9 ms·
Inside Team Romney’s whale of an IT meltdown
- brudgers 14y agoFrom Slate back in July: an interesting background piece about the campaign's approach to staffing for data analysis. http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/victory_lab/2012/07/the_romney_campaign_s_data_strategy_they_re_outsourcing_.single.html http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/victory_lab/... What the debacle brings to mind is the consequences of putting "idea guys" in charge of software development when there is a hard deadline. "Orca had been conceived by two men—Romney's Director of Voter Contact Dan Centinello and the campaign's Political Director Rich Beeson." I imagine them saying, "We shall have an app," while thinking, "How hard can it be?" While the developers were rationalizing, "Well, a web app is technically an app...and a lot easier to complete than an iPhone app, an Android app, and the web app we will still need to build for the old people with a Windows desktop."
- eli 14y agoA Web App is actually the right call. It was for volunteers doing GOTV in the field, not as much for people sitting at a desktop. And you would want to be able to issue updates quickly and carefully control access -- things that are much more difficult with an App Store app.
- lifeguard 14y agoUsing Windows was a mistake, that's for sure. Good thing for Democrats they didn't know about the open source ushahidi platform.
- WrkInProgress 14y agoHow did you determine using Windows was a mistake from the information presented in the article ?
- meepmorp 14y agoCause it's a bias of his, likely. What I get from the article is a classic tale of crappy IT management, the like of which I've seen and heard of several times.
- njharman 14y ago"Using Windows was a mistake" is a truism. Also, from the article, project failed. Failure is regularly equated with having made mistakes.
- timeshifter 14y ago> "Using Windows was a mistake" is a truism. No. No, it is not. > Failure is regularly equated with having made mistakes. And what mistake did Windows make here? Keep the baseless insults inside your head, please.
- recoiledsnake 14y ago> "Using Windows was a mistake" is a truism If you use or have used StackOverflow or Newegg, realize that you too are using Windows. Projects' success and failure is much more correlated with the folks running them than the technologies they use.
- smsm42 14y agoIn the same vein, one could claim use of humans to write code was a mistake. After all, the project failed, this means they made a mistake, so obviously they should have used trained hamsters instead. Do you see where your logic failed you?
- lifeguard 14y agoA: ungraceful crash under load
- ams6110 14y agoSorry, a database-backed web app works just fine on a Microsoft stack, there are thousands of them out there and I say that as someone who vastly prefers unix but this is clearly a project management fiasco and architecture design fiasco, not a technology stack fundamentally unable to handle the demands.
- timeshifter 14y agoWhy do you choose to throw out an insult at Windows? Is there anything about this story that points to Windows being at fault? How about you think before you flame next time, okay?
- lifeguard 14y agoI have been a professional webmaster since 1995. I have worked for California's largest privately held webhosting company. I am an MCP in Windows server and have been the only guy on staff willing to support customers with IIS. I base my statement partly on that experience.
- timeshifter 14y agoIf you want to make a thread for insulting Windows, go right ahead. It has absolutely no place in this thread, which was about people failing, not any specific technology. People can fail with Apache just as badly as they can fail with IIS. I'm a web developer who's made his career working with IIS. I think you know where I'm going to tell you to shove your insults.
- atlbeer 14y agoStackoverflow crashes daily
- lifeguard 14y agoDon't take it personal. Inferior products need support, too. You will always be able to find work making IIS sites as long as MS is selling server software.
- Daishiman 14y agoLooks like someone has a bit of an emotional investment on a tool, eh?
- timeshifter 14y agoNope, I just strongly dislike tangential and unfounded insults.
- outside1234 14y agoYou can fail on any platform with bad implementation and/or bad management and/or bad planning. That's the lesson here. (and at Twitter when they fail whaled for months on end with Rails - it wasn't Rails fault - it was the application of Rails in too high a volume deployment)
- scarmig 14y agoNGP-VAN, which is probably the most important company in the Democratic sphere, uses a Microsoft stack. And it didn't lead to a spate of post-election recriminations about how its tech fell apart.
