12 ms·
Congress, at Last Minute, Drops Requirement to Obtain Warrant to Monitor Email
- ghayes 14y agoI wish we would treat cyberspace analogues of established property with the same respect given to the original. For example, your e-mail inbox is the online equivalent of your mailbox. Yet, one being "on your lawn" and the other "at Google's data-center," all bets are off. While I believe the Supreme Court should do better job at explicitly addressing this (for instance, "responsible expectation of privacy" established Katz[1] would be a fair test for e-mail, while Jones[2] and Kyllo[3] show the importance of taking modern technology into account), the government needs to firmly establish which techniques are important for security while protecting us from those which recklessly violate privacy. [1] http://www.law.cornell.edu/supct/html/historics/USSC_CR_0389_0347_ZC1.html http://www.law.cornell.edu/supct/html/historics/USSC_CR_0389... [2] http://www.law.cornell.edu/supremecourt/text/10-1259 http://www.law.cornell.edu/supremecourt/text/10-1259 [3] http://www.law.cornell.edu/supct/html/99-8508.ZS.html http://www.law.cornell.edu/supct/html/99-8508.ZS.html
- woah 14y agoThere is nothing about monitoring our email that is necessary for security. The war on terror is a giant hoax, more people are killed every year choking on peanut butter. Members of the government are always reaching for more and more control over our lives and power to watch us.
- mikeash 14y agoDo you have a cite for the peanut butter thing? I'd love to use that figure, but would hate to be unable to back it up if asked.
- mtgx 14y agoI don't know about the peanut one, but you can find plenty others. Like more people die because of alcohol every year, or one that I read recently that more veterans commit suicide every year than die in the wars, etc.
- w1ntermute 14y agoAnother good one is the number of people that die in car accidents in the US every year, largely due to human error - 32,367 people in 2011. If the government took one tenth of the money it spends on defense every year (which was $1.030–$1.415 trillion for 2012), or approximately $100 billion dollars, and invested it in driverless car research and the infrastructure changes necessary for it, a much bigger benefit could be wrought. But that won't happen, because it's the lobbying of the military-industrial complex that determines where money is spent.
- mikeash 14y agoI use that one a lot. Roughly one 9/11 every month, continually, and nobody really cares.
- jwoah12 14y agoIt isn't that nobody cares. It's that people see (however irrationally) car accidents as an unpreventable occurrence, while they see terrorism as something that can be stopped if we go and kill the bad guys that are doing it.
- pjbrunet 14y agoIf you want to play that game, nothing beats abortion deaths. http://www.numberofabortions.com/ http://www.numberofabortions.com/
- monochromatic 14y agomilitary-industrial complex Most of what you said is true enough, but this nonsense loses you credibility. It's like saying "it's the corporations, man."
- rcsorensen 14y agoThe best source I can find is http://www.huffingtonpost.com/meredith-broussard/food-allergy-deaths-less_b_151462.html http://www.huffingtonpost.com/meredith-broussard/food-allerg... . A call to the CDC press office revealed that the number of deaths from food allergies, as collected from 2.5 million death certificates across the country, is miniscule. Only eleven people died from food allergies in 2005, the last year for which we have data available. More people died from lawnmower accidents.
- gnaritas 14y agoNot that I disagree entirely, but looking at deaths prevented isn't really relevant. Terrorism isn't about death, it's about terror, putting people in a state of fear. The war on terror isn't about preventing death, it's about preventing fear. People aren't afraid of choking on peanut butter or car accidents because they feel they have some control over those situations. Terrorism creates fear by removing that sense of control.
- polshaw 14y ago>The war on terror is... about preventing fear. Many people would argue exactly the opposite
- gnaritas 14y agoYou can argue the opposite of anything, and many do; doesn't mean anything. 911 for example, caused the fear, which then was used to pass draconian laws, but those laws were meant to both seize power and alleviate the fear, to the point of implementing things like the TSA, which aren't real protection, but make people feel less fear.
