19 ms·
The Pirate Bay Is The World’s Most Efficient Public Library
- shurane 14y agoThat's a fun comparison. That's discrimination right there, innit? Artists and authors aren't going after the library for copyright concerns the same way they go after torrent sites. Does the library have some type of licensing agreement with the media it purchases? The article indicates that it isn't the case, but if there was, could that be the reason why libraries aren't attacked but torrent sites are? Though libraries have a lot less traffic and loss in potential sales compared to a torrent tracker. This type of discrimination happens with website scraping too. Websites don't go after big search indexers like Google and Bing but will and can sue local scrapers who never entered some type of agreement with the website.
- markyc 14y ago"Artists and authors aren't going after the library for copyright concerns the same way they go after torrent sites." > They might if the library would share everything digitally, which would directly compete with the artist's own marketing efforts "Websites don't go after big search indexers like Google and Bing but will and can sue local scrapers who never entered some type of agreement with the website." > They don't go after Google because they (supposedly) make something out of getting scraped
- hfsktr 14y agoI swear I've heard libraries rent out books for e-readers. I might be way off in my memory though as I don't keep up with those types of things (or libraries). Isn't getting scraped by Google voluntary with the robots.txt? Also a question for anyone who knows the answer: does Google/Bing/etc use the same amount of resources as someone using whatever to scrape a website (bandwidth, whatever else websites might be concerned with)? Genuinely curious as I don't have much experience scraping and even less dealing with crawlers. Edit: This link appears to confirm ebooks can be rented and loaned personally in some cases. http://ebooksinlibraries.blogspot.com/2011/03/loaning-and-borrowing.html http://ebooksinlibraries.blogspot.com/2011/03/loaning-and-bo...
- dagw 14y agoI swear I've heard libraries rent out books for e-readers At least in Sweden, e-books are licensed to libraries under an entirely different set of rules, and as such it costs the library a lot more when you 'borrow' and e-book than when you borrow an actual book. The result of this is that libraries have been forced to limit the number of e-books people can borrow pr. month.
- thefreeman 14y agoAny scraper will use essentially the same bandwidth (varying slightly on how much content they actually download). Their can be issues with server load depending on how fast you are getting indexed and how much content your site has, but Google takes care to detect this and you can also manually reduce the speed / schedule via Webmaster Tools.
- kijin 14y ago> Does the library have some type of licensing agreement with the media it purchases? IANAL but I think it's called the first-sale doctrine. Once you buy a book, you can do whatever you want with it as long as you don't try to copy and sell it. Of course, publishers don't like it any more than the MAFIAA likes Torrent users. As more libraries now stock digital items, publishers have taken the opportunity to put restrictions on libraries' right to lend [1]. [1] https://www.nytimes.com/2011/12/25/business/for-libraries-and-publishers-an-e-book-tug-of-war.html https://www.nytimes.com/2011/12/25/business/for-libraries-an...
- knowtheory 14y agoTo this point, content companies hate libraries, but they can't do anything about it because of the doctrine of first sale. But that's why there were huge public media campaigns decrying any kind of recordable media. Libraries could acquire all this content, and anybody could go to the library, check out a piece of content, and make a copy. This is also why in the world of objects that only exist digitally, libraries are having such a hard time with digital lending. Content companies don't have to play ball when they own the devices on which lending takes place.
- belorn 14y agoIn Sweden (The context of which the author talks about this), there are no such licensing agreement but rather praxis. Libraries are for the common good, and as such, they get treated as such. There's one exception, as there is a law requiring a copy to be sent to the main library in Sweden if a book gets published. As for artists and authors, normally they don't go after anyone, be that libraries or the pirate bay. Copyright and publishing organizations however, do go after the pirate bay. They also go after libraries, but through the lobbying route. Audio books has come and gone, drm'ed, limits and so on. Many libraries has totally given up on audio-books, as its a loot of trouble for rather small gain.
- dagw 14y agoIn Sweden libraries have to pay a small sum to the publisher each time a book is borrowed. The exact details vary slightly depending on a bunch of factors, but it's normally around $0.10-0.15.
- belorn 14y agoIn a comment by Rick Falkvinge in the comment field, he explains this point. Basically, only Swedish authors and translators receive any money at all. Its also not a licensing deal between the copyright owner and the library, but rather a money distribution method, using the statistics of book lending gather by the library to grant money to Swedish authors.
- pi18n 14y agoI've seen it asserted (I think by Falkvinge himself) that the model of paying a bit per view would be heavily abused on the internet, which I don't doubt. It would be interesting to see how many Swedish authors routinely borrow their own book or books authored by friends and family from the library.
