14 ms·
Bitcoin exchange hacked via Rails exploit, funds stolen
- Pr0 14y agoThe good news is that they are going to cover the losses: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=135919.msg1448056#msg1448056 https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=135919.msg1448056#ms... edit: I was wrong about the title, see below comment.
- wereHamster 14y agoNo, some other site (https://bitcoin-central.net/ https://bitcoin-central.net/) fixed it within 5 minutes, not the one that was compromised (https://vircurex.com/ https://vircurex.com/).
- dirtyaura 14y agoVircurex developer Kumala says on the thread that they will cover the losses: "Before the wild speculations beginn, the service will be recovered and we pay the losses out of our own pockets."
- pavel_lishin 14y agoI guess this is still the Wild Wild West era of Bitcoin; I'd wager plenty of banks got knocked off by bandits back in the day, too. What happened to a bank's customer's funds if it got robbed prior to 1933?
- pdog 14y agoThe banking system was already very sophisticated pre-1930s.
- hexis 14y agoIn the US, at least, people still got famous for being bank robbers back then. The FDIC, which provides limited insurance for bank deposits, started their insurance on January 1, 1934. So, sophistication aside, it's an interesting question what happened to depositors after a bank robbery.
- maxerickson 14y agoFDIC doesn't insure against robberies.
- tptacek 14y agoNo, but banks are insured against robbery.
- maxerickson 14y agoSure. I was headed in the direction of the FDIC not changing much about robberies.
- sp332 14y agoThe FDIC doesn't cover bank robberies. https://www.fdic.gov/consumers/consumer/information/fdiciorn.html https://www.fdic.gov/consumers/consumer/information/fdiciorn...
- nickpinkston 14y agoThough I believe they've got another form of insurance for this.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- roel_v 14y ago"In the US, at least, people still got famous for being bank robbers back then." What are you talking about? People are still famous for being bank robbers, e.g. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_bank_robbers_and_robberies#United_States http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_bank_robbers_and_robber... . FDIC insurance has nothing to do with robberies, it insures against banks going bankrupt.
- pavel_lishin 14y agoMy question was, specifically: It's 1903, you deposit your life savings into your local bank, and a week alter it gets robbed. Do you get any of that money back? Or are you now broke?
- glesica 14y agoHow would the bank know whose money got stolen? It's basically a bad question. If the bank fails because of the robbery, then you lose all your money in 1903 (or at least most of it). Otherwise, things just keep on trucking as normal. Edit: See the response from raganwald
- raganwald 14y agoA deposit is an IOU from the bank to you; If the bank fails as a result of the robbery, you are SOL. However, if the bank remains solvent, it absorbs the loss. In most cases, even a large robbery wouldn't ruin a bank: They could borrow against or sell their mortgages to another bank for cash to pay depositors. This is different than a safety deposit box: The fine print is that you are responsible for its contents and if the bank is robbed, they will not replace the contents or reimburse you. So, if you put your life savings into gold and put the gold in a safety deposit box, you lose. If you put your life savings in a deposit account, you will be reimbursed unless the bank fails outright. (Prior to the creation of the FDIC in the US or deposit insurance in Canada).
- Graham24 14y agoshort answer: you get your money back.
- raganwald 14y agoBanks don't keep all of their assets in cash in the safe. In its very simplest form, a bank takes money from depositors and pays a small "savings" rate. It then lends this money to borrowers at a higher rate. Every dollar in the safe is a dollar that isn't out earning interest, so the bank wants to only keep enough on hand to cover what customers will need for withdrawals. I met an ex bank robber once. He and his "gang" attempted to rob a branch that was near a factory. The factory employed a number of immigrants who were fond of cashing their entire paycheques on pay day, so it would bring in a lot of extra cash every pay day. They timed their robbery for when the payroll money was present. Unfortunately for them, the scheme had been rumbled, so the payroll delivery was fake and the police were waiting in plain clothes for them. He was shot in the neck but survived and learned to play bridge in prison, and in the fullness of time was released, where I met him and heard his story. Any ways... It seems quite possible to me that a bank could be robbed but remain solvent.
