2 ms·
Why is Terry Tao even talking these arguments when all OpenAI did was a sophisticated brute force search with LLMs? Give them Navier-Stokes in a vacuum
by vatsachak 2mo ago
Why is Terry Tao even talking these arguments when all OpenAI did was a sophisticated brute force search with LLMs?
Give them Navier-Stokes in a vacuum
- dcl 2mo agoWhat do you think all the PhD's and post-doc students are doing...? It's not called graduate-descent for nothing :p
- EA-3167 2mo ago> What do you think all the PhD's and post-doc students are doing...? Thinking.
- sinuhe69 2mo agoBecause it’s high time to rethink the incentives and rewards structures to nurture the next generations of mathematicians when corporate money and automated AI systems are mining the pool of limited interesting problems without giving back or enhance our understanding. The problem they care about is not just “AI replaces human mathematicians” but rather the society thinks mathematicians can be replaced by AI.
- red75prime 2mo agoBrute-force search is called that specifically for its lack of sophistication. A "sophisticated brute search" is an oxymoron.
- vatsachak 2mo agoYou're right. But... Spending 132 billion tokens is definitely way more energy than human mathematicians would have thrown at the problem and probably would have solved within two years.
- unsupp0rted 2mo agoSame reason Gary Kasparov and Lee Sedol started their morning in one universe and ended their evening in another. Brute Force or not, the game is being played and won without them all of a sudden, and even worse: at a level of output far beyond them
- vatsachak 2mo agoNo it's not though. Can OpenAI prove Navier-Stokes from a vacuum with no human knowledge?
- gjm11 2mo agoCan a human? (Evidently not, since humans hadn't managed to do it even with the entirety of human knowledge available to them.)
- vatsachak 2mo agoThey used an agent swarm. Could humanity? Of course; it was close to being solved. It might have taken five years
- red75prime 2mo agoReplication of the development of mathematics by human civilization is a task for an artificial hyperintelligence.
- jambalaya8 2mo agoWhat will anyone do? What will anyone feel their purpose would be? Can't all have the same one, either. What will the planet 'need' homo sapiens for (arguably it never needed homo sapiens at all)? Would anyone's time or life really have significant value?
- red75prime 2mo agoI didn't mean that as "we need hyper-intelligence." I mean that going all the way from nothing to singular, dual, plural grammatical numbers attached to particular nouns to abstract one, two, three, many to zero, one, two, three... to rationals to... is a very long way.
- demibabs 2mo agoThe article wasn’t written by Tao.
- vatsachak 2mo agoHe's expressed similar fears of being replaced in a recent talk