6 ms·
How a Supreme Court ruling may stop you from reselling just about anything
- pngai 14y agoPlease read this for a more through discussion of the issue and applicable laws. http://us.practicallaw.com/9-519-7148 http://us.practicallaw.com/9-519-7148
- slapshot 14y agoGood discussion of the same case here: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4706572 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4706572 There's a lot of FUD ("they might" "a ruling could") in this article. The short version is that this case deals with the fact that the Copyright Act prohibits unlicensed copying _and_ importing of copyrighted goods.[1] It comes up because (just like in the textbook case), it behooves a lot of manufacturers to charge a high price in the US and Western Europe and a lower price in the rest of the world. The price difference goes to cover things like research, writing, and other fixed costs that exist no matter how many marginal copies are sold. The case deals only with the "gray market" importation question --- not what you do with your iPad that you bought in the US from Apple. There's no question (before or after this case) that if you buy an iPad in the US, the "first sale doctrine" still applies. Any copyright interest that Apple had in the device were terminated by their licensed sale to you in the US (even if the device was made in China, shipped directly from China, whatever). Nothing about this ruling would change that. Same for your DVD collection you bought from Amazon. Or any other product you bought in the US. The only question raised by this case is if you wanted to fly to Manila, buy 1,000 textbooks at the Philippines price and then sell them in the US at the US price, could the textbook manufacturer claim that you imported unlicensed goods into the US? There's a good economic analysis from the old thread: if the Court rules that publishers cannot prevent gray-market imports of textbooks that sell for $100 in the US but $20 in the Philippines, publishers aren't going to set the price to $20 in the US. They're just going to raise the price in the Philippines to $100 minus whatever it costs to ship from Manila to the US. Students in poor countries just get further screwed. [1] http://www.copyright.gov/title17/92chap6.html http://www.copyright.gov/title17/92chap6.html
- mseebach 14y ago> There's a good economic analysis from the old thread: if the Court rules that publishers cannot prevent gray-market imports of textbooks that sell for $100 in the US but $20 in the Philippines, publishers aren't going to set the price to $20 in the US. They're just going to raise the price in the Philippines to $100 minus whatever it costs to ship from Manila to the US. Students in poor countries just get further screwed. The problem with that is that they'd loose the PH market which presumably is worth >$0 to them. An alternative strategy is to "edit" the foreign versions enough to make them unusable in the US, such as changing the homework questions enough that anyone working from the international version will get them wrong, or fiddle the fontsize/linespacing/margins so the page numbers are screwed up. That would automatically enlist the help of TAs to warn against the horrors of foreign books.
- stonemetal 14y agoOr they could provide a better product for that market that made it naturally distasteful to the US market. Like a book written in the language of the land (The market for CS books written in Filipino should be relatively small in a non Filipino speaking countries). Why make them work when we could just legislate profits their way?
- mseebach 14y agoThe issue is significantly more complex than "legislat[ing] profits their way". It's very unlikely that the discounted overseas textbook market constitues a very large amount of profit. Indeed, it could certainly be seen as reasonable CSR project: "Let's sell our books at marginal cost+10% to poor asian students, but have legal make sure those copies can't cannibalise our domestic market". If it turns out legal was wrong, the response is more likely to be "though luck, the global price is now $100" instead of "drat, let's lower the US prices to $20". Now, being nice, even charitable, should not be a ticket to get to write your own laws. But Wiley is unlikely to celebrate a ruling of global first sale doctrine by convening an editorial committee to produce a Filipino CS textbook (and a dozen other languages times a dozen other subjects), to then go and sell that at $20 there. Also, on a tangent, as the lingua franca of CS is English, it's convenient to learn the subject in English. I was taught CS mostly in English, but one time where the teacher insisted on speaking Danish, it took me half the class to realize that oversætter (literally translator) was meant to describe a compiler.
- mseebach 14y agoCorrect me if I'm wrong, but isn't there a " ... purchased outside the US" missing from the title of the piece? The article says: "... seeking to knock out the "first sale" doctrine on goods made abroad" (emphasis mine) - surely a product made abroad, but sold in the US by an authorized importer/reseller will still be subject to first sale? And it would still be legal for students to buy books for themselves abroad? Even the example mentioned where US students buy books directly on Amazon UK doesn't seem to be affected - just their right to resell that book in the US? It's still a big deal, but it seems that Ars is making it quite a bit bigger than it is.
- olefoo 14y agoIf the ruling is narrow enough to allow the resale of goods purchased from the US that were imported under license, and forbid the resale of unlicensed imports; that would be one thing. But... It won't necessarily be that narrow, and it is but one battle in a long war over who gets to control a good once it has been sold. It certainly would be possible for the Supreme Court to produce a ruling in this case that would see grandmothers being cuffed for illegal reselling at flea markets.