- makomk 14y agoMost Bitcoin exchanges - apparently including this one - only store a small portion of their funds in the wallet on their live server for exactly the same reason. They claim they can cover the loss.
- michaelfeathers 14y agoRobert Heinlein makes good meat out of this misunderstanding of banking in his book 'Time Enough for Love'. The nearly immortal protagonist often ends up being the banker in a small frontier towns. He routinely has to deal with mobs of people who attempt to "nationalize the bank" and are dumbfounded to discover that the bank does have all of the money in a safe.
- eduardordm 14y agoPlus, there is the compulsory reserve you need to send to the central bank. Example: http://www.centralbank.ie/mpolbo/mpo/pages/reserve.aspx http://www.centralbank.ie/mpolbo/mpo/pages/reserve.aspx
- numbsafari 14y agoIt probably depends. Banks are typically capitalized by a variety of assets, of which cash is typically a small amount. In addition, the bank typically has its cash holdings distributed at a number of different branches. Your account at the bank is technically it's liability. Essentially, you've loaned your money to the bank with an option to redeem it at any point in time (demand-deposit account, or checking account) or up to some period of time after asking for it (time-deposit account, or savings account). So, let's say a bank's branch is robbed of $10,000. What happens? The banks shareholder lose $10,000. Let's say all the cash and physical assets at a branch is robbed. The bank will typically cover those assets with assets from other branches. The bank's shareholders swallow the losses. Sometimes the bank will sell additional shares, or some of its remaining real assets to help provide it with more liquidity so it can continue to cover funds requests by account holders. Let's say a bank has all its assets in cash in a single branch location and that location is robbed, meaning the bank now has no assets left. That bank is now bankrupt. It goes to bankruptcy court and you are a creditor. Once the banks remaining assets are sold, you may get a few pennies. This is a major failing of the existing bitcoin repositories. They aren't banks and so aren't regulated as such. They're just storage lockers where you hide your cash under a mattress. In the event of a theft or fraud... oh well! It'd be interesting to see someone get a bank charter and backup those bitcoin deposits with real capital.
- numbsafari 14y agoIt should be obvious that the above is a gross simplification on my part and the FDIC and modern banking arrangements make things much more complicated when it comes to bank failures. That said, the simplification gets to the original question of what happens without modern banking arrangements.
- pbhjpbhj 14y ago>Let's say a bank has all its assets in cash in a single branch location and that location is robbed, meaning the bank now has no assets left. // Governments can and do offer an insurance system whereby they will ensure that customers receive a substantial part of their monies back - this aids against bank runs (where customers panic and all try to withdraw their money as cash and so cause the bank to implode).
- lucisferre 14y agoA lot of banks get knocked off today http://www.fbi.gov/stats-services/publications/bank-crime-statistics-2011/bank-crime-statistics-2011-q1 http://www.fbi.gov/stats-services/publications/bank-crime-st...
- makomk 14y agoYeah, most banks just intentionally try not to publicise the fact they've been robbed from what I've heard - it's bad for business and tends to encourage future robbers.
- noahjk 14y ago> tends to encourage future robbers If only people would understand this about school shootings and the like
- slajax 14y agoWow awesome link. That fully blows my mind.
- viraptor 14y agoI wasn't expecting this, but it feels good to know: "Number of incidents in which deaths occurred: 3" all 3 were the perpetrators rather than employees / customers. On the other hand 2 hostages being the employee's family members is disappointing. It's really sad that people really do involve the families of targets just for a bank robbery.
