12 ms·
Avis acquires car sharing company Zipcar for $500 million
- rikacomet 14y agopretty sweet deal, given it is in cash, no stocks that deflate :? for a rent-a-car company.
- CodeCube 14y agoGood for them! I've been a fan of zipcar ever since I moved to work in NY for a few years. Made my time in the city without a car really convenient.
- kokey 14y agoI was a bit annoyed with Zipcar when they took over Streetcar, especially since the Streetcar site and app was better than the initial integration into Zipcar. Fortunately they seemed to have fixed most of the issues since.
- kokey 14y agoPotential for a lot of synergies here. Bigger fleet purchases and flexibility to move between daily and hourly rental, giving Avis card holders access to car sharing, the potential to cover more locations, etc.
- fesja 14y agoHopefully one day you will be able to drop a Zipcar in another garage. That would be awesome!
- kokey 14y agoThat would be nice, but it would only really become practical with self driving vehicles, or maybe with enough scale.
- seanmcdirmid 14y agoOnce we get to self driving vehicles, they'll probably be evolve into more like an affordable taxi service.
- jaggederest 14y agohttps://www.car2go.com https://www.car2go.com Better let them know it's not possible to avoid returning cars to their place of rental yet...
- sksksk 14y agoCar2go does do one way, but it's not always the best solution: It's more expensive, the cars are all smart cars, and you have to leave the car within a home location.
- philwelch 14y agoCar2go just seems like a drive-it-yourself taxi to me. If you have any need for that sort of thing it could even be a complementary service to Zipcar, but I would never use it as a replacement.
- vanhiker 14y agoDrive yourself taxi is pretty accurate. In Vancouver it's closer in cost to a bus ride for a couple people going a few km.
- michaelt 14y agoLondon has a bicycle sharing scheme where you can rent a bike at one station and drop it off at another. A side effect of this is in the mornings, when most traffic is from stations towards the city centre, there are no bikes at stations; and in the evenings, when most traffic is from the city centre towards the stations, there are no free return spots near stations. To compensate for this, lorryloads of vans shuttle back and forth in the opposite direction to the commuters. Obviously, zipcar would follow a different demand pattern to a bike hire scheme, but there's still a risk there'd be large scale patterns in demand - for example in the holiday season all the zipcars might get driven to the airport. That isn't an insurmountable problem, of course. Presumably Avis deal with this every day. But presumably they don't plan to turn Zipcar into Avis.
- jre 14y agoMaybe you could give a bonus (price reduction, points) to customers that drops a car in an empty station.
- mikeash 14y agoAnd conversely, penalize trips to extremely popular stations. It ought to be doable purely through economics, although perhaps not without pissing off customers excessively.
- tedunangst 14y agoYou just described airline ticket prices.
- mikeash 14y agoThere are some differences. For example, an airline needs to hire a pilot to fly the plane regardless. For the return trip on a route that's popular in only one direction, if nobody wants to take the plane for a very low price, the airline will fly it empty. For Zipcar, it could conceivably be worthwhile to actually pay customers to drive cars from a popular destination to a popular origin, to avoid having to pay their own workers to do it. But the overall idea is no doubt the same.
- prostoalex 14y agoAirport garages, specifically, would be huge.
- allertonm 14y agoDaimler's "Car2go" service (available here in Vancouver and some other cities) allows you to leave the car anywhere in their core service area. http://car2govancouver.com/ http://car2govancouver.com/
- 3JPLW 14y agoAlso, insurance for actual rentals from Budget/Avis for Zipcar members.
- mseebach 14y ago"Significant revenue growth opportunities exist, including by leveraging Avis Budget’s fleet to meet more of Zipsters’ weekend demand, which is currently constrained by fleet availability." Yes! Make this work - yesterday, preferably!
- philwelch 14y agoHopefully this doesn't mean a deluge of crappy domestic cars. The thing I like about Zipcar the most is the availability of some really nice cars, especially the German makes.
- krschultz 14y agoI hope they tier the pricing. I like having a nice car when I am driving somewhere for fun (or the distance is long). If I just need a car for a couple of hours, budget crappy domestic car is fine.
- philwelch 14y agoThey do, but on the lower tiers you can still get a late-model VW Golf, which is actually pretty nice. On the higher tiers you can get Audi, Mini, BMW, Mercedes-Benz C-class. Avis's idea of a nice car is a fucking Chrysler.
- joeguilmette 14y agoMy idea of a nice car is one that starts and still has some of the brake pads remaining
- smackfu 14y agoI guess that varies. Around here in New Haven, CT, Zipcar just has typical rental car makes and models. Ford Focus, Honda Civic, Nissan Sentra, Mazda 3, and a couple of hybrids.
- corresation 14y agoIf you had just said "crappy cars", then sure. The "crappy domestic cars" bit was worn out a decade or so ago.
- anu_gupta 14y agoAs a long time user of Streetcar / Zipcar, I really hope Avis doesn't fuck with the model too much. For densely populated urban environments, the car-sharing model is just too useful - I don't miss not owning a car in London - no more worrying about break ins, theft, insurance, parking spaces, etc.