- kriro 14y agoAt 10 cents per borrow (no idea if that number is right or not but it seems reasonable enough)...only the authors that don't value their time very much. The average book will have at most 2-3 copies but even if we assume 10 for arguments sake you'd earn yourself 1$ per library that you visit. Given that you have to get to the library, spend time checking the books out and returning them and only get a cut of X% of that one dollar to boot it seems like a pretty futile exercise :D
- Nursie 14y agoThe library doesn't give out infinite copies of anything, nor allow for permanent ownership - it lends.
- jellicle 14y ago> Artists and authors aren't going after the library for copyright concerns the same way they go after torrent sites. Actually, the American Association of Publishers, which represents exactly the people you might think it does, has repeatedly and publicly attacked the existence of libraries. They've kind of backed away from it in the last few years since it seems like a poor argument from a public relations point of view, but that's clearly the view they hold: all libraries should be eliminated.
- b3tta 14y agoI don't understand why everyone feels the need to portrait piracy as something good. I do it because I can.
- icebraining 14y agoBecause some people do actually believe it's something good?
- belorn 14y ago"If all knowing, all culture, all art, all useful information can be costlessly given to everyone at the same price that it is given to anyone; if everyone can have everything, anywhere, all the time, why is it ever moral to exclude anyone?" - Eben moglen
- webreac 14y agoBecause the only way to prohibit piracy is to kill freedom of speech. If you want to protect freedom of exchange of data between people with no eavesdrop, you can not fight piracy.
- Tyrannosaurs 14y agoPerhaps but that doesn't make piracy good. It might make it an unavoidable side effect of something that's good, but that's a different thing.
- vy8vWJlco 14y agoIf the freedom to communicate without fear of arbitrary interferance is a good thing (via the U.N. Declaration of Human Rights) and "piracy" cannot be realistically stopped without compromising that freedom (for example, by requiring ISPs to support large-scale surveillance, or by undemocratically influencing the government to adopt positions that are in conflict with social norms) then "piracy" is a good thing in at least the sense that the freedom to participate in "piracy" is a pre-requisite for that other good thing. I think privacy easily trumps non-commercial copyright so even when I'm feeling sympathetic to the pro-copyright arguement I am not willing to budge if it means things like more surveillance or increasing the fear that your are being watched by your government or some copyright enforcement company. I think that's a common enough feeling to explain why "Pirate" political parties have any success (despite many political systems being dominated by a small number of established parties, and the popular sentiment being that voting for anything else is throwing your vote away). As you have observed, that is quite a different arguement from the other possibility presented in the main article - that "piracy" (what everyone used to simply call sharing) is a good thing - which I am also receptive to. I mean, why bother having the Internet if not for the potential to distribute everything everywhere without saying "Please sir, I want some more"?
- alan_cx 14y agoThe comparison is bogus because a specific copy is passed around. With file sharing a new copy is made each time. What this means is that with a library only one person can use the media at one time. That person gives the copy back, no so in file sharing. Shame 'cos it was a nice point for a while!!! Thing is, file sharing isnt sharing. If I "file share" I still have my copy to use. A second person wanting to borrow doesn't have to wait for my copy to be returned to me. They can make a new copy. So.... can such an arrangement work in place of current "file sharing"? Can a file be borrowed and sent beck for re-borrowing after use? Since my local library in the UK does films and box-sets, can government or local government implement such a system?
- icebraining 14y agoThere was never a requirement in the definition of "sharing" that the sharer was deprived of the thing being shared. When it comes to non-scarce things - like ideas, knowledge or experiences - we've always used the word 'share' without implying rivalry.
- benologist 14y agoWhy stop the hyperbole at public libraries? TPB is the world's most efficient Walmart too because Walmart has per-item and per-person overhead that will never compete with "click this link". It's the most efficient two way mission to Mars as well when you really think about it: no rockets, no loss of life, and all the latest movies!
- morsch 14y agoWho is being hyperbolic now? It's easy to see that TPB accomplishes few things that Walmart does (such as distributing groceries) and almost none that a Mars mission does (other than serve as entertainment). It's also easy to see that TPB does accomplish many of the things that a public library does, such as offering access to copyrighted works and helping in finding the work you're looking for by maintaining an index. Did you really not see this or were you being disingeneous to make a point?
- roryokane 14y agoThis article has a similar argument to “The Teleporter Library: A Copyright Thought Experiment”: http://www.juliansanchez.com/2011/07/11/the-teleporter-library-a-copyright-thought-experiment/ http://www.juliansanchez.com/2011/07/11/the-teleporter-libra.... The comments on that blog post contain useful discussion of the argument. I especially agree with comment 18 on that blog post, http://www.juliansanchez.com/2011/07/11/the-teleporter-library-a-copyright-thought-experiment/#comment-14798 http://www.juliansanchez.com/2011/07/11/the-teleporter-libra.... It argues that the only reason we find public libraries morally okay in the first place was because we couldn’t copy their work. So perhaps if hard drives were invented before physical books, public libraries would have radically different restrictions, or not exist at all.
