13 ms·
There are only three meaningful things you can do with a computer with specs like this: development, design, or gaming. And yet ChromeOS can't do any of these t
by javajosh 14y ago
There are only three meaningful things you can do with a computer with specs like this: development, design, or gaming. And yet ChromeOS can't do any of these things.
Perhaps this is a vanity product for the wealthy. But wealthy people are going to just surf the web on an iPad.
I really don't get this product.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- commandar 14y ago>And yet ChromeOS can't do any of these things. Am I just imagining all the posts I've seen on HN from people talking about being extremely happy using Chromebooks as development platforms?
- theoretick 14y agoI'll assume that's sarcasm but I haven't personally noticed that trend. The only way I made my cr-48 useful was by flashing the BIOS, adding a bigger SD, and running ubuntu on it.
- taeric 14y agoAren't most of those folks replacing the os on their machines?
- criley 14y agoHow do you develop on this? I'm used to using Linux, command line, text editors, local installs of the product I'm developing for, virtual machines, etc... Are you simply forced into using ALL websites to actually develop and unable to use anything else? Seems strange to pay $1250+ to develop on a machine that cannot even run or test the code you write.
- raingrove 14y agoAction.IO... Cloud9... Koding...
- untothebreach 14y agoNone of which use the $1250+ machine to actually "run or test the code you write." If you are just using a browser for coding, why pay that much money for a machine to run a browser?
- aalbertson 14y agoOne could argue that if a browser is your only environment, that you'll be spending the most time in, then why wouldn't you want the best option for running said browser? The way I see it, if you're going to be working in a completely remote/cloud capable environment, then a powerful, fast, beautiful screened machine to work from makes the most sense. My current job gave me a Dell Latitude E series machine for work. I work exclusively in AWS. The screen on this laptop is so horrifically bad that I practically get sick looking at it. Compared to my personal (2010 era) macbook pro, or the Retina MBP's I've used at my last two jobs, there is no comparison. I'd much rather have a lightweight powerful little machine that I can ssh from and have some sort of IDE or text editor to work on my AWS projects then worry about a big bulky crappy laptop that is overkill for my work. Obviously I realize this is MY current use case, however I'd be willing to be that the majority of dev/devops type folks on HN have a similar type of use case. AWS, Heroku, just about any PaaS, Saas, or Iaas, etc... would take advantage of a machine like this beautifully. Oh and the last time I had an Air (right before upgrading to the rMBP), My use case? Chrome, Chrome, Terminal, RDP, Chrome. That was at a PC Game dev/publisher company where I administrated all windows based desktops, mac laptops as well as all servers of misc variety... Sooo.....Is this machine useful? I think it is, and I am excited to check it out and may look to getting one. One more thing, I too am one of the lucky Cr-48 owners and LOVED the concept. Biggest reason I hacked it to load ubuntu? SSH. Had the plugin existed back then? ChromeOS ALL THE WAY BABY!!! /rant.
- javajosh 14y agoTotally dig hosted IDEs. I think it's the way of the future. But why do you need a powerful computer to use them? How does it help? I'm genuinely asking.
- Kerrick 14y agoChrome has a wonderful SSH client [0], and with a $5/mo Digital Ocean [1] (or other [2]) VPS for all your UNIX work, it's a perfectly capable dev machine. [0]: https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/secure-shell/pnhechapfaindjhompbnflcldabbghjo?utm_source=chrome-ntp-launcher https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/secure-shell/pnhec... [1]: https://www.digitalocean.com/ https://www.digitalocean.com/ [2]: http://www.lowendbox.com/ http://www.lowendbox.com/
- rayiner 14y agoSo you pay $1,300 to log into a $5/month remote box with 20GB of storage and 512MB of RAM?
- elarkin 14y agoWell, you probably would not get this chromebook if you were only going to use SSH. You'd buy the $250 one.
- jonknee 14y agoUnless you wanted the gorgeous 2560x1700 display... Many people have paid close to the whole computer's price just for the screen (I'm typing this on a 2560x1440 screen that I paid $999 for).
- Gormo 14y agoIs your 2560x1440 screen only 13" though? I don't see the point of having a pixel density that high; almost no one has sharp enough eyesight to distinguish individual pixels at even lower densities than that, and enough people have poor enough eyesight that they won't be able to read text on software that doesn't scale its fonts properly. That resolution is appropriate for a monitor with twice the diagonal size. Also, what's up with the 3:2 aspect ratio? That seems awfully odd.
