8 ms·
Why police lie under oath
- ObnoxiousJul 14y agoWell it is a known QA practice: never base incentive on metrics or people will cheat one way or another with the metrics. If your dev have a prime based on SLA or tickets solved guess what? You are giving them an incentive to cheat. You will have nice figures to show your investors, ypur stock options' values will raise and coder will be better paid. Everyone is happy, who cares about the truth, the unfairness, the lie. This is just mis placed moral. Stats that can be tricked are the prozac of our society. It make the metrics describing a situation improve with mutual benefits for (almost) all the stakeholders. Who cares about the customers or minorities anyway? I mean not on the paper but honestly?
- Spooky23 14y agoIs even worse in NY -- quotas are illegal, yet they exist. But there is no record of what quotas are assigned to a given detail of officers.
- pkteison 14y agoStory about people lying is exclusively based on interviewing a few people and trusting that they are telling the truth about people lying. I'm sure it happens, I'm sure it's terrible, but I'm sure interviewing people isn't a useful means of doing anything about it. The whole premise is that people lie and are incentivized to do so, but somehow this is magically not true of the people telling you about the lies?
- danso 14y agoYou must have missed the part about hundreds of drug cases being thrown out because of such lies. Here it is from the OP > The New York City Police Department is not exempt from this critique. In 2011, hundreds of drug cases were dismissed after several police officers were accused of mishandling evidence. That year, Justice Gustin L. Reichbach of the State Supreme Court in Brooklyn condemned a widespread culture of lying and corruption in the department’s drug enforcement units. “I thought I was not naïve,” he said when announcing a guilty verdict involving a police detective who had planted crack cocaine on a pair of suspects. “But even this court was shocked, not only by the seeming pervasive scope of misconduct but even more distressingly by the seeming casualness by which such conduct is employed.”
- pkteison 14y agoYou actually think this is a good article? Most of that case was also just testimony, this time people saying people are lying. The article backs up its case with: 1) Article written by a former police commissioner. 2) Quote about one actual case that apparently had some videotape proving a lie. 3) Bronx district attorney decides that the means to deal with lying is to interview the cops who are supposed to be lying about whether they are lying or not. 4) Back to former police commissioner again. 5) Passing reference to 'numerous scandals' 6) Interviews with 'numerous officers' by Urban Justice Center's Police Reform Organizing Project The former police commissioner writing an article, the supreme court justice, the police being interviewed about their lying, the folks investigating the 'numerous scandals', and the Urban Justice Center's Police Reform Organizing Project -all- have their own agendas, but everything they say is blindly taken as fact in the same article that claims humans lie every day. If you want to mistrust cops because their funding is tied to arrests, you should probably mistrust the urban justice police reform project because their very name is tied to proving the cops are wrong. Why is one side automatically trustworthy? Solely because they support the premise? I feel like this could be an interesting topic, but approaching it from a he-said/she-said interviewing standpoint is laughable, it should be obvious that interviewing people about lying is downright counterproductive.
- danso 14y agoAh yes, you're right. Anytime someone accuses cops of lying, those cops usually go straight to jail, and judges rip them a new one. That is most definitely how the system is stacked up, especially in New York. And a few years ago, when an officer secretly taped his bosses deliberately fudging statistics, that was just another case of biased recording devices...chronic issue, for sure. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adrian_Schoolcraft http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adrian_Schoolcraft I wonder why the author of that piece couldn't devote 30,000 exhaustive words for the article. Another conspiracy of course.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- wylie 14y agoThere's a typo in the link, the one that works for me is: http://www.nytimes.com/2013/02/03/opinion/sunday/why-police-officers-lie-under-oath.html?pagewanted=all http://www.nytimes.com/2013/02/03/opinion/sunday/why-police-...
- saosebastiao 14y agoLink is broken for me. But it should be obvious...the reason cops do anything that is illegal is that they are not subject to any consequences.
- ricardonunez 14y agoThey are free to do what they want and rarely get any punishment. The only thing they get is Leave Without Pay for some time and that's only when they screwed up really bad.
- saosebastiao 14y agoIf by bad you mean they committed mass murder.
