9 ms·
The Unreasonable Ineffectiveness of Mathematics Education
- edtechdev 14y agoOne other suggestion: read some research on mathematics education. Look through some of the proceedings of some of the recent RUME (research on undergraduate math education) conferences, for example: http://sigmaa.maa.org/rume/Site/Proceedings.html http://sigmaa.maa.org/rume/Site/Proceedings.html This book How Students Learn (PDF can be downloaded for free) covers math education (as well as history and science) http://www.nap.edu/catalog.php?record_id=10126 http://www.nap.edu/catalog.php?record_id=10126 it is a sequel to the excellent (and free) book How People Learn: http://www.nap.edu/catalog.php?record_id=9853 http://www.nap.edu/catalog.php?record_id=9853 Students need a motivating context, a reason to learn mathematics (or any topic). It's called situated learning (also situated cognition, situated action) - with techniques like problem-based learning, challenge-based learning, service learning, project-based learning, learning by design, learning through games, simulations, modeling, programming, etc. That's one side of it. Another is embodied learning. That's how we understand math (and other) concepts. See for example work by Rafael Nunez http://vislab.cs.vt.edu/~quek/classes/aware+embodiedinteraction/papers/nunem99.pdf http://vislab.cs.vt.edu/~quek/classes/aware+embodiedinteract... http://www.cogsci.ucsd.edu/~nunez/web/FM.PDF http://www.cogsci.ucsd.edu/~nunez/web/FM.PDF
- wisty 14y agoOK, I know a bit about pedagogy, and a lot of it is crap. There's an awful lot of relativism in most of it. Many of the people who teach teachers simply don't care about what works in classrooms, because empiricism is an evil capitalist plot (or something like that). When the Wikipedia page for Education has gems like "Based on the works of Jung", you know you're not in a field which cares about hard facts. Not that it's a real problem - the statistics show that first year teachers are pretty poor (regardless of the amount of pedagogy training they have), but they learn on the job and are pretty good after about 2 years (unless they are just doing a year of teaching to pad their resume, but that's another debate). I've got a lot of respect for cognitive science though, and that seems to be what you are recommending.
- disgruntledphd2 14y agoNote that Jung was one of the first people to invetigate the use of words in schizophrenia (in his thesis, as a matter of fact). Secondly, he created the conception of extroverts and introverts that we typically use to describe people today. Seriously, go read some of the works of Jung before you sound off on his issues. I did, and I was pleasantly surprised at just how sensible he was. I completely agree that much of modern educational training is quite poor, but take aim at (for example, the Myers Briggs or visual, auditory, kinesthetic learning) rather than poor old Jung.
- marshallp 14y agoExcept the examples you've given like extroverts vs introverts are not scientifically rigorous and the terms already existed well before him all around the world in different cultures (outgoing vs shy/retiring etc).
- disgruntledphd2 14y agoStatistics was pretty much in its infancy back then, how would you have proposed he be scientifically rigorous? Actually, if you could give me your definition of scientific rigour that would probably help.
- marshallp 14y agoStatistics was around then. I consider science to be the art of making correct predictions. So you need a hypothesis (in the form of equations or computer programs) that can be tested on observations leading to correct predictions. Extroversion/introversion might be scientifically rigorours by that definition (they might have done quantitative studies) but I'm not sure Jung did those, and even that it makes sense to create such a classificaton - people are a lot more complex and I don't really see the need for use of such classifications. That's a problem I see with psychology, sociology, economics, and other "soft" fields. The quantification of things which are far more complex than the simplistic models created to the point that they are essentially meaningless. It's meaningless to quantify people into races or skin colors and that's about the level that those sciences are at.
- capnrefsmmat 14y ago(author here) Thanks. I'm a physics major, and I've done quite a lot of research into physics education, but I haven't looked into math education. I'll have to take a look into your references. I wrote this article a few months back when there was a flood of "why do we need math?!" articles after some editorial said it's worthless; I only got around to putting it up Friday. So it's aimed more to why we need math, rather than how we should teach it. I've got a whole separate article on physics education which I'll have to put up soon.
- hdivider 14y agoUseful resources - thank you for that. "with techniques like problem-based learning, challenge-based learning, service learning, project-based learning, learning by design, learning through games, simulations, modeling, programming, etc." I'm glad you mention games, because currently this field is mostly all about teaching arithmetic and other elementary subjects. Notable innovative exceptions are DragonBox and a few others in development. It's probably a clichè to say that mathematics education is archaic, but it's true in a lot of cases. I've been to lectures where a simple 3-D program like Blender a few minutes of simple 3D work would have significantly helped countless students to imagine the mathematical entities being discussed. But alas, such things seem to be too advanced for much of academia - instead they build plastic models that only 1 person can use at a time.
