8 ms·
The Old Guard: Confronting America's Gerontocratic Crisis
- bell-cot 7mo ago[flagged]
- XorNot 7mo agoThat's just mandatory voting. The fine for not voting in Australia is about $30. This is...nothing in the grand scheme of things. But it's enough. And you don't even have to vote: you have to turn up, that's it.
- FireBeyond 7mo agoYeah, I've lived in Australia and the US. The fine isn't big, the attempts at suppressing voter turnout or inconvenience aren't there, and the privacy of the ballot box means that even if you turn up, and put a ballot in the box, no-one's stopping you writing "You all suck" and not casting any preferences.
- Forgeties79 7mo agoBut at that point you are choosing to explicitly express your non-support of the candidates. That is still more meaningful than simply not showing up IMO
- FireBeyond 6mo agoThe Australian system is certainly not perfect, but I think the indirection of the "leader of the party" choice and Prime Minister is helpful - it promotes a greater willingness of the party members to say "Okay, you're hurting -my- re-election chances now", with the result being, whether the ultimate motivation is self-interest, you often (or much more when I was younger) would see no-confidence votes and leadership changes, certainly far more than in the US, where I am now. And signals like you mention, "explicit non-support" seem to carry greater weight.
- stackedinserter 6mo agoDoes Australia perform better?
- CalRobert 6mo agoMaybe the real secret is the free sausage.
- egypturnash 7mo agoThis would mostly end up punishing people who live in places where voting is deliberately made difficult due to having to skip an entire workday (and its pay, if you're paid hourly instead of salaried) to go to some out-of-the-way location to vote.
- NegativeK 7mo agoA not thoroughly thought out response: Those people would heavily incentivized to protect their ability to vote.
- hilariously 7mo agoPeople in America die from preventable illnesses constantly because they cannot afford access to care but I guess they forgot to protect the ability to not die or whatever.
- solid_fuel 7mo agoNo, they're already being suppressed. They'll take the easiest action possible to ease the pain, which means voting for whoever does away with the fines.
- Teever 7mo agoHere’s a better proposal: add none of the above to every ballot. If a super majority (say 80%) pick that the election is an automatic do-over and the people on the ballot can’t run for a period of say five years. A couple cycles of this will flush the crap out of the system.
- throwaway173738 7mo agoWe could pay people to vote. Many states have unemployment insurance and that system could be repurposed to give people a wage for election day without making it political.
- deleted 7mo ago[deleted]
- WalterBright 7mo agoPenalizing people who don't vote will not result in carefully considered votes. Voting rights include the choice to not vote.
- kevin_thibedeau 6mo agoMandatory voting would be nice to have, but it is a form of compelled speech.
- defrost 6mo agoWrong. In Australia, mandatory voting is compelled real or virtual attendance. You are required to cast or mail in an anonymous response, that response can be blank, a vote for someone not listed, a regular vote, a donkey vote, paper with many pictures of various genitalia, etc. No speech is compelled, no pen to paper is compelled, just that registered voters are ticked off the rolls and those registered that don't respond provide at least a weak excuse (my grandmother was sick that day) or face a nominal fine (eventually). Think of it a citizens part to play in a democracy, the commitment to at least pay attention to the government hired by and paid for by citizens.
- bell-cot 6mo agoBeyond "what superficially sounds best for me", I don't see much evidence of "carefully considered" voting now. :(
- bell-cot 6mo ago9 hours, 5 serious HN users replying...and nobody noting that "A Modest Proposal" might flag satire.* Or that my "proposed" solution, in many ways, describes the current status quo. Tricks like California's Prop. 13 have created enormous gaps between the taxes paid by the old and the young. Warren Buffet has criticized how much lower his own (income) tax rates are than his secretary's rates. Some days I feel really, really old. *https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Modest_Proposal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Modest_Proposal
- ungreased0675 7mo agoTerm limits would fix it
- adrianN 7mo agoDemographics in most developed countries make catering to old people the strategy to win elections.
- applfanboysbgon 7mo agoTerm limits are perhaps the dumbest idea that ever plagued democracy. The idea of mandatory firing your most qualified, experienced employees in an incredibly difficult job that can only be learned with on-the-job experience is literally insane. If not for term limits, the US would have had Obama in the presidency this entire time instead of the absolute garbage scraps that were left over when they fired the only person remotely competent enough to lead them.
- cosmotic 6mo agoExcept in many cases the experience isn't benefiting the electorate.
