6 ms·
Why are people on HN still using Chrome? (or Edge, or Opera…)
by dotcoma 4mo ago
Why are people on HN still using Chrome? (or Edge, or Opera…)
- partiallypro 4mo agoThat's pretty irrelevant isn't it? Shouldn't all users demand privacy, especially from ads?
- dotcoma 4mo agoAll users should demand privacy, but they don’t. Take a look at Firefox’s market share, or Brave’s etc.
- JumpCrisscross 4mo agoWon’t Brave follow Google’s lead on this? Gecko, WebKit and—hopefully—Ladybird are the true alternatives. I used to think this was too extreme. But the ad vendor dragging ad blockers out of the engine flipped my view.
- dotcoma 4mo agoBrave, like Vivaldi, I think, have developed their own ad blocker. No idea if they will fight to keep UBlock Origin accessible or not. I think and certainly hope that Helium will fight the good fight.
- deleted 4mo ago[deleted]
- pseudalopex 4mo ago> Won’t Brave follow Google’s lead on this? They said they could offer limited MV2 support even after it’s fully removed from the upstream Chromium codebase.[1] [1] https://brave.com/blog/brave-shields-manifest-v3/ https://brave.com/blog/brave-shields-manifest-v3/
- riffraff 4mo agoBrave has its own ad blocker engine built-in rather than as an extension, and it can reuse uBlock's lists https://github.com/brave/adblock-rust https://github.com/brave/adblock-rust I use brave on my phone and I can't really tell the difference from desktop browser+UO, so I guess it works well enough.
- Gualdrapo 4mo agoEx-bosses used it so had to test shit on them.
- dotcoma 4mo agoOk but if you use it only for testing, and not for your ‘real’ browsing, then probably the fact that they track what you are doing is not that important, even if it’s still a nuisance. Or not?
- Scoundreller 4mo agoLocked down computers that still let you install extension.
- evolighting 4mo agoI'm a Firefox user for about 20yrs (since Firefox 3); but too often I have to use Chrome, as so many sites only work properly on it; Firefox is really buggy or laggy on those websites; For a time, all those AI chat web pages were just very slow on Firefox even with very little context, whereas Chrome only gets laggy when there is a lot of context.
- t0bia_s 4mo agoHow many extensions do you use on laggy FF?
- shellwizard 4mo agoNot using many extensions on my case, but Google meet remains unusable for a long time, sound is horrible during meetings. Chrome on the other hand works fine
- miriam_catira 4mo agoSame here, but when a site completely fails in Firefox I either A) use my phone because mobile Firefox occasionally works or B) use Ungoogled Chromium. https://github.com/ungoogled-software/ungoogled-chromium https://github.com/ungoogled-software/ungoogled-chromium Really hoping the uBlock will continue to work on that project...
- MasterYoda 4mo agoAre you really sure it’s not because of an add-on? If I remember correctly, Mozilla has said that about 95% of all pages that don’t work aren’t due to Firefox, but to an add-on. I use Firefox exclusively and don’t usually notice that pages don’t work. When that happens, as I said, it’s almost always an add-on that’s to blame. And I dont notice its buggy or laggy. So could be good check your addons next time.
- hansvm 4mo agoIs that a rhetorical question suggesting those people are wrong, or are you asking for, e.g., the technical reasons some software only works with Chrome in the mix?
- tgv 4mo agoI'm betting there are a lot of people here using Chrome as their "daily driver".
- dotcoma 4mo agoTo people who like Chrome, or some of its features (I love their bookmarks), I say: try Helium. Or Iridium. Or even Brave.
- worthless-trash 4mo agoWhich one isnt going to get unmaintained first.
- dotcoma 4mo agoBrave, then, I imagine.
- ceving 4mo agoDon't know, but I have uninstalled it a few minutes ago.
- TiredOfLife 4mo ago[flagged]
- kelnos 4mo ago> Firefox will also disable V2 sooner or later. Got a source for that, or is that just unfounded speculation?
- gblargg 4mo agoWell given a long enough timeline, everything will be disabled at some point.
- doikor 4mo agoThere is currently no plan to deprecate V2 manifest in Firefox. And Firefox version of V3 supports browser.webRequest blocking (the part that adblockers need to work properly)
- Krssst 4mo ago> Firefox will also disable V2 sooner or later. Source? > Firefox won't, because mozilla banned that extension from store. It's unbanned; the author chose to not put it back. https://www.ghacks.net/2024/10/01/mozillas-massive-lapse-in-judgement-causes-clash-with-ublock-origin-developer/ https://www.ghacks.net/2024/10/01/mozillas-massive-lapse-in-...