- Heliosmaster 14y agogreat article, very well written with many agreeable points. But I doubt that the teaching of mathematics can be easily subverted into a better one, mostly because there is plenty of people that do not care enough: they think "math is hard and sucks" or simply do not care about knowing the alphabet of the knowledge. That's why at the University math is taught the good way, because there almost everybody is genuinely interested in the subject.
- kiba 14y agoMath is hard and sucks because we are forced to do tedious and time consuming calculations by hand. Even with a calculator, it's still painful. I basically cringe at khanacademy everytime they forced me to do this.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- j2kun 14y agoMathematics is not about calculations. That's exactly the problem with math education, that the people designing the curriculum don't accept that.
- Evbn 14y agoYou seem to be unaware of how curriculum has been designed in recent decades. The current "Where's the Math" protest movement is complaining that the curriculum is devoid of calculation.
- orangeduck 14y agoGreat article. The lego air plane analogy is very accurate. It is certainly true that maths has lost some of its mysticism in early education but I think perhaps telling students that "maths is a set of abstract made up rules governing an imaginary universe" might alienate them just as much as before.
- davidkatz 14y agoThis is indeed a serious problem. An interesting startup that is trying to address it is http://www.mathalicious.com/ http://www.mathalicious.com/. They give math teachers lesson plans which tie math to things that students care about - 'is Kobe Bryant a better shooter than LeBron James?'. Things like that. From my own experience, I was pretty bored with Math in high school. Through a series of coincidences I started reading some popular physics books, which led me to study Physics and re-discover Math as an incredible tool.
- Tycho 14y agoA pattern i see a lot is that people develop and interest in maths outside what their school was doing. Maybe we need to shift the onus onto individual children and families to foster interest in maths, regardless of how the schools teach it. It doesn't really matter how well you prepare the food if people don't have an appetite.
- Evbn 14y agoYou say that parents should take a role in their children's intellectual development? Then what am I paying property taxes for?
- lutusp 14y ago> You say that parents should take a role in their children's intellectual development? Then what am I paying property taxes for? Let me ask another question -- do you really want to avoid having to provide an intellectual context for your children's life experience, and assign that responsibility to governments instead? Doesn't that sound dangerous? I shall resist quoting historical examples in which governments became the primary source of ideas and intellectual content for a new generation.
- bmuon 14y agoI disagree on the premise that math is tought in the wrong way. Repetition is a very important part of learning so learning to use mathematical constructs is just as important as learning to know how to build them. Also, people don't naturally think in abstract terms, many learn from example first, interpolate and then gain an understanding. Humans are more inductive than deductive. So at the very least it's not that the current education is wrong, but that it needs to add the teaching of another skill. Like another poster says, the topic requires research. Teaching to think in abstractions isn't easy.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- 001sky 14y agoMath = Numeracy, logic, geometry. Those are the three reasons I learned math. All three benefit from memorization. All three are practical. All three speed up future thinking. All three are scalable. All three are intuitive. All three are thinks you can't live without. The reason why math is 'hard' is the same reason 'exercise' is hard. It takes a combination of skill and practice (a/k/a discipline) to make it 'easy'. And in a similar way to the endless "how to lose weight" fads, we see "how to do make math easy," when <easy> is not 'in their nature'. The main problem with math education is that it is falsifiable. Math teachers can be measured, because math performance can be measured. This is why it makes educators nervous. And, I suspect, why they mostly suck at teaching it. They are the ultimate risk-averse sub-population. Subconsciously, 'educators' <hate> the idea of accountability, because it is predicated on the notion of potential failure. But the 'educational' establishement is <built> on the foundation of unquestionable <authority>. so math is for these guys an existential threat. TLDR: To be good at teaching math, you have to be open to measuring your failure, which makes people feel bad. Including the teachers.
- Tycho 14y agoYou can't live without geometry?
- 001sky 14y agoYou must like taking the long way. =D [1] ___________ [1] Example: In navigation, the shortest route between two points may be a straight line. Or not. Depending on the scale of your journey.