- illuminate 14y agoAnd aside from movies, the meth-heads can only carry and drive off with so much money. A few thousand here and there. It's a very inefficient time to be a bankrobber. http://www.allgov.com/news/unusual-news/robbing-banks-is-not-a-cost-efficient-profession?news=844940 http://www.allgov.com/news/unusual-news/robbing-banks-is-not... "Using confidential data on the value of every bank heist in the U.K. from 2005 to 2008, the trio came up with an economic model of bank robbery. They found that the average revenue from a British bank robbery in 2005-2008 was only $31,600, although excluding the one-third of robberies that came up dry boosts the average to $46,600. But those proceeds have to be divided among the gang, and while extra gang members raise the average take, the haul per person decreases. The average take per person per successful job was $19,792, equivalent to less than six months’ average wage in the UK, although being armed increased revenues substantially. While that may not sound too bad, multiple jobs greatly increase the risk of arrest and incarceration, as 20% of heists ended that way. Data from the FBI paint a similar picture. In 2011, there were 5,086 bank robberies in the U.S., generating $38,343,501.96 in revenues for the perpetrators, or an average of $7,539 per heist. Excluding the robberies where nothing was taken increases the average only to $8,457. Not only is the return low, the risk is high: out of 13 people killed during bank robberies in 2011, 10 were robbers."
- tveita 14y agoIf only there were some way to learn from history - then it wouldn't take newly launched services decades to meet basic modern security standards. Seriously, I don't see any comparison between this and a bank robbery. It's not like banks in 1933 were only just figuring out that they should lock the door where they stored the money, or that they should repair any holes in the wall, or even that paper walls, though they are quick to build, have a very bad record on security.
- lucb1e 14y agoWell, this is what I'd call service! "Before the wild speculations beginn, the service will be recovered and we pay the losses out of our own pockets." If they can, of course. But still, a very nice gesture.
- bstar77 14y agoI can't get to the article at the moment, but I'd love to know why they failed to update their app especially since it handles financial transactions. I had several apps to update and the process took very little time and effort.
- kindaobv 14y agoHey, are you also basically free, well-advertised and available to everyone in the world who is running rails simultaneously I don't understand why they also didn't use you then.
- anonymouz 14y agoCache: https://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache%3Ahttps%3A%2F%2Fbitcointalk.org%2Findex.php%3Ftopic%3D135919.0 https://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache%3Ahttp... . It's a forum post without any details - your question is raised, but has (so far) not been answered.
- utnick 14y agoIt's not excusable really, but I'm not too surprised. It was only a day or so from when a patch was available to when a public exploit was everywhere. Maybe they were on vacation, maybe the site was built by contractors who have since moved on, maybe they don't read hackernews or other programming news sources. I expect to see similar stories in the coming weeks.
- revelation 14y agoOr, you know, why their wallet is compromised just because the web interface is. It's like a CA that creates the certificates in PHP right there.
- btilly 14y agoThis is a remote code exploit. For the web interface to do its job, it needs to be able to manipulate the wallet. They can stare at the code that does that, write their own, and do whatever they want.
- batgaijin 14y agojust out of curiosity, is anybody, uh, mortally afraid of running a bitcoin exchange? I feel like once you have 100k+ in there you become a target for some very persuasive people... http://xkcd.com/538/ http://xkcd.com/538/
- meaty 14y agoWell that's not really a surprise. Perhaps the "Rails generation" will gain some engineering, product selection and QA skills now. There's a big reason banks operate the way they do with the kit they do.
- Xylakant 14y agoEven given I must admit that this was a spectacularly stupid hole[1], I don't think your point is valid. It's not like other frameworks in other languages don't have similar issues [2]. Rails is for what it does well engineered, well tested and using it for what it's intended is usually a solid choice. Rails enables and pushes testing on all levels, thus improving quality of all rails apps that follow the lead. You can argue that rails is not a good fit for a lot of use cases, but that's a completely different argument - and one I usually agree with - but all in all rails and its ecosystem pushes exactly the values that you say are missing. [1] Auto-Unmarshalling yaml in xml, seriously? Who wants yaml in xml? [2] I'm sorry to single out spring here, but this is a nice example since it's the same kind of attack: Instatiation of an arbitrary class, in this case by modifying the class loader and loading the class from a remote server: http://support.springsource.com/security/cve-2010-1622 http://support.springsource.com/security/cve-2010-1622
- amalag 14y agoAs a Rails developer myself, it is really embarrassing to admit that all Rails apps in the last few years have been completely and totally vulnerable. The good point that it was discovered by security researchers without a known exploit is good, but we don't know if it was previously exploited without anyone's knowledge. Maybe there were smart pen testers who were routinely getting in to Rails apps without anyone's knowledge for years.