- Zak 14y ago
- stuartmemo 14y agoI use the Secure Shell extension to ssh onto a dev environment and use vim from there. https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/secure-shell/pnhechapfaindjhompbnflcldabbghjo?hl=en https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/secure-shell/pnhec...
- criley 14y agoSo I have to buy another machine to develop and test my stuff on? What's the point of a powerful laptop if it's just a dumb terminal to connect to my actual development machine? Why not just buy a $300 super cheap laptop and do the exact same thing? Sure I'll have less resolution on the machine, but seeing as the developing is happening on another machine all together, it seems like the performance would be similar.
- MatthewPhillips 14y agoWell, if you're a developer, presumably this isn't the first computer you have owned. I'm using a 5 year old cheapy HP laptop as my dev server and it works wonderfully. There are other alternatives, of course, Cloud9 premium account gives you full shell access, Action.IO gives you full shell access as well.
- mfn 14y agoRegarding the idea of using an old laptop as a dev server, have you run into any issues as a result of having the laptop on all the time (such as overheating)? Also, how would you set it up so that you can log in to your laptop from outside your LAN? I have a few old machines lying around and it would be great if I could put them to use as servers.
- MatthewPhillips 14y agoShouldn't have overheating issues as long as you sit it so that the vents can breath. I leave mine in the basement where it's a little bit cooler. My current uptime is 45 days, I only restart for kernel upgrades and never shut it down. I purchased dynamic DNS, which IIRC is around $35/year, well worth it for the convenience of logging into my home server whereever I am.
- evv 14y agoI bet serious developers will buy these things for linux development
- emidln 14y agoI paid $200 for an Acer C7, $80 for 16GB of RAM, $100 for a 128GB SSD, and $50 for larger capacity battery to end up with a portable linux box (running ubuntu 13.04 now) for under $450 that is light, fast to boot, and has reasonable connectivity (wifi, gige, 3x usb ports). This took me about an hour of reading, 45 minutes to go from sealed boxes to linux, and a small phillips screwdriver (one screw on the back to get to ram+hard drive).
- anigbrowl 14y agoYou could put the original Chromebooks in Dev mode and have a terminal with a build environment, or just install your own Linux build on it. Or even Windows. Not the fastest machine in the world, but not the slowest either. I quite liked it. This feels wildly overpriced to me though.
- ConstantineXVI 14y agoEither after flipping the dev-mode switch and running a chroot or such (thus being outside CrOS's use case), or using it entirely as a thin client (which doesn't need this kind of horsepower).
- micro_cam 14y agoI really hope that running a chroot or vm becomes a fully supported part of chrome os along with an x server. Working with a crouton ubuntu chroot on my (free) chromebox feels a lot like using OS X circa 10.3 or so and I would consider using it as my full time dev box if autoupdate worked in dev mode. I think i would actually prefer it to modern os x if I could tweak some keyboard shortcuts and run an x sever (even an annoying one like apples) mixed in with aura instead of having to switch back and forth.
- rayiner 14y agoPeople are happy using Chromebooks as development platforms because they're $250 for an ARM laptop with long battery life, and you can hack them to run Ubuntu, not because Chrome OS has any merit on its own. Things that are cute on a $250 machine are not so cute on a $1,300 machine...
- rbanffy 14y agoI believe it's much easier to hack this one to run Linux than any ARM-based Chromebook. It certainly has enough memory, storage and processing power to be a decent development machine (provided you avoid heavy IDEs). It's likely possible to even run Windows on this machine.
- neverm0re 14y agoIt's already braindead easy to put Linux on the ARM Samsung Chromebook. One of the first things I did was to assemble my own personal Linux distro and besides having to copy some blob files out of the original ChromeOS image, it's all very straight-forward stuff and I pulled up about a hundred packages I wanted including an X.org stack without fuss. The compile speeds are adequate if you aren't cross-compiling, I've certainly put up with worse. I personally have little interest in the Pixel based on the specs. I think X86 is excessively 'big iron' now for a majority of needs and I find the lack of USB3 is mystifying. The screen looks interesting, but it's nothing I actually /need/ and certainly not worth another thousand bucks. I've personally taken to just using X86 for storage/cross-compile servers for the rest of my cheap ARM/MIPS/etc. crap and I've made it a point to stop buying expensive hardware. What $250 buys you now is actually pretty ridiculously awesome.
