3 ms·

Am I the only one around here who’s sick and tired of the bitching and moaning on every post about how something was vibe coded or written by AI? Without fail,

by jm4 3mo ago

Am I the only one around here who’s sick and tired of the bitching and moaning on every post about how something was vibe coded or written by AI? Without fail, someone complains and it shoots up to the top of the comments. It’s gotten ridiculous and it’s off topic. The easiest thing for you to do is just not engage with the post if you don’t like it. You people don’t need to pollute the comment section for anyone else who’s actually interested. Just about everything is vibe coded or written with AI these days. Assume that’s the default. Comments pointing it out or complaining about it is just noise.

martinky24 3mo ago
You could have simply just not engaged…? It’s no different. You’re doing a similar pollution! The lack of self-awareness is baffling.
- Rychard 3mo ago
  There is something to be said about this particular style of argument, as it's akin to the "paradox of tolerance". Ultimately I think the most fair thing is to let both sides attempt to build support until a clear victor emerges.
tlack 3mo ago
It seems like everyone is more worried about how something was made rather than what it is or whether or not the work is good on its own merit. Ironic from a group that is surely using AI tools in their own work.
- IshKebab 3mo ago
  How it is made is often a strong indicator of whether or not the work is good. You don't find many literary masterpieces scrawled in permanent market on a toilet wall.
  - lostlogin 3mo ago
    But you do find plenty of dubious traits in the authors (both the toilet scrawlers and the literary gods).
  - jschveibinz 3mo ago
    "...on the subway wall." - Paul Simon
  - rjsw 3mo ago
    They are not in the website business though.
    - IshKebab 3mo ago
      All businesses with websites are in the website business.
superb_dev 3mo ago
Vibecoding your whole website is an indication of how seriously you’re taking a project. With how new this company is and how clearly this whole website was made with AI, how can you trust a single thing this website says about a product that barely exists? The AI probably just invented half of it
- bruckie 3mo ago
  Worse than vibe coding is vibe copywriting—and it appears to have that in spades. I have a really hard time taking something seriously that reads like it came straight out of Claude Code without even a minimal editing pass. I hope it's legit, though, and that they succeed! I'd love to buy a product like they're planning to build.
- tclancy 3mo ago
  Damn you, company who isn't making websites for a living, where are your priorities!?
  - superb_dev 3mo ago
    Well when you don't even have a product to sell yet the website is the second most important part, right after actually making the thing. The website is there to sell preorders
skippyfish 3mo ago
I'm confused by your response. I was trying to understand if the product and the company are real. An AI-generated website is not a positive signal. Neither is the lack of any product photos. And if you go to Wikipedia, you'll learn that the REO Motor Car Company went defunct in 1967, with no mention of any revival. So my first thought was that it might be a subtle troll or a hoax. I did a bit more research and found the links to trade articles. It's not a dig at AI. And TBH, I'm sure that LLM's feelings weren't hurt.
jonathanlydall 3mo ago
I too find "looks written by AI" comments tedious. I feel that the following guideline [0] actually covers this, perhaps it should be updated to also specifically mention "AI written": > Please don't complain about tangential annoyances—e.g. article or website formats, name collisions, or back-button breakage. They're too common to be interesting. [0]: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html#comments https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html#comments
nearlyepic 3mo ago
> Just about everything is vibe coded or written with AI these days. And I’m supposed to just accept this? The fact that this is the case sucks. Don’t tell me to stop complaining about it. Just because you don’t have standards or have given up on trying to make things better doesn’t mean the rest of us have. Plus, it takes up a slot on the front page that could be taken up by something worth reading.

by jm4 3mo ago

martinky24 3mo ago

You could have simply just not engaged…? It’s no different. You’re doing a similar pollution! The lack of self-awareness is baffling.

Rychard 3mo ago
There is something to be said about this particular style of argument, as it's akin to the "paradox of tolerance". Ultimately I think the most fair thing is to let both sides attempt to build support until a clear victor emerges.

tlack 3mo ago

It seems like everyone is more worried about how something was made rather than what it is or whether or not the work is good on its own merit. Ironic from a group that is surely using AI tools in their own work.

IshKebab 3mo ago
How it is made is often a strong indicator of whether or not the work is good. You don't find many literary masterpieces scrawled in permanent market on a toilet wall.
- lostlogin 3mo ago
  But you do find plenty of dubious traits in the authors (both the toilet scrawlers and the literary gods).
- jschveibinz 3mo ago
  "...on the subway wall." - Paul Simon
- rjsw 3mo ago
  They are not in the website business though.
  - IshKebab 3mo ago
    All businesses with websites are in the website business.

superb_dev 3mo ago

Vibecoding your whole website is an indication of how seriously you’re taking a project. With how new this company is and how clearly this whole website was made with AI, how can you trust a single thing this website says about a product that barely exists? The AI probably just invented half of it

bruckie 3mo ago
Worse than vibe coding is vibe copywriting—and it appears to have that in spades. I have a really hard time taking something seriously that reads like it came straight out of Claude Code without even a minimal editing pass. I hope it's legit, though, and that they succeed! I'd love to buy a product like they're planning to build.
tclancy 3mo ago
Damn you, company who isn't making websites for a living, where are your priorities!?
- superb_dev 3mo ago
  Well when you don't even have a product to sell yet the website is the second most important part, right after actually making the thing. The website is there to sell preorders

skippyfish 3mo ago

I'm confused by your response. I was trying to understand if the product and the company are real. An AI-generated website is not a positive signal. Neither is the lack of any product photos. And if you go to Wikipedia, you'll learn that the REO Motor Car Company went defunct in 1967, with no mention of any revival. So my first thought was that it might be a subtle troll or a hoax. I did a bit more research and found the links to trade articles. It's not a dig at AI. And TBH, I'm sure that LLM's feelings weren't hurt.

jonathanlydall 3mo ago

I too find "looks written by AI" comments tedious. I feel that the following guideline [0] actually covers this, perhaps it should be updated to also specifically mention "AI written": > Please don't complain about tangential annoyances—e.g. article or website formats, name collisions, or back-button breakage. They're too common to be interesting. [0]: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html#comments https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html#comments

nearlyepic 3mo ago

> Just about everything is vibe coded or written with AI these days. And I’m supposed to just accept this? The fact that this is the case sucks. Don’t tell me to stop complaining about it. Just because you don’t have standards or have given up on trying to make things better doesn’t mean the rest of us have. Plus, it takes up a slot on the front page that could be taken up by something worth reading.