8 ms·
You Can’t Sell News by the Slice
- mattmaroon 18y agoEvery article expounding how you can't get people to pay for news content online should be required by law to explain how the Wall Street Journal's website has nearly 1 million paying members.
- fallentimes 18y agoAre those just the same people that subscribe to the WSJ in print? Or is it a different group?
- jonknee 18y agoI would guess there's some overlap, but when I was a WSJ Online subscriber I didn't get the print copy. Just a waste of resources in my mind, something else to throw away.
- sethg 18y agoJournal readers have more disposable income than typical newspaper readers, and the WSJ is a valuable brand, so its subscribers are willing to pay extra (where "extra" means "more than zero") for the quality. There are other niche markets where this works: e.g., LWN.net is supported mostly by subscriptions. But the history of mass media publications charging for content, as Kinsley describes, is a history of one failure after another.
- mattmaroon 18y agoYou don't think NYT is a valuable brand or his great reader demographics? I certainly wouldn't argue charging is right for every newspaper. At the risk of getting some Michael Dell-style egg on my face later, I'd say that most of them ought to just shut down now and give what little they can get via liquidation back to the investors.
- markessien 18y agoThat's a very short-sighted view you have there. I really hope you are not working in this space, because if you are, you are blinding yourself to the reality of the situation. Numbers are down everywhere. The question is - how are those numbers broken down? Are these people who stumbled across the site and decided to subscribe because the content convinced them? Or because of the already existing brand? Think of a paper just launching with no name, but that wants to go the pay route. How long do you think this paper will survive before running out of money? The wsj is just moving subscribers from it's paper to the online, this is completely different from launching a successful pay website.
- mattmaroon 18y agoThe reality of the situation is that online advertising doesn't make enough money to support real journalism. It just doesn't. I wish that it did. I'd prefer to continue reading NYT for free of course. But my wishing it doesn't make it so. I have no doubt that new papers would find it near impossible to draw paying subscribers online, but they'd find it totally impossible to profitably put out good original content via ad revenue. I'll take nearly impossible over totally impossible any day. People used to think it nearly impossible that the Japanese could succeed in the car market. I'm assuming this Op-Ed was aimed at the NYT itself, given the news yesterday. They almost certainly need to charge, and their content is of the same caliber as WSJ (and has impressive demographics) so they can get away with it. It won't work for local papers, of course, they're just doomed. But those are irrelevant anyway. They're merely a bunch of AP/Reuters stories with a little poorly written sports commentary and a police scanner tied in. Nobody under 60 will miss them.
- markessien 18y agoI read a lot, but I have little interest in reading the new york times or the wall street journal - because they mean nothing to me. I was never exposed to them being some type of authority, and the few articles I've read on their site did not in any way impress me as being way above the caliber of any other article on any other site. The biggest papers may succeed based of their current name recognition, but this is going to disappear soon. What's real journalism? Opinion pieces? I think Michael Arrington knows a lot more than most tech NY Times writers. Interviews? The info comes from the interviewer. Sending reporters to the Congo to cover some local conflict? Well, the Congo has local newspapers, and they are covering the conflict there extremely well. And their coverage is also available online to be mixed and matched. "Real Journalism" cannot be supported by ads - this does not mean that the alternative is a pay system, it means that "Real Journalism" will die. The information monopoly is dead, and that's a good thing. A newspaper is a combination of opinion pieces, current affairs and analysis. Opinion pieces can be purchased from freelance experts, current affairs can be mashed together from more local and accurate news, and analysis can be done by people who actually understand the topic. Sure, you don't want your favorite newspaper to die, but there were people who wanted carriages to last forever. You're one of the technologists, accept the new reality.
- lliiffee 18y agoHis argument is basically that even if people do, it isn't enough money. The WSJ costs 79 bucks a year (and I somehow suspect many people aren't paying that full price) 79 million a year isn't nearly enough to save the NYT. I guess the value of our eyes looking at ads printed on paper for a year is much higher than $79?
- swombat 18y ago79 million dollars of operating profit (hosting costs assumed to be negligible) a year is quite a lot of money, and that's not even counting advertising. If the NYT's costs are so far above $79m/yr, perhaps it needs to slim down a little...
- lliiffee 18y agoAccording to the article, NYT revenue last year (a bad year) was $1 billion.
- swombat 18y agoEven more shameful that they can't run their operation on that much money. I appreciate it costs money to retain good writers, but $1bn a year? Surely that's enough to run a newspaper on?