- lifeguard 14y agoUsing the MS stack for a situation where you will have huge spikes of activity on an app with an expected lifespan of less than 24 hours is not best practice.
- acdha 14y agoI'm an open source developer – working on Linux servers since 1997 or so, etc. etc. Please stop what you're doing: it's not very funny and it's not helpful, but it does give OSS people a bad reputation. You can host plenty of high volume things on Microsoft's code – Azure, Bing, etc. have proven scale. We can argue about cost, ease of use, etc. but a decent team should have no trouble making a serious service. The problem here is that they didn't hire a decent team – from the sounds of it, it was the usual executive-level schmoozing and managerial incomplete you see throughout large organizations of every type. They could have used HN'a favorite stack and failed just as hard.
- lifeguard 14y agoHey, dogs can swim but that doesn't mean I use them to pull a barge up the river. I will not shut up about the ground truth I and many other people know about Microsoft and their software.
- acdha 14y agoThe way you're doing it won't will anyone over. Open source has been winning where I work because we've demonstrated better results with less cost. I suggest you try to outperform rather than out-market.
- waqf 14y ago
- brudgers 14y ago"A Web App is actually the right call." Yes. Calling it "an app" however was a bad call. From a practical standpoint, that is. From the standpoint of "an idea guy" and a "communications expert" it was of course a requirement.
- eli 14y agoWhat else do you call it? A "mobile website"? I don't think that's the real problem... the real problem is none of the users actually had an opportunity to use prior to it being absolutely mission critical.
- zachrose 14y ago"It's a website: http://orca.mittromney.com http://orca.mittromney.com. It works on smartphones."
- 7952 14y agoBut so much can go wrong with an app, especially in the field. Give every team leader a fax machine, a phone, and some pens.
- smsm42 14y agoThere's nothing wrong with web app over mobile app. Actually, recently here on HN was a number of articles about coming trend of switching from native apps to HTML5/web apps. It is a valid choice, especially when you need to communicate a lot of data, so you need network connection anyway. Of course, that web app needs to be working - but the choice itself is completely fine. Given the circumstances, I would seriously consider going the same direction if I had to do an app like that.
- smacktoward 14y agoOrca had been conceived by two men—Romney's Director of Voter Contact Dan Centinello and the campaign's Political Director Rich Beeson... To build Orca, the Romney campaign turned to Microsoft and an unnamed application consulting firm. This sounds like a lot of failed IT projects in large corporations -- dreamed up by upper management types who don't know anything about tech, then farmed out to consultants and tech vendors for the actual implementation. The consultants and vendors then either proceed to wander in the weeds expensively due to lack of direction, or actively seize on the client's ignorance and take them for a ride. The problem is that the people nominally in charge of the project, the upper management types, don't have the experience or expertise to know they're getting taken for a ride until it's too late. So there's no way to hold the contractors accountable, or to get the train back on the rails once it's jumped off.
- incision 14y ago>This sounds like a lot of failed IT projects in large corporations -- dreamed up by upper management types who don't know anything about tech, then farmed out to consultants and tech vendors for the actual implementation. The consultants and vendors then either proceed to wander in the weeds expensively due to lack of direction, or actively seize on the client's ignorance and take them for a ride. In my experience, this is 100% correct. At least this mess has been exposed to some degree. There's something of a saying around these kind of projects to the effect of "This project -WILL- succeed". The subtext being that that no matter what the facts are, the project will be promoted publicly as a success. It's incredibly disheartening to see an abortive mess transformed into a sparkling success via fake dashboards, paid press and the like.
- brazzy 14y agoO2 had such a "success" in Germany, to the tune of (IIRC) over 100M€. A colleague who was involved told me it had to be officially successful so they could at least write off the money as expenses.
