17 ms·
Google's Driverless Car Is Worth Trillions
- jacques_chester 14y agoThis assumes Google will have the market to itself. Cars aren't like search. It's not a winner-takes-all market.
- zasz 14y agoWhy wouldn't self-driving cars be networked somehow? Like, what if in order to access the Google fleet of cars, you had to have a Google membership?
- anigbrowl 14y agoThat would conflict with public safety considerations and possibly with antitrust/consumer legislation. The system has to work on a standalone basis even if communications go down, but you can be sure it will be super-easy to integrate with or obtain Google account privileges. Having been part of the test group for several Google hardware products, I'm optimistic about the possibilities - although Google will have to up its game regarding customer service, tech support etc.
- anigbrowl 14y agoGoogle's not selling cars. It's selling automotive technology that will soon become standard in cars.
- wololo 14y agoI don't understand. Why license it out? Isn't this like the iPhone?
- jlgreco 14y agoAll those other car companies? They are the ones with the brands and the cars people want. They are the iphones in this situation. Sure, if you're pushing a new powertrain you can do okay making one or two of your own cars (which will take years) and you can shortcut the time to build up a brandname to a degree by being exclusive, but none of that effort is warranted because this technology does not require that sort of vertical integration. If your competency is not making cars but rather automated cars, why would you want to get into the business of making cars?
- logn 14y agoGoogle has loads of money. They can buy a car company. Tesla has a $4B market cap. Or they could invest significantly in a car company. Or they can strike exclusive agreements.
- jlgreco 14y agoGoogle can buy a lot of different companies. But why would they want to?
- dagw 14y agoWhy deal with the hassle of actually owning a car company and factories and all the related problems of actually building things. Also what does Google gain by offering an exclusive agreement to a nice car maker? Wouldn't it be better to offer the tech to everybody, sit back, focus on R&D and take a percentage of every sale made while let them deal with all the problems of actually building and selling cars.
- GIFtheory 14y agoThe solution is much farther off than Google would like you to believe. As in, we'll be lucky if driverless cars become feasible before fusion becomes commercially viable.
- sshumaker 14y agoEvidence?
- onedev 14y agoPlease don't make statements like that without providing your reasoning (whether right or wrong).
- GIFtheory 14y agoI've worked on autonomous cars, and no, I am not a crank. I could go into technical reasons why this is nowhere near ready, but there is no need. The onus is on Google to prove that they have the technology (or that it will arrive soon), and proof has not been forthcoming. I'm not even claiming that Google is claiming that autonomous cars are almost here--I am saying that people should take their carefully controlled demos with a grain of salt.
- taligent 14y agoVolvo is shipping a self-driving car in 2014. It's not far off.
- jacques_chester 14y ago> It's selling automotive technology that will soon become standard in cars. This still means that they aren't going to be making the "triiiillions of dollars!" [Dr Evil pinkie finger here] I mean sure, they can make a lot of money further down the value chain. But so do Motorola whenever someone installs a few dozen PowerPC chips into a new BMW. It's just lazy link-baiting conflation of the Biggest Number Available with what might actually happen, and that annoyed me.
- taligent 14y agoNobody is interested in Google's technology. They all have their own implementation: Audi, BMW, Ford, GM, Honda, Hyundai, Lexus, Mercedes-Benz, Nissan, Porsche, Tesla, Toyota, Volkswagen, Volvo
- daniel-cussen 14y agoThe software might become like Android---a standard. Largely because of interoperability: it's advantageous for cars to talk to one another in order to coordinate on the highway better than just with sensors, so it makes sense for them all to be of the same operating system. Further, people who make apps for these cars will want to deploy to as many as possible. So, "IceDriver 2015" will choose Google's car OS over (shivers) GM's OS.
- wwweston 14y ago> it's advantageous for cars to talk to one another If "never trust the client" is a truism in software, I'd assume it'd be doubly so for P2P communication, and add another doubling for a situation involving humans + relatively high masses and speeds.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- moocow01 14y agoThe market is worth trillions... not Google's solution. One thing tech reporters seem to have failed at recognizing is that this research has been taking place at every major car company out there - many many others are legitimately in the race. Ultimately its the manufacturers that get to pull the trigger on how driverless cars will become driverless.
- mc32 14y agoNot only car companies either. Lots of state DoTs like CalTrans (in conjunction with UCBerkeley) have been working on self driving cars. The Caltrans-UCB PATH prgram was begun way back in '86 and demoed self driving cars back in '97! http://www.eastbayexpress.com/ebx/the-future-is-in-the-past/Content?oid=1077926 http://www.eastbayexpress.com/ebx/the-future-is-in-the-past/...