- _delirium 14y agoI agree copying is a difference, but for >90% of my own usage, at least for books and films, it's not one that makes a practical difference. I don't typically watch a movie hundreds of times: I watch it once, maybe twice. So really I only need to loan it, whether from a library or TPB. In theory TPB would let me not only "loan" it, but actually keep a permanent copy for myself, which the library doesn't. But I have no desire to archive hundreds of gigabytes of films I've already watched, so I typically delete them. Another approach I sometimes take is to buy a used copy and then resell it. This ends up costing the price of shipping + Amazon/eBay/etc. transaction costs. It doesn't really benefit the artist/studio/etc. any more than torrenting it, though, since they don't get a cut of used sales. With music it's a bit different because I do actually listen to the same album multiple times over an extended period of time, so prefer a permanent copy of music I like.
- jiggy2011 14y agoIt may benefit them a bit. In order to get that used copy there had to be an original sale at some point. So if there is a big market for people to temporarily buy and resell something then there will need be be a fair number of original sales unless people are prepared to wait a long time to get their "turn". With TBP in theory you can give the entire planet parallel access to something by seeding only one original sale.
- georgeorwell 14y agoIf you think TPB is good, you should see what private trackers have to offer.
- INTPenis 14y agoExtreme hyperbole. The local library here in Malmö have a much better IT-infrastructure than TPB. The TPB website is built like something I made at 15 years old in PHP. It's in fact a terrible product by todays standards. And that's with noscript+adblock. I wouldn't want to see it without.
- ajuc 14y agoInfrastructure doesn't matter, quality doesn't matter. What matters is how many people use it, and how often. And there TPB wins by several orders of magnitude.
- INTPenis 14y agoYes of course, Rick is trying to say that regardless of technology it feels like a big library where you can find whatever it is you're looking for. At the core I'm for piracy, hell I was raised a pirate and I will forever be a pirate. I'd much rather donate my money to indie-artists and software projects.
- xyzzy123 14y agoThe hard problems for a TPB-like are DDoS, takedown and lawsuit resistance. They seem to be doing pretty well at that, considering. Despite not have a nice GUI, a lot of people use it. Why? because everyone has heard of it - and it's still there.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- paul_f 14y agoIf libraries did not exist, and I created one, I'd be sued out of existence.
- adrianonantua 14y ago"If free and open access to all of human knowledge at the push of a button truly prevents our society’s beloved artists, authors, thinkers, and other creative people from putting food on their tables, then maybe it’s time to rethink how to put food on their tables." This itself nails half of the core of the issue. The other half is getting rid of the middle men, who are now just struggling to justify their existence. Their time will come.
- tmh88j 14y ago> The other half is getting rid of the middle men, who are now just struggling to justify their existence I may be misinterpreting the quote, but it seems like the middle men are entirely the "issue," not the artists and creative people. Artists like Louis CK and Smashing Pumpkins have already proved they can make money without the middle man.
- crdoconnor 14y agoLouis CK is able to make it on his own because he's already a big name. He can do without middle men who control the marketing channels. Smaller artists can't - not so easily, anyway.
- tmh88j 14y agoJustin Bieber was a nobody until he put his videos on Youtube. Kendrick Lamar was discovered this way too. It's easier to gain recognition now than ever. If the world enjoys what you produce you don't have to worry as much about a distribution channel like you did 10+ years ago.
- chaz 14y agoJustin Bieber had just 70k YT views [1] before he was discovered by Scooter Braun. He didn't make it big until he was signed with Braun and Usher. 70k views in 2008 wasn't nothing, but I don't think it's reasonable to assume he would have grown to his current 3+ bn views, becoming an international A-lister, and a household name without signing with a major label. YouTube and online help nobodies become somebodies. Labels help somebodies become megastars. The bottom end is rising, and the top end is compressing, but I don't believe we'll ever see them equalize. [1] http://www.forbes.com/sites/danschawbel/2011/02/11/inside-the-brand-of-justin-bieber-an-interview-with-manager-scooter-braun/ http://www.forbes.com/sites/danschawbel/2011/02/11/inside-th...
- sgdesign 14y agoMaybe one difference is that libraries don't operate for profit, while pirate sites display ads and (as far as I know) don't redistribute any profits to the content creators? Although I would gladly pay $X/month to TPB if it did give some of it back to the artists.
