13 ms·
The Importance of Being Idle
- mitchbob 7mo agoEarlier discussion of Lafarge's The Right to Be Lazy (217 comments): https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33901623 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33901623
- Fricken 7mo agoAnd Bertrand Russel's "In Praise of Idleness" (1932) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40257677 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40257677
- dripdry45 7mo agoI started with “How to Be Idle” by Hodgkinson about 20 years ago. Found “The importance of living “ by Lin yutang. I now have a small collection of books about idleness… yet here i am working and then throwing myself into working on a century house in my spare time… feeling starved for idleness. Yet my most creative ideas for it come when I’m idle. Idleness led to Taoism, the pursuit of being useless. Led to Buddhism: just sit. As the quote sort of goes: The great preponderance of society’s problems come from people’s inability to sit quietly in a room by themselves. It’s a noble pursuit, idleness. Really. If you haven’t tried it, give it a real shake. A little more might fall out than you expect.
- sph 7mo agoThese essays on idleness, along with the more radical ones against work in general (love Bob Black’s take on it), have been great comfort to my tired soul. I will once again recommend the works of philosopher Byung-Chul Han, especially The Burnout Society. The older I get, the more pointless I find the modern goal of productivity. If there is one asymptotic goal one should rather pursue, is to do the most with the least bit of effort. And it all circles back to the teachings of the Tao. Be like water, not like the machine.
- syphia 7mo ago"All of humanity's problems stem from man's inability to sit quietly in a room alone." - Blaise Pascal Translations vary slightly.
- Animats 7mo agoComputers, TVs, video games, and smartphones have solved that problem. There are now more things to do alone in a room than ever before. It didn't help.
- lmf4lol 7mo ago"All of humanity's problems stem from man's *inability* to sit quietly in a room alone." - Blaise Pascal Smart phones etc just prove that we can't sit quietly in a room alone.
- latexr 7mo ago> Computers, TVs, video games, and smartphones have solved that problem. No, they exacerbated the problem. The point of the quote is not the being alone, but the doing nothing. All your examples just made it harder to do so because there’s always something you can distract yourself with. The point is that you should be able to be alone with your thoughts and nothing else.
- iammjm 7mo agoHow is that quiet or alone? Stuff you listed is exactly the perfect enemy of what Pascal meant.
- a96 7mo agoBP died in 1662 and that's a translation. The phrasing isn't quite timeless or perfect. The central point anyway is the ability to be without entertainment and possibly also focus. Not just people.
- nullhole 7mo agoIt's hard to escape the tick-tock of time slipping away, even if there's no clock in the room
- nicbou 7mo agoYou can microdose idleness. Be productive in general, but make time for doing nothing without guilt. I made it a habit to spend my first waking hour idle, and it feels great.
- tonyedgecombe 7mo agoI prefer to microdose work.
- mjklin 7mo agoReading Lin as a teenager made me want to visit China, where I met my wife. Thanks Lin!
- namanyayg 7mo agoIt feels like there is no correct translation for it in English -- idleness carries connotations of laziness whereas a better way to think about it is being aware and present of the moment. I have been practicing Buddhism for a while and it often is indescribably blissful to just sit in nature, feeling the wind in my hair and sun on my back. Anyone can experience this door with just a little bit of practice and I encourage everyone to try.
- pandatigox 7mo agoI think I would say a better variant would be "the importance of being still"
- 10729287 7mo agoAs a french I like the term "idle", as the state my computer switch to when i'm not asking it anything.
- strken 7mo agoI have never practiced Buddhism and it is still indescribably blissful to sit in a clearing in a forest, provided you aren't sitting on the wrong kind of anthill.
- rewgs 7mo agoIs there a right kind of anthill to sit on?
- ibeckermayer 7mo ago[flagged]
- deleted 7mo ago[deleted]
- supliminal 7mo ago[dead]
- suradethchaipin 7mo ago[dead]
- christoph123 7mo agoI don't know... I know a few people who inherited enough money to be idle and they don't seem particularly happy with their idleness. Could of course be the social pressure we live in, and that could change if we're all idle.
