4 ms·
Leading Neuroscientist Says Kurzweil Singularity Prediction A “Bunch Of Hot Air”
- joe_the_user 14y agoSome of this actually fits perfectly into the framework of Kurzweil's The Singularity in the sense that you could argue that most neuroscientists are too focused to the complexity of the brain and aren't anticipating the progress that may be possible through rapid evolution of tools for looking at the brain. The said, I think Kurzweil's plan for constructing an intelligence actually oversteps his basic approach. Tools are advancing on multiple fronts. Not only does that give us multiple ways a singularity could happen (from brain-simulation to simplistic-but-massive-ai to clever-ai to bio-computers) but the multiple advancing fronts could go around apart walls (a sufficiently sophisticate computer could make brain processes look less opaque etc). Personally, I'd say Paul Allen's counter-argument, which I recall as boiling down to the inherent limits of human-produced software, is the most plausible counter-argument.
- zmmmmm 14y ago> Personally, I'd say Paul Allen's counter-argument, which I recall as boiling down to the inherent limits of human-produced software, is the most plausible counter-argument I often wonder if the ultimate end counter argument may be that the same things that make us "intelligent" are also those that give us our human flaws - exactly the same things that we were trying to avoid in the first place by using computers. Perhaps we can't have human-like intelligence without also being forgetful, inaccurate, selfish, lazy, irrational, greedy, angry, sad etc. If someone did invent a computer with all those attributes, would it be useful?
- Filligree 14y agoMost of those attributes turn out to have perfectly good explanations in evolutionary psychology. That being the case, there's no reason to expect a mind that isn't produced by the same process to possess them.
- zmmmmm 14y ago> there's no reason to expect a mind that isn't produced by the same process to possess them True ... but then will those minds be able to perform the feats of intelligence that we hope for from the "singularity"? Will a mind unable put aside the fact that valves can make a t.v. set run, unable to dream, imagine, love, and lacking the motivation of greed and competition with its peers etc. - will that mind be able to discover the transistor as an alternative? Perhaps our evolutionary psychology is part of the reason we exhibit what intelligence we have, not just an unnecessary relic of our past?
- Filligree 14y ago> Perhaps our evolutionary psychology is part of the reason we exhibit what intelligence we have, not just an unnecessary relic of our past? Dare we take the risk that it isn't?
- pixl97 14y agoINSUFFICIENT DATA FOR MEANINGFUL ANSWER http://filer.case.edu/dts8/thelastq.htm http://filer.case.edu/dts8/thelastq.htm http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Last_Question http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Last_Question
- jasonkostempski 14y agoI keep asking Siri "Can entropy be reversed?" hoping she'll respond with that. And Google hoping it'll show just that answer, no links. Wolfram get's it.
- eli_gottlieb 14y agoOh good, a few more years until I'm coerced into uploading my brain into bizarre-o-land by someone's deliberately-create-the-singularity-project gone horribly right.
- nawitus 14y ago>“Fallacy is what people are selling: that human nature can be reduced to [something] that [a] computer algorithm can run! This is a new church!” Actually, the "new church" is that human nature is something more than physics. Even if Kurzweil is wrong in his predictions, certainly this neuroscientist is also wrong with his metaphysical beliefs that the brain is something more than a mere "machine".
- geuis 14y agoThank you for summing that up so concisely. I'm going to try to remember the "so you think human nature is something more than physics?" argument for the future.
- jessedhillon 14y agoThere's nothing new about that belief.
- ericb 14y agoTrue, but calling materialist views a "church" while holding a mystical viewpoint oneself is a clever bit of doublespeak.