- alexkus 14y agoSame here. I'm one of the (numerous) "founder members" of Streetcar so I pay no annual fee to be a member, this was one of the major things that enticed me to Streetcar in the first place. Luckily that deal stayed in place when it was taken over by Zipcar and I'm really hoping Avis continue to honour this agreement.
- jusben1369 14y agoThat's interesting. Zipcar was acquired as it's growth just wasn't good enough (Q3 was 15% YoY I think I read) Stock was well below IPO levels. Too often I see startups do a) Initial crazy pricing deals to get traction b) Initial members who will light up the internet if they're not grandfathered forever and c) Initial members who curse when the service shuts down or is acquired. Now if that lack of an annual fee really is what enticed you then maybe the economics of these services aren't compelling enough to built independent, sustainable businesses.
- ragmondo 14y agoMe too ! I held out and held out and held out and I think they even threw in 200 quid credit into the deal too after the streetcar-> zipcar takeover. I am a family chap and we used to be a 2 car house but that was just due to the occasional time where the missus was using the main car for work and we "needed" a 2nd car. I only use zipcar 10 times a year but it works well enough for me (apart from the nearest car being 2 tube stops away). I don't think Avis can rescind on this ??? I hope not anyway...
- unreal37 14y agoPerhaps off topic, but I love all the Britishisms in this comment. So many words Americans and Canadians don't use in there.
- samstave 14y agoI've been a zipcar user for several years. I hope they have some more affordable rates coming up after this. I don't have a car, and so I rely on zipcar when I do need one. The problem is that if I need it a few times a month it's rediculous compared to the cost of having a car. One month I needed a car a lot, and wound up spending $850 on zipcars! That sucked.
- philwelch 14y agoWhere I live, owning a car would cost $150/mo for parking, another $100/mo for insurance, maybe $50/mo for gas, and maybe $300-400/mo for the car itself. That's $600-700/mo TCO, and that's before maintenance and repair, and I only get one type of car at a time rather than being able to upsize and downsize as required. If you only go over that by $150 in one peak month, and you're usually under it, you're getting fantastic value. For me, I break even compared to parking and insurance alone
- albedoa 14y agomaybe $300-400/mo for the car itself. This is true only if you ever own a car white it is under financing and it loses its full value over the course of the loan. Edit: unless you were simply dividing the cost of the car over the number of months you'd be driving it and you already factored value retention into that number, in which case either you don't need to worry about money anyway because you are rich or there are much better ways for you to better manage your money!
- philwelch 14y agoSo buy it cash, $12,000 figuring a 10 year depreciation. That's still $100/mo, and probably a lower end car than you'll drive with Zipcar. I'm breaking even assuming even a free car, though.
- albedoa 14y agoSure, and that's a $36,000 difference over those ten years. It's much easier to break even when you make that change :D
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- ollysb 14y agoI'm struck by how much lower the valuation is than for the purely web based companies. Zip car has been operating for 12 years and looks like it will be operating for a long time to come. Even with facebook there's a question mark around whether or not it will be operating in another 10 years.
- Mvandenbergh 14y agoThe main reason for that is that scaling works so differently. A purely web based company that hits on a really good operating* model can potentially scale whole orders of magnitude in a short period with relatively limited additional investment. ZipCar can't do that because their growth is constrained by the need for expensive assets (cars). Even if they were popular enough to expand by a whole order of magnitude over the course of a year they would require a huge injection of additional cash from additional equity sales or lending. As a result, it just isn't really possible for ZipCar undergo the huge upside that a web-only company can.
- Mvandenbergh 14y ago(*) I wouldn't call an operating model that doesn't produce revenue a business model
- ollysb 14y agoThe problem is they scale down just as quickly. Currently they're sold with valuations that speculate about the potential profits according to their level of engagement. In many cases they'll scale down before they ever deliver on the kinds of profits that would justify their price tag.
- dasil003 14y agoTrue, but it will take a few more decades before the market gets as comfortable valuing web companies as they are at valuing rental car companies. A big part of the valuation is simply unknown upside of the web in general and business models that will emerge. We like to laugh at the excesses of the dotcom boom, but the uncertainties that drove the insane valuations are still at play on a smaller scale.
- patrickod 14y agoI'd love to use Zipcar but the under-21 filter for non-students means it's out of reach at the moment. If I could avoid buying a car in the bay area I would
- robbiet480 14y agoI was under 21 until 11/2. I got into Zipcar when I was 20. The tip is walking up to one of their on the street tables, getting into the registration process and then saying "Oh wait, I'm under 21!" They really want to make a sale so they say "Don't worry, I will put you under the UC Berkeley plan". The only restriction is you can only rent cars around the school they added you to. All of the cars around them are nice cars but you won't be getting the Mercedes or BMW.
- patrickod 14y agoThe on-campus limitation would also be a bit much for me. I'm living in Downtown Menlo Park which means that I'd have to go onto Stanford campus to rent a car. Think I'll just have to wait until I'm 21 :)
- superuser2 14y agoZipcar could be massively useful to college students. The 21+ age limit is a shame.