- applfanboysbgon 6mo agoAt that point, the blame lies with the electorate for choosing to re-elect somebody who has a proven track record of harming them. You can't realistically prevent people from making bad choices in a democracy, at some point the voters have to have accountability for who they choose to vote for. Restricting who they are allowed to vote for is liable to backfire if you're arbitrarily removing the best candidates from the pool, especially out of a misguided belief that term limits prevent elderly politicians from taking power (yet Trump was elected for his first term at 70, his second term at 78, and Biden for his first term at 78... because, allegedly, disqualifying 55-year-old Obama in 2016 was somehow meant to help prevent geriatric politicians from being in power).
- ungreased0675 6mo ago
- deleted 7mo ago[deleted]
- tsunamifury 7mo agoThis is likely the worst issue humanity will be facing over the next 50 years, even more than climate change. An increasingly old demographic will sabatoge the future of humanity as they drain enormous resources and abuse democratic processes to reroute resources to their preservation of life over young people and familes. Young people and families will choke to death under the strain of elders who demand unlimited services, money, support while outvoting them, staying in jobs and houses and giving little to nothing back to society. Innovation will grind to a halt, families will continue to shrink, work hours will get longer and longer as taxes get higher and higher to pay for and increasingly super old leadership and voting base. Society will begin to lose hope to solve problems like going into space or fixing climate change as increasingly the elderly population will obsess over themselves and continued life. It is one of the hardest moral problems we will face in our era.
- MrBuddyCasino 7mo agoI don’t know why people downvoted this because it is obviously correct. In a democracy you have to buy the votes of the largest constituency with other people’s money, which in this case is the boomers votes with the younger generations money. This will continue until nothing is left. This already happened with the triple pension lock in GB, mathematically ensuring the bankruptcy of the state.
- lenerdenator 7mo agoIt's happening in the US, too. I know of a senior couple where the husband recently retired after forty years of working in a professional field. They live in a house worth over $750k that is paid off. They have three new or late-model vehicles. Both the husband and wife could, if necessary, work for an income. They also collect Old Age, Survivors, and Disability Insurance checks after enrolling for them. The common name for this is Social Security. Why the hell are they able to collect on that? They have the ability to work and assets that could readily be made liquid to fund living expenses.
- nixon_why69 7mo ago
- deleted 7mo ago[deleted]
- lwansbrough 7mo agoBeing ruled by Generation Lead doesn’t seem like a great improvement.
- ImPostingOnHN 7mo agolead-ership
- franktankbank 6mo agoIts right there in the damn name!
- vi_sextus_vi 6mo agoVenetian Republic wasn't big on lead piping. not what you'd expect for an Italian entity..
- 01100011 7mo agoOld people are organized and more social. I see it in my community. They run the newsletters and they host community events. "Oh that's because they're retired!" No, many of them are not. Many still work. I want the gerontocracy to end, but I'm also worried what takes its place. Gen Xers like me seem to lack some of the abilities present in our older generations. We'll probably be more equitable and fair, but will we be as politically effective and organized towards achieving our goals? I sort of doubt it.
- throwaway173738 7mo agoOrganization is a skill that can be passed on, and to the degree that old people are still doing it themselves they’re depriving us of opportunities to learn and to practice and to benefit from their experience. That’s why we’re not as good at it.
- lostapathy 7mo agoRelatedly, it's a skill that goes with positions that are clung to such that nobody else gets to practice and learn said skill.
- WalterBright 7mo agoAn awful lot of young people are starting businesses. Look at all the people under 30 becoming billionaires. This just didn't happen when I was young. https://www.forbes.com/sites/mattdurot/2025/12/22/why-there-are-suddenly-so-many-self-made-billionaires-under-30/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/mattdurot/2025/12/22/why-there-...
- estimator7292 6mo agoYes it did. Billionaires are a relatively new thing, but successful businesses were led by young people across the entirety of human history. And you should not praise someone for simply being a billionaire. That's a bad thing to be.
- johngossman 7mo agoWhile I mostly agree... Venice was run by very old men. It was common for the Doge to be in their 80s. Meanwhile, many of their neighbors had kings who were very young, sometimes teenage boys. Venice was the longest lasting, most stable state in Europe.
- Mistletoe 7mo agoIt may have been stable and dominant in spite of that, like America, currently being run by senile old men. The human mind is a biological computer and it isn’t pretty the older it gets. https://medium.com/psyc-406-2015/how-fast-does-iq-decline-can-you-do-anything-about-it-f5ca370d8b62 https://medium.com/psyc-406-2015/how-fast-does-iq-decline-ca...
