4 ms·
A substantial pain no doubt to have to rebrand the most valuable product on the planet just for the Brazil market, but given it's such a huge market I'm sure th
by adventured 14y ago
A substantial pain no doubt to have to rebrand the most valuable product on the planet just for the Brazil market, but given it's such a huge market I'm sure they'll figure it out.
Apple Phone? iPod Phone? iOS Phone?
- seanmcdirmid 14y agoBrazil is one of those very dysfunctional markets. Apple (well Foxcon on Apple's behalf) had to setup final assembly their directly to get around crazy tarrif rules, which assume most value is added during final assembly! Sure, Apple tries its hardest, but at some point it won't be worth it to them.
- kawera 14y agoThe funny thing is that Apple sells those locally made products for about the same price they sold the imported (taxed) ones.
- seanmcdirmid 14y agoI didn't think Apple sold iPhones in Brazil before they started building them there; are you sure you aren't referring to gray market imports? If so, there is probably some amount of tax avoidance going on. Doesn't Brazil have a high VAT?
- kawera 14y agoApple definitively sold iPhones in Brazil before building them here, as they did with the iPad. VAT varies slightly from state to state, mostly in the 20-22% range.
- malandrew 14y agoIt's due to cost rebalancing across the entire line of Apple products, including those that are imported.
- eduardordm 14y agoI worked for the brazilian IRS for twelve years, I will say you just invented that. Imported iphone taxes: 60% import taxes + 7%-15% sales state tax if you are a reseller or 0% if you are the customer. 0% industrial tax. Made in brazil taxes: 7-15% sales state tax, 6% industrial taxes.
- jessaustin 14y agoI'm probably misunderstanding something, but how does this contradict seanmcdirmid? Why wouldn't Apple want to avoid 60% import taxes?
- eduardordm 14y agoBecause the minimum wage in brazil is 25x higher than the chinese...
- jessaustin 14y agoA) 25x? I'd have to be an idiot to believe that. The ratio isn't that high between the USA and China. B) When I looked this up the ratio between Brazil and China ranges between 2x and 3.5x. (China doesn't have a single national minimum.) C) On the more important comparison, PPP per capita GDP the ratio is less than 2x. It seems like 60% tariffs are still significant. We're all acquainted with the nearly universal practice of doing most manufacture in a cheap nation and then doing only the final assembly (or sometimes disassembly) in the importing nation. If this isn't what you're seeing you haven't been paying attention.
- seanmcdirmid 14y agoA factory worker at Foxcon these days is probably making 4K RMB a month, which is around $641. It is perhaps half to a third of what a similar factory worker would make in a first world country (if such jobs existed). Also, note that China also has a significant import tax, and you don't get around it by making things in China! Special export zones are complicated, so basically everything is imported. The markup on China vs. US is about 20-30% right now, not as bad as before. As noted in another thread, wages in Brazil aren't that great, its still a 2nd-world country. Perhaps ahead of China, but the growth vectors are fairly clear that China will overtake Brazil soon in per-person GDP and probably wages after that.
- timcederman 14y agoThey don't need to rebrand - the article states they just don't have exclusivity.