13 ms·
Einstein's list of conditions for staying together with his wife
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- pav3l 14y agohttp://www.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,1211594,00.html http://www.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,1211594,00....
- davesmylie 14y agoIt's hard to reconcile the popular folk hero that is Einstein with a letter like this. I suspect a lot of this may come from us not being in a position to judge people from almost 100 years by the standards of today.
- scarmig 14y agoI suspect that even a century ago that list of demands would have been seen as very cold and mean.
- refurb 14y agoWe don't really know the back story is I guess. I could see if their relationship had completely fallen apart by this point, but that they both wanted to stay together even though they were no longer in love, that a couple could come up with ground rules like this. Who knows what her list of demands for him were?
- PeterisP 14y agoThese aren't 'prenup' demands, these are no-love separation demands. What points exactly feel mean to you? Requests for lack of intimacy are understandable, given the no love situation. It is strange that the household chores are described - at the time it would be 100% understood that it would be so even if it wasn't written down; apparently it was a problem in their past. I mean, at that time and place, wife not cooking for you would be reasonable grounds for divorce. The "no belittling before our children" is natural as well.
- romnempire 14y agoi mean, i don't see what's wrong with it, even by today's standards. she probably didn't work, so it's practically just a relaxed maid contract. i mean, hiring a woman you shared kids with solely as your maid would be weird by today's standards, but bigoted? don't see it.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- pfortuny 14y agoYeah there was a previous agreement called marriage before which puts that list in a very specific context: it is not a "contractor" relationship.
- callmeed 14y agoWhat's to reconcile? You will find character flaws and chronic bad judgement in the most successful/accomplished people–it will just be in some other area than what they're known for. John Calvin had a man burned at the stake. Henry Ford was an anti-semite. 8 of the first 10 US presidents owned slaves. And, no, I don't think it's a matter of shifting standards. Look at Bill Clinton, Martha Stewart, etc.
- seanmcdirmid 14y agoConsidering Einstein didn't kill anyone...he did OK. No one is a saint (except for maybe a saint, but then I've heard crazy things about Mother Teresa also).
- philwelch 14y agoEinstein didn't directly kill anyone, but he did sign a letter to President Roosevelt urging him to fund research into nuclear weapons.
- tadfisher 14y agoI think this is a rational thing to do -- after all, he was fearful of what would happen should the Germans have completed their nuclear program first.
- philwelch 14y agoSure, but there's a big moral weight on using your fame and influence to get your government to built atomic bombs. Though this was before the advent of strategic bombing, so I'm not sure how obvious it was to Einstein exactly how such a weapon would ever be used.
- mylittlepony 14y agoYeah, he only helped to build the most destructive weapon ever.
- ekianjo 14y agoMaybe I am missing something but since when was Einstein considered as a "popular folk hero" ? I have never heard of him portrayed as anything but a renowned scientist (with controversial political views).
- victorhn 14y agoYou must live in another world, as Einstein is maybe the most popular scientist/genius in any part of the world.
- ekianjo 14y agoI do not question the popularity of Einstein, I just wonder why the term "hero" is applied to him in the parent post. Why would Einstein be considered a "hero" compared to other scientists ?
- peterarmstrong 14y agoHis hair. Seriously.
- waterlesscloud 14y agoAnd his eyes. And that one equation that's easy to remember and sort of understand vaguely.
- nthitz 14y ago"They eventually divorced in 1919, having lived apart for five years." Surprise surprise...
- aidenn0 14y agoPresumably they got divorced so that Albert would be able to marry his second wife that he had been in a relationship with for a while at that point.
- tadfisher 14y agoHis second wife also happened to be his first cousin. Interestingly, they shared the "Einstein" surname (their fathers were also first cousins) and would have shared it at the time they married, but Elsa had already married and divorced by that point.
- wilfra 14y agoThis is one of those rare HN posts that would be better to discuss on Reddit. I doubt the community here would do anything but downvote the most appropriate/interesting comments.
- monochromatic 14y ago... what?
- cup 14y agoConsidering the post has already drawn such comments as > " He was right about so much, you have to wonder if he might have been right to list-slap that gal." you might be correct.
- DanielBMarkham 14y agoI had heard a while ago that Einstein was a womanizer. Looks like he was a demanding jerk as well. Just goes to show that there is usually a huge difference between what we think of historical figures and how they actually were. It's interesting how much we want our heroes to be pure and spotless -- unlike any other humans we encounter.