- maxloh 4mo agoYeah, pissing off the ecosystem is a great way to drive users to your competitors. Requiring users to manually install and update a popular extension is a subpar experience. It seems they spent so much of their budget on the CEO's salary that they couldn't afford an extension review team. Quoting open-paren comment (2024): > As far as I can tell, there are maybe two reviewers that are based in Europe (Romania?). The turn around time is long when I am in the US, and it has been rife with this same kind of "simple mistake" that takes 2 weeks to resolve. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41710183 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41710183
- 20k 4mo agoFor me the two reasons I can't live without are 1. Firefox's ctrl-f search doesn't highlight all instances of a found item on the right hand side. It sounds petty, but its a gigantic timesaver for looking through research documents 2. Firefox's tab crash recovery isn't as solid. I use chrome with fully persistent tabs, and its a gigantic pain if I can't re-open them If I could find a way to fix these I'd swap in a heartbeat
- Ennea 4mo agoFirefox has added highlighting of search terms in the page's scroll bar quite a few versions ago, if you want to give it another spin for that.
- 20k 4mo agoWeird, it still only highlights a single occurrence for me if I ctrl-f something, is there a setting for this or something?
- Chiron1991 4mo ago[dead]
- deleted 4mo ago[deleted]
- jeroenhd 4mo agoYou need to click "highlight all" to highlight all occurrences. It's the checkbox to the right of the search box. If you enable it for the first time, you may need to hit enter in the search bar again for it to show up (it remembers the setting and works instantly the next search)
- 20k 4mo agoApparently I'm just a moron and have never seen it has settings in 10+ years. Thanks!
- 4mo ago
- girvo 4mo agoWork forces me to on the work laptop. But Ublock Origin Lite is good enough for that use-case. I use firefox everywhere else.
- ano-ther 4mo agoSome pages do not work in Firefox, so I keep a copy of Chrome around. It’s a bit like with Internet Explorer which back in its day was also needed for some stubborn sites.
- fsflover 4mo agoName and shame?
- raffael_de 4mo agoNetflix.
- sakisv 4mo agoThis is not true. I'm a Firefox user and it works perfectly fine in Firefox.
- raffael_de 4mo agoWindows or Linux?
- CyberDildonics 4mo agoYou brought it up, you specify where it doesn't work.
- raffael_de 4mo agoNetflix doesn't serve maximum res for Linux and Firefox due to DRM related reasons. Chrome on Linux usually resolves or at least amends the issue.
- TingPing 4mo agohttps://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/netflix-1080p-ua/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/netflix-1080p...
- djfergus 4mo agoOn lower end cpus (N100) chromium/brave benchmarks 10-20% faster than Firefox.
- michaelt 4mo agoI don't, 99.9% of the time. But when your browser has a 2% market share worldwide, some developers won't bother to test on it. And if your setup is even more obscure (I use Firefox on Linux with an adblocker and third-party cookies blocked and DRM disabled and autoplaying video disabled and so on) making you rare even among that 2%, sometimes sites won't have tested with your specific configuration. It's useful to have a second browser around, as a fallback when a site is broken. Uploading images when creating a listing on ebay is broken, but I don't have to figure out which element of my setup is breaking it, I can just switch to the other browser.
- m-schuetz 4mo agoI switched from Firefox to Chrome a couple of years back because Firefox always dragged its feet when it came to implementing important developer features. Like, DataView was excruciatingly slow in Firefox; WebGPU support didnt go anywhere; and they initially refused to implement import maps. I consider the latter to be an essential tool as it allows me to work without the need for build systems. Also, chrome dev tools worked far better. Since Chrome blocked ublock, I switched to Edge. Not sure where I will go next, but I dont think it will be Firefox since they are always years late.
- maxloh 4mo agoActually, I opted in for tracking. Knowing my interests, Google suggests good articles on their Android app feed. Also, there are a few parts of Firefox that still look ancient, like the bookmarks and history managers, as well as the PDF viewer, where the buttons are too small to click easily. Unfortunately, those are unusable for a Gen Zer.
- dijit 4mo agoSince it underpins so much of the modern browser ecosystem it becomes a primary target for webapps to work. As such, if you want to be sure a website will work you use chrome. Since chrome has such a market share, developers feel justified testing primarily for chrome. Self-fulfilling cycle.