- Tycho 14y agoIf you are innumerrate, you're going to have trouble with your bills and interest rates and such; if you can't apply logic then you'll have trouble holding a job where you have to make a lot of decisions; but geometry? How many people are concerned with geometry beyond the most rudimentary concepts like interpreting a street map. I just think statements like 'you can't live without geometry' further the 'disconnect' (as they say in America) between the people who 'get' maths and the people who don't. It's almost like a religious person telling you that 'you need Jesus in your life' or something - it doesn't actually persuade in any way, just signals that this person maintains some sort of alien, abstract belief system which they cannot relate to the lives of ordinary people.
- quinndupont 14y agoThis article really should reference Kirby's excellent article about a non-Platonic concept of mathematics, which, in arguing that the writing of mathematics is necessary for the doing of mathematics. On this view, mathematics education is a necessarily in scriptural activity. Kirby, Vicky. "Enumerating Language: "The Unreasonable Effectiveness of Mathematics"" Configurations, 11, 3 (2003).
- 7952 14y agoA few years ago I read an article [1] about a school teaching maths by pretending that the process was magic in Harry Potter. Perhaps what children and adults lack is a sense of imagination of how to apply concepts. [1] http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/england/nottinghamshire/7094593.stm http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/england/nottinghamshire/7094593.s...
- marshallp 14y agoThere's a few problems with the article. The rules argument he makes could instead be made for the more useful field of computer programming. Also, the reductionist paradigm is dead. It worked for finding laws of physics and some chemistry, but otherwise, in the most useful fields of today, like biology/materials/chemistry (high throughput methods), computer vision, search engines etc. the automated creation of hypotheses through machine learning is winning out. Conrad Wolfram gives a talk about the need for math education reform http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=60OVlfAUPJg http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=60OVlfAUPJg He uses the term mathematics, but completely removing that term and replacing it with computer programming and machine learning should be done. They sound cooler and this step will remove all the baggage and ill-will mathematics has in society. That way, all mathematics teachers can be simply removed from high schools and colleges and replaced with computer programmers. Estonia is one of the few enlightened places on this subject with their introduction of programming as mandatory from year 1 in k12. Almost the entire high school drop out rate can be attributed to maths teaching, and their is no solid empirical proof of it's utility over programming (the practice of "science" hasn't been applied to "maths" itself). http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mathematical_anxiety http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mathematical_anxiety The same argument can be made for a number of other subjects, such as chemistry (why teach the periodic table?), languages (we have google translate and should taxpayers be funding this unproductive activity), and others (everything should be reexamined in light of search engines and instant information access). The only useful subjects in k12 are probably - computer programming, including machine learning/statistics - physical education, - communication (reading/writing/public speaking/socialization) - general studies (trivia like history, geography, astronomy), - personal finance - physical crafts (3d printing, woodshop, cooking)
- capnrefsmmat 14y agoI'm curious how you would replace mathematics with programming. My undergraduate thesis project involves a lot of programming, but I also had to determine that I can detect anomalous gamma spectra through some linear algebra, a correlation matrix, an assumption of Poisson-distributed counts, and a chi^2-distributed anomaly statistic. This gives me a statistically well-founded way to detect anomalies. Would you have me replace this process with some sort of automated machine learning, hoping it could produce better results than a special-purpose algorithm?
- tokenadult 14y agoOnce again ColinWright graces the front page of HN on a weekend by submitting a story on mathematics education. The blog post submitted here, by an undergraduate physics major at the University of Texas at Austin, prompted me to read some of the author's other writings. The author's perspective on the importance of mathematics as a tool for understanding physics immediately reminded me of some good reads by older authors on physics. "How to Become a Good Theoretical Physicist" (HTML title "Theoretical Physics as a Challenge") by Nobel laureate Gerard 't Hooft http://www.staff.science.uu.nl/~hooft101/theorist.html http://www.staff.science.uu.nl/~hooft101/theorist.html lists essential knowledge that everyone should possess who desires to advance theoretical physics, and included in that knowledge is much mathematics. There is a whole book, The Road to Reality: A Complete Guide to the Laws of the Universe by Roger Penrose, http://www.amazon.com/The-Road-Reality-Complete-Universe/dp/0679776311/ http://www.amazon.com/The-Road-Reality-Complete-Universe/dp/... that is marketed as a book about physics but includes a huge section reviewing secondary school mathematics as an essential background to physics. The blog post submitted here has a title that is an homage to the article "The Unreasonable Effectiveness of Mathematics in the Natural