- Xylakant 14y agoI completely agree: It's a stupid bug that lingered long in the codebase, probably because it was hidden in an obscure feature that nobody knew about or used. It's embarrassing, but I bet that pretty much every larger framework out there had a remote code execution bug[1]. Still, it's wrong to point at it and say "that's an engineering or QA bug that's symptomatic for the rails bunch." I'm not a rails friend, but the response showed that the rails developers take security and QA serious. Patches and workarounds were released not only for the supported versions, but also for older, long-dead releases. [1] Sinatra didn't, but that's < 1000 LOC.
- muyuu 14y agoPeople still keep big hot wallets?? Wow.
- Benferhat 14y agoThey probably had a decent chunk in cold storage, which is why they can afford to 'cover the losses': "Before the wild speculations beginn, the service will be recovered and we pay the losses out of our own pockets." [0] [0] https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=135919.msg1448056#msg1448056 https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=135919.msg1448056#ms...
- drcode 14y agoLooks like this is one of those stories that belongs in an "always-true" newspaper, along with "tensions in the middle east escalating" and "congressman apologizes for affair".
- TazeTSchnitzel 14y agoIf it's that easy to steal, you're probably doing it wrong. The front-end server should never have direct access to the bitcoin RPC server, since the front-end is likely to be vulnerable. Instead, it should contact a robust back end server, which then talks to the RPC.
- badgar 14y agoBitcoin bank developers commonly "do it wrong."
- TazeTSchnitzel 14y agoUnfortunately. It's a real shame that despite the security features of the client and such, nobody seems to use them.
- the_cat_kittles 14y agoSeems like it's high time for someone to come along who knows how to do it right.
- SkyMarshal 14y agoI don't think the economics are there yet to attract such people.
- TazeTSchnitzel 14y agoI think someone has, but they ran off with the money of their users.
- rplnt 14y agoIf anyone has problem accessing the site, it's Vircurex and Cryptostocks. "Before the wild speculations beginn, the service will be recovered and we pay the losses out of our own pockets." from this summary: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=135926.msg1447905 https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=135926.msg1447905
- hnolable 14y agoThe majority of legitimate people running Bitcoin related services are of a very fringe type. It will probably remain this way for a while. This is because there is so much risk involved. Not just risk of currency or business failure, but risk of harsh legal action. The subsection of the population this selects for ends up being... let's say... not so reliable. Then worse, you have tons of internet criminals coming up with clever strategies to part people with their Bitcoin. Will these guys reimburse their users or end up giving an excuse and disappearing into the ether? Only time will tell. That said, Bitcoin itself remains strong and probably one of technologies with the biggest potential in quite a long time. These issues will continue to occur and spawn drama for the foreseeable future. At some point the good Bitcoin news will drown out the bad Bitcoin business news. But that's not going to happen anytime soon. So let's get used to it.
- DanBC 14y agoAre these different exchanges at least talking to each other and trying to learn from experience? Is there a Best Current Practice for all steps in BitCoin - for people wanting to buy or sell bitcoins; for people wanting to trade goods for bitcoin; for people wanting to run bitcoin financial services or exchanges?
- MrBra 14y agoI suspect that a lot of anti ruby / rails people are happy to have the occasion to prove that the language and framework that they didn't want to learn is ...bad... and are posting these news all around the web... with that small grin in their mind... fair enough... but rest assured, Ruby & Rails haven't even came close to the end of their ass-kicking :)
- eertami 14y agoI'm pretty sure this would be news no matter how the exchange was exploited.
- MrBra 14y agonews, not town's fair adverts
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- danielweber 14y agoI'm building a new site from scratch soon, and was considering what language, and decided against RoR because of this. Perhaps not rationally, but it's been 5 years since I last did RoR, and I know there's a lot I don't know that's changed in that time. So better to stick with devils I know.