- timr 18y agoThey run multiple foreign bureaus, one of the most widely circulated print publications in the world, and a top-100 internet website. I'm not saying that they couldn't be leaner, but let's try to keep some perspective.
- ijntybvrt 18y agoBecause people will pay for 'NEWS' but not for newspapers. People will pay for upto the minute stock market data rather than the 15min delayed version, they will pay $1000s for market reports, they will pay for WSJ articles on companies they want to buy. But most newspapers aren't selling news - they are selling entertainment. I don't pay to find out the death toll in some plane crash the day before - I pay for a newspaper to read columnists, editorials, cartoons. That's why sunday papers are the largest and most profitable. It's like the difference between paying to watch a movie and reading the plot summary fro free on IMDB.
- gabrielroth 18y agoBecause access to the WSJ can be charged to its readers' expense accounts. Customers are a lot less price-sensitive when someone else is picking up the tab. Given that the financial climate will presumably lead to some corporate cost-cutting, there's probably an opportunity for someone to undercut the incumbent business-news providers (WSJ, Bloomberg, Reuters) in the next two years.
- antidaily 18y agoRelated (micropayments): "One of history's ironies is that hypertext - an embedded Web link that refers you to another page or site - had been invented by Ted Nelson in the early 1960s with the goal of enabling micropayments for content. He wanted to make sure that the people who created good stuff got rewarded for it. In his vision, all links on a page would facilitate the accrual of small, automatic payments for whatever content was accessed." Source: http://www.time.com/time/business/article/0,8599,1877191-1,00.html http://www.time.com/time/business/article/0,8599,1877191-1,0...
- markessien 18y agoMicropayments for news will never happen. The thing with most news is that WE DON'T NEED TO KNOW IT. Think hard about this - has it made a difference that you know about some lady who got kidnapped? What has changed that you can read about the details of the Iraqi election? You want to know this stuff only because you are aware of it - and you are aware of it only because you started reading the paper in the first place. If you never read a paper (because for example, you needed to pay to read it), then you'll not be interested in this news, and you won't see any need to pay for it. People will pay for information, but they will not pay for news. People want to be aware of what is going on in general, and if this is available for free, they will use those sites. The business of journalism is shrinking, and it will have to evolve fast. News will become more local, several cheap sources will be used to build a picture of a situation, and people will pay for more niche and more technical magazines (e.g Finance News). These papers have a strong brand now, but those brands are decaying. They should work on making sure their brands are strongly available everywhere, so that when the reorganisation happens, they can still remain a recognizable name.
- run4yourlives 18y agoNeeding to know it and wanting to know it are two very different things. Ask Nancy Grace. The issue for newspapers is that they are hampered by their current medium, which is simply too slow to provide up to the minute "breaking news" stories that people want. Even worse, there are other mediums that can do exactly this! Newspapers need to focus on their quality, and remove the shackles of an outdated medium for once and for all.
- jamesbritt 18y ago"If you never read a paper (because for example, you needed to pay to read it), then you'll not be interested in this news, and you won't see any need to pay for it." Yet newspapers have been charging for quite some time, and people have been paying to read them, up until they found cheaper, faster, more complete sources. You're digging yourself into a hole of ignorance if you are only following what you've become accustomed to follow. Newspapers offer the accidental, and I bet many people enjoy them for that reason. You read things you didn't know would be interesting until you turned the page and there it was. It's not that there is a cost, it's that despite the cost newspapers are still increasingly inferior to, say, Google News.
- run4yourlives 18y agoThe decline of the newspaper business is more a classic case of living in your own bubble long enough to lose the ability to adapt to changing realities than anything else. In this case the internet is the catalyst for change; just like in the music industry and the movie industry. Shareholders should be demanding their respective CEO's have vast experience in the domain that threatens to defeat them, instead of continuing to twaddle along in a world that will die with the boomers. I'd imagine 20-30% of this board would excel at the c-suite level of a newspaper. The rest of us would be more than adequate strategists and advisors. Why? Because we understand the nature of the medium that matters, not the medium that is already dead. For example, my two cents worth: What is it that local papers, including the Times (which is basically a local paper from a city many people enjoy reading about) do that the internet can not? Easy - they offer consistently high quality and in-depth analysis of current events. It's their editorial board that matters, really. They can't compete with timely news delivery. They can't compete with bloggers breaking stories. They can deliver a broader and deeper explanation of what events mean to the lives of others. They can provide opinions of well respected and well researched individuals. If they were to truly leverage this strength, they would do the following: 1. Shut down their physical production lines, immediately saving millions of dollars a year. Move to online only format. 2. Move full time staff to consultant roles, and retain a small editorial staff of the highest quality. 3. Focus less on news snippets, possibly partner with companies that can already do this better than they can - Google news anyone? Newsvine? 4. Focus more on opinion, editorial and deeper feature stories that appeal beyond the 10 second sound bite. Attract readers with the higher quality that they can provide. (Again, there's a market in every local for this - the Guardian doesn't care about what city hall is doing in Buttfuck, Iowa, but the people living there sure do) 5. Either sell ads or subscriptions for such content. Does this mean they can't rake in the revenues that they once did? Certainly. Does it also mean, however, that they'll remain relevant for the foreseeable future? Of course. Most papers have already conquered the biggest challenge to doing this - building a strong brand-related audience of readers. They've already got the leg up on competitors, and they don't even realize it. First one for each market to do this well wins.