- mseebach 14y ago> If the ruling is narrow enough to allow the resale of goods purchased from the US that were imported under license, and forbid the resale of unlicensed imports; that would be one thing. If the sale happened in the US, it doesn't matter where the product was produced, first sale applies. Apple can't in any form claim that an iPhone purchased in an Apple store in the US was, in fact, an unlicensed import. Again, correct me if I'm wrong: But "first sale" is a long-lived and fairly unambiguous law. Unless it's found to be unconstitutional (which is not being questioned), the courts can't just change it. The question before the court is what happens when the sale happened abroad, because US copyright law doesn't trivially apply abroad. What gets murky, as far as I can tell, if first sale doesn't apply abroad are online merchants that can trivially fulfill your order from abroad, thus making you the importer - just like the Amazon UK case. Then you'd be forbidden from reselling that product in the US without the copyright holders permission.
- anigbrowl 14y agoOh dear, how much linkbait are we going to have to go through with this case? Look, your first sale rights within the US are perfectly safe. This case only affects people who do bulk buys in an overseas market and then try to resell within the US. Claims that it will be impossible to sell anything without an exhaustive audit trail are absurdly overblown. The legal issue here is whether a company has the right to exert control over the distribution of its product. The USSC will probably find for the publisher on public policy grounds (IMHO), since it would be difficult for publishers/manufacturers to execute agreements with distributors if it were not also prepared to go bat against unauthorized distributors. Not the most consumer-friendly situation since it allows producers to engage in market partition, but on the other hand exclusive distribution agreements are often the key to establishing a market presence in the first place. The arguments in Omega v. Costco (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Omega_S.A._v._Costco_Wholesale_Corp. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Omega_S.A._v._Costco_Wholesale_...) are particularly instructive in this regard; amicus briefs in support of Costco offered long parades of horribles, but were built on absurd premises, such as speculation that courts would suddenly start interpreting statutory protections for libraries in direct contradiction of their plain meaning.
- jsnk 14y agoWhenever someone tells me that certain ruling only applies to X, and people worrying about Y are misguided, I almost always side with people who are worried about Y. Court cases set a precedence, and there are unintended consequences for it. Given that a court cases are not 100% exploit-proof, you can bet your bottom dollar that eventually there will be some lawyer referring to previous rulings to justify some other rulings.
- belorn 14y agoIs it just me, or is it a bit odd that copyright is used for market control in regards to importation and exportation? I thought most countries used tariffs to produce this effect. If you want to stop people from buying TV's cheap from somewhere, the state add a tax to encourage local production. Is this somehow not enough to stop people from buying books cheap and sell them expensively in the US? Isn't the solution then to just increase the tax? Are there a reason why copyright can do a better job at this, and are there a substantial difference between copyright regulation and tariffs?
- cardine 14y agoThe US government doesn't want textbooks to be more expensive in the US so a tariff makes no sense. This is corporations wanting their goods to be more expensive where people have more money, which they can legally do. Tariffs are unrelated.
- belorn 14y agoTariffs purpose is to allow corporations to have higher prices locally. Both tariffs and copyright regulations are laws created by the government, and both increase how expensive a item is in the country. How are they unrelated?
- eigenvector 14y agoNo, the purpose of tariffs is to make domestically-produced goods cheaper than imported goods, not to raise the price for the consumer.
- belorn 14y agoHow exactly do you make local prices decrease by making imported goods more expensive? It does not make any sense. If the global market price of a product get artificial higher, one do not lower the local prices. The local prices get increased to match what ever the effective global market price (price + tariff) is. Of course. The purpose of tariffs is neither to increase nor lower the prices of goods. The purpose of tariffs from the government point of view is to increase self-production, value generating, and self-sustainability. But the practical effect of an tariff is a higher priced product for the consumer. In the word of wikipedia: Typical analyses find that tariffs tend to benefit domestic producers and government at the expense of consumers.
- camus 14y agoArent Big Corporations importing cheap goods and reselling them in USA for a huge profit ? so why an individual could not be able to do the same, even if that good has been produced in US at first place ? why should i pay 150$ for a book produced here while people on the other side of the world get the same book for 40$ ? Because it is not like i can choose the book i need for my studies.
- cardine 14y agoBecause big corporations generally follow copyright laws.