- MrBra 14y agoI wouldn't call this an informed decision...
- danielweber 14y agoIt's a decision about how uninformed I am. While I could certainly learn to become an expert in RoR security, I shouldn't do it on this specific project.
- bdcravens 14y ago
- vannevar 14y agoThere seems to be a pattern emerging in all of these 'disruptive' business models, whether it be Bitcoin (banking), AirBnb (hotels), or Uber (cabs). We look around and see these industries burdened by regulation, which tends to create entrenched players and which seem to us to be inefficient. So we create similar peer-to-peer equivalents, only to start rediscovering the reasons for all those regulations in the first place. I would argue that one reason mature industries seem inefficient to us is that it's been so long since we've encountered the problems the regulatory 'inefficiencies' were meant to address, that we've forgotten why our ancestors put them in place. Peer-to-peer is not a new idea, it's how things worked back before we started using government to solve the problems inherent in the peer-to-peer model.
- AlexMuir 14y agoBrilliant point. It's a case of experimenting with the balance of freedom vs regulation. Perhaps it's not vital that a hotel(or taxi) is licensed today, because we can easily see its realtime feedback from previous users. But then again, perhaps those users don't notice that there is no emergency lighting and the fire alarm is disabled, or that the driver has multiple convictions for dishonesty.
- jberryman 14y ago> it's been so long since we've encountered the problems the regulatory 'inefficiencies' were meant to address. This is the same effect that has made the anti-vaccine movement popular.
- snitko 14y agoExcept that regulating things is not the same as holding a monopoly on regulations. If government is so completely confident that its currency is much more superior and stable, well, allow the competition! Make it legal to receive whatever I want to receive as a payment. Let businesses regulate the currency market and determine what currency is reliable. Oh wait, except that then government cannot tax you, of course. Also, this incident has nothing to do with regulating bitcoins. It has to do with Rails and this particular exchange site, whose reputation is now damaged and who's going to lose business. Note how free market works great in this case: the organization costs people their lost money and will most likely go out of business. Unlike big banks.
- jart 14y ago> The system was not breached, no passwords were compromised (they are salted and multiple times hashed anyways) When they say "multiple times" I hope that means they're using PBKDF2 or bcrypt, because if they were simply using SHA1 then their users are even more doomed.
- Xylakant 14y agoGiven that this is a Remote Code Execution vulnerability I'd be very careful about the "not breached" as well. For all we know, the attacker could still have a shell or a rootkit on the server.
- lallysingh 14y agoIf you want to get free security research from the best in the business, running a bitcoin exchange seems like a lovely way to do it. Just keep good logs to a write-only device.
- gst 14y agoAfter the Rails exploit was announced I was jokingly mentioning to a friend that this will hit a few Bitcoin exchanges. Seems there are still exchange operators that haven't learned anything about the previous exploits.
- astrodust 14y agoAny exchange operator that didn't stop whatever they were doing, be it eating a sandwich or having a baby, and run to patch their servers has failed their user base completely. This was no undocumented zero day hack.
- hackerboos 14y agoExactly. They should have shut down immediately. This is amateur hour for the Bitcoin community, yet again.
- UnoriginalGuy 14y agoAn exchange operator that operates both the exchange its self and its web-facing front end from the same server(s). You really have to wonder what they were thinking? While a front end compromise is always going to be bad, splitting the two gives you more options and more ability to spot when the front end is acting unusually.
- JulianMorrison 14y agoIf you are writing a bank, write it in SPARK Ada.
- mattlong 14y agoIt's likely due to confirmation bias, but it seems that almost every bitcoin company has some (usually careless or inexcusable) gap in their security...
- danielweber 14y agoBack when I cared about bitcoin, I'd go look at their websites for vulnerabilities and usually find them. Then I would tell them. They never replied but did fix them.
- Benferhat 14y agoWhat made you stop caring?