- aneth4 14y agoIndeed. Particularly in contract to the Obama machine, which was built by passionate technologies motivated mostly to help Obama win, not make money.
- lifeguard 14y agoThe campaign could not manage launching a web app and they wanted to run the entire USA !?!?!?!
- atomical 14y agoYes, people who make mistakes can still run the entire USA. It has been done before.
- lifeguard 14y agoThis kind of false equivocation is dishonest and intellectually lazy.
- Xcelerate 14y agoI disagree. His point is very valid.
- lifeguard 14y agoHis use of "mistakes" is a verbal fallacy called equivocation. Not all mistakes are the same. wikipedia: Equivocation ("to call by the same name") is classified as both a formal and informal logical fallacy. It is the misleading use of a term with more than one meaning or sense
- Jare 14y agoThis "mistake" is what most people would call 'utter incompetence'.
- WrkInProgress 14y agoSome key points - 1.) 11 database servers. 1 app server 2.) Not redirecting http to https 3.) not stress tested or apparently tested in any way 4.) users got their first taste of the system the morning of the election.
- mrdodge 14y agoSounds like Microsoft was trying to sell a few SQL server licenses.
- CletusTSJY 14y agoAs a conservative and a software engineer, it's heartening that they at least had a plan and tried something. The fact that it was poorly implemented and unstable doesn't surprise me. Most last minute projects end up that way.
- meepmorp 14y agoZero training? A single web server? No end users even touching the system till it's time for mission critical use? No frigging redirect of http->https? And it looks like, as has happened more than once in my professional life, people outside of the management structure saw possible risks and were blown off by those in charge. Even if you supported Romney, this has to give you some pause about the man's management skills and who he hired to run things.
- mrdodge 14y agoHe hired Microsoft and what sounds like a Microsoft Partner. No one gets fired for buying Microsoft.
- jvehent 14y agoOh yes, people do get fired for buying microsoft. Switch industries and you'll see. Or try spending 2 years building your company knowledge base into sharepoint and you'll see.
- niels_olson 14y agoSharePoint. Oh my head. When I saw us using that in the future ops center for Fukushima, it was the same feeling I had when I came back from sea duty and there was this thing called PowerPoint: I felt like they were asking me to put my brain in egg slicer. Giving a bunch of Marines with history degrees network and expecting them to understand version control is a step to far. Maybe in ten years. But the interface is sooooo bad, they'll never figure out how to use the one feature the system is intended to provide.
- dblock 14y agoThe assumption that software can work from the first try is proven wrong, time and again. Software is something that needs to grow, mature and stabilize. The Romney campaign had the thing that's usually hardest to get - the human beta test resources. It should have been dry run for months.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- lkrubner 14y agoNo one should allow a business or non-profit to face a situation like this. Only bad managers put something so important into such difficult circumstances. Why go live the day of the election? Are they insane? Unless the contract (to build this application) had some kind of clause like "This thing must work perfectly or all the money will be refunded" then this is a great contract to get. Let us consider this cynically for a moment. I wish I could land contracts like this one. Can you imagine building an app that the client will only need for 1 day, and you still get paid even if the thing does not work? The chance for fraud is huge. Who would even allow this? The people pitching this must have been some very talented salespeople (perhaps they were convincingly able to argue that they were such huge Republican supporters that if they lost then that would be punishment enough, as it would be so very sad for them to see Obama win?) I've worked with a lot of startups and clients and the staff always needs training and you never, ever know what all the bugs are until you've gotten some feedback from the staff who are using it for real. To suggest that a software project is done the day you first give it to the staff is idiotic -- that's simply the moment you move to real world testing. Some developers might suggest that a really good suite of unit tests might provide enough insurance, but that is not true -- I've worked with non-technical staff who tend to confuse bad UI decisions with software bugs, and if a UI decision is bad enough, I think it is fair to classify it as a bug. If some_important_action is crucial to the staff, and none of the staff can find the link to some_important_action, then the UI decision that hid it is effectively as bad as a Fatal Exception, but no amount of unit tests can tell you that the staff finds the UI incomprehensible.