- lutusp 14y agoYour link is broken. Here is a corrected one: http://www.nytimes.com/2013/02/03/opinion/sunday/why-police-officers-lie-under-oath.html http://www.nytimes.com/2013/02/03/opinion/sunday/why-police-...
- DenisM 14y agoOn a historic note, Stalin's first, bloodiest purges were also governed by quotas and the heads of various departments of the secret police (NKVD) trying to one up each other, exerting pressure on their subordinates, and in the absence of judicial oversight. Stalin ended up replacing over-enthusiastic NKVD chiefs twice, and the last one, the one we remember the most and whose name, Beria, we come to associate with the oppressive force, was actually less brutal then the previous two (Yagoda and Ezhov).
- rdtsc 14y agoRemember reading in a memoir of someone who had access to the NKVD (then KGB) archives from that era. The log would go something like this: -- Dec, 14 : Found and eliminated Ivan X. -- Dec, 17 : Turns out that was the wrong Ivan X. -- Dec, 20 : Found and eliminated the real Ivan X.
- philwelch 14y ago> Stalin ended up replacing over-enthusiastic NKVD chiefs twice You know things are bad when Josef Stalin replaces you because you're overenthusiastic.
- btilly 14y agoNo, he was just following Machiavelli's advice for how a prince (ie dictator) should enforce law and order when extreme measures are called for. Namely assign the job to a henchman, and then when the deed is done, convince the people that the henchman was acting on his own, and execute the henchman: http://faculty.cua.edu/pennington/churchhistory220/Lecture13/PrinceCesareBorgia.html http://faculty.cua.edu/pennington/churchhistory220/Lecture13...
- philwelch 14y agoOne would surmise that if Stalin's goal was to avoid building a reputation as a brutal mass murderer, he certainly failed.
- 14y ago
- Alex3917 14y ago"Not just because the police have a special inclination toward confabulation, but because, disturbingly, they have an incentive to lie." Actually there have been studies showing that police lie much more than the general public. E.g. here is a summary of one such study showing that: http://www.erowid.org/psychoactives/statistics/statistics_article2.shtml http://www.erowid.org/psychoactives/statistics/statistics_ar...
- jacalata 14y agoThe only section of that page that might be relevant to what you just said was " police and military personnel, groups with more reason to deny past illegal drug use, were twice as likely to recant than the general population." You appear to be arguing that police are intrinsically more likely to lie, but this study doesn't support that, it actually supports the quote you are trying to refute.
- Alex3917 14y ago"You appear to be arguing that police are intrinsically more likely to lie, but this study doesn't support that, it actually supports the quote you are trying to refute." I actually wasn't arguing that cops are more intrinsically likely to lie, only that they are more likely to lie. Although I do also believe that they are probably more intrinsically likely to lie. Why? I think you're right that of the non-police population, many would lie if they became cops due to the extrinsic incentives to lie. At the same time though, people who aren't comfortable lying about their current/past drug use are effectively banned from becoming cops. So while the study might not prove that cops are more intrinsically likely to lie per se, the fact that there is a significant disparity suggests to me that it's highly likely that part of that disparity is due to differences in who decides to be a cop. And, if it is the case that some significant portion of that disparity is due to selection factors, which seems likely, then my it would be accurate to say that they are intrinsically more likely to lie.
- dionidium 14y agoHomosexuals in a homophobic culture are more likely to lie about sex. But it's entirely situational and tells us nothing about homosexuals in general.
- noonespecial 14y agoNearly the entire job of police is to collect evidence of crimes being committed. (Actually stopping crimes in progress is secondary at best). Falsifying evidence is the opposite of this job. Not just not doing the job, but doing its inverse. Provably falsifying evidence even one time should be enough to be banned from ever being entrusted to carry out this role again.
- jlgreco 14y agoForget banned, they should be jailed, if not worse. They are undermining the entire legitimacy of the justice system, a cornerstone of our society. There are few worse crimes than undermining our ability to punish crime itself. Extraordinary responsibility should be balanced with extraordinary liability.
- noonespecial 14y agoI suppose it would only be fair that they received the mandatory minimum sentence for the crime of which they were making the false accusation. Bonus points for allowing the trial to procede untainted and then just transferring the sentence.
- pasbesoin 14y agoThere are already laws against perjury, and in many cases, IIRC, it is a felony. Ironic, isn't it, that prosecutors are unwilling to pursue all these potential felony convictions...