- AndrewNCarr 14y agoThat has always been my response to John Searle's Chinese Room [1] thought experiment. The argument boils down to the human consciousness either being magic or not. Magic being something beyond physics. 1: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chinese_room http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chinese_room
- jamestc 14y agoHe doesn't suggest that human nature is more than physics, he is saying that consciousness isn't computable. If neural subsystems are a hierarchically arranged and internally generated chaotic dynamic activity, there is the problem of long-term predictions and causal inference. >It may seem paradoxical that a deterministic phenomenon is inherently unpredictable, but in systems that exhibit chaotic behavior, small uncertainties are amplified over time by the nonlinear interaction of a few elements. The upshot is that behavior that is predictable in the short run becomes intrinsically unpredictable in the long term. As a result, physiologists cannot make strict causal inferences from the level of individual neurons to that of neural mass actions, nor from the level of receptor activity to internal dynamics. The causal connection between past and future is cut. http://sulcus.berkeley.edu/freemanwww/manuscripts/IC13/90.html http://sulcus.berkeley.edu/freemanwww/manuscripts/IC13/90.ht...
- blackhole 14y agoThe part of the article that bothers me here the most is a leading nueroscientist asserting that the brain is not computable. That is demonstrably false: The brain is a quantum system, just like everything else in the universe. All quantum systems containing n qubits can be simulated by 2^n classical bits. It may very well be impractical to compute a decent sized brain, but that's still technically computable, which is a serious problem in his whole "you can't reduce human nature to a computer algorithm" tirade. Yes, you can. It will be impossibly huge and slow, but you can.
- diminoten 14y agoWhat you're saying is merely postulation, it's not "demonstrably" true, not to mention your use of the term "impractical" is probably the most misleading use of that word I've read today. You're writing off thousands of years of philosophy and dozens of years of experimental results in maybe a paragraph, if I'm being generous.
- pwny 14y agoIt actually IS demonstrably true that the brain is made of atoms. That makes it a quantum system, which our modern physics tells us how to simulate. The use of the term "impractical" here refers to the fact that we don't have quantum computers and that we don't have the computing power required to simulate such a large quantum system. I'd say dismissing thousands of years of philosophy here is relevant, since it was likely produced before we had the tools to understand what we're dealing with. All experimental physics points towards an understanding of how quantum systems work, and that's all we need to model any quantum system. The brain is not any different because it's a brain.
- dododo 14y agoquantum theory is a hypothesis. perhaps it's the best one so far for what the brain is made from. but it's truth is only as demonstrable as this: it's not yet been falsified.
- 14y ago
- JohnsonB 14y ago>Addressing fellow scientists, he dismissed the singularity as “a bunch of hot air,” and went on further to declare that “the brain is not computable and no engineering can reproduce it.” wat.
- Tichy 14y agoThere are also people who believe in god and all other sorts of things. Doesn't mean they should be taken seriously.
- OGinparadise 14y agoGod means different things to different people, from one that watches everything you do, to one that maybe is a force out there, like gravity.
- vor_ 14y agoA physical force like gravity? Why refer to it as a god then?
- OGinparadise 14y agoHere's another belief http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pantheism http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pantheism Why call it God? Because it means different thing to different people and no on owns the word. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/God#Other_concepts http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/God#Other_concepts
- kmfrk 14y agoAnother good rebuke of Kurzweil's theory of the mind: http://www.nybooks.com/articles/archives/2013/mar/21/homunculism/?pagination=false http://www.nybooks.com/articles/archives/2013/mar/21/homuncu....
- cwzwarich 14y agoThe human mind is one of the few things that we encounter during everyday life that we may not even have the right conceptual framework to understand. It is an open question whether the physical processes of the brain can be simulated by a computer, and it is even an open question whether the physical processes of the brain account for the full range of human conscious experience. I look forward to seeing this field evolve during my lifetime, but significant progress may continue to elude us.
- snambi 14y agoit may be more accurate to say "parts of the brain of an average human may be computable". Ofcourse I have no data to prove either way. There are incredible human beings who lived in the past and living in the present, who brain is faster than the fastest computers put together. But simulating super humans like ramanujan, is it even possible?
- pwny 14y agoRamanujan isn't different than you or I in that regard. His brain was an assembly of neurons, connected via synapses. There's nothing pointing towards the fact that this assembly is any different from any machine, regardless of achievements in the field of mathematics. Because we fail to understand it fully yet doesn't mean it transcends physics, that would be absurd.