- cschneid 18y agoWhat you are describing is already done as a news magazine. Take away the immediate snippets of news and focus on indepth stories? Well, now you are running another Time, NewsWeek, Economist, etc.. How are those businesses doing?
- harpastum 18y agoA very forward-thinking exposition coming from a print source, but still telling in it's anachronisms: "...Or some Web site might mutate into a real Web newspaper." A Real Web Newspaper? No. They will be much, much better than that.
- brand 18y agoCare to expound a bit? (I'm not trying to be antagonistic, just interested.)
- harpastum 18y agoMy point was just that it's still the mindset of those in the newspaper business that their goal is to create an "Web newspaper," which I find similar to wondering a few decades ago whether jet fighters could ever become "flying tanks." I don't think consumers will find much value in a 'real' Web newspaper, because the web has so much more to offer. Real-time news, real-time sports scores, live video feeds, user interaction, the list goes on and on. Newspapers have always been an imperfect media outlet restricted by their medium and distribution. The Internet promises to alleviate many of these issues. This is why I believe it is quaint to hope that we will someday have "real Web newspapers."
- aasarava 18y agoWhen news reports were first brought to television, they often consisted of an anchor at a desk simply "speaking" the news to the viewers. Now, television news has taken on its own format that's very different from the printed format -- events are relayed as they unfold, reporters are on site, etc. So far, news on the Web hasn't matured in the same way. Most news is still delivered as straightforward text (newspaper model), or else video (television model). What's an example of something that truly uses the Web medium? Here's a piece in which the (UK) Guardian uses Flash to show the history of the Arab-Isreali conflict: http://www.guardian.co.uk/flash/0,5860,720353,00.html http://www.guardian.co.uk/flash/0,5860,720353,00.html
- AndrewO 18y agoAfter seeing Walter Isaacson on the Daily Show last night, I couldn't help yelling at the TV. The thing that I really wish someone had asked (and was alluded to in this op-ed) is this: What do you do about the entire generation reaching adulthood who has _never_ had to pay for news?
- ja2ke 18y agoYou give them increasingly shitty news reporting.
- kenshi 18y agoI still think some people will pay for quality news reporting. Maybe not the crap that seems to pass for journalism in a lot of publications these days. If you provide people with well-researched information, give them access to people/places/things they couldn't otherwise reach, you will be providing some value which you can charge for. If you are just doing lazy, surface level reporting on things that a horde of citizen-journalists are going to throw onto the web for free anyway, you might be screwed.