- orng 14y agoIt would be very interesting to see what happened if TPB were to start distributing their revenue to the rights-holders without asking for their permission though. Maybe it could work in a similar vein to flattr, where the recipients have to claim their money? Perhaps the future of torrents is a Spotify-like model where anyone can upload anything, and if you can prove that you are the owner of something you get your share of the revenue? edit: minor change to phrasing
- muuh-gnu 14y ago> if it did give some of it back to the artists. I'd guess they would if they legally could. But if they could, everybody else also could, and then the cash cow of "selling copies" would finally die in an era where everybody can produce copies themselves. Therefore they cant, because the current stakeholders have too much power in legislation.
- Surio 14y agoSince game of thrones got mentioned a couple of times, and quick and easy download/wait times and SD files with 720p resolution, etc...etc... in some of the comments obligatory comic: http://theoatmeal.com/comics/game_of_thrones http://theoatmeal.com/comics/game_of_thrones
- laserDinosaur 14y ago"It begs the question why every author, filmmaker, and musician isn’t up in arms about the New York Public Library’s rampant sharing" It should be noted there IS a somewhat large group of book authors who protest that library's are just government sanctioned piracy. Which I think is a fair enough stance to take.
- smacktoward 14y agoThen those authors are idiots. Libraries pay for their books, they don't seize them for free through some kind of literary eminent domain. If their argument is that it should be illegal for anyone to share a book that they've paid for with someone else, that would be a radical redefinition of what it means to "own" a book.
- silverdrake11 14y agoSimilarly, someone had to pay for their movie or album or w/e before they ripped it and posted it to the Pirate Bay.
- millstone 14y agoMy mom borrowing my book is qualitatively different than a public institution set up for the mass renting of media. The law makes that distinction all the time; for example, the CRA prohibits discrimination in a restaurant, but not at my potluck. Back during the 90s, video rental stores would have to pay a higher price (around $100 IIRC) for a copy of a movie they were licensed to rent. If you believe that media should be licensable, then it follows naturally that more permissive licenses should cost more. The main reason that libraries are morally acceptable, by the way, is that they are viewed as institutions of learning and betterment that service students, the unemployed, and the less fortunate. If libraries were focused on entertainment instead, they would not be so highly regarded and their copyright issues would come to the fore.
- ry0ohki 14y ago"The Pirate Bay, on the other hand, requires you to type in a search term, click on a download button, and wait a little while" This is basically how it works at my local library, I search on their website, click "Request to my local branch", wait a while, and then it's there for me to pickup. I can't imagine the NY Public library is much worse.
- cwkoss 14y agoUnless you don't have to put on pants, I'd still call the Pirate Bay more efficient.
- tzs 14y agoThe article overlooks the fact that the demand for an item like a book varies over time. Typically, there is an initial high demand period shortly after publication, and then a very long tail of low demand. Libraries generally don't significantly undercut sales because the bulk of sales occur during the early high demand period, when the library's limited number of copies force waiting lists so that those who want the item sooner rather than later buy it. This was the basis of an interesting law review article published by Justice Breyer back in his academic days, called "The Uneasy Case for Copyright", where he argued that because such a high fraction of the profits from a work occurred from sales shortly after publication, before copiers had time to typeset and get into print unauthorized copies, there might not be a need for copyright law. Since then, copying technology has gotten much better, and so Breyer's argument is no longer plausible.
- Offler 14y agoI read Justice Breyer as Justin Bieber for a second, I immediately had to double take!
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- jivatmanx 14y agoAs an argument for reduced copyright terms, it's even more valid than before. Why does a poor person from a developing country have to pay $10.00 for an eBook from 1923? Was the Author really thinking "I won't write this book unless my third generation heirs get royalties".
- tptacek 14y agoBecause when companies sell books to poor people in developing countries at steep discounts, rich people in the US buy them at the discount rate and "import" them back into the US. Book authors are generally thinking more about which second job they're going to get to pay their rent, because apart from some notable outliers, it's extraordinarily difficult to make a living as an author. But, by all means, let's make their work product even less marketable!
- lominming 14y agoInteresting comparison but failed at making a substantial argument. - Library has limited copies. If the library has only 10 copies, only 10 people have access to it. On Pirate Bay, 1 million people can instantly download and have access to it. - Time period to access an item. Even when 10 people have access to it, they will probably borrow it for 2 weeks. This limits circulation. However, it does bring up an interesting thought experiment. What if the library has 1 million copies of an item, and 1 million people can instantly borrow it? Essentially, what happens when a library is very effective? This comes down to whats the mission of the library. For NY library: "The mission of The New York Public Library is to inspire lifelong learning, advance knowledge, and strengthen our communities." This quickly becomes a very philosophical debate.
- ripperdoc 14y agoThis is all a very nice philosophical discussion. People argue that libraries do pay rightholders - whatever amount, it seems to be less than $1, and that's nice. BUT, why can't we just agree then that we pay a couple of dollars straight to the rightsholder and in exchange we get to download it with one click and use it as we like? Is it really that difficult?