- josh2600 14y agoIt's to keep liability down. The insurance pool that ZipCar benefits from would be significantly skewed towards youth and impacting the majority of their client base to generate more credit-risk revenue is not part of the model. An 18 year old is at least twice as expensive as a 40 year old business man when it comes to car insurance.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- jamesjporter 14y agoThe age limit doesn't apply if your Uni has a contract with Zipcar — many of my under 21 friends are Zipcar members . . . and its great!
- oh_sigh 14y agoWhy? Most rental companies charge extra fees, or don't let you drive, if you're under 25.
- superuser2 14y agoYes, but most college students aren't doing independent long-distance travel. The 40-year-old businessman can probably afford a car and almost certainly needs it frequently; the 19-year-old college student has very infrequent and short-term (but inescapable) requirements, for which Zipcar is perfectly suited.
- caffeine5150 14y agoThe only thing I'd predict is that Avis will screw up Zipcar in some way. They'll raise prices or make the service worse or both. The major car rental companies for years have been owned by major car manufacturers and, in part, serve as backdoor dealerships. Ever wonder how the Ford Taurus was the top selling car in America? I wonder if and how Zipcar will be modified to support that model.
- uladzislau 14y agoI've being a ZipCar member for a year and this is why I cancelled my account recently: 1) Availability There's no way you can reserve a ZipCar exactly WHEN you need it. Most ZipCars are spread evenly between locations and in a popular ones you can only reserve something available a few days in advance. This makes the idea of using ZipCar useless because now you need to waste an hour of your time commuting to a remote ZipCar location. Weekends? Forget about it. Unless again you'd like to travel to an inconvenient remote location or book 3 days in advance. 2) Missing/broken car - ruined plans It happened to me twice but this was enough to make me reconsider ZipCar. Once I reserved a car for a day for a very important trip but when I showed up at a parking location my car was missing. ZipCar CSR on the phone refunded my order and offered drive credits but has no idea of what was going on. Needless to say how frustrating the whole experience was. The second time my reserved car was out of order, it just simply wouldn't drive normally. No way I would be happy to exchange this stress and ruined plans for 50$ in driving credits! 3) Dirty Car/low on fuel A couple of times the car I reserved was as dirty inside/outside as it can be after days of abuse on the country roads or in the mud races. And the only thing I could do is to report the issue to ZipCar. I still have to use this dirty car for my business trip. The other annoying issue has been a car low on fuel. Despite taking a car for a couple of hours the first thing I have to do was to locate a gas station and fuel the car. 4) Overpayment and stress First of all, advertised "starting as low as" prices are non existent or impossible to find. They say you save money using ZipCar. This might be true if you're using ZipCar a couple times a month for a few hours. If you need a car for more than that you're certainly better using a conventional rental company. Considering that a few rental companies offer "driver pickup and dropoff" service it makes ZipCar highly inconvenient and stressful if you think about all above mentioned issues. I personally found myself extending reservation hours a few times, hurring up like crazy when there was not an option to do it. 5 or more hours using ZipCar equals in price to a 24hrs. using almost any other car rental company. 5) Damage horror stories ZipCar damage waiver is a joke. You can buy an extended waiver which covers only 750$ in damage. Again unlike other conventional rental companies which would happily provide you with a full damage waiver. Fortunately it didn't happened to me but there's a bunch of horror stories around when ZipCar users were asked to pay fully for the damaged car or had to fight with ZipCar for a long time even if it wasn't their fault.
- 14y ago
- gcv 14y agoAt least in the Bay Area, that sounds like a boon for City CarShare.
- chockablock 14y agoGlad someone brought up CCS. I'm a member of both, and use CCS for all my in-city reservations--they are significantly cheaper (and provide 15-minute reservation increments). Zipcar I mainly use for longer trips (since CCS has a per-mile charge), moving vans (through ZipVan), or as a backup option. All the talk in this thread about this acquisition being an anti-competitive move by Avis ignores the fact that Zipcar isn't the only game around in many cities, and will continue to need to compete on price and service.
- sethbannon 14y agoThis is a disaster for ZipCar customers. There are few industries that are as poorly run or that show as much contempt for their customers than the car rental industry. And Avis is a big part of the problem.
- nicholas73 14y agoAt my first and only time renting a car, I was told that I was required by law to buy insurance covering damages. I did not know that I might have had insurance covering rentals elsewhere, even on credit card member benefits. I bought it for 20 something per day, and went outside to be presented a dented up car, whereupon I was told to not worry about dents since the car was already beat up. On the plus side, I was also told the car only had a quarter tank full, but found a full tank. I didn't bother to report that, so I guess things evened out.
- philwelch 14y agoThat's quite possible. But some companies do these acquisitions with either some sense of self-awareness or at least a willingness to leave the subsidiary alone. Intuit's acquisition of Mint, followed by their decision to put the Mint team in charge of all their personal finance products, is an example of the first. Match's acquisition of OkCupid is an example of the second.
- mixmastamyk 14y agoAlways wanted to try zipcar. The only thing that scared me off was the yearly fee, though I know that's kind of silly.