- johngossman 6mo agoAverage is probably not what you need to worry about: I'd bet David Attenborough and Mel Brooks still have IQs considerably higher than the average 25-year old. And I'm not convinced IQ is as important as that elusive factor called character. But you may be right. Maybe what the US really needs is a lagoon.
- floodfx 7mo agoThe Doge had no power.
- johngossman 6mo agoWelcome to my rathole: Venetian history. To expand on your thesis, the Council of Ten was the executive power in Venice, but the Doge and minor council attended the Council of Ten meetings and the Doge often chaired those meetings. And even if he was powerless, the Council was made up of other old men. I don't want to push this whole argument, I'm not recommending we adopt the Venetian constitution. But I don't think you can blame current chaos on age.
- izacus 6mo ago
- 0xDEAFBEAD 7mo agoCommentators: "America's young are addicted to their phones, hopelessly politically polarized, and socially illiterate. Test scores are dropping and critical thinking skills are at an all-time low. They hate and fear the other gender, mainline conspiracy theory podcasts, struggle with anxiety, were coddled from birth, etc. etc." Also commentators: "The elderly have to go. We need fresh blood." (Yes I acknowledge there is a middle position where you elect 45-year-olds who came of age before the internet yet are still reasonably sharp mentally. I just think it's interesting that the two narratives above seem to coexist so easily.)
- Terr_ 7mo agoBut are they the same commentators each time?
- 0xDEAFBEAD 6mo agoI didn't claim they were. Just claimed that those two narratives have been coexisting for a while and I've never seen them duke it out.
- jandrewrogers 6mo agoHonestly, 45 year olds will probably have some of the most objective views across that reality.
- throw-234 6mo agoAh yes, the squeeze in the middle. My default assumption is that people outside ~35-45 range are often impatient to the point that they are, for practical purposes, functionally illiterate Older side has those who invented and lived by powerpoints / the executive summary, and they are more executive than ever, preferring to leave early or not show up at all because it's time for golf. On the younger side, people who grew up on social media and twitter, very media literate in some respects but also often stuck at high-school level reading / writing at best. They are leaving early too, because it's not like staying will help them get ahead! You know what these very diverse groups have in common? Shared disinterest in nuance, and the idea that no matter how subtle something is, 280 chars or 2 slides should just about cover it.
- throw-234 6mo ago> Our gerontocracy is not the result of a malevolent plan, .. Boomers aren't distinctively evil.. The fact that they are so numerous and the fact that they are aging in era when life has been extended make the syndrome endemic. .. America faces a gerontocratic crisis of succession on the scale of society itself. The melodrama of succession—waiting for the old to make way for the new—defines not only our politics but also our economy and our culture writ large. I'll be honest, everyone I know thinks cordial relations between the generations are over. Seems like the author knows it too but wants to be gentle. Let's just say it. America straight up looks Saturn devouring his children. Is he horrified? Sure, but mostly just horrified to be caught in the act. And now that he thinks about it, kind of disgusted with you that you'd want to be so judgemental about the whole thing. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saturn_Devouring_His_Son https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saturn_Devouring_His_Son We may continue to see generational wealth-pumps installed by the elderly to destroy the youth, but at some point soon it will be a kind of survival cannibalism. Boomers did it for fun and are still doubling down every chance they get.
- jmull 6mo agoSounds dramatic, but what are we talking about here? Are you planning to work through democratic processes or do you mean revolution?
- xboxnolifes 6mo agoby law, then by unrest, then by revolution.
- jmull 6mo agoBy law is how we got to where we currently are. There's no reason to think that would change. You'd have to trick all the people who are old (plus all the people who realize they will get old too) to vote away their assets, income, and power. Unrest will just harden the people who see your cause as unjust against it. That will be a strong majority of people, so will go no where. Revolution seems highly unlikely to succeed -- it would be unpopular and you'd have to turn much of the military/police to your side. Frankly, I think the push of the idea of the intergenerational conflict is a con. It will not lead to anything getting better, but when people are angry and scared, they become vulnerable. Be wary of anyone offering big, impossible promises. They'll be sticking their hands into your wallet soon enough.
- bdangubic 6mo ago“The world is run by old men in a hurry” https://www.ft.com/content/1d41a591-940d-4936-b79f-4c7857138903 https://www.ft.com/content/1d41a591-940d-4936-b79f-4c7857138...