- incision 14y ago>I wish I could land contracts like this one. Can you imagine building an app that the client will only need for 1 day, and you still get paid even if the thing does not work? The chance for fraud is huge. Who would even allow this? The people pitching this must have been some very talented salespeople... Anecdotally, this is exactly how large consultancies, particularly those who specialize in serving the public sector, operate. 1) Deploy an army of "talented" salespeople to establish favorable executive-level relationships by exploiting every available loophole to provide trips, gifts, dinners and sporting events. Once the top has been won over, everyone below will fall in line. 2) Write contracts meeting the barest minimum interpretation of the requirements. Design them to specifically exploit uninformed procurement departments which are better equipped to source millions in copier paper or bolts than complex software. 3) Farm out any actual deliverable to the cheapest sub available nationwide. Ideally, you will have hidden travel and per diem for the talent in #2 leaving you free to fly in folks from the cheapest parts of the country. 4) Upon encountering any serious issue once work is underway simply scapegoat the current PM and shuffle in a new one. 5) Go to #1 employing the latest project as a reference that likely won't even be properly checked. In the event that diligence is performed, feed them to one of your friendly executives.
- SkyMarshal 14y ago>To build Orca, the Romney campaign turned to Microsoft and an unnamed application consulting firm. Lawsuit incoming in 3...2...1... I can't imagine the billionaires who funded the campaign and the various Super PACs are going to be pleased to find out Romney likely lost because of a failed GOTV effort.
- jfc 14y agoExcept that there are several reasons Romney lost. The system crash may be one contributing factor, but it is far from the only reason his campaign was ultimately unsuccessful.
- ams6110 14y agoIt's a stretch to think that a functioning mobile app on election day would have made the difference between Romney winning and losing. The election wasn't really that close. And I say that as someone who voted for him.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- SkyMarshal 14y agoIt's not a stretch to think that a functioning GOP GOTV campaign could have made the difference in 4 swing states that tipped the election to Obama (CO, FL, OH, VA), where the vote differential was just under 400,000. http://fivethirtyeight.blogs.nytimes.com/2012/11/08/as-nation-and-parties-change-republicans-are-at-an-electoral-college-disadvantage/#more-37366 http://fivethirtyeight.blogs.nytimes.com/2012/11/08/as-natio... https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/ccc?key=0Au5WjgbQnYrSdFdpN2lWTlhrV2dkSExncjZrTmZQZGc https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/ccc?key=0Au5WjgbQnYrSdFd... Romney had 37,000 field volunteers, plus phone bank. I don't know how many were in each of the four tipping point states, but had each of them been able to bring in between 10 and 20 voters who didn't vote (of the 2 million extra who voted for McCain in 2008 but were absent this year), Romney could have won. Instead it sounds like due to the massive Orca failure, they all gave up and went home. (and fwiw, I say this as someone who voted for Obama. Not sour grapes here, just assessing the IT project failure.)
- SkyMarshal 14y ago>"We asked if our laptops needed to be WiFi capable," Dittuobo told Ars. "Dan Centinello went into how the Garden had just finished expansion of its wireless network and that yes, WiFi was required. I was concerned about hacking, jamming the signal,* etc...* This brings up a whole nother can of worms - electoral cyber warfare. What if the Dems, or some sympathizer group, say some local Anonymous, decided to disrup the GOP's centralized GOTV operation? They could point LOIC at the IP receiving all the real-time field reports, set up hidden wireless jammers around Boston Garden, and any number of other hacks and exploits to disrupt this centralized system. I use the GOP and Anonymous as an example here, but it could work in any direction. It's one thing for a campaign to lose due to its own incompetence and negligence, but quite another to lose due to outside interference and being the target of cyberwarefare.