- chimeracoder 14y ago> Just goes to show that there is usually a huge difference between what we think of historical figures and how they actually were. It shows that people are complicated and multifaceted. While we have a tendency to either laud or vilify figures (with nothing in between), in reality, historical figures can be both "good" and "bad" in different aspects of their lives... just like the rest of us. My favorite example of this is Helen Keller[1]. Almost nobody these days knows anything about Helen Keller beyond the age of 18 - they know that learned to communicate despite being deaf and blind, but the nearly 70 years of her life after that are almost buried in history. Which is a shame, because Helen Keller would have been a notable figure in her own right even if it weren't for her disability[2]. But because she was a member of the official Socialist party, we can't use her story as an inspirational lesson and mention that she held political beliefs that we may or may not agree with. Instead have to make a judgement call as to whether her "good" or her "bad[3]" side is more important to teach, and then forget about the rest. Worse, this principle is applied in reverse to dehumanize people whom history has classified as villains. The result is that our history is filled with monochromatic caricatures, and we forget that, were we to see the complete picture, our modern-day "villains" may not look so different (for better or for worse!) [1] I believe Loewen talks about this in his excellent book Lies My Teacher Told Me (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lies_My_Teacher_Told_Me http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lies_My_Teacher_Told_Me) [2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Helen_Keller#Political_activities http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Helen_Keller#Political_activiti... [2] Naturally, this presumes that you either disagree with socialist politics or think that history lessons should be politically neutral, which is the predominant belief in the USA.
- aufreak3 14y agoIt is more complicated I think even in the case of Einstein. The period of strained relationship mentioned coincides with the period during which he was building up General Relativity (which he published in 1916). Given the intensity of work that would've been needed for that (all that gorgeous new math and physical insights!) with wrong turns to avoid in every move, it is well conceivable that his marriage was placed at risk. This list might even have been his way of expressing that his life priority is finding a unified theory of everything. Now when I write that, does our welcoming of his great contributions need to make us guilty of also endorsing morals we perceive behind this "list of demands" he made of his wife?
- kasra 14y agoHe reminds me of Sheldon Cooper.
- dm8 14y agoI had same reaction. It looks unerringly similar to Sheldon Cooper's relationship agreement. May be writers of Big Bang Theory might have referred to this letter to draft that.
- kasra 14y agoHe reminds me of Sheldon Cooper.
- 001sky 14y agoThis reads exactly like an employer/employee relationship. [1] -- Whether ironically or obviously ... is harder to tell. ________ [1] eg, no sexual expectations of a colleague (ie, harassment), no disturbing a colleague's work/space, no insulting in public manner (of a colleague in front of clients, etc).
- sarah2079 14y agoThis makes him sound like a jerk, but man was life tough for couples who stopped getting along back when men did all the income earning and women did all the child care and housework. This actually seems like an OK arrangement when you think about it in that context, they were both holding up their ends of the bargain. It just makes me glad that both men and women are more independent these days.
- macey 14y agoMost of these demands relate in some way to staving off a meaningful emotional connection, keeping things "all-business" etc. There's significant evidence that Einstein had a form of high-functioning autism (likely Asperger's). A signature symptom of Asperger's syndrome is discomfort with emotional intimacy and a lesser capacity for empathy. I can't say if that's true or not, but if you combine these symptoms with the state of women's' rights at the time, this really isn't surprising at all - and in any case, there are far more explicit examples of sexism from this period.
- sliverstorm 14y agoAt least Point D seems reasonable, he's only 75% cold?
- saheel1511 14y agoI see lots of people commenting how Einstein was a jerk, etc. But somehow, I think that list (if it's real) just shows that he wanted order (and control?) in everything he did, which doesn't resonate as bad to me. We have no idea what kind of relationship he had with his wife, so I think it is unfair to judge him like that solely based on that list, more so, because his wife accepted it!
- illuminate 14y ago"more so, because his wife accepted it" That people cope with emotional abuse in different ways does not justify emotional abuse. As plenty of people mentioned in the thread, this was a different time when women had less possibilities and support systems for themselves.
- randomdata 14y agoShe couldn't really expect him to be the sole breadwinner for the family, and do all the housework, and be always there for her emotional needs. There has to be some give and take. I'm not sure why his request for a reasonably equitable partnership would be considered abuse? These are, most likely, the issues that lead to the demise of the relationship in the first place. It is the only way their living arrangement would be able to continue at all.
- unreal37 14y agoWe have no way of knowing WHO was the emotional abuser, or even if any emotional abuse was going on. That's quite a leap from what we know.
- illuminate 14y agoWell, aside from the infidelity, sure. I was saying that because someone agreed to a set of conditions, it doesn't make the conditions necessarily okay or reasonable.
- pfortuny 14y agoOh yeah there are a lot of children accepting labour conditions in the East of Asia with which we get scandalized and the. this is ok: she accepted! come on....
