11 ms·
Under the hood of Windows 8, or why desktop users should upgrade from Windows 7
- gutyril 14y ago"...and unproven tablet market." that's so true.
- code_duck 14y agoMaybe they thought italicizing it made it seem more realistic.
- chc 14y agoAre you trying to suggest that the market for Windows tablets is well proven?
- code_duck 14y agoI'm suggesting the market for tablets is well proven, as demonstrated by the 100 million plus Apple and Android tablets out there. I have no doubt that were it well done, a Windows tablet could be a success. I'm not, of course, saying I have any confidence that will ever happen.
- knowtheory 14y agoA meta-comment: I'm really pleased to see an article like this at the top of HN. It's informative and side-steps both the marketing bullshit about the metro interface and all of the wailing and gnashing of teeth that metro has engendered. More like this please.
- freehunter 14y agoEven better, it's an informative article from ExtremeTech. Perhaps their editors have been listening to my tirades here on HN every time a biased, unfair, and completely wrong article is posted. Reading this article, I kept going back to the top of the page to make sure I was still on ExtremeTech and didn't get rerouted to a different site.
- batgaijin 14y agoNo no no no no. If Linux people had to put up with crazy shitstorms over Gnome 3 and Unity, Metro most certainly is going to get it's fair share as well.
- freehunter 14y agoUnity and Gnome3 had maybe a year of shitstorms before it died down to some grumblings here and there. Metro has been around for two years, and one year for desktop Metro. It's getting on time to move it along.
- jiggy2011 14y agoThe thing with Metro is that nobody yet knows how well it will fare with it's target audience, the so called "average user".
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- smacktoward 14y agoIt's been around for two years, but on a platform that nobody uses: Windows Phone. It's only been around for nine months or so on a platform with an actually significant number of users: XBox 360. It's coming soon to a platform with something like ten times the number of users the 360 has: Windows. So there's going to be a lot of people encountering it for the first time over the next few months.
- freehunter 14y agoBut we here have known about it for a long time. The shitstorm might come from the average user. I guess that it won't. But seeing HN folks screaming at the walls every time some blog troll writes an article saying "Windows 8 Sucks!" really gets old. I'm getting sick of writing long-form comments pointing out the truth about Windows 8 rather than the lies that are being spread, having those comments get upvoted and some good comments on them, and then five minutes later there's another post that makes people scream and holler again. It gets old. I'm getting tired of sounding like a Windows 8 fanboy (I'm actually fairly ambivalent) just in comparison with the ridiculous hyperbole and FUD being spewed here constantly.
- Joeri 14y agoAlso meta: i appreciate the irony of an informative article about a tablet-friendly OS on a site with the worst tablet presentation of pretty much all mobile-optimized sites I've seen (it took almost a minute to load on my ipad 1, and crashed the browser partway through).
- robk 14y ago"Incidentally, if you want to perform a full “cold” boot (without the kernel being hibernated), simply select Restart from the shutdown menu or run shutdown /s /full /t 0." Why should it require a command line statement with three switches to simply shutdown?
- Sumaso 14y agoReally? Can you explain why you would need to do a full cold boot?
- apawloski 14y agoDisk encryption comes to mind (ie you might not want the OS to persist keys that should only exist in RAM), although I haven't investigated this further on Windows 8 yet.
- cdawzrd 14y agoIf you are using third-party disk (or anything) encryption tools, the keys would be stored in userspace RAM, which isn't saved to disk by shutdown. It only persists parts of the kernel, and presumably does not persist Bitlocker keys.
- archangel_one 14y agoBecause something has gone wrong at a fairly low level of the OS and you want to reboot to clear it out. I know theoretically this shouldn't happen, but it does happen all the time - I've not yet seen a system that I've really never ever needed to reboot (excluding my toaster), and previous Windows have not been the least offenders in this regard, so I have no confidence that Windows 8 will be the first where I don't need it.
- Dylan16807 14y ago>reboot to clear it out That's what the reboot option is for. Can you explain the problem again?
- learc83 14y agoWhenever someone talks about Windows 8, the question that pops up in my mind is: why include metro in the PC version? Why would I use anything but the Desktop mode? I can already make apps fullscreen if I want, but I definitely don't want to be limited to only fullscreen mode. So what advantage does Metro have for a desktop user?
- avolcano 14y agoNone. Zero. This is why I don't understand, say, the Verge's positive Windows 8 review. Sure, the desktop is still "usable." If you ignore Metro, it becomes an over-engineered full screen start menu. And somehow, having the most massive upgrade to Windows be, at best, ignoreable on desktops and laptops doesn't make Windows 8 instantly a massive failure?
