions and self-control are the deciding factors here; it's clearly important to be seen to feel, but also to be in control of your emotions.
- KWD 18y agoI'd actually suspect it was part of the business model. They're banking on companies paying for reputation management. After the recent Yelp discussion (and some other older examples of a similar issue), I was not surprised at all about Jason's post.
- randy 18y ago> I only wish that you hadn’t implied inethical motives with words like “extortion,” “mafia shakedown,” etc. The fact is, many people hear those words and nothing else, and it compromises years of work by our small but committed team. Well, at least now they know how Jason (and potentially thousands of other committed teams) felt.
- trapper 18y agoIt's quite ironic given their business name how unsatisfied many people are with them. I certainly felt this way, but thought there was nothing I could do about it. Thanks Jason I say.
- davidw 18y ago> thought there was nothing I could do about it. Did you contact them?
- trapper 18y agoNo. I don't contact the bakery if it's bread is mouldy either.
- davidw 18y agoTheir service might affect your site even if you're not interested in it in the slightest (you sort of give the impression that you'd become frustrated with them prior to Jason's letter), whereas it's very easy to change bakeries with no second thoughts or problems, so the two are not equivalent.
- trapper 18y agoThey aren't equivalent, but are similar. I was offended by their business model (pay to get your competitors ads off your support page - wtf) and would never use them for that very reason. I must admit it's a pretty impressive model regardless. It's like something Mr Burns would come up with :)
- evil 18y agoThor Muller wrote: You were angry, and honestly I don’t blame you. We all know what it’s like to feel manipulated. And while I would have preferred you sending us a note, or even posting it somewhere less trafficked than your popular blog, the fact is that Get Satisfaction is a huge proponent of public airing of grievances. You were right to bring it to our attention any way you saw fit. I only wish that you hadn’t implied inethical motives with words like “extortion,” “mafia shakedown,” etc. The fact is, many people hear those words and nothing else, and it compromises years of work by our small but committed team. "Inethical"? That's not even a word!
- erlanger 18y agoPlease stop doing that. Paul will never fix this bug, which gives any commenter the ability to force everyone to scroll horizontally. Edit: I see that this style is in place, which should work: pre { overflow: hidden; } but Mr. Graham's insistence on table-based layout thwarts this attempt to control user content (table cells stretch to accommodate their content).
- michael_nielsen 18y agoUser "evil" created two hours ago, and all three comments so far do this. A troll, someone unable to get better kicks.
- ptm 18y agoI couldn't find a Greasemonkey script which fixes this, so I just wrote one. http://userscripts.org/scripts/show/45619 http://userscripts.org/scripts/show/45619
- steamboiler 18y agoIs it just me or has this bug been addressed after the parent comment was posted? The page (as I see it) does not require horizontal scrolling any longer.
- erlanger 18y ago
- Raphael_Amiard 18y agoI think i'll buy into the fact that they're dedicated and willing to fix this when they will have links to the official support page, and changed again this banner to something like : "37signals decided to handle their web-support by themselves. You can reach them at <url>". Their site is build upon a conception about "big evil companies", thor said that himself in the so called open letter. So it makes every company on their site that hasn't suscribed to their thing an evil one by definition. Now don't get me wrong, this can be very good, when it is true. And very bad and harmfull when it isn't This is not a technical issue. This is a structural flaw into the conceptual design of their website, so maybe they meant no harm, but that's not the point at all. If they can't fix it, it would probably be better for everyone if they went down. On a brighter note, it's probably not that hard to fix. But it needs to be taken very seriously. Also i don't buy the garrett dimon line, even if i understand his motivations. Those companies also leave in a world where they have very real possibilities of harming each others. So in the end, the fact that they're "really good people" is totally emotional and strictly not related to the issue in place here. And the fact that they're willing to fix, while a good thing, is also tied in my opinion with the fact they did a mistake that could have hurt anybody in the community. So this is not 'nice' of them, it's just well, the regular attitude to have !
- tokenadult 18y agoTheir site is build upon a conception about "big evil companies", thor said that himself in the so called open letter. They may find out that big, well advised companies that stay within the law can crush little start-up companies without good legal advice like bugs.
- swombat 18y agoThis is not a technical issue. This is a structural flaw into the conceptual design of their website, so maybe they meant no harm, but that's not the point at all. Of course that is the point! Intention is important, not just actions. It makes a world of difference. Every business is "flawed" in some sort of way - if only because they all aim to trounce their competition and make money. But there's a whole lot of difference between a business that willfully takes unethical steps that they know are morally wrong, and one that merely makes a mistake. Until I see proof that the GetSatisfaction team is actually a collection of thugs, I will believe the various reports that indicate they're just like the rest of us - nice, smart guys trying to solve a real problem as well as they can.
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- fallentimes 18y agoNot once in that entire letter do they say the word "sorry". You'd think a company so experienced with corporate indifference would have the courage to admit they made a mistake, say I'm sorry, state their next actions to fix the problem and move forward. I know these situations are tough, but Thor spends way too much in the letter promoting and PRing instead of apologizing and fixing.
- Semiapies 18y agoFor all the complaints about how Jason Fried should have given them a holler and jawed it out person-to-person, none of GS's defenders note that they aren't doing what one person would do upon accidentally wronging another: apologize. Of course, there's a very good reason for that: saying "Sorry" can be cited as a possible admission of guilt. Really, it looks like GS is trying to establish a public record that they acted quickly to resolve these problems without admitting wrongdoing at any point. That isn't behavior that's very consistent with "smart, but naive guys at a startup". If they didn't run out and get a lawyer and have him/her start looking over their copy and responses to the blog post, then they're more sophisticated than their defenders give them credit for.
- webwright 18y agoExcept here: "Thanks for the feedback, and I’m sorry for the hassle." http://www.37signals.com/svn/posts/1650-get-satisfaction-or-else#comment_41863 http://www.37signals.com/svn/posts/1650-get-satisfaction-or-... Do you have to use the word "sorry" to express regret/"mea culpa"? All of that stuff felt pretty apologetic to me (comments, blog posts, etc).
- Semiapies 18y agoYou're right. Muller's comment there is head and shoulders above later remarks by GS (and much of the arguments made on their behalf). As to your question, yes, you do have to say "sorry" or "I apologize". You also have to avoid criticizing those you've wronged while doing so and in subsequent statements on the matter.
- tptacek 18y agoPeople keep saying these guys are awesome at PR and are doing a pitch-perfect job of handling this crisis. But the second graf of this letter just shovels more coal onto the fire. If you made mistakes, apologize and move on. Don't ask the people you offended to apologize.
- Semiapies 18y agoI'm actually pleasantly surprised at the amount of skepticism people are showing towards the defenses of GS around the web.
- webwright 18y agoHave you MET the internet? You're surprised that people are quick to attack, slow to defend, and assume the worst about every other human being alive?
- Semiapies 18y agoI'm surprised that in tech circles, the conversation hasn't been dominated by GS fans or knee-jerk support of a "pro-consumer" site. EDIT: or for that matter, hatred of 37Signals.
- tptacek 18y agoNot sure it's 37s's fault that the behavior observed here is really easy to characterize.
- WebTom 18y agoIn Get Satisfaction You have to pay a ridiculous amount of money to remove your competitors from a support page you didn't even create on the first place? HOW IS THAT NOT BLACK MAIL?
- yan 18y agoI wonder why they're using Hype Machine's logo on their front page..
- trapper 18y agoI think it's time for an open source getsatisfaction.