- shawndumas 14y agowith one webserver they were their own worst enemy; no need to look elsewhere
- eropple 14y agoThis is a great point, and it's one of the more frustrating things to encounter as a developer who knows more than just "the language I'm writing a website in". Security is not optional and security must be managed at every level of the infrastructural stack. But that's hard, and nobody's going to know anyway, so let's just roll with it.
- csel 14y agoIf a hacker looks into their web and db infrastructure...I think he would just shake his head and move on.
- gamble 14y agoPolitico's article on ORCA today claims that one of the major problems was that they deployed the system in their election night HQ just prior to the election, and the surge of legitimate traffic on election day triggered their DDOS defences. They'd never tested it in that location with realistic traffic levels.
- nhangen 14y agoComing from a launch that had its own share of issues, I can say that things like these happen for a variety of reasons: 1. Developers overestimate their capabilities 2. Developers underestimate timelines 3. Client overestimates developer throughput 4. Client underestimates man hours required for any given feature. 5. Someone expects someone else to do QA. 6. Project manager assigns everything an ASAP priority And this is just to start.
- xoail 14y ago1. They should have hired best UX engineers for the design. 2. Hosted the solution in the cloud and called and made sure the host is aware of the upcoming traffic. 3. Rolled out the application in test mode at least a week before so that staff can do trail runs. 4. Worry less about hacking and made it easy to login (just via an ID) ~ me being Captain Hindsight.
- acslater00 14y agoI'm not so sure. Intentionally disruptive behavior by the opposition -- or even some motivated kid who wanted to cause trouble for the campaign -- would be one of my biggest concerns if I were designing this thing.
- inpHilltr8r 14y agoFaith based development.
- Bud 14y agoPerhaps Republicans should have spent more time actually displaying the business and organizational acumen and discipline that they claimed as an advantage over the Obama team, and less time suppressing the black vote. Snark postscriptum: Also, next time, GOP, you might wanna hire some IT guys who make more than $12 an hour.
- pkulak 14y agoWe're all lucky that an organization too inept to manage a campaign is ultimately not allowed to manage the country.
- csel 14y ago11 DB servers and 1 web app? Let's look at how the db was structured. Wait...nevermind forget it.
- jongalloway2 14y agoThis is an absolutely perfect use case for cloud hosting like Azure - dev local, test on a few small instances, scale up as needed on election day, then shut it down. From the article it sounds like they paid for eleven servers, which was significantly more expensive and lower powered.
- brown9-2 14y agoThis wouldn't have helped their training problem however - volunteers confused about how to find the site, not sure how to use it, etc. Several dry runs and stress tests would have helped them alot.
- antidoh 14y agoIt's too bad the Romney campaign was unable to tap the services of an experienced businessman who is expert at management and delegation.
- djt 14y agoi find it interesting that they named it Orca as Obamas system was called Narwhal. for those of you that dont know, Narwhal is an animal, but its also a internet meme. Obviously a very nerdy reference by Obamas team. The fact that the Romney team had to name their software as a killer for a Narwhal goes to show that they wanted to win at any cost, unfortunately when that happens you sometimes lose sight of the goal, which in this case is to have a working system.
- jacalata 14y agoI find it interesting that they made this exact point in the article we are discussing here, and you don't appear to have read it.
- djt 14y agothey didnt mention that it was a animal made famous as a meme
- pjscott 14y agoOr it means that whoever came up with the name was aware of Narwhal and thought it fitting that their system should also be named after a cool-looking whale. If this had not been a political issue, would you have been slower to reject this obvious innocent interpretation?
- djt 14y agothey mentioned in the piece that it was named as an animal that is the only natural predator of the Narwhale. Please read the article before you downvote or comment.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- lifeguard 14y agoI think the cake eaters cynically turned up the hate in 2008 and were rewarded with a landslide in the House in 2010. But in the long run, this was an unsustainable strategy to create a majority. The tea party was heavily funded. Occupy can't even hold a candle to it. Providing only half the stimulus requested created a lot of misery while providing political cover of 'doing something'. Then the Republicans condemned Barry in 2012 for failing. This was known as the "bodies on the beach" strategy. If enough bodies piled up on the beach the electorate would vote out any sitting president. People would need some 'other' to blame the status quo on.