- mladenkovacevic 14y agoAs the resident Serb here I should point out a Wikipedia page on Mileva Maric who was a brilliant scientific mind in her own right: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mileva_Maric http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mileva_Maric There are even some theories that she helped him early on in his career although there is no strong evidence to support that theory. As part of the divorce agreement Einstein made with Mileva, his Nobel Prize money was transferred to her and in trust for their two sons.
- klepra 14y agoWhy are Serbs always pointing out their nationality?
- hilko 14y agoAny ideas on why?
- zerostar07 14y agoDon't forget the balkans have been destroyed multiple times by nationalistic wars, most recently in the Former Yugoslavia, so nationalistic sentiments may be more prominent.
- majelix 14y agoIt tends to be more about ethnicity than nationalism per se, but yes. Your membership in the Albanian/Serb/Roma/Croat/etc. community is central to your personal identity in the Balkans, far outweighing where you happen to live or where you happen to spend your Sunday mornings/Friday afternoons. They're all interrelated though, so it gets complicated rather quickly. But yes: Serbs are proud to be Serbs.
- aswanson 14y agoYou guys have got to chill out. You've got beautiful landscapes, mountains, ancient architecture there. Why focus on that divisive ethnic bs? Enjoy your area of the planet.
- masterponomo 14y agoHe was right about so much, you have to wonder if he might have been right to list-slap that gal.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- sethbannon 14y agoThe entire site is, unfortunately for productivity, a treasure trove of interesting historical lists. For instance: http://www.listsofnote.com/2012/04/simple-rules-for-life-in-london.html http://www.listsofnote.com/2012/04/simple-rules-for-life-in-...
- prawn 14y agoFrom a different site, but relationship oriented: Charles Darwin's list covering the pros and cons of marriage: http://www.brainpickings.org/index.php/2012/08/14/darwin-list-pros-and-cons-of-marriage/ http://www.brainpickings.org/index.php/2012/08/14/darwin-lis...
- noonespecial 14y agoMy favorite: F × S = k. The product of Freedom and Security is a constant. To gain more freedom of thought and/or action, you must give up some security, and vice versa. These remarks apply to individuals, nations, and civilizations. Notice that the constant k is different for every civilization and different for every individual. --Larry Niven
- revgeeky 14y agoLike a boss!
- zoba 14y agoDifferently from most other comments, I didn't see this as Einstein being a jerk. I more feel compassion for him since, to me, this list is like an admission of his solitude. It must be quite lonely being so unique as Einstein. Most people have a hard enough time finding someone who they can relate to. When you're as publicly distinguished as he was I imagine finding someone to relate to must've felt entirely hopeless. Particularly since she was a bright woman, and 'on paper' should've been a good match and now it wasn't working out. Einstein's second marriage was with his cousin which could be seen as more evidence of his desire to be able to relate to someone. Having family history probably helped them feel close, and he probably gave up on someone being able to relate to his intellectual pursuits by that time. Unfortunately I don't have any hard evidence to point to support my ideas. I have been thinking of this since Steve Jobs died and have been wondering how such unique people like him, Einstein, and others dealt with not being able to feel true connection with another human being.
- ricardobeat 14y agoDrifting off-topic, but according to written history SJ did have strong relationships with his wife, children and friends.
- unreal37 14y agoNow way off topic, but I don't think Steve Jobs is comparable to Einstein in the same way. Einstein needed long months of solitude to come up with his formulas, which must have been brutal on his family and friend relationships. Steve Jobs had other people execute his vision.
- erichocean 14y agoI'm not disagreeing, but I'll add that having "vision" itself is a form of execution. Sometimes I think we give the impression that having "vision" is like some innate quality a person has, and not the result of intense effort over a long period of time, which is what it actually is.
- freework 14y agoI think there are two types of 'geniuses'. One type is 'people geniuses'. These are people like Steve Jobs, Ronald Reagan, Sarah Palin, Billy Mays, etc. These people are geniuses in the way they were able to understand people and get the to do things (vote for them, buy their products). The other type of genius are the 'systems genius'. These are people like Tesla, Einstein, Newton, etc. The first group are not renown for their intelligence, the second group are not renown for their people skills.
- jacquesm 14y agoLots of judgments in this thread. Don't judge a man until you've walked a mile in his shoes. And keep in mind that we're looking at all this from almost a century later and that society has moved on quite a bit. Things that my grandparents would have considered perfectly a-ok would look ridiculous to you and me. Context is everything. In plenty of places in the world this would be an 'amicable arrangement' even today. Mote, beam, eye etc. Without knowing what went on before this it is very hard to judge the list. Maybe they reached a stage of armistice and decided to live like this for the sake of their kids. Whatever it was, it spells out tragedy rather than malice.