- DanielBMarkham 14y agoWhen Newton came up with his universal law of gravitation, he also made an interesting observation. He had no idea why gravity worked the way it did, he could only model its behavior numerically. It's been over 300 years and we're still trying to figure out exactly how gravity works. But in a way it doesn't matter: his law has given humanity tremendous abilities it didn't have before. When Deep Blue won the Jeopardy contest a couple of years ago, it was obvious that it wasn't intelligence in the sense that we commonly understood it. Yet it was able to beat the human champions. Deep Blue wasn't a model of a human player, but it didn't matter because for the purposes of its construction it performed just as well as one. My money says the singularity happens the exact same way -- we are able to "fake" more and more things that look exactly like intelligence until one day we're able to fake intelligence to a degree that it's virtually indistinguishable from our own. We're eventually able to do something that looks like moving our sentience into a computer even though it "won't really" be doing it. My guess is that we're hundreds of years away from that date, but whether it happens or not, the fact that an expert right now in the complexity of the underlying physical system has an opinion on the computational problem that probably won't be solved until after 2100 doesn't seem to me to be very relevant. Of course it's complicated. Of course we don't understand it. And of course we can't duplicate the structure of things we don't understand. I believe for any layman in the field all of that goes without saying?
- robryan 14y agoIt is possible that the easiest way to simulate the brain in a way indistinguishable from an actual brain isn't to have something work in the same way. There is nothing to say that evolution has arrived at the perfect method.
- uncompetence 14y agoSmall nit: Watson, not Deep Blue.
- Retric 14y agoThe "singularity" is never going to happen because it assumes intelegence is a single thing that can be increased with more processing power and better algorithms. Completely ignoring things like information theory, over fitting, insanity, training data, and chaos theory. We can and probably will build reasonably general AI, but you far more likely to see each generation of AI being an ever smaller improvement than any sort of runaway exponential progression. Not to mention hardware progress has slowed to a relative standstill.
- Lerc 14y ago> “the brain is not computable and no engineering can reproduce it.” If you assume this is true then the brain is a physical entity which cannot be constructed by mechanisms that manipulate physical objects. The question arises "why is a body growing a brain not a feat of engineering? What did the body do that similarly sophisticated machines cannot?"
- s_baby 14y agoI believe the argument is consciousness is not a causal product of relations represented in the brains structures but a property of the substrate. Consider that a brain model on a turing machine is equivalent to a sticks and stones model running the same program. Do you believe some person moving a bunch of sticks and stones around can produce conscious experience?
- bermanoid 14y agoIf the first paragraph is correct and the crux of his argument is that the brain is not computable, then there's nothing to see here. Once you assume that, then of course you don't think it can be simulated. That this further devolves into meandering about consciousness just says to me that even at the point where Kurzweil's singularity has already happened, he wouldn't call it AI. Yes - if you take it as an axiom that humans have special sauce that you can't reproduce with an algorithm, AI is impossible.
- alexvr 14y agoWe're just waiting for a really smart simulation programmer with access to a super-powerful computer to create a simulation of a small, earth-like world so we can watch as accelerated evolution creates some human-like (or not) being with a similar brain. I think we can write an algorithm for an AI that can pass the Turing test, but I think serious AI that will precipitate the singularity will come as a result of evolutionary algorithms and very powerful computers.
- Filligree 14y agoThat would take a seriously powerful computer. I remember reading a short story along those lines.. it ended with the simulated beings hacking physics and dropping off into a pocket universe, without helping at all. Well, I guess they didn't kill us all. Might have been written by Greg Egan. Sounds familiar?
- jokermatt999 14y agoYup, Crystal Nights by Greg Egan http://ttapress.com/553/crystal-nights-by-greg-egan/ http://ttapress.com/553/crystal-nights-by-greg-egan/
- Filligree 14y agoRight, that. Border Guards probably counts as a sequel. I hope we'll get a novel-sized story set in that universe, eventually.
- dreamfactory 14y agoIs this any different from http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Emperors_New_Mind http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Emperors_New_Mind?