- smsm42 14y agoWhere Ace of Spades HQ says it's the reason for the Romney defeat? Here's their article: http://ace.mu.nu/archives/334783.php http://ace.mu.nu/archives/334783.php Nowhere in it it is said that Romney was defeated because of this.
- credo 14y agoThe Ace of Spades post suggests that Orca was a key reason for the defeat (though it doesn't explicitly assert it). The post attacks Orca and asks "If this had worked could it have closed the gap?" Erick Erickson makes the suggestion more strongly. He points to the "Ace of Spades" post and uses it to reject the possibility that the election was a defeat for "conservatism". In http://www.redstate.com/2012/11/09/the-only-thing-you-need-to-read-today-about-the-election/ http://www.redstate.com/2012/11/09/the-only-thing-you-need-t... he says that "the biggest problem the Republicans had on Tuesday night was not demographics, but turnout operations." The post on Breitbart makes a similar suggestion and leads with "As Republicans try to explain their Election Day losses in terms of policy, tactics, and strategy, one factor is emerging as the essential difference between the Obama and Romney campaigns on November 6: the absolute failure of Romney’s get-out-the-vote effort, which underperformed even John McCain’s lackluster 2008 turnout. One culprit appears to be “Orca,” the Romney’s massive technology effort, which failed completely." Orca is just the latest reason I've heard, previous theories (from staunch conservatives) can be best summarized by what I heard Charles Krauthammer say on Fox News (on election day). He dismissed the defeat by describing Romney as a "northeastern liberal". [edit] See http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/election-2012/wp/2012/11/09/romney-campaign-orca-wasnt-a-loss/ http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/election-2012/wp/2012/11... “I’m very surprised, as digital guy, about the pushback people are getting” over Orca, Moffatt said. “This didn’t materially change the course of the election.”
- PakG1 14y agoWhen I worked for the Winter Olympics in Vancouver, it was pounded into our heads all the time that there was no second chance. Everything we did would get one chance only. For that reason, we had two Technical Rehearsals. The purpose was to test both our systems and our procedures, and identify how they could be refined for the real thing. It was someone's job to actually design a huge number of expected and unexpected issues so that tech operations teams at each venue could be tested as to their response. Issues ranged from broken printers to network meltdowns to broadcasting failures, etc. We had two Technical Rehearsals for hopefully obvious reasons. And before the Technical Rehearsals, we also had the test events (i.e. world class but lower profile sporting competitions held at the Olympic venues to see whether we fell short in putting up a world class competition event). We also had Disaster Rehearsals to test our disaster recovery systems and procedures, though I wasn't personally involved in those. I did get a string of text messages when it was happening though. "Primary datacentre flooding, starting emergency processes to switch to secondary datacentre now." etc. Never mind that nobody could ever believe that the primary datacentre could get flooded in a million years. The attitude was that any disaster was possible, and we had to prepare for the impossible. If you have one shot only, and that shot is important, you need to have a large process committed to making sure that one shot goes well. And that process needs to be managed by someone experienced in that type of thing.
- pyre 14y agoLike the IBM "Black Team": http://www.t3y.com/tangledwebs/07/tw0706.html http://www.t3y.com/tangledwebs/07/tw0706.html
- unreal37 14y agoIronic that Mitt Romney ran the Salt Lake City Olympic committee in light of this. Also, the Ars article seemed to imply they wanted to keep how it worked a secret, so big testing like this would have tipped Obama what they were doing.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- danso 14y agoIn the past week, there's been discussion of how sophisticated the campaigns are at managing and leveraging the vast volumes of data they collect. I've argued that while they may have lots of data, and that they think they're being sophisticated with it, the results don't seem to indicate that they're particularly clever (or, more importantly, clever enough to be devious with it). Having access to data is one thing...having the logistics and middle managers who have good insights is the other. I think it's safe to say that no matter how much money and resources these operations have, it doesn't mean anything without campaign operatives who have a real IT/data background.