- danielweber 14y agoI built a simple program to transfer money between two of my wallets, and .01 bitcoin (a substantial fraction of my bitcoin wealth) disappeared as a transaction cost. I asked around and was told "oh, yeah, they changed the defaults recently so there is always a transaction cost, you should pay closer attention to mailing list X, it's more up-to-date than the API documentation." I decided I didn't like dealing with something where I had to assume the fine print was out to screw me and walked away. I have other things to do with my life. (I probably am misremembering a few details of something that took place a few years ago.)
- Benferhat 14y agoYes, fuck transaction costs! I understand why we have them, though.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- scorcher 14y agoPerhaps I'm being nieve but it seems like very bad coding when front end exploits can lead to cash being stolen. I would expect the bare minimum of a message bus or some other separation between back end payment components and the public facing boxes.
- martinced 14y agoBasically all the comments points to how amateurish that exchange was run compared to a real online banking website. Now how many real banks do run their website using Rails? Ruby? You guys certainly aren't as stupid as to believe this is the latest major 0-day Rails exploit to create havoc right? And now comes the answers containing the logical fallacy: "All languages/frameworks have security issues". Which is rubbish in that it would imply that all the languages/frameworks do offer exactly the same level of security...
- tlowrimore 14y agoMany banks like to use Java rather than something amateurish like Ruby. Here's a link for you, I'll let you draw your own conclusions: http://blog.trendmicro.com/trendlabs-security-intelligence/java-zero-day-exploit-in-the-wild-spreading-ransomware/?utm_source=feedburner&utm_medium=feed&utm_campaign=Feed%3A+Anti-MalwareBlog+(Trendlabs+Security+Intelligence+Blog) http://blog.trendmicro.com/trendlabs-security-intelligence/j... Cheers!
- benmmurphy 14y agoand if people ran ruby applets in the browser they would have much worse security :) java client sandbox is a different story than java server side
- dons 14y agoMost languages are inappropriate for highly sensitive information or other critical systems. You don't see the the aerospace industry putting Ruby hardware controllers into planes, nor do you see the defense industry putting classified information behind Ruby web servers.
- raesene2 14y agoWhile you're obviously correct to imply that languages/frameworks have different levels of security the problem with that proposition is how does a prospective user of the framework assess the level of security it provides? You could argue that "big, enterprise" systems are likely to be more secure, but experience with things like Oracle databases around 8/9/10 would indicate that's not always a good measure. You could argue (and people do) that the framework being open source is a good thing, or a bad thing. So absent that information how would someone factor that into their choice of system?
- mark_l_watson 14y agoWow, that was such an easy patch, too. I only had one affected app. I just bumped my Gemfile to rails 3.2.11, gem update.
- TallboyOne 14y agoAnd this is why I would NEVER in 10,000 years trust an anonymous form of money that can't be recovered or tracked to a group of average developers who in this case are obviously are amateur and don't even respond to massive critical security updates. I'm sure all the rest are like that to some degree as well. No thanks, I'll stick with cash under my matress before ever using that. I feel bad for anyone that actually got screwed because of this.
- mrb 14y agoYou are wrong, bitcoins can be "tracked". The whole point of the Bitcoin block chain is to track all transactions. The community has developed a few tool to track "tainted" money. Also, you already trust an anonymous form of money: cash. Why so? Mostly because insurance exists against cash theft. As the Bitcoin ecosystem develops, eventually an insurance market will develop too. It sounds like Bitcoin is too unmature for you. So, wait. In this theft case, the exchange itself is providing this insurance to you: they guaranteed they will cover the stolen funds themselves. Also, the beauty of Bitcoin is that you don't have to trust an exchange like the one that was the victim of the theft. You can decide to take care of your own security by storing bitcoins on your own computer. There are a few efforts in progress to develop credit-card sized hardware wallet in order to provide extremely safe bitcoin wallets to non-technical users who are unable to, or don't know how to keep a computer secure for hosting a Bitcoin wallet. Again, it sounds like you need to wait for these efforts to mature before judging Bitcoin.