- OkayPhysicist 4mo agoThis isn't the 90's anymore where browsers behave wildly differently for the same page content. If you're not using absolute, bleeding age web APIs, Firefox and Chrome work identically. In my experience, there are exactly 3 types of websites that work differently between Firefox and Chrome: The Toy Hobby Experiments (who are just demoing some bleeding-edge API feature), The Monopoly-Bootlicking Liars (who reject my request based on UserAgent string alone, and when I spoof a Chrome UA the site works perfectly), and the Evil Monopolist Themselves (a few of Google's own sites run notably slower on Firefox, most notably Google Cloud Console).
- dijit 4mo agoWeird how vmware console and my bank don’t support firefox. Oh, and Microsoft Teams for a super long time (haven’t checked in a little while). Theres dozens of examples tbh.
- OkayPhysicist 4mo agoTeams has worked on Firefox (on Windows at least, haven't tried on Linux) since at least the beginning of the pandemic. Can't speak to the other two. What does the console start screaming about when you try?
- dvh 4mo agoThere are 2 reasons why I'm using chromium (with ublock origin lite) over Firefox: 1. Chromium is significantly faster (maybe 5 to 10x faster on certain tasks mostly around canvas but anything that requires fast ui really). Every time I use Firefox it feels like it has some kind of serious problem. If chrome was this slow I would stop working and start investigating what part of my computer is broken. This experience hasn't changed over span of 10 years, 3 OSes and several computers. 2. Neverending caching issues on Firefox. It just caches too aggressively which makes development really annoying to a point where anytime I encounter issue on Firefox my first thought is "Is this Firefox caching issue?". On chrome when I change button color and I don't see it, I know I made a mistake. If I change button color on Firefox, my first thought is, is this Firefox caching issue? When I develop web I have very quick update loop and I really can't be questioning browser. I cannot work like this. Firefox is unusable for me.
- emayljames 4mo ago[dead]
- elashri 4mo agoCtrl + shift + R would solve your second problem at all times. And I don't think your first point is quantified correctly and I am sure there is no data to back it up. But I understand the appeal of trying to quantify your personal experience.
- moebrowne 4mo agoYup, or open dev tools and enable "disable cache". This applies only while dev tools is open
- pebble 4mo agoI can back up their first point a tiny bit with regards to canvas. The primary product of our company is heavily canvas-based so I’ve always noticed that canvas on Firefox on macs is slower than on Chrome but it used to be in the 2-3x range and nowadays is more in the 1.5x range. They’ve made great improvements and I’ve never noted anything close to 5-10x slowdowns. On Windows Firefox and Chrome canvas has performed equally well at least for the past ten years. Got no data for linux tho.
- anal_reactor 4mo agoOn mobile, Opera is the only usable browser. It supports text reflow on zoom, and also I can choose the download folder for each file. Allows me to keep porn and non-porn downloads separate.
- nmeagent 4mo agoI keep chromium installed mostly to run virtual tabletop software (specifically Foundry VTT), because webgl performance in firefox is not great (though it has improved somewhat in the last couple of years). There are also a few sites (mostly restaurants for some reason) that just refuse to work properly in firefox, so I sometimes fall back to chromium. I wish I could drop it like a bad habit, because frankly Google's shenanigans piss me off on a semi-regular basis.
- nubinetwork 4mo agoFind me a browser that doesn't have ai shoved into it... and no I don't mean 10 year old versions of iceweasel.
- fsflover 4mo agoFirefox has a single switch to turn off all AI functionality. Does Chrome have it?
- nubinetwork 4mo agoI'd rather the code not be there at all, if they leave a toggle for it, they're likely to turn it on without my permission. Mozilla has little trust in my book after mr robot and their other nonsense.
- fsflover 4mo agoSo you trust Google who is killing any protection from tracking but do not trust Mozilla that supports a strong protection?
- nubinetwork 4mo agoI never said that I was a Chrome user, I said that I equally don't trust Mozilla.
- fsflover 4mo ago> equally Here comes the problem. I don't see how this is justified.
- Markoff 4mo agoonly reason I can think of is synchronization among devices since you can't find same decent browser you could use on Android phone and desktop, Firefox ain't decent browser on neither of those, on desktop Vivaldi with customization and stability is superior, on Android Firefox actually ain't THAT bad since good browsers with extensions support are not that common, I would recommend Cromite, though there is also Helium and Ultimatum
- fp64 4mo agouBlock Origin Lite works perfectly, so I have no complaints?
- fsflover 4mo agoIt doesn't protect from important tracking cases and will eventually allow ads, as the advertisers adjust: https://github.com/uBlockOrigin/uBOL-home/wiki/Frequently-asked-questions-(FAQ)#filtering-capabilities-which-cant-be-ported-to-mv3 https://github.com/uBlockOrigin/uBOL-home/wiki/Frequently-as...