- bromagosa 14y agoSame thoughts here. It's Intel-based, I wonder whether one could just install a Debian into this beast...
- d23 14y ago> I really don't get this product. Reminds me of what every techie said about the iPad too.
- rayiner 14y agoOr the Surface. Or BB10.
- LilValleyBigEgo 14y agoI own a Surface Pro and it's crap. It's like someone chopped the screen off a laptop and put it where the keyboard goes. If you're considering a Surface Pro just get an ultrabook instead.
- psbp 14y agoNeither of those have shown to be a success.
- dannyr 14y agoI agree it doesn't make sense. Unless Google announces something in the near future that would make it more than just a web-browsing device...
- rjv 14y agoIf that's the case then they should have waited to reveal the Pixel. I'm of the mind that you should buy a device for what it is, not for what it may be in the future.
- dannyr 14y agoNo. Buy a device for what it is capable of doing in the future. You buy a computer with faster processor so it can support applications in the future. The Pixel will be the same a year or so from now. I don't think the hardware is upgradable. But it will be handle resources-intensive apps coming in the future. Imagine a video-editing app or 3D games.
- j_camarena 14y ago^ this
- DanBC 14y ago> I really don't get this product. Many people are not rational when they buy products. All you can do with a pair of jeans is wear them. Nice denim, nice rivets, nice pockets, and a nice zip (or buttons) - and then some quality control. And yet people can pay very much money for jeans. (Sort by price, high to low. (http://www.mrporter.com/Shop/Clothing/Jeans?sortBy=price-desc http://www.mrporter.com/Shop/Clothing/Jeans?sortBy=price-des...) You say that wealthy people are just going to surf the web on tablets. This is just a tablet with a keyboard. Some people type enough to make on-screen keyboards painful to use.
- baddox 14y agoIf buying a product makes the buyer happy, you can hardly call the purchase "irrational."
- DavidBradbury 14y agoA product making a buyer happy is not a condition for whether a purchase is rational or not. If you have a family, then suddenly you decide to buy a ticket to Amsterdam and burn your kids college money on hookers and blow, being 'happy' doesn't suddenly make all of that rational.
- antimatter15 14y agoApparently the codename for the Pixel (in the chromium os issue tracker, svn, etc) was Link[1], and recently they've added a metallic (i.e. chrome) android statue (without a corresponding android update) [2]. I might be just over-analyzing things, but there might be some software update in Google I/O signalling a merge between Android and Chrome OS (where the latter is already starting to get features like Google Now on that mobile-convergence pathway like Apple's OS X Lion). Android has arguably more high-performance, graphics-heavy and touch-enabled apps, and has the toolchains to compile more sophisticated applications (IDEs, etc). [1]: https://plus.google.com/100132233764003563318/posts/exCKa13F6KZ https://plus.google.com/100132233764003563318/posts/exCKa13F... [2]: https://plus.google.com/+PaulWilcox/posts/23QtTfiVrtk https://plus.google.com/+PaulWilcox/posts/23QtTfiVrtk Also, Google has a weird ironic naming paradigm. First is Chrome which is named as such because they want to minimize the browser's chrome (tab bar, menus, buttons, etc.), and now is the Pixel which has a HiDPI display so people kind of forget the pixel. It would probably be a bad idea to call their self-driving car Crash though.
- mtgx 14y agoExactly. ChromeOS is not for such powerful machines, because the OS itself is not powerful. So ChromeOS with a $1000 machine is far from a perfect match (at least it isn't yet, maybe 5-10 years from now). But right now ChromeOS is and should be for light web machines. And I've said it many times before. There's absolutely no reason for Chromebooks to use x86 chips. I've said Google will almost surely mess up the pricing of Chromebook Pixel because they never seem to understand how to price a new product. Maybe if they would've made a quad core Cortex A15 machine with this display and for $500, that would've been a little more attractive - although for people just looking for browsing the web, there was no need for such a high resolution anyway. Just keep Chromebooks at $250 and use ARM in them, and get to that 10h battery life.
- MatthewPhillips 14y agoThe Chromebook with the best battery life is the Atom-based Samsung Series 5.
- polshaw 14y agoThat is because they cheaped-out on the battery in the ARM chromebook, which almost defeats the point of going ARM for me.