- jey 14y agoThe PATH stuff isn't even in the same ballpark. It only worked for specially-outfitted express lanes that had magnets embedded in the road.
- mc32 14y agoYes, it's true the roadbeds had to have embedded mags but it was a beginning. It was exploratory and they got it to work back then. It was different tech, for sure. My point is that people were looking at solutions more than two decades ago. We don't expect solutions to follow the same path to resolution.
- coopdog 14y agoStill, I can't help but feel that maybe Google have the final piece of the puzzle. We've had computers and sensors powerful enough for decades, only Google have all of that maps data, polished again and again by android users using maps (and now Ingress) to make it more reliable. Google almost specialise at crunching massive data into useful products, and building reliable supersystems from millions of unreliable subsystems. Car companies might have some software knowledge these days but they really are a long way from the capabilities Google has. They solve car problems, but it might turn out that this is an information system problem.
- anigbrowl 14y agoThat's why the CA legislature pssed legislation to allow self-driving cars on public roads with such unusual alacrity - this is a technology we want to ensure gets a foothold in California, both for direct revenue flowing to the state and for the second order economic gains that would result from wide deployment - environmental improvements, lower accident rates, and new service markets. EDIT: as well as the ongoing perception of economic and technological leadership, which has taken a bruising after our per-student educational funding fell to an embarrassing 49th in the nation.
- tokenadult 14y agoafter our per-student educational funding fell to an embarrassing 49th in the nation I had heard that funding levels in California, as ranked against other states, had fallen in recent years, and that is surely embarrassing to Californians, who historically have taken pride in generous state funding for schools up to and including universities. But of course even more embarrassing to California in the years that I have been an adult have been the poor results in California schools, even compared to funding levels there that were higher than in some other states. I wish the school administrators in California well in learning how to spend their resources better. I note that the Gates Foundation studies of effective schooling practices often include schools in California in the study samples, and I hope actionable data lead to better results.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- logn 14y ago"Because people consistently underestimate the implications of a change in technology—are you listening, Kodak, Blockbuster, Borders, Sears, etc.?" Um, are you listening Ford, Hyundai, Honda, GM? Can't wait until they legislate their way back to competitiveness with google.
- taligent 14y agoAll of those companies have had self-driving car projects for a decade now. Might want to pay attention.
- autarch 14y agoI think the implications are huge, but I question the 90% reduction in cars figure. While it's true that most people don't drive their car most of the time, when they do drive, most of them are driving within a relatively small time window. I could imagine a 25-50% reduction in the number of cars, but I just don't see 90% happening unless it's accompanied by a huge increase in people working from home or working non-standard hours.
- rsingel 14y agoWhile I agree car culture is powerful, I've been persuaded that it'll be over 50% faster than you think. The cost saving of not owning a car will become apparent quickly. Cars that can be much smaller (since you no longer buy/rent a car for the biggest task you have a year), carpooling gets MUCH simpler. It's going to reshape cities and entire industries. We'll get most of the best of cars (flexible mobility and independence) and get rid of most of the worst of them (cost, insurance, waste of public space, car-centric architecture, deaths, drunk driving, etc.). I cannot wait.
- rogerbinns 14y agoYou haven't taken into account car pooling. Driverless cars can do adhoc car pooling. I can even see things like local 4 seater driverless cars picking you up, and taking you to another 10 (or more) seater vehicle for the rest of your journey. (By definition the congestion is because a lot of people have overlapping routes.) Additionally you are no longer to blame for your commute since the driverless system would be responsible for timing, in much the same way trains are to blame for timing now. I'd also expect the driverless system to have variable pricing - need to get to work by 9am instead 9.15am and it is $5 more out of your pocket. Ultimately your employer is paying that and they have an incentive to only do so if it is valuable.
- moconnor 14y agoMany people don't like sharing a car with strangers; I doubt this will change as quickly as the technology.
- lylemckeany 14y agoLike some others have mentioned, the title is somewhat misleading. There is no feasible way that Google ends up owning the entire market. And I'm not talking about the actual cars, because they're definitely not getting in the car making business. Even when it comes to the software, they could only be the only provider in the market if it becomes a government regulated monopoly. As a side note, I think the resistance to driverless cars will be a big psychological stumbling block. I can't ride in the passenger seat of a car without hitting the "brakes" and pressing my foot into the floor. It will be tough to break habits and to trust that the software is safe.