- hackable_sand 7mo agoThe ability to be at peace Everyone struggles with it. Would be nice to have some societal hooks so that more people could be confidently serene And then go about their day
- silversmith 7mo agoWhat do you mean by societal hooks? The ability to be at peace, in my world view, stems first and foremost from the ability to be at peace with yourself. Being able to look in a mental mirror, and accepting the image staring back as yourself, warts and all. It's not exactly liking every last imperfection, rather not feeling guilty for not measuring up in all aspects to the ideals of a society or dreams of your younger self. Accepting that you are not the universal paragon and probably never will be, all the while not giving up on the idea of improving yourself. Only when one can be locked in a room with oneself for a measure of time and not get in a fight, can we talk about being at peace with society and other external factors.
- tock 7mo agoIt's conditioning. We cannot be happy idle because society deems idleness as bad. Just like people cannot be happy with a balding hairline because society has deemed it to be ugly. If the trend changes in a century and balding is suddenly hot then the same people would be happy.
- mr_toad 7mo agoIt’s all about sex. Being idle typically means being poor. Try being in the dating market when you’re poor. Being bald means being middle aged which is also a big negative in the dating market. The people who are lauding the virtues of being idle probably have money, and are of the age where they’re past measuring success by body count.
- pestatije 7mo agoproblem with being idle is you end up with nothing to show for it
- camillomiller 7mo agoI hope that people realize still that LLMs will never ever be able to produce a piece like this. This is extraordinarily written. It is etymologically out of the average. It’s complex. Concepts intertwine and build on each other. The linguistic choices are unusual but perfectly placed. >>“But even idlers, try as they might, cannot ignore the passage of time. In 1911, a dozen years before Capek published his essay, Paul Lafargue and his wife committed suicide—he was 69; she was 66. His reason, it seems to me, dovetailed with his philosophy”. “Dovetailed”. Call me when an LLM will ever be able to pick and use such a perfect, yet statistically improbable, word to construct such a sentence.
- gilbetron 7mo agoThis easily could be AI generated, there is little character to it, and if you told me it was AI generated, I would believe you.
- camillomiller 7mo agoYou clearly don’t understand shit about good writing.
- justonceokay 7mo agoIf you’re picking apart sentences looking for signs of AI then you’re already rotted. Address how it makes you feel and the argument being made. Determining if something’s AI generated just gives us another reason not to engage. Like solving a puzzle on the kids menu instead of eating the food on the plate
- missingdays 7mo ago> Address how it makes you feel and the argument being made. Why are you telling other people what to talk or not to talk about?
- ejoso 7mo agoHrmph I say!
- addybojangles 7mo agoThis was a great read. Thought-provoking.
- s20n 7mo agoReminds me of the essay 'In Praise of Idleness' by Bertrand Russell <https://harpers.org/archive/1932/10/in-praise-of-idleness/ https://harpers.org/archive/1932/10/in-praise-of-idleness/>
- lmf4lol 7mo agoI really do like the idea and the thinking behind it. I wpuld even argue that modern Europeans are already embracing and practicing much if it. Nearly no one I know in NL and DE works more than 36hrs per week. And we all have a sh”tload of holidays and irregular days off additionally. Need to get kids from school earlier? no prob… Need to spontanously (!) to go the dentist? no prob. (Honest disclaimer: I am talking here solely about my white collar bubble, no idea about blue collar to be honest. Not much contact with people from that field unfortunately) So we surely made progress here in the direction of being more idle (though one could question wether you are truly “idle” if you fill your free time with staring at your phones screen, consuming the latest societal rage bait. But i’d say in the spirit of the essay, yes, we are much more idle thanks to tech). BUT! Is this a survival strategy? While we Europeans are super idle, Chinese arose to be a super power. The US dominates tech and the future technologies. Russia is banging on our front door and we dont have the military means and will to put an end to it. So while idle ness is a great mode for Being, is it a great mode for making sure the own civilization survives? Thats always my problem with those ideas. They sound super nice in theory, but in the harsh world, there will always be a predator who just works a little bit hardwr to get you … anyway! loved the essay. thanks for sharing
- zemvpferreira 7mo agoEuropean who has travelled/lived extensively in China and the US. I don't believe our problem is idleness. It's instead a pernicious belief in peace. There's no sense of geopolitical competition in society at large. We generate a lot of wealth in those 36 hours, but an immense amount of it is syphoned into areas that don't help us get ahead. We are too invested in tides that lift all boats. Being well-rested is not the issue. Edit: I’ve recently started spending a lot of time in Switzerland and the contrast in mindset (and wealth) with the EU is staggering. There is a healthy amount of communal paranoia. They don’t work any harder either, if anything it’s the contrary.