- timr 18y agoIgnoring the silly, uninformed arguments (i.e. newspaper readers "have never paid for the content"), this piece contains several classic arguments from the Bible of New Economy Bullshit: 1) The Bricks Are the Problem: "In theory, a reader who stops paying for the physical paper but continues to read the content online is doing the publisher a favor." Mmhm. They said this about store-based retail, too. "Stores can operate more efficiently on the web, and will take over because they don't need the bricks and mortar!" What happened? Well, for starters, we found out that people like to shop in stores. We also found out that logistics, customer service and returns are always significant fixed costs, and the absence of bricks and mortar doesn't necessarily make them cheaper. 2) Race to the Bottom: "every English-language newspaper is in direct competition with every other. Millions of Americans get their news online from The Guardian, which is published in London. This competition, and not some kind of petulance or laziness or addled philosophy, is what keeps readers from shelling out for news." ...and last I checked, the Guardian has the same problems as everyone else in the business. I guess the Utopian ideal here is that every newspaper on the planet gives their content away for free, until they all simultaneously combust in a cloud of bankruptcy lawyers and rainbows. More seriously: the end-game here is not a world where we have the journalism quality of the New York Times, the Washington Post, and the San Francisco Chronicle, only online and free. The end-game is Gawker and TechCrunch. Sound like a fair trade? 3) Everything Is Different Now, Man: "And the harsh truth is that the typical American newspaper is an anachronism. It is an artifact from a time when chopping down trees was essential to telling the news" This is not "harsh truth" -- this is 95% wishful thinking, 5% fact. The 5% fact is that there is another way to access media, that has both benefits and drawbacks. The other 95% is that the Silicon Valley, VC-for-everyone corporate culture has infected media, and given it a business model as unsustainable and wasteful as a midnight candy bar delivery from Kozmo.com. People still like to consume media on paper. It doesn't require electricity, can be done without the aid of a machine, and can be archived easily, by anyone. Granted, the type of content served by traditional media is shifting, but that doesn't mean that newspapers and magazines don't have a future in the Brave New World of digital media. More importantly, the internet hasn't made it free to produce good content. We all like to dance around this critical fact, pretending that if we just spend enough money on viral loops and news aggregators, we'll be able to reproduce our current media offerings. But we conveniently neglect to notice that many of the interesting articles we read on Digg or news.google are produced by reporters who are being paid by the old media. When it dies, so does the content that powers whizzy web-2.0 social media.
- jonasvp 18y agoClay Shirky wrote about micropayments and free content a while back: http://shirky.com/writings/fame_vs_fortune.html http://shirky.com/writings/fame_vs_fortune.html Basically, he's saying that micropayments will not work because they introduce a transaction cost into the act of reading: you not only have to decide if you want to read (or skim) the article in question, you have to decide if it's worth x cents as well. And that transaction cost kills the transaction before it happens, never mind the x cents that would have been transferred.
- iron_ball 18y agoYep... it's called the "penny gap," and it's what micropayment proselytes fail to account for. I've noticed something similar on the New York transit system -- when I have a prepaid MetroCard with limited rides, I think twice before taking any individual trip, but when I buy the unlimited-use monthly card, I feel much more free to consume the service even if the total price per month ends up roughly the same. Yearly subscriptions to sites seem much better. I'd pay a subscription to the Times, though this certainly puts me in the minority. Heck, I'd pay a subscription to Hacker News, too.
- access_denied 18y agoBut if that minority is big enough to sustain a business that delivers journalism of a certain quality? Oh, they had to move offices to another building, where the rent is less expensive...
- electromagnetic 18y agoI'm seeing a lot of people making the judgmental mistake of thinking that news is simply read on paper because no one has established a sufficient way of accessing it online. I'm sorry but this is just a fallacy, until I can read my news at the kitchen table, on the sofa and on the toilet then newspaper still has a significant use. I mean it's a quite dismal future, if everyone gets up in the morning and sits in front of a computer eating their cereal so they can read the news. News, and likewise information, will become ever increasingly available. The first publicly available newspapers were government-published tablets posted in public places by Julius Caesar, the Chinese circulated news to court officials in the 8th century. Eventually news will become more accessible through digital media, but this isn't going to happen anytime soon. Portable devices aren't ubiquitous enough yet and so news isn't freely available enough on digital media to take over the ultimately portable disposable newspaper. I can take a newspaper, read it at breakfast, on the toilet, on the bus, at work and then when I'm done with it I can discard it. Until I can do all the same, except discard it, with a digital device then the newspapers won't be destroyed, they'll merely recede. Newspapers are going to suffer more from attrition than an assault. There's so many people who've read their news from a paper every morning, that's a habit that is largely unbreakable. You can't stop a 60 year old picking up a news paper. My father's in his 50's, has worked in IT since the beginning yet he still sits down with a newspaper. Newspapers won't die until their readership does. This gives the newspapers a long time to adapt to current technology and establish a brand amongst the younger age group in a fashion that allegories the elder age group. The other assumption people make, is that news will become more refined and from local sources. This assumption is quite laughable, local sources are increasingly irrelevant. Yes it's good to get the news from your home town, however do you really think that matters anymore? I live in Canada, so why do I care about Obama in the US or Brown in the UK? Because they both affect me. I've been to a dozen countries and I know people from even more and this is becoming the norm in our current era of civilization. The whole notion of globalization dictates that we're going to begin caring about world events more and more as they increasingly affect us. Just look at the economic crisis, the US fudged the brownie, but it's affected nearly every country and person on the planet, so why wouldn't people be paying attention to news like that?
- catman 18y agohttp://www.imaginationgames.com/ http://www.imaginationgames.com/