- OGinparadise 14y agoFasten Your Seatbelts: Google's Driverless Car Is Worth Trillions Amazing! He studied and compared all other driver-less cars to Google's and came to this conclusion. I know a writer getting paid for clicks wouldn't forget that virtually every major car company is working on http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Driverless_car#History http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Driverless_car#History
- dmix 14y agoXerox's GUI was worth trillions.
- megablast 14y agoIt is easy to throw out a statement like that, but hard to justify. How big would computers be today without the GUI, with a different system.
- kamaal 14y agoJust like how Xerox was unable to realize the value of what they had. Its very possible the car makers too, might think on the same line. Sometimes you need a outsider to show you how powerful your own work can be.
- thesash 14y agoOr that google isn't an auto manufacturer...
- shaurz 14y agoNot yet.
- cremnob 14y agoA lot of people here seem to have the blinders on about this. It's kind of funny. I've posted this before the last time this came up. Car companies have been working on this for a while, unless Google's offering is just light years ahead of the rest, no car company is going to pay a Google tax for this tech (and it's unlikely it will be any better than what they are already working on). https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5017784 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5017784
- jmspring 14y agoThe next several years should prove "interesting" for the car market. Driverless cars and assorted state DOT departments pushing for black boxes in cars on the basis of tracking milage are both going to see pushback from the general public. I've bought two new cars (and 1 used) in the last 15 years. The oldest lasted 11 years and 256000 miles. The used was a truck when I bought my house. The newest is a diesel wagon getting 40+ miles to the gallon, I don't plan on selling it anytime soon. I will be loath to add GPS for purposes of tax calculation (sure it can be done based off registration or other means -- at least the GPS data isn't there). And, I don't predict any incentive to move people from driving their own cars to self-driving cars. The above is in addition to the "independence" baked into the American culture about the open road and the automobile.
- vecinu 14y agoThe above is in addition to the "independence" baked into the American culture about the open road and the automobile. Do you think there is something inherently wrong with the feeling of independence and happiness attained from the car culture in the US? I am still dubious that self-driving and non-self-driving cars will be able to share a road in the future. If this doesn't happen, I doubt Americans will freely give up their 'right' to drive the way they want.
- jmspring 14y ago"Do you think there is something inherently wrong with the feeling of independence and happiness attained from the car culture in the US?" Not at all. Note, I had a car that in 12 years, I put 256000 miles on, while I had a second vehicle during that time that had many miles put on it as well. I personally love road trips. One area where modern vehicles (hybrids and eventually self-driving) have no place (for now) is off roaring. Every year or two, I do road trips that include up to (and sometimes exceeding) 1000 miles off road -- not just dirt, but jeep trails, high clearance, having one person act as a spotter kind of stuff. Where my comment was directed is that all the technology in the world isn't going to do away with the car culture you point out anytime soon (probably not in my lifetime).
- 14y ago
- rayiner 14y agoPedantry: not "Google's Driverless Car" but rather "Google's IPR on Driverless Cars" (http://www.foxnews.com/leisure/2011/12/16/google-granted-patent-for-driverless-car-technology http://www.foxnews.com/leisure/2011/12/16/google-granted-pat...).
- fourstar 14y agoSensationalist headline but I can conclude that Google and SpaceX are the tech leaders of our generation. Love hearing about companies focused on the future. To think that potentially this guy who has to depend on other people to take care of him and drive him places, or he has to take the bus, won't have to because he can hop into his self-driving car and be independent.
- spc476 14y agoHmm, no mention of the disruptions in employment due to driverless cars. There go taxi drivers, bus drivers and a big segment---truck drivers, so I would expect a large push back from the various unions (I'm extrapolating from _The Box_, a history of container shipping).
- elchief 14y agoAmerica still has unions?
- clarky07 14y agoThe interesting part about this is everything mentioned was about saving money on things. It sounds like it could destroy a few trillion in revenue. I don't think it is actually worth trillions to google though. (Obviously it could be worth a lot though)
- Cushman 14y agoI've been saying this to anyone who will listen for years. I really believe this technology will touch everything. Real estate markets will shift dramatically as the average commute time halves or quarters. Transport costs will plummet, making every single physical object cheaper. Public transit will be dirt cheap, always punctual, and take you absolutely anywhere. Tens of thousands of people each year will escape death; millions will lose their jobs. Safe to say I'm really, really excited about the future.
- Joeri 14y ago90 percent of those in the transportation sector will lose their jobs. Car companies will go broke when demand plummets. Pizza delivery will not be an entrylevel job. I think the net effect will be hugely positive, but like all paradigm shifts this is going to cause immense social upheaval and initially look like it only makes things worse.