- joe_mamba 7mo ago>I don't believe our problem is idleness. It's instead a pernicious belief in peace. There's no sense of geopolitical competition in society at large. I disagree entirely. It's because most EU workers(at least in the richer most developed countries) don't get a proportional slice of the fruits of their labor, but only breadcrumbs after taxes. Working harder as an EU employee just means your boss/company gets to be richer and your government gets more of your taxes, while you get nothing more in return, just taking home a few extra bucks at the end of the month, making the juice not worth the squeeze, causing everyone to optimize for doing the bare minimum because why bother. Especially when the big city CoL rises higher than your salary anyway, what's the point of working harder? You'll be more tired now and still won't be able to buy a nice house, ending up on the same standard of living and housing affordability as someone who optimized his life around extracting the most amount of welfare and benefits from the government while dodging work. So then why wouldn't you do the same? Same story around entrepreneurship and VC funding or lack thereof. The taxes, risk and responsibilities of being a business owner with employees on your payroll are far higher that in other places on the planet like the US, making it a better deal to just not bother with all that and choose the cushy life of an employee in a old dinosaur company in an ageing and declining industry, rather than the stress of being the employer/innovator. Geopolitical competition will not fix this because the monetary incentive structure around hard work still remains messed up. You can fix this by changing the tax laws to reward those working harder instead of punishing them with higher taxes and no gains to pay for the lifestyles of those who contribute the least in society. Simply look at what Poland or Czechia did to become economic powerhouses in a short amount of time, and just do stuff like that. And you'll find out they didn't start off by giving their workers Scandinavian style of income taxes, welfare and benefits, that I can tell you, but more like cutthroat capitalism and the harder you work the more you can earn tax structures.
- shevy-java 7mo agoIRC taught me to idle to power. Still doing so in 2026 ...
- PinkSheep 7mo agoTurn this into linkedin-speak, how you inevitably are promoted to power and a leadership position. This is not a tactic, it is a long-term strategy. #softskills #success
- milan777love 7mo ago[flagged]
- bell-cot 7mo agoPerhaps. But if you look into the history of that idea, you may notice that it's almost always applied to the young and the lower classes. Perhaps the Baron, Bishop, and Business Magnates are too godly to be at risk?
- milan777love 7mo agoI don't mean it in a clock more hours in at the factory way. Some people can direct themselves. But you've got to do something, even if only for the personal outcomes, i.e. comparing retirees who keep busy to those who do not, you'll find a significant effect on health, satisfaction with life. And of course there's a ripple effect on others, I am one who gets many presents cooked up in that workshop, and am hardly alone.
- bell-cot 7mo ago> Some people can direct themselves. That's the ideal. Really is a complex grayscale, depending greatly on the person's current circumstances. And, factory or not, for society to function it needs 99% of people to pick from a pretty short list of fairly prosocial choices. > But you've got to do something, even if... Yes-ish? I'm not saying it was good - but society didn't much mind people being couch potatoes watching 1960's-era TV. Vs. falling down the addictive rabbit holes of modern social media - that's not looking like it can end well.