- TallboyOne 14y agoAlright, fair enough. I suppose my point moreso was that the fate of your very hard earned cash was bested by a rails update that any noob developer should have seen. Given that simple scenario, think about who is watching your money.. That's great its ensured though. Good deal
- jacquesm 14y agoYou're confusing several things there. Bitcoin the protocol and rails the framework are not the same thing. Bitcoin was never compromised, rails was, and if these devs would have done their work and patched their servers they'd have been fine.
- api 14y agoAs soon as I heard about the Rails 'sploit, I was waiting for the first Bitcoin exchange to get hit.
- lucb1e 14y agoRelated: http://securityreactions.tumblr.com/post/40252712480/me-waiting-for-someone-to-use-the-rails-0-day-to-plant http://securityreactions.tumblr.com/post/40252712480/me-wait...
- bdcravens 14y agoSo where's DHH's long blog post? Last I checked, he was still in charge. He's quick to talk about hypermedia, or his latest Le Mans effort, or how profitable Rails apps are.
- kawsper 14y agoI wondered this myself, but I think the reason is that there is a lot of eyes on 37signals and DHH. I think they downplay it a bit till the storm rides over and people get patched up.
- cs702 14y agoImagine that a thief breaks and enters into a warehouse which is holding physical gold for its customers, and the thief steals all their gold. The warehouse and/or its customers will suffer losses, but every single ounce of the gold stolen by the thief will continue to be as valuable as any other ounce of gold. In other words, gold will continue to be the same exact commodity. Essentially the same thing has happened here, but in the digital realm. A thief (or thieves) broke into the backend systems of an exchange which was holding bitcoins for its customers, and the thief stole all their bitcoins. The exchange and/or its customers have suffered losses, but every single bitcoin stolen by the thief will continue to be as valuable as any other bitcoin. In other words, Bitcoin will continue to be the same exact commodity -- its integrity has NOT been compromised. The moral of this story: if you own bitcoins, make sure they are stored in a truly secure system. Many Bitcoin exchanges claim to be -- but really aren't -- truly secure!
- thomasz 14y ago> its integrity has NOT been compromised Shesh. A Bitcoin has no inherent value. If such incidents become common enough, nobody will be willing to buy bitcoins for dollars or accept bitcoins as payments for goods,which means that the thieves will sit on a bunch of useless bits.
- a-stjohn 14y ago...which is also no different than paper money, or the money we store digitally in our banks...
- philwelch 14y agoThe difference is, you can't pay your taxes in bitcoin.
- coconutrandom 14y agoYou can't pay your taxes in gold. Or yuan for that matter. That doesn't invalidate it as a currency.
- rprasad 14y agoThe Bitcoin economy is learning, repeatedly, the hard way, that financial systems security is one of the most difficult, intransigent problems that any business will face. The goal posts are constantly moving, and there are always people trying to break in.
- temphn 14y agoWell, with a Bitcoin bank, at least as a customer you have a chance of not being robbed. By contrast, if you keep your money with an FDIC bank in USD, you are having your funds diluted away every day (the latest proposal is to print a $1 trillion coin).
- redtexture 14y agoTrillion dollar coin or no coin, the debt ceiling attempts to regulate (in part) expenditures already authorized by Congress and signed into law. It's a tempest in a teapot for one party in Congress to argue that it's irresponsible to conduct authorized expenditures, because in fact, Congress did authorize the expenditures. The two transactions, debt providing cash to the government, and seigniorage (difference in value from the metal in the coin and the fiat value asserted) providing cash to the government for the coin issuance are approximately equally inflationary, over time, assuming that the debt remains outstanding. If such a coin were undertaken, in all probability, it would be repurchased by the Treasury and retired, and debt would be issued. Indeed, the a return of the coin to the Treasury could be via issuance of debt directly to the Federal Reserve. A little perspective on Federal Reserve Bank's process to create cash: Federal Reserve Balance Sheet - by James Hamilton on Econobrowser http://www.econbrowser.com/archives/2008/12/federal_reserve_1.html http://www.econbrowser.com/archives/2008/12/federal_reserve_...