- freehunter 14y agoThe usability of Metro is there for the tablet market. The people who don't need a PC and have decided they will not use a PC anymore. PCs are complex and confusing to many casual users. We thought it would get better with education, but we still have millions of young adults who grew up with computers yet are completely unable to function with any slight change. It's easier for them, for one reason or another, to completely jump ship to a tablet. The Metro interface on a PC is designed to stem or reverse that trend. Why jump to a tablet when you can stay with the PC and use it like a tablet? Or better yet, when your tablet IS your PC, and your PC is a tablet. Metro is useful. Maybe not to me, maybe not to you, but we're a small subset of users. There are many who don't tolerate the desktop.
- hnriot 14y agoYou are glossing over all the non-metro reasons like the security and performance.
- jiggy2011 14y agoIs there a performance benefit to running metro apps over desktop apps? The security comes from the sandboxing model rather than the UI.
- conradfr 14y agoMS say Windows 8 eliminates most reboots needed by OS upgrades. Great, but didn't they already say that for Win7 ? The new Task Manager looks great though, and the document history might be proven to be useful. I think I'll wait Windows 9 to upgrade my desktop & laptop.
- freehunter 14y agoMy main issue with Windows 8 updates is that, yeah it's nice that it tells you when it needs to reboot for updates and when that is going to happen, but I don't feel in control of it at all. I was taking a test online for a class, and the notice popped up that it was going to reboot in 15 minutes. I explicitly did not reboot before the test because I figured I could delay the reboot. It didn't give me that option. I started flying through the test in the hopes that I could finish in time. I didn't. Halfway through the test, the PC reboots without ever giving me an option to make it wait. There might be an option in the settings menu, but most time I want it to reboot automatically. Occasionally I would like to defer that for another 15 minutes.
- joenathan 14y agoWindows 8 gives you three days from the time it installs an update and until it forces a reboot, 3 days. If you don't like that then you have many options, to say "I don't feel in control of it at all" is pretty ridiculous when you have all these options http://i.minus.com/i4uIsZYCj4oek.jpg http://i.minus.com/i4uIsZYCj4oek.jpg
- hackmiester 14y agoThree days is too short. I should be able to prolong it forever, because it is MY computer. This should not require an option change. What if, just this once, I want it to reboot after 3 days and 15 minutes?
- joenathan 14y agoThen you set the updates from automatic to manual and install them when or if you ever feel like it. Most people never update their Windows PCs and they end up using a PC with bugs and performance issues that have long been fixed and security holes you could drive a truck through, I'm glad automatic updates are now turned on by default and that you also have to option to opt out.
- dested 14y ago"In Windows 8, Metro apps run on top of a new application architecture called WinRT, which is a low-level set of APIs that run just above the Windows kernel. WinRT is the Metro equivalent of Win32, which is the API that Desktop apps use. " Didnt we just read an article yesterday about how this isnt true? WinRT is built on top of win32, not parallel.
- manojlds 14y agoI trust Scott Hanselman - WinRT is built on top of Win32 - http://www.hanselman.com/blog/HowToCallWinRTAPIsInWindows8FromCDesktopApplicationsWinRTDiagram.aspx http://www.hanselman.com/blog/HowToCallWinRTAPIsInWindows8Fr... Another blog that says the same - http://blogs.microsoft.co.il/blogs/sasha/archive/2011/09/15/winrt-and-net-in-windows-8.aspx http://blogs.microsoft.co.il/blogs/sasha/archive/2011/09/15/...
- reddiric 14y agoIt's both. WinRT is an ABI as well as a set of tools. The WinRT API can be implemented as wrappers around Win32 APIs (as would make sense for functionality in the WinRT surface area that mirrored applicable functionality in the Win32 surface area) or new code (as would make sense for new functionality).
- nemo1618 14y agoNeat, I've been using Win8 since the first preview was released and I still learned some new tricks. File History, for instance, looks handy if you can afford the storage space. And I wasn't aware you could refresh from a user-created image; how exactly does it differ from a system restore though?
- mertd 14y agoWhat is the deal with boot time as an OS metric? Is it really important to boot 5 seconds faster than the previous iteration?
- wtallis 14y agoIt's an obvious measurable performance indicator that shouldn't get worse without a very good explanation, and when it gets significantly better, indicates that the developers are capable of optimizing something. Often times, boot time improvements can be partially due to optimizations that help during ordinary use as well.
- OriginalSyn 14y agoWhen the OS forces a reboot after 3 days of an update if you don't manually do it yourself it can be important.