- sunny678 7mo agoIt is really thought provoking. Interesting how lafargue saw machines as a path to freedom, yet today we fear them for the opposite reason. Maybe the real issuen't AI replacing work, but our inability to redefine what "valuable time" looks like without it.
- latexr 7mo agoThe issue is that he saw machines as working for the greater good of all, yet the reality we have are machines working for the benefit of a select few, who use that advantage to perpetuate the system where they are at the top and everyone is below. We have the technology to feed and clothe everyone and live comfortably, just not the collective will. Too many of us have been sold the fake idea that “everyone can make it” but individually. That you should be selfish and trample over others for your own personal success, instead of defining success as helping everyone do better.
- quirk 7mo agoThis is so full of holes I don't even know where to start. But the main one is that you have a false dichotomy in assuming that individual success and "helping everyone do better" are mutually exclusive. For example, see the free market economy of the past 250 years.
- latexr 7mo ago> This is so full of holes I don't even know where to start. I recommend you start by understanding the argument instead of straw manning it. > But the main one is that you have a false dichotomy in assuming that individual success and "helping everyone do better" are mutually exclusive. So your main objection against my point is an argument I haven’t made? There is a canyon of difference between “we have been sold idea X” and “idea Y and Z are incompatible”. Of course you can have individual success while helping everyone do better, because if you help everyone do better you also help yourself. That’s obvious, you are part of everyone. > For example, see the free market economy of the past 250 years. Yeah, that really helps everyone, that one there. No problems whatsoever that anyone can think of. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Free_market#Criticism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Free_market#Criticism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Criticism_of_capitalism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Criticism_of_capitalism
- udave 7mo agoits a good idea in theory. But capitalists will make sure this does not happen because greed is never ending. today its AI, 10 years down the line it something else. Hence i think the right to be lazy is for a lucky few.
- latexr 7mo ago> Hence i think the right to be lazy is for a lucky few. The freedom or ability to be lazy may be for a lucky few, but the right should be for all. A right doesn’t stop being a right when it’s not being observed, and when that happens it should be a warning to us all. For example, access to clean water should be a right. But some communities don’t have it, and we should collectively help them. Due process is also a right, and when people are systematically captured from their communities and unilaterally stuck in a cell, we should collectively remove the power to do so from those who are doing it.
- littlexsparkee 7mo agowell not only that but the space to think about systems of power and possible realities (like the COVID lull) is antithetical to capitalist aims. leisure is doled out just enough to prop up consumer spending. if you restrain your desires you can buy back your time (FIRE) but that affordance is reliant on the status quo (others consuming so that your investments do well).
- maplethorpe 7mo agoI feel like right now is the worst time to be idle. Stopping to smell the roses or lie on the grass when you could be spinning up agents and burning tokens means you'll be left in the dust.
- sph 7mo agoSaid the Hare to the Tortoise.
- maplethorpe 7mo agoIf you read the whole fable, the hare lost because he stopped to lie in the grass. If he had just kept going, he would have won easily. It would have been embarrassing for the tortoise.
- latexr 7mo agoOh you will, will you? And what, pray tell, happens in this dust you’re left in? What’s the reward for working so hard right now? More work? What a rotten deal. It’s common for people on their death beds to wish they had spent more time relaxing. It’s not common for anyone to wish they had spent more time working. The sentiment you’re expressing has been sold to us for a long time, way before “agents” were a thing. “You have to work harder, pull yourself by your bootstraps, build a company, spend all your free time on side projects, …”. It’s a grift designed to keep you busy, selfish, and brain dead, oblivious to your own condition and the state of the world. Stop drinking the Kool-Aid.
- tonyedgecombe 7mo agoAnybody can spin up agents and burn tokens. There is nothing special or particularly valuable about that.