- rehack 14y agoAgree with you. Otherwise, it was totally puzzling to me a simplistic, judgmental view calling him a jerk as a top comment. Don't know how many people have been married a long time here (i.e. > 10 years). Looking at the responses, it seems to me not that many. Thankfully, my marriage is several orders better than his was. But still I can perhaps see where the conditions are coming from. Just to take an example - C(3) - you will leave my bedroom or study immediately without protest if I request it. I can see that for whatever reasons any fights between a husband (who works from home) and wife start when the husband is nicely all set to begin the day's work. It may be over a trivia discussion (perhaps because the husband has some work related frustration) or it could be the result of something building up. Now as a husband who is working from home, does not even have the choice to go to work elsewhere, in such a situation. And the argument/discussion/fight won't end until one person leaves the place. And countless hours can get lost, for a trivia thing.
- waterlesscloud 14y agoIt's a pretty safe bet that most people reading this know a couple living under terms a lot like these. Right now. Today. The fact that we're often not aware of it doesn't change the reality. When it comes to other people's relationships, the one thing you can be absolutely sure of is that you don't really understand them.
- mmaunder 14y ago
- wildranter 14y agoTo the individuals who are defending Einstein's behaviour towards his wife, I'm sorry to inform, you'll be ripped off of everything you have in a messy divorce. If you really think that's the right way to treat a person, please do a favor to humanity, marry your hand. Now that aside, looks like Einstein was human after all. And one full of behavioural defects for that matter. He could've handled that in a much more civilized, and I dare to say, adult way by just having a honest conversation with his wife. It's very easy to explain your goals, and why you need cooperation from your family to achieve them. If you can't, you have deeper problems than not being able to work properly.
- wildranter 14y agoTo the downvoters, I meant it as a personal advice. However, your disaproval yield two things: Firstly, I'm right. Down voting what I said doesn't alter the truth embedded within. Unless you change your mind and grow your heart, you're gonna get screwed by a divorce lawyer. Secondly, it's just a freking integer on my screen, I like better floats! No mater how much that counter gets decremented you're still looking at it from the wrong perspective.
- dyeje 14y agoYou know after reading the comments on here I was expecting something really horrific. It was pretty short and not all that ludicrous when the time period is taken into account.
- smadaan 14y agoWithout making this about judging a specific person in a certain context, what are the implications today? (Some) folks seem to suggest that since Einstein was working on something as significance as GR, the solitude prioritized over family made sense. If Einstein's work had not succeeded, would the justifications still hold? Actually... the question on my mind is: every person trying to do something on their own believes in their heart that it is the most important thing, something that will change the world. How far should one take that conviction/belief as justification to forego responsibilities of being a spouse or parent?
- Tichy 14y agoDoesn't a person have the right to demand solitude either way? He presented his conditions for getting on with the marriage. The alternative is to simply get a divorce. If what he needs is solitude, what is he supposed to do? I mean I don't see where the guilt comes from?
- fimbaz 14y agoChrist, what an asshole.
- nu2ycombinator 14y agoconditions reminded me of Sheldon from Big bang theory tv series
- stuaxo 14y agoNo wonder she looks a bit pissed off in that picture !
- sayYaeah 14y agoOr 'What To Send Your Wife If You Want a Divorce'.
- Ilmarinen 14y agoWhy is this piece of celebrity gossip on hacker news?
- sh_vipin 14y agoProbably because it was after his divorce we got the famous quote ( which applies so well to entrepreneurship ) - "A person who has never made a mistake has never tried anything new."
- maked00 14y agoPoor guy, sounds like he married his mom. She must have been a real harpy. All perfectly reasonable requests.
- frendiversity 14y agoPeople are naturally manipulative, especially in relationships, and people naturally play mind-games without necessarily knowing they are. A quarrel ending in a door-slam can have damaging effects on the psyche, as a common example that most of you have experienced. It can make it difficult to concentrate. This just seems to me to be a typical negotiation tool during a relationship gone wrong, trying to prevent further emotional distress. Nothing to see here.
- mattacular 14y agoThis comes as a huge shock... developers on HN defending obviously misogynistic behavior with an ample dose of cognitive dissonance and mansplaining. Also since when does staying together in a terrible relationship benefit the children? That is a specious argument at best.
- CletusTSJY 14y agoLike a boss. Just kidding, this list is ridiculous and he should have never married if this is what he was expecting.
- mcgwiz 14y agoHis goal was to create a sustainable relationship with her, and therefore he proposed a new set of expectations of her in consideration of his household cash flow. She consented to them; she wasn't forced to. This resembles a typical "live-in servant" relationship. The only strange part is that this falls out of a prior arrangement/agreement that was considered a "marriage" relationship. It's obviously no longer marriage in spirit, so why all the judgment of it that way?