Sciences" by Eugene Wigner in Communications in Pure and Applied Mathematics, vol. 13, No. I (February 1960). https://dtrinkle.matse.illinois.edu/_media/unreasonable-effectiveness-cpam1960.pdf https://dtrinkle.matse.illinois.edu/_media/unreasonable-effe... People who know physics have long been delighted to find in physics applications for the mathematics they learned in mathematics courses without a hint of how useful the mathematics would be. The blog post author, however, goes beyond that perspective to urge, "Let’s think of mathematics in the abstract. Mathematics, at its most basic, is a very simple set of very well-defined rules. The rules describe the behavior and interaction of certain completely imaginary objects. Upon these rules, mathematicians have built others." And that brings to mind Paul Halmos's article (with its intentionally provocative title, an example of Halmos's spicy style in expository articles about mathematics) "Applied Mathematics Is Bad Mathematics" Halmos, P. "Applied mathematics is bad mathematics." Mathematics tomorrow (1984). http://books.google.com/books?hl=en&lr=&id=FcgB818WAQgC&oi=fnd&pg=PA193&dq=paul+halmos+applied+mathematics+is+bad+mathematics&ots=p0vNtw9Mxt&sig=VcLMDtZX26VSaeMCse4wPqjyzcs http://books.google.com/books?hl=en&lr=&id=FcgB818WA... Halmos claims that mathematics is interesting and beautiful whether or not it has an apparent application. Other replies already posted to this submission have helpfully mentioned the issue of empirical tests of what method of teaching mathematics may best help young learners appreciate (and later apply) mathematics. I have been deeply interested in cross-national comparisons of educational practice since living overseas beginning in 1982. In those days, one way in which school systems in most countries outdid the United States school system, economic level of countries being comparable, was that an American could go to many different places and expect university graduates (and perhaps high school graduates as well) to have a working knowledge of English for communication about business or research. I still surprise Chinese visitors to the United States, in 2012, if I join in on their Chinese-language conversations. No one expects Americans to learn any language other than English. Elsewhere in the world, the public school system is tasked with imparting at least one foreign language (most often English) and indeed a second language of school instruction (as in Taiwan or in Singapore) that in my generation was not spoken in most pupils' homes, as well as all the usual primary and secondary school subjects. At a minimum, that's one way in which schools in most parts of the world take on a tougher task than the educational goals of United States schools. It was on my second stay overseas (1998-2001), that I became especially aware of differences in primary mathematics education. I began using the excellent Primary Mathematics series from Singapore http://www.singaporemath.com/Primary_Mathematics_US_Ed_s/39.htm http://www.singaporemath.com/Primary_Mathematics_US_Ed_s/39.... for homeschooling my own children, and I browsed Chinese-language bookstores in Taiwan for popular books about mathematics as my oldest son expressed an avid interest in mathematics. I discovered that the textbooks used in Singapore, Taiwan (and some neighboring countries) are far better designed than mathematics textbooks in the United States. (During that same stay in Taiwan, I had access to the samples United States textbooks in the storeroom of a school for expatriates, but they were never of any use to my family. I pored over those and was appalled at how poorly designed those textbooks were.) I discovered that the mathematics gap between the United States and the top countries of the world was, if anything, deeper and wider than the second-language gap. Now I put instructional methodologies to the test by teaching supplemental mathematics courses to elementary-age pupils willing to take on a prealgebra-level course at that age. My pupils' families come from multiple countries in Asia, Europe, Africa, and the Caribbean Islands. (Oh, families from all over the United States also enroll in my classes. See my user profile for more specifics.) Simply by benefit of a better-designed set of instructional materials (formerly English translations of Russian textbooks, with reference to the Singapore textbooks, and now the Prealgebra textbook from the Art of Problem Solving), http://www.artofproblemsolving.com/Store/viewitem.php?item=prealgebra http://www.artofproblemsolving.com/Store/viewitem.php?item=p... the pupils in my classes can make big jumps in mathematics level (as verified by various standardized tests they take in their schools of regular enrollment, and by their participation in the AMC mathematics tests) and gains in confidence and delight in solving unfamiliar problems. More schools in the United States could do this, if only they would. The experience of Singapore shows that a rethinking of the entire national education system is desirable for best results, http://www.merga.net.au/documents/RP182006.pdf http://www.merga.net.au/documents/RP182006.pdf but an immediate implementation of the best English-language textbooks, rarely used in United States schools, would be one helpful way to start improving mathematics instruction in the United States. The blog post author begins his post with "In American schools, mathematics is taught as a dark art. Learn these sacred methods and you will become master of the ancient symbols. You must memorize the techniques to our satisfaction or your performance on the state standardized exams will be so poor that they will be forced to lower the passing grades." This implicitly mentions another difference between United