- mhurron 14y agoOther than the government with it's war on terror, who has actually done anything to perpetrate fear in the population? Since 2001, there has been no terrorist activity against the US. You are told about threats the war on terror has dealt with, but no actual action or actors can be pointed to yet the government is keeps the fear of terror alive. They have done far more to that end than any terrorist organization has. This causes the population in general to accept any course of action that they are told will deal with that looming threat, but it never seems to do so. Once side of the government generates and keeps the fear alive, the other side uses the fear to do what they wish. Neither side wants the fear to go away. The US Government is the largest group terrorizing the US population today. They use the war on terror to do it.
- gnaritas 14y ago
- tsotha 14y ago>The war on terror is a giant hoax, more people are killed every year choking on peanut butter. The fact that the Islamists don't kill millions every year doesn't make it a "giant hoax". The fact that they haven't killed more isn't due to a lack of motivation, only to a lack of means. And they've been reaching for the means.
- Hikari 14y agowtf would do you know about it ? if you have nothing to back up your claims then it might be better to just keep it quit.
- tsotha 14y agoI know documentation was found in Afghanistan outlining attempts to acquire sarin gas for use in a terrorist attack in the US. On the other hand, maybe it was all faked, right, like the WTC attack? Maybe you should keep it "quit" yourself. And while you're keeping it "quit", take an English class. I would advise keeping it "quit" during the class so the teacher doesn't realize you're not the sharpest tooth on the saw.
- FuzzyDunlop 14y agoI find it interesting that the treatment of the digital analogue in legislation is contradictory. While it's beneficial to the government and businesses to remove the distinction between digital and physical when it comes to IP and copyright, it's just as beneficial to maintain that distinction for 'security' or 'anti-terrorism'. 'Modern' legislation doesn't feel all that progressive when it comes to technology.
- rayiner 14y agoSo the rights with respect to your mailbox derive from the fact that the Post Office was historically an appendage of the government. Giving your personal information to a government-run Post Office versus giving it to a third party like Google (that mines your personal information for advertisements!) is a salient distinction.
- stephengillie 14y agoMy question still is: why can't a judge subpoena all mail you have within the Post Office's sorting system? Don't say it's due to prohibitive expense unless you can prove this would be more expensive than Carpathia hosting Megaupload for free.
- rayiner 14y agoI think you drew the opposite inference from what I intended. Postal mail is more protected because the Post Office is (was) an organ of the government. As an organ of the government, it is restricted by the 4th amendment as to what it can do with your mail. E-mail is different because the intermediaries are non-governmental third parties. The idea is that you do not give up your expectation of privacy by giving mail to the Post Office to deliver, because you know the Post Office is limited by the 4th amendment, while you do give up your expectation of privacy by giving mail to your e-mail provider, because you know your e-mail provider has no obligation to protect your privacy.
- shawn-butler 14y agoThe Sixth Disctrict court of appeals did address this directly in US v Warshak [0]. What this scare article does a good job of is confusing the reader. Unopened email left on a 3rd party server for longer than 180 days was considered discarded or abandoned property. Discarded physical property has never retained a reasonable expectation of privacy (for instance, the police are free to dumpster dive once your property is considered discarded). Similarly when you vacate an apartment and leave all your belongings behind, they become the property of the landlord. These are firmly established principles of common law. The waters become more grey when you are not using the 3rd party for communication but for storage, say for emails you have read and leave on the server for 180+ days. [1] So in this case Congress wanted to establish a new right to privacy that required a warrant on rather vague and nebulous grounds. It was dropped and so the status quo remains. All the people here complaining apparently have no idea what the law of the land currently is? Email communications residing on a third-party server for less than 180 days that offers services to the public can not be obtained without a warrant. Notification of the issuance of a warrant could be delayed by 90 days. This does not apply to 3rd party services that do not offer services to the public. They can voluntarily disclose content at their whim. If you believe my understanding to be flawed I welcome the opportunity to be corrected. [0]: https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2010/12/breaking-news-eff-victory-appeals-court-holds https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2010/12/breaking-news-eff-vict... [1]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stored_Communications_Act#Overview http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stored_Communications_Act#Overv...