- Eyosias_x5 7mo ago[dead]
- sanbor 7mo agoIt is very important to have the time and freedom to be idle. In our modern society, however, we hear the phrase "time is money". So, if you are idle, you are not making money. Instead of being idle, you should be busy. "business" is good. I learn this play of words in Spanish. Idle in Spanish is "ocio". Business in Spanish is "negocio". Thus negocio is the combination of words "negación" and "ocio". The phrase "negación del ocio" translates as "idleness denial/negation".
- Leomuck 7mo agoBoy does that resonate with my current feeling. I've spent the last maybe 18 months constantly working, paid, non-paid, voluntary work, side-projects, etc. I almost feel like I'm confusing myself with the amount of work/different projects I have. All while whenever I find an hour or two to just sit idle in the sun, I feel the very best, happy almost. No, I have nothing to show for this time, I can't go to bed with the feeling I've achieved something, I wasn't productive. But I feel.. good? We have all learned (especially men I think) that we define parts of ourselves through what we achieve. However, is that a good idea? Also, what counts towards that goal? Did I achieve something if I support a friend that struggles? Or do I only achieve something that can be added to my CV? Who am I trying to show what about me? I absolutely love the idea of being idle. It strictly goes againt current societal developments, but I think it would do a lot of good for a lot of people. We don't have to perform all the time, we don't have to be perfect all the time. What's the end-goal anyway? Rich people, statistically speaking, are not more happy. Managers with 60 hours a week often suffer from depression or burnout. The only two valid reasons in my mind to work hard are: 1. bring in enough money to live comfortably (which unfortunately isn't achievable for many) and 2. do good for society. Meanwhile, most people are struggling to even get by and tech CEOs can buy a new fancy car every day and tell us how to deal with the disruptions they cause? They tell us how we can save the economy? Why us? What did we do for the economy to be bad? Did we start wars, increase the cost of oil, create a self-inflicted banking crisis? What's it to us anyway? We're the ones suffering in the end, regardless of what we do. I also find it quite irritating that the comments started discussing geopolitical power conflicts regarding idleness. Anyway, I'm going to shut down my computer now and enjoy the sun. Happy idleness guys!
- ThisNameIsTaken 7mo agoIn a similar vain, I currently enjoy reading A Philosophy of Walking by Frederic Gros. Gros draws the musing of various philosophers on walking. To me, his description of the slow beat of the footstep that propels imagination resonates with how walking works for me. When I'm stuck on something and feel I need to keep pushing towards a solution, a short break, often the result of an obligatory walk/ride to the train station, already sets my mind in motion. Crucial is that the walk is not an intentional break for the purpose of brainstorming, because then my thoughts stay stuck. Such walking is 'idle' in the sense that it is an almost automatic process. The whole point is that walking/idling should not be a productivity tool.
- k1m 7mo agoIf you enjoyed this article, you might also like: Head-Trapped – Descartes, Dawkins, Hobbes, Marx, Mill, Darwin, And The Myth Of Western Civilisation. > Marx, then, argued that the more we subordinate our creative needs to dead capital and its goals, the less we are. But this is also true when we subordinate our creative needs to revolutionary goals in the future. Why? Because the future is non-existential, it does not exist; it is as dead as capital. https://www.medialens.org/2023/head-trapped-descartes-dawkins-hobbes-marx-mill-darwin-and-the-myth-of-western-civilisation/ https://www.medialens.org/2023/head-trapped-descartes-dawkin... The author's book, A short book about ego, is also very good.
- opinion3k 7mo agoWe need more businesses run like the co-op models in some European countries where the workers own a large percentage of the business. Or those rare, profitable US companies that are privately held and offer significant ownership stake to their employees with upside (not fake startup options). I don't expect to ever be in that position, but I couldn't imagine becoming a multimillionaire off the backs of my employees and to keep on stacking more money than I could ever spend just to feel like I'm still winning. Point is, there's enough money being made to employ just about everyone and at fewer than 40 hours a week, but instead we have multi billionaires with more money than a dozen generations could spend.