States schools and schools in countries with better performance: American teachers show a method and then expect students to repeat applying the method to very similar exercises, while teachers in high-performing countries show an open-ended problem first, and have the students grapple with how to solve it and what method would be useful in related but not identical problems. From The Teaching Gap: Best Ideas from the World's Teachers for Improving Education in the Classroom (1999): "Readers who are parents will know that there are differences among American teachers; they might even have fought to move their child from one teacher's class into another teacher's class. Our point is that these differences, which appear so large within our culture, are dwarfed by the gap in general methods of teaching that exist across cultures. We are not talking about gaps in teachers' competence but about a gap in teaching methods." p. x "When we watched a lesson from another country, we suddenly saw something different. Now we were struck by the similarity among the U.S. lessons and by how different they were from the other country's lesson. When we watched a Japanese lesson, for example, we noticed that the teacher presents a problem to the students without first demonstrating how to solve the problem. We realized that U.S. teachers almost never do this, and now we saw that a feature we hardly noticed before is perhaps one of the most important features of U.S. lessons--that the teacher almost always demonstrates a procedure for solving problems before assigning them to students. This is the value of cross-cultural comparisons. They allow us to detect the underlying commonalities that define particular systems of teaching, commonalities that otherwise hide in the background." p. 77 A great video on the differences in teaching approaches can be found at "What if Khan Academy was made in Japan?" http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CHoXRvGTtAQ http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CHoXRvGTtAQ with actual video clips from the TIMSS study of classroom practices in various countries.
- j2kun 14y agoInteresting mathematics can be taught in high schools. In fact, I've tried and had some wonderful results. See my account of it here: http://jeremykun.wordpress.com/2011/06/26/teaching-mathematics-graph-theory/ http://jeremykun.wordpress.com/2011/06/26/teaching-mathemati....
- peripetylabs 14y agoI don't recall ever wondering "why" I would ever "need" mathematics. I just always enjoyed it. To me, trying to convince students why they should enjoy mathematics (just because we do) seems like a good way to make students miserable. Is mathematics education really failing because it doesn't produce many mathematicians?
- ams6110 14y agoI think this is the real issue. A small fraction of people are fascinated by mathematics and enjoy it. The idea that there is some specific way to teach mathematics that will ignite some spark in a person who doesn't inherently have it I believe is false.
- bearmf 14y agoI will present a somewhat controversial point of view here. The problem with math education lies as much with teachers as it does with students. If you have students that cannot understand basic formulas and memorize them, you are not going to teach them abstract concepts. Concrete math is much easier than abstract math for the vast majority of people. I cannot really believe the stories about people who are supposedly talented at math but are not engaged enough by the school curriculum and consequently fail at the tests. School level math is very easy for anyone with some aptitude for math. Anyone who fails it will probably have even greater difficulties with abstract concepts behind it. That gifted students are not stimulated enough is the real problem. Math classes for gifted children is probably the only solution. Something like Stuyvesant High in New York City but on a wider scale. As for better math education in Singapore and Taiwan, well, they do have better students than most US public schools. Both genetics and culture play a role here. Asian people have both higher average IQs and higher average conscientiousness. Their teachers are able to teach math at a higher level. US could surely learn from them, but not every school could use their techniques.
- guylhem 14y agoI disagree. The current perspective of IQ and ethnicities show that while there might be slight differences, they are dwarfed by the differences in the education process. If you want another example besides Singapore, look at french math textbook for highschool students - with nth derivatives, etc. Here's the first link googles gives me - something that a finishing highschool student, around 17 years old, is expected to do if he is enrolled in a "scientific" curriculum. (basically there are 4 curriculums - scientific, economic, literary (humanities), technical (vocational)) http://maths54.free.fr/terminal/ch7_der_fonct_comp/cours_chap7.pdf http://maths54.free.fr/terminal/ch7_der_fonct_comp/cours_cha...
- bearmf 14y agoI do not want to discuss race/national IQ differences, this is a sensitive topic and does not really belong here. I am quite sure individual IQ differences are not controversial though and cannot be "dwarfed" by good educational processes. The French textbook looks reasonably rigorous but as you say it is intended for "scientific" students. Thats basically what I was talking about in my post - you need to select for gifted students before moving on to complex math (not that derivatives are particularly hard if you do not have to prove theorems). In US I believe differential calculus belongs to AP Calculus high school classes. No idea about their level but content on the internet looks similar, maybe less rigorous.