- paulsutter 14y agoAnything we can do to proactively claim or declare our emails older than 180 days to be not discarded and not abandoned? Or move them to a new server periodically so that they aren't stored in a server for more than 180 days? From Wikipedia [1]: "Property is generally deemed to have been abandoned if it is found in a place where the true owner likely intended to leave it, but is in such a condition that it is apparent that he or she has no intention of returning to claim it." I'm winging it here, but Gmail could have an optional feature to prompt every three months "do you claim your mail from January 2005 to December 2012?", and just answer yes every time. Then Google could respond to be subpoena that the user has no mail that has not been claimed in 180 days. Any lawyers here who can come up with something more solid? [1] http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lost,_mislaid,_and_abandoned_property http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lost,_mislaid,_and_abandoned_... (Be nice if you had some contact info on your profile)
- chacham15 14y agoThe common analogy given from law academics is that email is more akin to the telegram than postal mail. With postal mail, no one along the entire path actually opens the envelope to see what is inside. This is in contrast to the telegram where the intermediary is exposed to the contents directly. This difference is what leads to the difference in expectation of privacy. In this analogy email is actually more like a telegram. Where I think that the analogy diverges with reality is that the intermediary is now a machine, not a person. Therefore, we expect the machine to not "understand" the data that passes through it and simply deliver it.
- ams6110 14y agoAnd then, using GPG or S/MIME would restore email to the status of a postal letter, with the message contained in an envelope of privacy. So if I GPG my email, that should confer a higher expectation of privacy than "normal" email would.
- Entr0p 14y agowhelp, that passing will end my use of free text email.
- JshWright 14y agoThis is an article about an amendment proposed to a law that's already on the books. The 180 days thing is already the law of the land, this amendment sought to change that. There's now nothing in this bill relating to mail privacy (i.e. the existing law isn't being changed at all). So, if that's the way you feel about it, the time to stop using free text email was 1986, when ECPA was first passed.
- Entr0p 14y agointeresting, I'll have to read more - I was expecting that a warrant was required under current law to use intercepted emails
- monochromatic 14y agoI think most people do expect that.
- tptacek 14y agoWarrants are required for mail less than 180 days old.
- pretoriusB 14y agoDoesn't matter. Your friends, family and colleagues will continue to do so, and thus this affects everybody, even if he's not using free text email.
- ihsw 14y agoGovernment hawks are well aware of this and they will use every chance they get to take the advantage. Maybe it's time we took a stand -- no communication unless it's encrypted or face-to-face.
- rsync 14y agoIf you don't host your own mail server, you are a clown-person. Joe 6 pack has an excuse, but nobody here does.
- dsplittgerber 14y agoHow can I, as a somewhat proficient non-techie, accomplish that without having to dedicate a 24/7 *nix box from home? Please, if anyone knows a simple, yet elegant solution, I'm all ears.
- Xylakant 14y agoyou can use encrypted mail, however that requires you to convince all people that you exchange mails with to use encrypted mail as well. You could use a hosted email service in another country where the american authorities don't have easy access. Europe might be an option. However, as with hosting your own email server, that's only a partial solution: If you communicate with other people, your mail is not only stored in your inbox but also in their outbox. So they'd have to use a mail provider outside the US as well - see the first paragraph. The best is probably a hybrid solution: Try to educate as many people to use encrypted mail as you can and use a mail server that's located outside the US. It doesn't provide 100% protection, but at least you're not part of the dragnet search.
- olefoo 14y agoErrr... the NSA is specifically charged with monitoring communications that cross US national borders. Using a mailserver in a foreign jurisdiction makes it more open to legal interception by the US government; not less.
- Xylakant 14y agoValid point. It's a different branch and a different issue though. Mails that are already on your server and stored there would be relatively safe. Make sure communication is encrypted.
- 14y ago
- dmix 14y agoAnother reason we need better encryption solutions for email. Are there any useful options that encrypt email?