- DanBC 14y agoLevis has jeans made abroad. They send these jeans to various regions for sale through a distribution network. Levis claims to be able to control where shops can wholesale buy jeans from. There's a UK case about Tesco and Levi jeans. (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grey_market http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grey_market) > Manufacturers or their licensees often seek to enforce trademark or other intellectual-property rights against the grey market. Such rights may be exercised against the import, sale and/or advertisement of grey imports. In 2002, Levi Strauss, after a 4-year legal fight, prevented UK supermarket Tesco from selling grey market jeans. However, such rights can be limited. Examples of such limitations include the first-sale doctrine in the United States [...] That's sort of what's happening here - a publisher is using some form of rights protection law to prevent someone importing many copies of a product from one region and selling them in another region. That feels to me anti-competitive, but it's pretty well established that region-locking is acceptable. In the UK you'd be able to buy a textbook from overseas for your own personal use. The problem is that it's hard for someone else to set up a business to do the importing.
- Jd 14y agotl;dr: Student resells textbooks produced in Thailand making $1.2 million. Publishers sue him. They win first two rounds because "first sale" law does not apply overseas. Ebay and a hodgepodge of other groups support student. Case about to start in Supreme Court.
- automaton 14y agoI am not sure if Wiley and Co have a case here. While the books clearly spelled out where they could be sold, if the guy paid duty (https://help.cbp.gov/app/answers/detail/a_id/124/kw/duty/related/1 https://help.cbp.gov/app/answers/detail/a_id/124/kw/duty/rel...) and other taxes in USA (https://help.cbp.gov/app/answers/detail/a_id/810/~/other-taxes-or-fees-required-to-import-goods-into-the-u.s.,-other-than-duty https://help.cbp.gov/app/answers/detail/a_id/810/~/other-tax...) on the value of the books being imported, then legally he has paid his dues and is free to profit from the import. I am not a lawyer. Even if the ruling goes against the guy who imported the books, I doubt if any end users will be affected.
- ck2 14y agoCannot root, cannot resell - it's America just consume more and more and more !? Make a pile of old tablets in your life that you cannot legally do anything with. When are we going to revolt and insist we own what we buy without being criminals?
- Nursie 14y agoThis whole area of law annoys me. Globalisation has meant that some companies can shop around the entire globe for raw materials and manpower, looking for the best price for both. They then throw up every barrier they can to stop individuals doing the same, region locking and other DRM, bought laws to prevent workarounds etc. They also try to prevent other businesses taking advantage of market disparities to undercut 'official' prices. The same market disparities that allow them to get their labour and materials for next to nothing. The whole thing stinks.
- tomp 14y agoWhat kind of solution do you propose?
- stretchwithme 14y agoSounds like he'd like to see the barriers removed.
- Nursie 14y agoOr made consistent. Another way to tackle it would be (IMHO) - If there are laws about working conditions for (say) electronics assembly plant workers in the UK, then the UK could insist that any imported electronics are made under similarly compliant conditions abroad - i.e. if you want to access out market you play by our rules. This could cover minimum wages also. Under those circumstances I would be more happy with grey imports being disallowed, and I would be interested to see the economic outcome.
- dsr_ 14y agoThree plausible answers: 1. Remove the barriers. Drop import and export restrictions, drop punitive tariffs, reduce taxes; at the same time, make restrictive DRM and equivalents (copyright controlling imports, in the instant case) illegal. This will reduce production costs and reduce selling prices. Overall, standard of living will rise slightly where production costs are low and sink more dramatically where production was formerly located. Eventually, the markets should reallocate themselves efficiently, but it can be a long and painful process and lots of people will get hurt. 2. Enforce all the barriers more rigorously. Apply import tariffs on everything, support local producers by mandating price floors, don't allow reimportation at all. Smuggling becomes much more lucrative, as does the black market. Advances in miniaturization mean that we can track fractional ownership of everything; instead of buying a coffee machine, you rent one, along with the mugs and spoons. (Clearly we need to reduce frictional costs immensely, or else the inertia drags us to a halt.) 3. We continue to muddle through, with incremental improvements when we (as a society, not we as hackers) recognize the need. Markets get regulated, but not very well or efficiently. Perhaps biases toward the established parties are corrected, perhaps not. If a sufficiently large proportion of the population is enraged, revolution ensues and all bets are off. Otherwise, business as usual.
- jivatmanx 14y agoI'm surprised nobody has mentioned that selling something at below cost (when R&D is factored) is clearly dumping and prevents the emergence of local publishers.
- helmut_hed 14y agoThose companies argue differential pricing schemes are vital to their success, and should be enforced by US courts I find this sort of reasoning very frustrating. It's not the job of the courts to ensure that anyone's business model can continue to be followed profitably. There may be sound legal reasons to overturn precedent in this case, but "companies are losing money" is not one.
- bsenftner 14y agoThis sure sounds like Corporate Welfare to me. Those damn Socialist Capitalists are pretty good at calling the kettle black.
- SparrowOS 14y agoGod says... dispenser Elect calamities wasting shortly Palestine dang_it freely Self enacteth recollection Danae's prescripts preparest ingrate at Human dispersion due VI look_on_the_brightside flood replace departed accomplished really infancy's recollect nature