- runn1ng 14y agoHow effective these things actually are in US? Why am I asking... I am in from Czech Republic, where I can't imagine anyone knocking door over door and asking people to vote. Actually, this behavior is so connected here to Jehova's Witnesses (yeah) that it would have only the negative effect. Similarly, I can't imagine any candidate seriously considering calling random people and persuading them to vote. Again, this behaviour is so connected to annoying salesperson (most often mobile operators) that it would hurt the candidate. And I don't think our democracy suffers because we don't have that in here.
- fernly 14y agoOur land-line telephone received at least six calls each day for two months, from political organizations representing candidates at the federal, state, and local levels. We never answer that phone, only let the answering machine take the call and return it in the very rare event it is someone "real". But we did not get calls on election day because we live in a state (CA) that both parties assumed (correctly) would give a majority to the President. "Get out the vote" operations (GOTV) are real and sometimes effective in states where the outcome is expected to be close. In this election there were a small number of these "swing" states where both parties thought they had a chance to win. In such states, if the early indications are that the voting is close, the party organization can redouble its efforts to contact known supporters (contributors, or merely people who are registered to that party in the public records, or people who have signed a petition or gotten on the party mailing list somehow) and persuade them to vote. (This is because in the USA, unlike some countries, it is not mandatory to vote, and rarely do even half the eligible voters do so. So if you can persuade a person who was not planning to vote, to do so, that is a net gain of 1 vote.) The purpose of this "Orca" system was to collate the reports from volunteers watching the polling places and identify precincts where a few extra votes might make a difference. You can see how serious the effort was, in that the Republicans had mustered 37,000 volunteers willing to do this sort of thankless work: to stand around polling places, politely asking people how they had voted and phone in the counts; or, sit in an office and make telephone calls to people who do not want to be called and politely urge them to go and vote. That is a large effort, and apparently wasted by poor planning.
- mmonoceros 14y agoAnother misstep of the Romney camp seems relevant, since a lot of the discussion so far is about project management. In September they admitted to wholesale copying of a key Obama fundraising page, with Zac Moffat blaming the issue on "junior staff confusion": http://www.buzzfeed.com/zekejmiller/romney-campaign-appears-to-copy-text-from-obama-we http://www.buzzfeed.com/zekejmiller/romney-campaign-appears-... The copy was lifted in its entirely. The similarity in the design is more subjective. (They were so similar that a lot of the discussion online speculated about a shared vendor -- which isn't the case. Quick Donate was a custom product internal to the Obama campaign.) Romney campaign seems to have had serious problems in a lot of their internal processes when it came to tech/web. (AMERCIA)
- b1daly 14y agoI think there is a connection between the sort of hand-waving, know nothing-ism of Republican political messaging and this tech fiasco. That kind of thing might work in the soft field of persuasion, but is pretty useless in creating a complex technical system. (By know nothing-ism of the Republicans, I'm referring to the birtherism, beligerent rhetoric about complicated diplomatic issues, anti-science views about global warming, trying to paint Obama as a socialist, in general the whole "Guns, God, & Gays" type of messaging).
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- irisshoor 14y agoThis is one area you don't want to hack a solution quickly, but want to use something that's been tried and tested in the field. You can be on the bleeding edge when you have time to iterate and fix things, not when you have just one shot. When it comes to having just one shot no one does it better than NASA - http://www.theverge.com/2012/8/9/3232160/curiosity-mastcam-2-megapixel-camera-project-leader http://www.theverge.com/2012/8/9/3232160/curiosity-mastcam-2...