- chrischen 14y agoBorrow money from the future to buy their complacency!
- jaggederest 14y agoOnly about 8m people in the US, we've lost more than that from the manufacturing sector over the last couple decades. The big effects will be on other aspects. No more drunk driving. Fractional ownership of cars.
- visarga 14y agoTaxi driving, RIP.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- rooshdi 14y agoTraffic tickets, BIH.
- gfodor 14y agoI'm going to disagree with other posters that Google is not going to own this market. It's hard to think of another company that is even close to being able to execute on this. It's the ultimate big data problem. The in-house experience of Google at running computing infrastructure is a must-have for this type of system to work.
- jaggederest 14y agoIt honestly makes me think that, much in the way that SpaceX is a sleeper for Elon Musk's desire to retire on Mars, so too was Google a sleeper to produce enough data and computing power to honestly enable self-driving cars. $15T GDP, ten percent of which is transportation. I think that a truly self-driving car and truck could eat 20% of that, easily. So $300b a year...
- defrost 14y agoRio Tinto. Not for general public driving, of course, but for fleets of trucks and excavators that operate globally 24/7. At various sites they are already operating driverless equipment using tech developed in house. For what it's worth, oil & gas & mineral exploration work drove a large part of the civilian development of tools like Google Earth / Google Maps in the decades prior to the first public offerings by Google (who acquired their tech from others (the chaps from Sydney for Maps, Keyhole for Earth)).
- gfodor 14y agoI still see it as orders of magnitudes off in complexity. You're talking about a system for autonomously controlling every motor vehicle in the U.S., or even the world -- that's effectively the end game. Google is among the handful of companies that has the computing infrastructure to have a "pulse" on the world at all times, and within those companies they are heads and shoulders above the rest in terms of being able to implement large scale, distributed information processing algorithms with low latency at that scale. It's a very rare, maybe completely unique cross section of capabilities. Google is better suited to solving this problem in many ways than any other problem they're currently solving. The point is the capabilities I'm talking about have nothing to do with cars and everything to do with computing. Pointing to another company doing autonomous vehicles as a counterexample is kinda-sorta missing my point.
- maym86 14y agoThe world will be a better place: Blind people, disabled people, people unable to drive in any way will be more independent. No need for expensive parking in a city. Car can go somewhere else cheaper. Expensive land used for parking can be better utilised. You can rent your car out to others while you’re not using it. No real need for personal car ownership. Why pay to own when you can rent whenever you need from car manufacturers or rental companies? Get the car that best suits your needs for a particular day at your door when you need it. Cars spend a lot if their life doing nothing. The car will be fully utilised and always in service making the most of the valuable resources used to build it. A car no longer needs to be car shaped. You can have cars for specific needs. A bar car if you want! Traffic efficiency when everyone has them. The road network can be utilised more effectively as the cars will be able to share data and calculate the best route. You can spend more time doing other things like looking at their adverts. They will be safer. Computers won’t make the mistakes caused by humans doing stupid things like sending text messages while driving. Drink driving. The won’t break the speed limit etc.
- thoughtcriminal 14y agoWe'll all be dead from toxic smog before Google's driverless cars get anywhere. I think the idea is extremely shortsighted. It's a technological feat but not a creative one. It just produces more cars, more fuel-burning and more roads. It's more cars and that will produce more pollution. Ultimately, it solves nothing. You want to stop deadly car crashes? Help save wildlife from excessive roads and urban sprawl? Stop driving. Live and work locally. But that would take real change.
- jaggederest 14y ago> We will need more roads, more cars and that will produce more pollution. Nope. Less. Cars-per-person will nosedive from almost 1:1 in the US right now to maybe 1:5 - that means the embodied energy wasted on cars will go down. Per-mile energy costs will go down too, if cars are driven efficiently. It also enables the large-scale conversion of the US car fleet to electric propulsion. Cars can recharge themselves and aren't range limited because you can swap cars rather than waiting. It's huge. It's as big as the invention of the car was. All the human hours wasted on moving things from A to B will gradually go away.
- visarga 14y agoImagine the delivery systems - FedEx, DHL, etc. Fresh food every day delivered from the farm? Not a problem any more. Also, regarding pollution - traveling salesman algorithm optimizations would reduce the distance travelled and CO2 emitted for the same outcome.
- thoughtcriminal 14y agoThat's a lot of ifs, and making a lot of assumptions. We don't have this kind of time. For God sakes, please snap out of your delusion.
- r0s 14y agoYou're deluded if you think car culture in the US can change significantly anytime soon. Call me a cynic, and I'll call you a fool. If you want to throw around platitudes, why not address the real problem: uncontrolled population. Or does that make you uncomfortable?