- batperson 4mo agoEdge user here. For one, chromium is faster than firefox, any given page will load about 20% faster, another reason is edge workspaces feature, I've grown to like it, which seems to be some sort of chromium feature that everyone bakes in weird ways if at all, and I'm still running ublock origin on edge without any funky bypasses. Then there's a fact that a bunch of sites/webapps straight up refuse to work on firefox and they ask you to install chrome or something. And lastly chromium the most popular browser flavor and as a web dev it helps to see pages through "the same eyes" as my users/customers. That's about it, the only reason I use firefox every day is their superior picture-in-picture player, chromium one is waaay inferior.
- lelanthran 4mo ago> Edge user here. For one, chromium is faster than firefox, any given page will load about 20% faster, I'm skeptical; You're probably measuring Chromium + ads against FF + ads. The only fair test is testing agains FF + uBlockOrigin. And there, FF wins hands down.
- tgv 4mo agoI'm hardcore FF, and it used to be a bit slower than Chrome, but nowadays the difference is barely noticeable. And on very large pages (e.g. big tables), Chrome is a lot slower than FF.
- nchmy 4mo agoGive Vivaldi a try. I used edge on windows and android ever since it started used chromium, and switched to Vivaldi on Linux and android 8 months ago. Generally quite happy with it - not really missing any features from edge.
- pseudalopex 4mo agoTo access Edge Workspaces, you’ll need a desktop running Windows 10, Windows 11, or Mac OS, Microsoft Edge version 144 or later, and to be signed into Microsoft Edge with a Microsoft (MSA) account or Microsoft Entra ID / Azure Active Directory (AAD) account.[1] > Then there's a fact that a bunch of sites/webapps straight up refuse to work on firefox and they ask you to install chrome or something. This is rare in my experience. And most were fixed with an extension to change the user agent string. Or were for amusement and used a new Chrome feature. Or used a feature Mozilla rejected for security and there were alternatives. [1] https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/edge/features/workspaces?form=MT0160 https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/edge/features/workspaces?for...
- pjmlp 4mo agoBecause they don't bother to learn the history, worse, they are also worshipping Electron crap, which is basically Chrome.
- hgoel 4mo agoI switched over to Edge from Firefox because it was simply much better at managing its memory on my laptop. With Firefox I had to be far more cautious about having too many things running at once. WSL2 would often be killed to free up memory. Recently I found they added the ability to auto-sort and group tabs via Copilot, probably the only thing I've found the non-GitHub copilot to be genuinely useful for.
- AltruisticGapHN 4mo agoBecause Chrome is the better browser, lelz.
- tgv 4mo agoI'll bite: why is it better? Did you try Safari or Firefox or Brave, and find deficiencies you can't live with?
- AltruisticGapHN 4mo agoThe UI is just better overall. Ever since Chrome came out with the "unified search bar" imho Firefox was behind in usability. Firefox just follows. Like recently didn't they add tab groups after Chrome implemented them? Isn't Brave based on Chrome? Personally I think it is really stupid to choose a browser based on privacy. I choose a browser based on usability. Whats the selling point of Brave? That it hides ads? Safari's OK if you're on Mac. I'm on Windows 11. Chrome looks tight, the tabs look great, my bookmarks bar looks great and I can fit a ton of bookmark folders on there. Firefox looks worse in almost every way.
- tgv 4mo ago> Personally I think it is really stupid to choose a browser based on privacy. I choose a browser based on usability. As in: you don't care about your privacy?
- JohnTHaller 4mo agoI use Firefox for everything on Windows, macOS, and Android. I do have to keep Chrome around on desktop due to VirusTotal + reCaptcha setup to be purposely onerous for non-Chrome users. I'll get caught in loops trying to scan files after only scanning a few where I'll get like 5 absurdly vague captchas in a row. You must solve all of them in a row or it starts over from the beginning. It does this even if I'm logged into Google, logged into VirusTotal, and have uBlock Origin disabled on VirusTotal.com. It appears to be by design. So, to ensure I get to scan all my PortableApps.com releases, I have to use Chrome.
- veber-alex 4mo agoIt's fast. All websites work. I like how it handles tabs and tab groups. uBO Lite is good enough for me.
- bigstrat2003 4mo agoBecause it works and I don't have any compelling issues that would cause me to switch. I switched to Brave a while back (cause built in ad blocking) and have been quite content with it.