- lutusp 14y agoLawyers tell me that judges rarely prosecute lying under oath, they just rule against the liars. The reason? If a person is accused of lying under oath, what's to stop him from lying more during the perjury trial? He's already accused of that crime, so more lies makes little difference. This is why perjury trials are so rare. Also, "perjury", strictly defined, means testimony that's both material to the issues and leads to a miscarriage of justice. That's a tough standard.
- inuhj 14y agoI was arrested when I was 18 after a guy I was with was caught selling mdma at a gathering in the desert. The police report was filled with lies. The officers approached me during the night(it was 10F) and asked to sit in my car. I was having a heart to heart with my girlfriend but obliged because they were obviously cold and being welcoming is part of that subculture. They made some lewd inappropriate comments about my gf and then asked to buy drugs. I told them I didnt have any. They begged. I said sorry I dont have any. I read the police report and they wrote that i wanted to sell them drugs but told them I had just taken the last of mine and recommended them to my friend. They were rude and total dicks to everyone. In court the judge admonished them for grinding up on underage girls on their surveillance videos.
- dlokshin 14y agoWholeheartedly agree with the erosion of personal freedoms in the favor of laws made by people 'who know better.' Speeding is a perfect example--any law that 80% of people on the freeway break is a terrible law.
- Anechoic 14y agoany law that 80% of people on the freeway break is a terrible law. They are actually supposed to be set so that 80-90% of the people are obeying the limit (see MUTCD), but that often results in limits that are perceived as being too high by communities.
- Firehed 14y agoWhy have speed limits at all then? I've heard anecdotes of professional drivers getting out of massive speeding tickets because they know how to handle a vehicle at that speed (and presumably had the good sense not to be driving way faster than traffic if there even was any) and its certainly possible to get a speeding ticket when traveling under the limit if conditions do not permit. Seems to me that they should be treated as good-weather guidelines (legally; that's already more or less the case in practice), and focus on the people driving recklessly - weaving in and out of traffic, going 10mph+ faster than everyone else, tailgating, etc.
- siphor 14y agoThe whole system is blatantly fucked up and I'm more stunned by people's non-chalant reaction or 'it's the law reaction'. I live in a small town in New Jersey where my mom works for the town.. recently there was a police 'strike' around contract negotiations, where, to prove the town should give them a raise they stopped writing tickets to show the town how much money the police department makes them. What this means to me (and I'm pretty sure is obvious) is that they stopped writing stupid 'money making' tickets and were actually... doing their job of protecting its citizens. The worst thing about all of this is I have no idea how to fix it. I can rant on shit like this for a long time but I'll ask one question that hopefully someone will be inclined to share their opinion. I think one major problem (that most seem to disagree about) is the slowly creeping loss of personal freedom 'for the publics best interest' I think speed limit's are against this freedom, is it really that inconceivable to believe we can't judge what is a safe speed? (obviously reckless driving would still be a thing that police would be used for) or even smaller... Why is it a law that I must wear a seatbelt? Or even drugs.. why does any law care if I want to smoke crack? this may have been off topic sorry.
- fossuser 14y agoI generally agree with this, but it gets tricky when you factor in social services. If a society decides that it should support health or medical services with public funds then there is a line of logic that conditions based on that support (such as a seatbelt laws, drug laws, or even banning soda) should be allowed. I don't agree with this, but if I was arguing for that side that would be how I'd frame it. The seatbelt law is particularly weird to me considering that motorcycles are perfectly legal.
- politician 14y agoWow, it never occurred to me that the seatbelt law is particularly weird given motorcycles.
- evanmoran 14y agoJust because people are insane on motorcycles doesn't mean the state should pay for the health care of people in cars who could wear a seatbelt. The legality of motorcycles is a separate issue. And lets be honest. We already have to drive regulated cars, with regulated emission, with gas that is regulated, at the speeds that are regulated, and only if we have regulated licenses. Is a seat belt really a big deal? Wearing one will probably save your life. Is that so bad?