- sukuriant 14y agoThat's a fair question. Personally, I'm impressed with how fast my machine boots up. It's certainly better than minutes/near-minutes my old machine used to. The same could be said about a few milliseconds when loading a web page; but Google Chrome does really weird (but awesome!!) network adapter/caching hacks to get those few milliseconds, and many people are grateful for it. And, 5 seconds on newer machines is a lot more time on older machines. (Disclosure, since the topic is on it: Microsoft employee. The remarks are my own, not the company's, blah blah)
- JeremyMorgan 14y agoThis is the equivalent of a plain looking girl dying her hair some crazy color. Personally I don't understand this concept of forcing a clunky and strange UI on people and having change just for the sake of change. Both suffer from huge amounts of backlash, yet their creators stand by it, for one simple reason: They have to change, so things don't appear stale. These interfaces aren't better, they're just new. It's really that simple, we've had 10 years of the same type of interface in Windows, Linux and OSX and they need something new. Apple of course knows they have something good with OSX and are unwilling to slap their users in the face, and they generally don't fix what is broke.
- B-Con 14y ago> Personally I don't understand this concept of forcing [...] on people and having change just for the sake of change Welcome to development, where anything over 24 months is old news and needs to be made different. Not better, just different. It's kind of a plague in the industry. Things change just for the sake of it. I'm all for changing to make things better, but a large sect of development seems obsessed with new just because... new.
- seunosewa 14y agos/girl/person
- grannyg00se 14y agoOne of the best windows 8 articles I've read to date. This actually has me considering an upgrade for the anti-virus/malware as well as the faster boot, leaner run-time, and Hyper-V included. I'll definitely go check it out at some retailer to see if I think I can get over (or minimize) the horrid multi-tile slate touchpad-friendly floating window interface.
- thomaslutz 14y agoI tried the final Windows8 (64bit) from DreamSpark in the latest VirtualBox again today (after giving the RC a shot). There were improvements, but it was slow as hell and finally crashed hard when I tried starting the Maps application. And it was gone as fast as it was installed. Perhaps it is usable after SP1, but it certainly isn't usable (for me) now.
- SkyMarshal 14y agoYou should try installing it directly the hardware of the same machine, I'd be interested to know whether it's VirtualBox issue or something else.
- thomaslutz 14y agoUnfortunately that is not an option right now, because it's my production machine with Windows7 as a host and some other VMs currently running. The machine should be powerful enough with a Quadcore i7 and 12GB RAM, though. Perhaps it really is a VirtualBox issue.
- joestringer 14y agoAnyone else familiar with "Arbitrary Free Protection"? 'cause it's only turning up one search result for me.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- Someone 14y agoSo, who is right? Ars Technica claims WinRT runs on top of Win32 (http://arstechnica.com/features/2012/10/windows-8-and-winrt-everything-old-is-new-again/6/ http://arstechnica.com/features/2012/10/windows-8-and-winrt-...), this text claims it runs just above the kernel. Also, completely unrelated: I hope that 'single keypress' for resetting your PC to a blank slate is somewhat exaggerated. If it isn't, leaving your PC alone for seconds becomes truly dangerous (yes, technically there is no difference; giving anybody local access to your PC puts your files at risk, but having a system make vandalism easier? I sure hope it asks for your password first)
- robomartin 14y agoFrom the article: "By installing Windows 8, companies will implicitly force its employees to use a new interface that could severely dent productivity. " This is, by far, the biggest issue with Windows 8. And, at least for me, the most confusing aspect of Microsoft's decision making process. I would be surprised if ANY business with more than two employees willingly shifts their PC's to Windows 8. Imagine having one hundred employees grind to a halt due to the UI shift. Deadly. I would really love to have the opportunity to hear from Microsoft on this one. Why is it that we don't even have an option to disable Metro (or tablet mode, or whatever they want to call it) on a desktop system? What was the logic behind that decision, if any?
- barista 14y agoWhile there are many enterprises that have willingly adopted the iPhone and later iPad in their organizations. The lost productivity due to a different UI is a misconception. What is important is legacy application support which I think continues to be there in Windows 8.
- sliverstorm 14y agoIt may actually turn out to be controllable via group policy. I swear you can control just about anything with GP. So, enterprise may have that option.
- magoon 14y agoWindows 8 is so good
- at-fates-hands 14y agoI hate to say it, but I'm becoming a but of a Windows FanBoi. After using Win 8 for a few weeks now, this article confirmed some of the things I was seeing, but not sure if it was just me seeing a new shiny toy or it really was happening. The two things I've already noticed are it starts up a lot faster, and comes back from sleep a lot faster as well. It's also a lot more stable. Almost no crashes when I was running several Adobe apps at the same time. I'm running with 4GB RAM and was impressed with the performance. I can only imagine how well it would run under a much faster processor and even more RAM. The real winners will be desktop users for sure. Losing the Start button was not a huge issue. I use an app launcher and just hitting the WIN button takes you to the main metro screen with all your apps. It's not hardly as confusing as everybody is crying about.