5 ms·
Ignoring the silly, uninformed arguments (i.e. newspaper readers "have never paid for the content"), this piece contains several classic arguments from the Bibl
by timr 18y ago
Ignoring the silly, uninformed arguments (i.e. newspaper readers "have never paid for the content"), this piece contains several classic arguments from the Bible of New Economy Bullshit:
1) The Bricks Are the Problem: "In theory, a reader who stops paying for the physical paper but continues to read the content online is doing the publisher a favor."
Mmhm. They said this about store-based retail, too. "Stores can operate more efficiently on the web, and will take over because they don't need the bricks and mortar!" What happened? Well, for starters, we found out that people like to shop in stores. We also found out that logistics, customer service and returns are always significant fixed costs, and the absence of bricks and mortar doesn't necessarily make them cheaper.
2) Race to the Bottom: "every English-language newspaper is in direct competition with every other. Millions of Americans get their news online from The Guardian, which is published in London. This competition, and not some kind of petulance or laziness or addled philosophy, is what keeps readers from shelling out for news."
...and last I checked, the Guardian has the same problems as everyone else in the business. I guess the Utopian ideal here is that every newspaper on the planet gives their content away for free, until they all simultaneously combust in a cloud of bankruptcy lawyers and rainbows.
More seriously: the end-game here is not a world where we have the journalism quality of the New York Times, the Washington Post, and the San Francisco Chronicle, only online and free. The end-game is Gawker and TechCrunch. Sound like a fair trade?
3) Everything Is Different Now, Man: "And the harsh truth is that the typical American newspaper is an anachronism. It is an artifact from a time when chopping down trees was essential to telling the news"
This is not "harsh truth" -- this is 95% wishful thinking, 5% fact. The 5% fact is that there is another way to access media, that has both benefits and drawbacks. The other 95% is that the Silicon Valley, VC-for-everyone corporate culture has infected media, and given it a business model as unsustainable and wasteful as a midnight candy bar delivery from Kozmo.com.
People still like to consume media on paper. It doesn't require electricity, can be done without the aid of a machine, and can be archived easily, by anyone. Granted, the type of content served by traditional media is shifting, but that doesn't mean that newspapers and magazines don't have a future in the Brave New World of digital media.
More importantly, the internet hasn't made it free to produce good content. We all like to dance around this critical fact, pretending that if we just spend enough money on viral loops and news aggregators, we'll be able to reproduce our current media offerings. But we conveniently neglect to notice that many of the interesting articles we read on Digg or news.google are produced by reporters who are being paid by the old media. When it dies, so does the content that powers whizzy web-2.0 social media.
- biohacker42 18y agoGawker and TechCrunch are at one extreme, The Economist and The Atlantic are at the other. Both of those extremes are easy to monetize... Now that I think about it, I'm not sure how financially stable Gawker and TechCrunch are. But my point is: Popular rags are cheap to produce and can live off ads. Intelligent content, on the other hand, can find paying cosumers. I think the problem with the NY Times and others like them, is that it's hard to find a sustainable business model for the middle ground that they are on. -EDIT- Yet a third way is a non profit news paper like The Irish Times, funded by a grant I believe. I hear the Seattle PI is going into chapter 11, if I was stinking rich, I'd turn it into a non-profit.
- whacked_new 18y agoTC vs NYT vs Economist is this really one continuum with two extremes, with NYT in the "middle ground"? It could be middle ground in terms of penmanship, but neither TC nor Economist can be a daily news source. Daily, with general relevance. Different function IMHO.
- jacoblyles 18y agoDo we need daily news sources of any sophistication? The New York Times reports the happenings of the previous day with a bunch of pseudo-analysis. I'm fine with just a plain statement of facts from cable news networks or the AP. Then I can get my in-depth discussion with a weekly delay from a publication like The Economist, which has more meaningful analysis in a single issue than the entire history of the Times. Why do I need the middle ground?
- whacked_new 18y agoI don't see it as a middle ground. I see it as a genre of news. You may not need daily news with any analysis, but that still doesn't put NYT on the same continuum as TechCrunch and the Economist. Granted, Economist is probably closer to NYT, in terms of scope, but I still don't see how NYT sits between the two as the optional "middle ground."
- 18y ago