- temphn 14y agoare approximately equally inflationary, over time. Exactly. Both terminate in the end of the US as the world's reserve currency, with the yuan as its obvious replacement. China has already signed deals with Russia, Australia, Brazil, Turkey, and the UAE to eliminate the USD from bilateral trade. [1] Your arguments appear to be directed at people who support the Republican party or are concerned about the partisan points here. Bush, Obama, Bernanke, Greenspan, Krugman, and the whole gang are peas in a pod. Bush won reelection in 2004 by having Greenspan inflate a housing bubble with Krugman cheering[2] the Fed Chairman on. Obama won reelection in 2012 by having Bernanke re-inflate[3] a housing bubble with Krugman cheering the Fed Chairman on. [1] http://www.forbes.com/sites/jackperkowski/2012/06/26/china-busy-signing-currency-deals/ http://www.forbes.com/sites/jackperkowski/2012/06/26/china-b... [2] http://www.nytimes.com/2002/08/02/opinion/dubya-s-double-dip.html http://www.nytimes.com/2002/08/02/opinion/dubya-s-double-dip... To fight this recession the Fed needs more than a snapback; it needs soaring household spending to offset moribund business investment. And to do that, as Paul McCulley of Pimco put it, Alan Greenspan needs to create a housing bubble to replace the Nasdaq bubble. Paul Krugman: August 2, 2002 [3] http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2012-09-13/fed-plans-to-buy-40-billion-in-mortgage-securities-each-month.html http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2012-09-13/fed-plans-to-buy-40... The Federal Reserve said it will expand its holdings of long-term securities with open-ended purchases of $40 billion of mortgage debt a month in a third round of quantitative easing as it seeks to boost growth and reduce unemployment.
- jcoder 14y agoDisclaimer: I know virtually nothing about bitcoin past what I've read on HN. Bitcoin are uniquely identifiable by nature. Has there been any attempt to create and maintain a manifest of "tainted" (i.e., stolen) bc that could be referenced during transactions? If a receiver of bc knows that they are tainted, and that the next receiver might refuse them, then they might refuse them as well. I understand that I'm hand-waving over the "Alice reports the bc she just paid Bob as stolen" problem, and I don't have an answer to that---maybe users subscribe to this service that investigates bc robbery---just thinking out loud.
- conroe64 14y agoThat is possible, but the problem is the time it takes to disseminate the knowledge of the crime is longer than the time to trade the bitcoins. So if the thief immediately exchanged them with some merchant right after the robbery, then sometime later, the coins were marked as tainted, the merchant would suffer as well, since they're now holding the coins. This would create a chilling effect on trade since now you have to worry about the legitimacy of the other party, which brings us right back to the problems we have with credit cards, etc.
- bbrian 14y agoHere's a study that follows the coins from one theft: http://anonymity-in-bitcoin.blogspot.ie/2011/07/bitcoin-is-not-anonymous.html http://anonymity-in-bitcoin.blogspot.ie/2011/07/bitcoin-is-n...
- zby 14y agoLook at the transaction volumes there https://vircurex.com/ https://vircurex.com/ - that does not look serious. By they way chrome shows their https certificate also has some problems.
- kirian 14y agoYeah, according to http://bitcoincharts.com/markets/ http://bitcoincharts.com/markets/ the 30 day monthly volume of Vircurex was just over $200 http://bitcoincharts.com/markets/vcxUSD.html http://bitcoincharts.com/markets/vcxUSD.html
- hnriot 14y agoBitcoin, the unregulated currency of OC & black hats gets hacked. This really isn't a big surprise. There's little or no come back for an individual, group or even nation state on this. This is evolution at work, where instead of survival, its a more tangible quality being selected for. The most ruthless, unremorseful and skilled the hacker, the more bitcoin they make allowing them to buy/build more RATs
- cyphunk 14y agothe comments for this item have gone way off topic and just to be clear if you look at bitcoincharts recording of trading history for this exchange you will see that no more than $3000 changed hands via the exchange. That means that the total amount lost is well under that.