- ryanmarsh 14y agoMy brother is in prison for murder. He did it and confessed to it. Still, during the trial the detectives saw fit to lie under oath, and bring forth evidence of his character (his diary) obtained illegally (they lied and said it was obtained via a neighbor who found it in a trash can in his house 0_o). All of this even though they had an open and shut case. It blew my mind that in a case that they had in the bag and where the evidence of the crime itself was enough to put him away forever they still did all of that. The story of the diary was especially ridiculous. It's not like the detectives told some whoppers just to make things easier on themselves. They lied about all sorts of small things, like how his arrest actually happened. From that I learned to fear the system. If they'll do that with a slam dunk case, what will they do to get a conviction when the case is a tough one? How many men has this state (Texas) executed as a result of this system?
- IamBren 14y agoI'm not involved with anything remotely illegal but I still watched this all the way through because of the police situation in the US: "An law school professor and former criminal defense attorney tells you why you should never agree to be interviewed by the police." http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6wXkI4t7nuc http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6wXkI4t7nuc It's quite fascinating really. The police officer he has come up to speak talks about some of the tricks they use to get people to confess and they talk about word tricks they use to get convictions even of innocent people. It's pretty terrifying. What I find interesting is how many TV shows depict suspects running their mouths to the police like they're all buddies. You're NEVER supposed to do that. Even innocent people can very easily incriminate themselves, as they show in the above video. Speaking of Texas and executions, have you ever read about Todd Willingham? http://www.newyorker.com/reporting/2009/09/07/090907fa_fact_grann?printable=true http://www.newyorker.com/reporting/2009/09/07/090907fa_fact_... Willingham was convicted of "multiple infanticide" for burning his house down with his daughters still inside. He maintained his innocence until the end, and finally found a fire investigator to review the case shortly before he was scheduled to be executed. The investigator provided conclusive evidence that he DID NOT start the fire, but the Board of Pardons and Paroles apparently didn't even read it: “The only reasonable conclusion is that the governor’s office and the Board of Pardons and Paroles ignored scientific evidence.” And so, sadly, he was executed. There are so many WTFs in this case, which is probably partly why the article is so long. One thing that stood out is how the witness testimony changed from "he was frantically trying to put the fire out" to "he didn't seem to be doing much of all" after he was charged with starting the fire (the witnesses became biased). And how the fire investigators could be high school drop outs with minimal training, and how they used gut feelings and super outdated science while investigating the case. Their investigation is really what caused him to be convicted. Pretty sad story, and it seems to happen a lot like this, especially in Texas.
- ck2 14y agoThe three word answer to this article is buried several paragraphs down: because they can
- ChuckMcM 14y agoMy sister in law is a public defender, she has managed to get cops that lie under oath fired. We're not talking capital crimes here, we're talking stupid traffic citations where the officer would rather lie than admit they made a bad call. Her belief is that lying is like cocaine, you use it once to get through the case because you know that even though its not strictly the truth the right thing will happen, and then you use it because you really didn't prepare enough, and suddenly its not a 'big deal' in your mind, after all these are people committing crimes right? We're protecting the 'good' people from these scumbags. And you lose yourself. Exceptionally sad.
- mattstreet 14y agoSadly it seems like they get treated the same as pedo priests, just shuffled around somewhere else.
- PeterisP 14y agoWhy managing to get them fired is considered a good result? Perjury is a serious crime and should be prosecuted as such. Cops should [be made to] understand that lying in court even in small cases carries a risk of criminal charges (in USA, up to 5 years IIRC) instead of internal disciplinary action.
- ChuckMcM 14y agoYes it is, which is why I really felt President Clinton should have resigned when he was proven to have perjured himself in the Monica Lewinsky investigation. But as we saw with him, Barry Bonds, and others, it is not effectively prosecuted. This is in part because the English language is so malleable to interpretation that 'reasonable doubt' becomes a massive impediment to conviction.
- hakaaaaak 14y agoWhy aren't lie detectors used in court on a regular basis? Even if it didn't work 100% of the time, it would be better than having to read posts like this.
- csense 14y agoThey aren't reliable. If I was a suspect or witness testifying in a trial that could result in myself or someone I know getting the death penalty or going to jail for a long time, I'd be really nervous and maybe fail the lie detector even if my answers were completely truthful. OTOH a police officer who's used to lying to suspects (it's the main tool police have in countries where torture or police brutality isn't allowed), or a hardened psychopath criminal who doesn't see anything wrong with lying to protect his own interests, may be so cool that he/she can easily pass the lie detector.