- napoleond 14y agoMy company is working on this: http://parley.co http://parley.co EDIT: As mentioned a few times elsewhere on this thread, the biggest barrier to encrypted email adoption is the network effect, ie. both ends need to be using it. That is the core problem we're trying to solve--making an email system that would be better than the rest even if it weren't encrypted, but that's the icing on the cake.
- mahyarm 14y agoThis is why I like OTR clients. You just check a box and if the other client has it, it automatically starts an encrypted session. Otherwise it works normally. It's seamless. And it gives you forward secrecy.
- tptacek 14y agoIf "works anywhere on any device" means it crypto code is loaded over Javascript without browser extensions, that's a goal that cannot share a project with "make it impossible for admins to read email even with a subpoena". The reason it's 2012 and there's still no universal solution for encrypting email is that it's a hard problem. If you care about the security of your mail, you should use GPG.
- napoleond 14y agoWe are in full agreement. Parley.co does not use Javascript crypto or browser plugins, ie. it is not webmail. (There is a webmail component that can be used to send messages which are encrypted at the server, and can allow synchronous two-way communications for logged in Parley users that is not end-to-end, but it is only provided as a stop-gap and the trade-offs are clearly presented. Discussing it usually ends up as a distraction, since our core offering is based on installing standalone clients.) We'll be posting more information about the whole thing soon, but if anyone has any questions I'm always happy to discuss what we're doing either by email (in my profile) or (at risk of derailing the thread) here. EDIT: Also, Parley uses OpenPGP. People who are happy with their PGP/GPG setup should continue using it, but the goal is to create a compatible service which those people would feel comfortable recommending to less tech-savvy friends.
- durpleDrank 14y agoDidn't they do the same dirty trick for the federal reserve act ? Basically all of congress is home with their families, and only a few people (who most likely want to see the change (for whatever reason AHEM)) show up to to vote.
- srj 14y agoI believe each congressional body requires a majority of members present to have quorum and conduct business.
- propercoil 14y agoThey always do that in holidays when no one is looking like they did with the NDAA. no suprise
- tptacek 14y agoThe NDAA did exactly what this bill purports to do: leave intact an unfortunate status quo. Almost nothing people say about it on message boards is true; it has become a shibboleth for "I pass along public policy gossip without verifying it".
- mtgx 14y agoBut did it leave it intact or did it enforce it? Why did they need to write in NDAA too that they can do that if there already was written in another law?
- tptacek 14y agoI don't understand the first question. The answer to the second question is that the powers granted to the executive under the 2012 NDAA (there's an NDAA every year) are more limited than the blanket authorization to use force granted in 2001.
- chris_wot 14y agoCould monitoring be the same searching? If so, that legislation is unconstitional!
- alexmat 14y agoThis looks like a promising idea: http://bitmessage.org/ http://bitmessage.org/ Edit: Send me a message if you get it running and I'll reply, BM-2nftGCPpQ9HtjwJgbZfSFhPHqiJbJK7pwvi
- QuantumGuy 14y agoUltimately isn't the way around something like this is VPN services and encrypting your email? Or is it more than that at this point?
- BrianPetro 14y ago'Burn' Emails Use https://receiveee.com https://receiveee.com for all of your illicit emailing.
- newman314 14y agoIt's got misconfigured SSL cipher settings. See https://www.ssllabs.com/ssltest/analyze.html?d=https%3A%2F%2Freceiveee.com%2F https://www.ssllabs.com/ssltest/analyze.html?d=https%3A%2F%2...
- shmerl 14y agoThey demonstrated that they value police state ideals over the civil liberties. Wasn't it expected?
- creativityland 14y agoObama State. FTFY.
- neumann_alfred 14y agoRight. Because Obama totally didn't continue a long legacy, he basically kickstarted this all by himself.. My suggestion would be to more or less ignore the sock puppet of the day and instead pay attention to interest groups and whatnot. Those don't change nearly as much as the faces or slogans that are put on stuff.