- RickS 6mo agoI have trouble predicting how public sentiment will evolve over time. I'm not that young, and still and the last 10 years have left me with an absolutely blistering distrust of the 70+ crowd on any matter pertaining to positions of authority. I'd like to see ~67 and ~72 become the other 18 and 21: hard lines beyond which the law progressively rescinds the presumption of total competence. It's not a pretty solution. There are certainly some 14 year olds who are more deserving of a drivers license than many of legal age. I would welcome a world where we can actually establish and enforce criteria that allow us to move beyond such crude numeric thresholds. But in the meantime, the bulk of us need protection from statistics. Desperately.
- johngossman 6mo agoGo look at the demographics of the last election and then tell me which groups shouldn't be allowed to vote.
- RickS 6mo agoThat's a response to an opinion I don't hold, but I could have been more clear. The claim I'm making is about the fitness to hold office. Specifically: septo/octogenarians belong at the ballot box, but not on the ballot. If you'd like to dissuade me of something, that's the meat of it.
- jgeada 6mo agoWhat is the justification? Why can someone vote for a future they're not likely have to endure? We don't allow under 18s to vote, so clearly some age restrictions are legitimate.
- mylifeandtimes 6mo agoHey, I hear you, but the age cutoff could also be on holding office. As someone just hitting the 60 yr old mark, and looking at my parents who are still pretty sharp in their late 80s, -- so definitely talking about myself and my capacity here, No-one over 70 has any business in a high ranking government office. The mental flexibility isn't there. Which means no one over 66 should be allowed to run office (yes, I know this puts senators in office until 72, and kicks out representatives at 68, but it also gives a single number which is easier to understand). It's also a question of accountability. A 40 year old politician will expect/have to live with their choices for another 40 years.
- momo26 6mo agoThe interactive challenges and the step-by-step mental models for recursive types and distributive conditionals are incredibly well-structured. It's cool to transform type gymnastics into a systematic engineering discipline.
- dzonga 6mo agothis problem with older people not giving in to younger ones is prevalent everywhere. professors - with tenure - they can die on the job. board rooms are visibly older e.g average age of Apple board members 68. the partners at law firms etc. now very few companies have very few succession plans. in other parts of the world even worse e.g in Africa - you have presidents with one foot in the grave tryin' to rule.
- y-curious 6mo agoWell the problem is much more pronounced as people live longer and longer. I think this will all come to a head soon. Social security, for one, is going to exceedingly get strained as people draw on it for longer. Being alive also doesn’t mean you’re competent.
- stackskipton 6mo agoProblem is, Social Security will be solvent until 2037 at current prediction which means it goes insolvent when youngest boomer is 73. So basically most of them will get all their Social Security, die and leave Gen X to get fucked.
- TheCoelacanth 6mo agoFortunately insolvency in this scenario mean that they will only be able to afford to pay around 3/4 of promised benefits. Closing that budget gap is a problem that will need to be dealt with, but it's not impossible to fix and it's a fairly long way away. There are a lot of proposals going around for how to fix it and those will become more politically palatable as it gets closer.
- underlipton 6mo agoHa, that's the way to really get Western society to rethink its trajectory. "You know, the things you're doing? Sounds quite African." The Southern Strategy is underutilized as a tool to rebuild, rather than dismantle, works for the public good. (/s but kind of not?)
- alphawhisky 6mo agoThis article touches on the fact that old folks have much more money accumulated than younger people, and this causes a large social disconnect. Maybe if we put a cap on the age for voting (i.e. no voting once you retire) then older people would be incentivized to spend their wealth, time, and energy on young people in the hopes that they would carry the torch politically. Regardless, it's obvious by current inflation of assets that these folks don't mind pulling the ladder up if it benefits them, and something should be done about that.
- newsoftheday 6mo ago> old folks have much more money I retired last year, lead software engineer, never got into management as a civilian, did software for over 3 decades. My salary was lower than it was as a mid level 20 years ago. What old people have "much more money", maybe they can send some my way. I thank God for Social Security and hope and pray it remains well into the future, even for the 99% of the people who are saying bigoted, dumb shit on this page.
- Lutzb 6mo agoPensioners in most western countries are the second most affluent cohort.
- memcg 6mo ago"Building a fairer system—with the elderly divested of political power, wealth, and property, but guaranteed dignity and state support at the end of their lives—would help everyone, including most of the aged." So, we just have to take all the wealth and property
- onetokeoverthe 6mo ago[dead]