- Jayschwa 14y agoBecause "lie detectors" are pseudo-science rubbish. The only thing they test is how well you handle lie detectors.
- eriksank 14y agoWell, as soon as the first commandment goes down the drain, all other commandments are quick to follow: "Thou shalt not bear false witness against thy neighbour." Exodus 20:12. It is the general public who is to blame, because they are not willing to enforce this. Police officers caught using force on behalf of the politicians or their servants to transgress on Exodus 20:12 must be served a final extermination order without trial, procedure or ceremony, executable by whoever happens to available and/or willing, because such is the will of the supreme being.
- edmundhuber 14y agoGopros for police officers?
- linuxhansl 14y agoIn the US perjury is a felony and provides for a prison sentence of up to five years. Does that somehow not apply to the police? If a cop's performance is measured by number of arrests or convictions, and the repercussions of lying under oath is maybe a suspension with pay or worst case being fired, I do not see how this is going to change. IMHO, law enforcement officials should be held to higher standard.
- nnq 14y ago...how expensive would it be to have all policemen use something like mini-cameras with mikes on them and have a full video archive of all police actions? If things like Google-glass catch on, the cost of a one way system without the projector, plus a streaming system via mobile phone app will make this disposable cheap (yeah, then we'll get into the privacy matter - like a video of you being stopped for speeding with a hooker in your car risking to get on youtube for your wife to see... but still)
- Create 14y agoyoutu.be/6wXkI4t7nuc
- mercurial 14y agoDisclaimer: my experience with US police officers is limited to being asked questions by a couple of cops at the airport and watching The Wire. Assuming that cops do actually have quotas, and that their bonus are tied to achieving these quotas, this effectively creates a for-profit police force. Which mechanically leads to aberrations like the DEA agent mentioned in the Caswell case[1] who was paid taxpayer money to find private properties for seizing. And who watches the watchmen? Note this situation is not unique: in France, the former right wing government put a heavy emphasis on crime statistics, and since the new "left wing" interior minister seems to follow the same policies, it's probably still the case. 1: http://whowhatwhy.com/2013/01/17/carmen-ortizs-sordid-rap-sheet/ http://whowhatwhy.com/2013/01/17/carmen-ortizs-sordid-rap-sh...
- robk 14y agoPlease don't base your judgments of real life policing on Hollywood productions.
- Dylan16807 14y agoDid you actually read the comment you replied to? It doesn't base anything at all on said productions; it was just a cute way of saying lack of exposure to US police.
- welder 14y agoI've witnessed a police officer lying under oath. I think it was a combination of bad recollection and justifying the lies as minor compared to the overall situation.
- neilk 14y agoWhen I worked on a student newspaper in Montreal, a photographer of ours was once detained by Metro (subway) cops and beaten in a back room. I did the followup and a cop read the police report to me over the phone. It detailed how the photographer had aggressively interfered with the police in the performance of their duties, quoting the French profanities he had uttered. Problem: the photographer was a unilingual English-speaker from Ontario. When they told me that, I got a little too excited about getting them to give me these exact quotes from the report. The police officer suddenly said he'd call me back. Fifteen minutes later, he called me back, opening with "aaah, actually we don't know exactly what he said." This isn't even the most interesting case of cops lying that I know of, but you always remember your first.
- stcredzero 14y agoOne of the things privileged members of society have a hard time understanding is the cynical viewpoint of the underprivileged. What does one think when the "justice" system commits fraud and one grows up realizing that you're too poor to afford facts being facts and the truth being the truth? It's George Orwell's "ultimate insult," writ savage. > Research shows that ordinary human beings lie a lot — multiple times a day — even when there’s no clear benefit to lying. Years ago, I mentioned the notion of never lying in front of my girlfriend's mom, and she laughed out loud. I was shocked. Is this what most people are really like? I'm beginning to think that I don't like most people.
- jrochkind1 14y ago> In this era of mass incarceration, the police shouldn’t be trusted any more than any other witness, perhaps less so. At least in Maryland where I live, whether you trust the police less (or more) so than other witnesses is one of the half dozen standard things they ask you in voir dire, and saying yes will exclude you from serving on a jury.