- chimpinee 14y agoCombine driverless cars with electric motors. Add a few driver-free high speed tunnels which connect to the existing road network (I assume tunnelling will eventually be cheaper than building new roads). Then we'll have a growing, backwards-compatible high speed freight distribution system which delivers to the doorstep. And as cars get quieter and pollution free (locally) our cities will suddenly become civilised places to walk around in, breathing freely. Maybe we'll hang out like philosophers in the market squares of Athens or Florence :-)
- weltall 14y agohonestly, isn't this the future you imagined? it's amazing how we see this for the first time and are initially underwhelmed or blase.
- h2s 14y agoHoly shit. Forbes is an absolute cesspool of a website. There are about three paragraphs of text, and then I have to pony up another ad impression by clicking through to the next page in order to keep reading. All the while, two enormous fixed nav bars follow my every move at both the top and the bottom of the page. Meanwhile a veritable flotilla of fixed-position "social icons" on the left beg me to help Forbes advertise their content. And to the right of the article? Adverts as far as the eye can see. Even within that center column, the content is occasionally interrupted with links to other unrelated content. And below the article text itself are a bunched of "Sponsored Content You Might Like" links doing their very best to look similar to "Related Stories". What's going on here? Is this what it takes for Forbes to turn a profit?
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- tiziano88 14y agoAt least the mobile version looks kind of Ok, only a small banner at the bottom, though the pagination is most definitely annoying, especially because it prevents Pocket from correctly extracting the text from the article.
- tzs 14y agoTheir print links[1] are pretty good though. Normally, I object to linking to print pages because they usually are formatted in a way that makes them unreadable (e.g., very tiny font and very wide columns), and often provide no way to reasonably find the non-print version if you want to look for things like comments and related articles. However, the Forbes print link uses a reasonable font and a reasonable column width, and has at the bottom a link to the non-print page. (It does invoke a print dialog, which is a bit annoying). [1] http://www.forbes.com/sites/chunkamui/2013/01/22/fasten-your-seatbelts-googles-driverless-car-is-worth-trillions/print/ http://www.forbes.com/sites/chunkamui/2013/01/22/fasten-your...
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- tluyben2 14y agoSo how many years are we talking until we see them in the US? Europe? Asia? Not seeing 1 or 2 with millionaires in them but when I buy any car I have the option, or, even better, it's mandatory driverless (which makes sense as the roads would be safer with only driverless cars there)? For me, this would actually be a solid reason to move to the country they have it first. I find driving an absolute waste of time, but busses and metros and trains are just not a good substitute unless almost empty and comfortable (which most are not).
- elchief 14y agoSergei Brin of Google has promised < 5 years for an average joe. And that was 6 months ago.
- tluyben2 14y agoThat would be the US I guess, but that's close enough :) Hopefully they can do it!
- tokenadult 14y agoSergey Brin's actual statement was "You can count on one hand the number of years until ordinary people can experience this" as transcribed from an interview. http://www.computerworld.com/s/article/9231707/Self_driving_cars_a_reality_for_39_ordinary_people_39_within_5_years_says_Google_39_s_Sergey_Brin http://www.computerworld.com/s/article/9231707/Self_driving_... That is an ambitious prediction, and I wonder what that suggests about the cost of the self-driving system, as fewer and fewer cars look affordable to many "ordinary people" these days. I think Brin, being a billionaire for several years now, may have a warped sense of what "ordinary people" can really afford, so I give it ten years till I'm likely to be able to buy a car with self-driving features. But that means I can buy at most just one more car without self-driving features (to replace a car that threatens to fail at any moment, after almost 170,000 miles of driving since 1999), and then the next car I buy will be a self-driving car. Cool.
- chrisfromto 14y ago
- gfodor 14y agoOne of great ironies of the 21st century is going to be that humanity had to build autonomous flying drones before it could build autonomous cars (to develop the algorithms), and autonomous cars before it could build flying cars (because average people could never be reasonably expected to pilot a flying car.) But mark my words in 2100 we will, at last, have flying autonomous cars (or something that can be described that way.)
- thepirateway 14y agoAmazing use of machine learning which solves the real world problem. This is kind of innovation which give the sign that Google is getting bigger everyday.
- gadders 14y agoOne overlooked factor is how much marital discord this will save. "I drove last time, it's your turn to drive." "But they'll be serving just beer. You don't even like beer." etc etc I also look forward to the day when you will be able to go to the pub, get absolutely wankered, and still be able to get home safely without waiting for cabs.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]