- steve-howard 14y agoI own a Series 5 chromebook. It's hands down the worst machine I've ever owned. I really wanted to like it, too. My issue is that I tried to use it for stuff like reddit, youtube, and whatnot, and because it has no swap space it would just kill background tabs once I had more than 3 or so open. Basically it's a machine built for browsing the web, but because of the way I (and possibly others) use the web it's not useful for that purpose.
- watmough 14y agoI have to put in a good word for the Samsung here. My wife's MacBook finally died, so she got a ChromeBook as a stop-gap, but in reality, it's really all she needs for basic surfing, Google Docs/Drive and watching CBS streaming (for stuff not on Hulu/Roku/NetFlix). It's cheap, adequately quick, easy to use and has all-day battery life, and charges up at night with the iPad and iPhone used by my toddler.
- dman 14y agoa) Read legal briefs b) View financial reports c) Read research papers d) Write web based apps e) Write apps so that more actitivities can be done with specs like this.
- chestnut-tree 14y ago"And yet ChromeOS can't do any of these things...I really don't get this product." I completely agree. If I pay $1300 for a laptop, I expect to be able to do some serious graphics work or video editing. Instead Chrome Pixel gives you powerful hardware coupled to an internet-connected OS with basic, limited apps like Google Docs. (As an example, Google Docs is so basic it can't even span table cells. Worperfect 5.0 could do this over 20 years ago. Pay $1300 for an OS so lacking in features or capable software? Is this progress?).
- JungleGymSam 14y agoI agree but the only explanation I can think of is in preparation for Native Client. But why buy now when the price is high, right?
- JungleGymSam 14y agoOh yeah http://tech.slashdot.org/story/13/02/27/038254/pixel-picture-clearer-google-ports-office-substitute-to-chrome-os-browser?utm_source=slashdot&utm_medium=twitter http://tech.slashdot.org/story/13/02/27/038254/pixel-picture...
- baddox 14y agoBy "specs like this," I'm assuming you just mean the high resolution display. I disagree that a hi-res display is only useful or "meaningful" for development, design, or gaming. It's great for web browsing, which is my main usage for the iPad, and I happily upgraded from iPad 2 to the 3rd generation iPad just for the retina display.
- strongvigilance 14y agoI imagine "specs like this" is referring to the Core i5 rather than the display.
- baddox 14y agoThe i5 is hardly a gratuitous CPU. It's a fairly mid-range CPU. The phrasing of the first comment sounds like it's talking about some completely over the top system, like a 12 core Mac Pro.
- ropiku 14y agoBut we're talking about something used to surf the web. An ARM is still powerful enough and will use way less power.
- baddox 14y agoWeb browsing is pretty darn good on the iPad and comparable Android tablets, but it's still a far cry from the performance you can get on x86 hardware. Many Surface Pro reviews mention this specifically. Now, there's still obviously value judgement to be made: is the Pixel worth the extra money, extra weight, and worse battery life compared to an Apple or Android tablet?
- mrb 14y agoWorse battery life compared to an Apple? I think you are wrong. I think Google is being pessimist when estimating the battery life to be 5h when their capacity is 59Wh. For comparison, Apple advertises the MacBook Air 13" battery to be 40% longer (7h) when their capacity is 15% less (50Wh). Maybe Google estimated a higher average power consumption (eg. using the LTE wireless network which is more power consuming than wifi). MacBook Air 13": 50Wh - starts at $1200 Pixel: 59Wh - starts at $1300 MacBook Pro 13": 74Wh - starts at $1500 Basically, the more you pay, the more capabilities and battery life you get. And both Apple and Google seem in line.
- mcantelon 14y ago>And yet ChromeOS can't do any of these things. It does seem weird, yes. My guess is gaming is definitely something it will be able to do (if not now then soon) via Native Client.
- wycats 14y agoI was delighted to see Bastion, a game I played on my Mac, available on the Chrome Web Store using Native Client (https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/bastion/oohphhdkahjlioohbalmicpokoefkgid https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/bastion/oohphhdkah...)
- jonknee 14y agoUsing that logic I don't know how Apple sells so many of its MacBooks. They're all expensive and have "specs like this", but the vast majority are not used for development, design or gaming. I can see the appeal of a small (thinner than a MacBook Air), well constructed, blazingly fast laptop. If I could run 1Password on it I would be very tempted to take it for a spin, with the LTE it would make an excellent travel machine.