- thoughtcriminal 14y agoWhere's Obama? Where's the great "centerist"? The great leader? He's invisible again.
- creativityland 14y agoWhy are you surprised?
- benhebert 14y agoWar on terror is a hoax used for pushing forward an agenda. Save us from the terrorists and drugs! God forbid you travel out of the US and see some of the world, you might be "taken". The way the media sensationalizes some of these shootings, it's like we have to live in a constant state of fear.
- neumann_alfred 14y agoGod forbid you travel out of the US and see some of the world, you might be "taken". Ironically, I feel the same way about the US since 9/11: I'd rather freely run my yap about (politics of) the country on the internet and not ever set foot there, than visit it and risk my freedom. Which makes me sad, because I know it has many great people in it... but a lot of things would have to change rather drastically for me to revise this.
- alan_cx 14y agoYeah, I feel broadly the same way. In so many ways the US is a fantastic country, but the government and its politics are insane, and frankly scary from the outside. I thought things would vastly improve under Obama, but from what I can see, he's little more than a "Bush Lite". Pity, IMHO. Worth separating the people from their government, although I would argue that in a democracy the government is the voter's fault. But it seems to me that the US government / establishment fears and hates its own population as much as it does foreigners. I kinda wish Americans would wake up and see the monster, then do something about it. If the US establishment starts treating its own people better, that might fan out internationally for everyone's good. Not least, Americans. But then, as I say, the US is supposed to be a democracy, so presumably they have what they want already. So, er, fair enough. Who am I to suggest otherwise?
- ams6110 14y agoToo many generations of poorly-educated and/or dependent voters are making your wish something that is less and less likely to be realized.
- derekja 14y agoHas anyone out there created a utility that will download and delete any gmail messages older than 6 months, storing them only in an encrypted local store?
- kleiba 14y agoI would be surprised if deleting a mail from your gmail account would actually delete them from Google's servers?! I was always under the assumption that Google will store them until eternity. But as assumptions go, I can't really back that up -- but perhaps someone on HN has better knowledge?
- aioprisan 14y agoI'd be interested to hear about this as well.
- pjbrunet 14y agoGood question. I deleted my Amazon account about a year ago which wasn't easy--required back and forth correspondence with tech support: "Yes, I'm absolutely 100% sure I really, really understand the implications of deleting my account." In any case, I keep getting Amazon gift cards from people so I go to sign up to Amazon for a new account. Turns out my account was never actually deleted, I was able to click "forgot my password" and they still had a record of everything.
- sown 14y agoSo how does this work if, say, I have an mbox file with messages from 7 months ago and also yesterday? Do they get to snag the entire mbox file or do they have to painstakingly filter out messages from the files?
- biafra 14y agoWhy is email that is 180 days old considered abandoned? Does this also apply to email, that is stored on a server that I rented or bought? Am I supposed to delete all email after I read it?
- raintrees 14y agoThis seems a good place for a dose of "what is good for the goose is good for the gander"... Since Congress is employed solely to represent its constituents, maybe all of their communications(public or private, if they are in any relation to their employment) be disseminated far and wide to all of those constituents to monitor those representative's abilities to fulfill their obligations to their constituents. A period of time observing the sausage-making process of crafting and passing law may be quite a wakeup call for Jane Q. Public....
- gasull 14y agoEvery year the average Westerner citizen is less free than a year ago, and the median citizen is also poorer than the year before. Is this just my impression? Is the pendulum ever going to swing back?
- crististm 14y agoSo congress can fuck around for free?
- whiddershins 14y agoIt's funny to see that headline jumps out at you, but not the one above it?
- hfsktr 14y agoI didn't see anyone post it but the link above didn't go directly to the article (at least for me). It was available in the recent stories though. The url on that page is: http://www.allgov.com/news/top-stories/congress-at-last-minute-drops-requirement-to-obtain-warrant-to-monitor-email-121225?news=846578 http://www.allgov.com/news/top-stories/congress-at-last-minu...