- abcde666777 7mo agoIdleness is something we crave when we lack it, but too much of it can also be its own kind of hell. For instance, post retirement depression.
- cindyllm 7mo ago[dead]
- pat_erichsen 7mo ago[dead]
- freemoss 7mo ago[dead]
- lo_zamoyski 7mo agoOtium refers to leisure, not laziness. And leisure in the classical sense is not idling, but rather activity that is not "servile", but rather free. So, for example, contemplation and the study of philosophy in pursuit of wisdom, with no immediate practical or instrumental aim, would be an example of leisure. Indeed, the opposite of otium is negotium, which is to say the negation of leisure. This supports the idea that classically, work was seen as subordinate to leisure and indeed something that was supposed to enable leisure. Today, we rather think of leisure as a recuperation from labor to which we must inevitably return. In Greek, we see something similar: schole meaning "leisure", and its negation ascholia meaning "busyness". Josef Pieper wrote "Leisure: The Basis of Culture" [0], a book on this subject that people should read. John Paul II also wrote an encyclical, "Laborem Exercens" [1], that discusses, among other things, the purpose and nature of work and responds to both communist and capitalist views on the subject. [0] https://ballyheaparish.com/resources/Leisure-The-Basis-of-Culture-copy-2.pdf https://ballyheaparish.com/resources/Leisure-The-Basis-of-Cu... [1] https://www.vatican.va/content/john-paul-ii/en/encyclicals/documents/hf_jp-ii_enc_14091981_laborem-exercens.html https://www.vatican.va/content/john-paul-ii/en/encyclicals/d...
- deleted 7mo ago[deleted]
- oliver236 7mo agowow, secular culture finally realizes that the sabbath is good
- mzelling 7mo agoIntermittent idleness is appealing and even productive, as it often surfaces valuable ideas from your subconscious. That said, today's society is badly equipped for idleness. With phone notifications going off every few minutes, it's difficult not to be constantly interrupted with the "task" of looking at a text. Let's throw out our phones first, then we can experience true mental repose.
- butlike 7mo agoPerpetual Do Not Disturb is a better stopgap
- mzelling 7mo agoI agree for the most part. DND isn't perfect, though. When you're bored, your mind naturally searches for things to do, and you'll be tempted to proactively check your lock screen, which unhelpfully informs you about "3 messages received while in Do Not Disturb." Now you really want to know what those messages are. This is why I tend to keep my phone physically far away from me, and out of sight.
- returningfory2 7mo agoIn my experience turning off my phone solves the temptation to check it. The friction of having to turn on my phone is small but apparently enough.
- a96 7mo agoSome smaller doses of friction include not putting icons of entertaining apps on home screen or removing such apps entirely and e.g. using a browser if you need a particular service. Making sure unlock requires entering a (long) code. Making the colour scheme dull, maybe B&W mode. Removing notification permissions as much as possible. Turning off notifications on lock screen.
- butlike 7mo agoLess phone usage makes for less phone usage. It gets easier. Now I don't particularly care what the messages are if they come outside of my designated "message checking time." Anecdotally, I'd give it 3 months of "reduced phone usage mindfulness." For further reading, check out the wikipedia article on ∆FosB expression, which is a gene expression which essentially tells your body to keep doing things that release dopamine. It takes about 3 months for the ∆FosB expression to decay.
- larodi 7mo agoThis whole essay very strongly resonates with the anti-natalistic movement. The fact the protagonist of the story kills himself adds to this in a very unmistakable manner.
- nyeah 7mo agoPlease! "Machines of loving grace" comes from Richard Brautigan, not Dario Amodei! https://allpoetry.com/All-Watched-Over-By-Machines-Of-Loving-Grace https://allpoetry.com/All-Watched-Over-By-Machines-Of-Loving...
- deleted 7mo ago[deleted]
- auvi 7mo agoI was expecting the Dutch term niksen.