- MrVitaliy 14y agoMBAir is best dev laptop I ever had. Its super light, plenty of power and space for most app development and within reach price wise. Also, I suggest you look up Linus's rant about how he loves Mac book air and SSD for kernel development.
- ImprovedSilence 14y ago>> MBAir is best dev laptop I ever had. seconded.
- rdl 14y agoI wish the MBAir had 4G/LTE built in. That (and the higher res screen, and the platform security hw) are the things I like about the Pixel. I'm sure Apple will Retinize the MBAir in 2013 or 2014. I just don't get why LTE chipsets don't appear in any Mac products. I have a VZ MiFi and it's such a pain by comparison -- I'm fine paying $10/mo to Verizon for each mobile/etc. device I have.
- jonknee 14y agoI never suggested it's not a great machine.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- masklinn 14y ago> Using that logic I don't know how Apple sells so many of its MacBooks. They're all expensive and have "specs like this", but the vast majority are not used for development, design or gaming. A macbook is more than a thin client running SSH and a browser.
- scholia 14y agoMaybe it's designed for Google employees. If so, we may not know why they wanted that spec, and the price doesn't matter...
- dudusmaximus 14y agoI agree. Dogfooding whilst ensuring their productivity won't suffer. Something to replace all those MacBookPros being used at Google ..
- ZeroGravitas 14y agoIt's got integrated Intel graphics. That's something I pay attention to because the open source support is great. But I was led to believe that no serious gamer would touch them. Note also that I could probably develop on it as I use Vim in a terminal, which I believe ChromeOS has.
- stanleydrew 14y agoYes ChromeOS has a terminal. Just hit Ctrl+Alt+T. The SSH interface is a little non-standard as I recall but not enough to be a problem. It has dynamic proxying support so you can set up a SOCKS proxy through localhost and on to a host in [country] to get around content licensing restrictions. I've done this for Netflix, Hulu, MLB, Fox Soccer, and the London Olympics.
- hiker 14y agoYou can always nuke Chrome OS and install a OSX/linux/windows/whatever-rocks-your-boat. You're paying for the hardware, not for Chrome OS.
- monochromatic 14y agoAnd who wants to smear fingerprints all over his laptop screen?
- RexRollman 14y agoThis! I just can't understand why it would be desired on a laptop.
- rayiner 14y agoNobody does: http://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2013/02/googles-new-touchscreen-chromebook-pixel-a-1299-laptop-for-cloud-dwellers/?comments=1 http://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2013/02/googles-new-touchscre... Not a single positive comment on the entire front-page, and Ars isn't exactly madly pro-Mac. I have to admit my feeling of schadenfreude is pretty strong right now...
- phaus 14y agoMy theory is that maybe this announcement was intended to make the $1500 Google Glass seem slightly less ridiculous. It's going to take more than a $1300 Chrome book to do that. In all seriousness though, I was really excited about this when I saw the first video, then it was reported to be a fraud, and now all of a sudden it has an i5 and it costs twice what I thought it would. At 600-700 bucks, I was ready to trade in my iPad, but for this amount, I'd rather get an XPS dev edition or a 13" retina macbook for just a bit more.
- hiker 14y agoBefore I read your comment I though that computers only good for accounting and scientific simulations. But then I remembered that it's not 1951 any more. Thank you. </bitter-irony>
- dannyr 14y ago"There are only three meaningful things you can do with a computer with specs like this: development, design, or gaming. And yet ChromeOS can't do any of these things." If ChromeOS wants to do these things, they need something like Pixel. You got it the other way around.
- curveship 14y agoSome speculation about one thing a machine like this might be for: 1. Google purchased Nik Software a few months ago. Nik makes several industry leading tools for photo retouching. 2. Before the acquisition, Nik had started transitioning their desktop technology to touch, for use in their tablet app Snapseed. 3. The Nik folk have been kind of quiet since the acquisition. 4. Now Google comes out with a hi-res, touch-oriented laptop, an absolute dream machine for photo editing. 5. ... New Chrome OS native photo editing app?
- colmvp 14y agoNeither do I. For an extra $200, you can get twice the RAM, four times the storage, a better battery, and the ability to install whatever OS suits your fancy.
- HNLogInShit 14y agoNot to mention yet another shitty glossy screen. And does this thing have a Delete key? Yeah, there are Chrome computers that don't have a goddamned Delete key. Unbelievable.
- medikoo 14y agowell.. 64GB limit of internal memory, makes this device not capable for any serious development, design etc. work.