4 ms·
LOOK MA, NO GOVERNMENT! With SOPA destroyed by the combined efforts of giant internet companies and internet users calling their congressmen, Hollywood was abl
by EGreg 14y ago
LOOK MA, NO GOVERNMENT!
With SOPA destroyed by the combined efforts of giant internet companies and internet users calling their congressmen, Hollywood was able to engage another group: ISPs.
Note: this is done completely without government. It is one of the best illustrations to date of what I was saying, about nannies curtailing liberties being possible even if government doesn't do them.
To all libertarians that single out the government for special thrashing, I have a question: doesn't this show that wherever power concentrates, you will find stuff like this. Government is just an example. We always knew they didn't need the government, just all the major ISPs.
- nitrogen 14y agoThis absolutely was not done with no government, but was created as part of a partnership put together with the direction of the White House. Also, there's no reason for a libertarian not to oppose concentration of power in anybody's hands, whether it's government or corporations. Let's let this thread focus on the issue at hand instead of derailing it into another fight between different quadrants of the political plane.
- pbhjpbhj 14y ago>a partnership put together with the direction of the White House // I'm wondering when the people of the USA voted for this in their great democracy? OT: As an outsider USA politics appears more and more about satisfying corporate desires and very little about government by the people and for the people.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- ams6110 14y agoAlmost all residential ISPs operate under government-granted monopolies, though. If this were not the case it's a lot less likely that "Hollywood" could get thousands of smaller competing ISPs on board.
- adventured 14y agoNo government? The telcos are government controlled, sponsored, and protected corporations. The entire industry is practically one giant government sponsored monopoly system. We live in an era in which the US Government has the power to directly control every single aspect of the economy. Either directly or indirectly via threats. There are laws on the books to dictate everything and anything, using one agency or another. This is nothing but government in action. Classic state sponsored corporatism, aka fascism lite. We have a Hollywood sponsored President for crying out loud. They own him, every bit as much as people liked to claim big oil owned George W. And we have a VP that likes to break international law to fulfill Hollywood's demanding lobbyists.
- aba_sababa 14y ago> We have a Hollywood sponsored President wat
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- zanny 14y agoOne of the primary reasons this can even happen is because all the internet infrastructure in the US is already government granted monopoly on the local level. It isn't free market at all, which is why ISP's can collude like this and get away with it. Nobody has an option. Though I am usually libertarian, I don't know a good way to see the mass deployment of essential 21st technologies like fiber / high speed rail / automated transport without the traditional forced violence method employed by government. You won't get those gifted through inheritance and chance with obscene wealth offering to build the next generation of infrastructure.