15 ms·
Miami, your Waymo ride is ready
- techIA 10mo agoThe competition is growing.
- melling 10mo agoI’m going to Miami next week. Time for my first WayMo ride.
- hypercube33 10mo agoWeirdly (well not for me it's a charter metal festival cruise) I am too and interested in doing the same. Typically we use Uber and it's been a not great experience.
- thomas_witt 10mo agoFunny that they apparently didn't include South Beach, at least according to the map.
- s-kymon 10mo agomiami beach is a different city = different laws and regulations
- treis 10mo agoWe got these in Atlanta. I haven't had the chance to ride yet but watching them it's pretty clear that they're legit. I think we're on the cusp of something that will change the landscape of our cities. It's going to revolutionize getting around and take a chunk out of the land dedicated to parking.
- nerdsniper 10mo agoIt will also funnel large amounts of revenue out of every city into s/SF/Bay Area. Currently around 35% of the money spent on Uber/Lyft stays in the local economy. Waymo in SF still employs a large number of highly paid engineers who are paid the money which used to move through SF via Uber/Lyft. And those SF engineers spend a decent chunk of it locally on food, art, entertainment, and various other services - so it has (somewhat) less of an effect on the city's overall economy/total employment. Waymo in Miami won't be locally re-spending nearly as much of Miami's money as Uber/Lyft did. Significantly more of it will be removed from Miami with each ride. This might be even more pronounced for cities like Houston, which don't attract tourism from Waymo staff.
- seanmcdirmid 10mo ago> It will also funnel large amounts of revenue out of every city into SF. Why SF? Does Google even still have an engineering office in the city? Alphabet is a publicly traded company with employees all over the USA and the world, even if you said the money would be funneled into Mountain View you'd be incorrect. The money will be funneled into 401Ks would be more accurate, and a lot of snowbirds in Florida are living off of their 401Ks and stock investments (which probably have a lot of Alphabet in them), so it is definitely something for Florida. But I think your point is that gig workers won't be making the money anymore. That's definitely true. That is just like when loom machines took money away from weavers back in the 19th century, or computers took money away from typists/secretaries in the 20th century. We should carefully consider whether or not that is a net good for society.
- spongebobstoes 10mo agoare there examples of jobs going obsolete being a net harm to society, over a long time scale? surely it's good to reduce the amount of menial labour being performed in the world
- seanmcdirmid 10mo agoThe loss of manufacturing jobs and the movement of jobs in to services has been hard for the US, and is basically where MAGA came from, which I would say is a net harm to society. We wouldn't be arguing about Waymo right now if those Uber drivers had better jobs making things instead of being forced into gig work.
- fragmede 10mo agoMidwives were replaced by the male-dominated medical industry, which initially raised infant mortality, nevermind women losing autonomy over birth. Night soil collectors were replaced by partial sewage systems, which resulted in cholera and typhoid outbreaks. Local butchers were replaced by meat packing plants. The Jungle tells us why this didn't go so well either. In all three of those cases, we rushed to an incomplete solution before it was fully ready. In this case though, no one's banning humans from driving cars anytime soon, so that part of it will go okay.
- kevin_thibedeau 10mo agoHave you watched them operate in a downpour? They've so far only been tested in semiarid locales.
- xnx 10mo ago> Have you watched them operate in a downpour? Waymo in heavy rain: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dG6u6QfTv6s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dG6u6QfTv6s > only been tested in semiarid locales Is San Francisco semi-arid?
- btmiller 10mo agoI’m skeptical. Is the presence of a human driver keeping you from using Uber/Lyft/taxis more than you currently are? Why would you think removing a driver will lead to more ride share trips? Capitalism is going to do its thing, so between the touted benefits of driverless ride shares and capitalist economics, could you please explain how exactly our city landscapes, namely parking lots, will be revolutionized in any way, shape, or form other than zombie lots occupied Waymos endlessly arranging and charging themselves? Forgive my cynicism, it feels like I’ve seen this how this dream turns out many times before.
- treis 10mo agoThe zombie lots can be consolidated and moved to less desirable areas. And I think there's some demand shifting that can happen. People get driven to the office in the morning. Deliveries happen during the day and then people are driven home. It also eliminates the need for parking for a lot of places. A restaurant doesn't need a parking lot if people are primarily arriving in self driving cars.
- dc396 10mo ago> Is the presence of a human driver keeping you from using Uber/Lyft/taxis more than you currently are? Yep. A couple of bad experiences with Uber/Lyft drivers put me off using them. Waymo is honestly more comfortable/less stressful for me. Similarly, I just read an article discussing parents making use of Waymo to schlep their kids to sportball practice/friend's house/wherever kids hang out these days, even though it is against Waymo's terms of service. The article indicated those parents didn't trust their kids to be in a car along with a strange human, but were ok with an automated system (and violating the ToS of that system). > please explain how exactly our city landscapes, namely parking lots, will be revolutionized in any way, shape, or form other than zombie lots occupied Waymos Today parking tends to be located near the shop/restaurant/office people want to go to. If people no longer need to park to go to where they want to go, parking (for charging) can relocate and be concentrated, thereby freeing up the parking spaces for other uses.
- btmiller 10mo ago
- giancarlostoro 10mo agoAny idea how much they cost? Because for me the main use is mostly one off rides to the city to have drinks with friends and go there and come home safely. I live in Central Florida, I mostly use Uber or Lyft for these scenarios.
- OkayPhysicist 10mo agoIn SF, Waymo costs about the same as an Uber or Lyft after factoring in a couple buck tip. For awhile, I checked both Uber and Waymo when I wanted to get somewhere, but after not seeing significant price differences I stopped bothering.
- giancarlostoro 10mo agoI guess the other thing is you dont have to tip your AI driver.
- spwa4 10mo agoThey're more expensive than Uber and Lyft including tips.
- timmmmmmay 10mo agoI can't speak to San Francisco, but in Los Angeles the waymo has been cheaper than the Uber even before tip every time I've compared them
- gs17 10mo agoIs that a recent shift? When I was there in the summer they were marginally more expensive pre-tip.
- dfxm12 10mo agoCan you elaborate? Are you saying you think people are going to give up their cars because Waymo is available?
- treis 10mo agoI think it fundamentally shifts the cost of transport from marginal to capitalized. Meaning a 20 minute trip is $0.50 of gas and some fraction of the manufacturing cost of the car. Today it's that plus $5-10 to the driver. It's somewhat equivalent to the advent of trains but on a personal level. In the way that trains made shipping goods across the country more or less free once the rail was built that's what's going to happen to people and packages getting around cities.
- dougb5 10mo agoWe've had it for a few years in SF and, while it's very convenient, I haven't witnessed the revolution you speak of. Judging from the traffic, people still mostly get around in their personal vehicles. There's about as much parking as before and it's still a nightmare. But I'd like to believe.
- krashidov 10mo agoMy prediction is it will make our cities worse. In 30 years every family will want one self driving car per person in the household
- tanseydavid 10mo agoIf they can figure out how to really take advantage of economies of scale, and drive the costs down quite a lot -- the desirability of car ownership will drop dramatically. Everyone I know under 40yo already professes to hate driving and hate car ownership.
- wooger 10mo agoOwning a car and living somewhere you have to use it for day to day everything is tedious. But the option of one for the weekend, trips out of town, into nature is ultra valuable, enough so that it's worth it to have a car sitting doing nothing during the week for us, even in a well connected large city, in a walkable area. At present or I suspect future costs, any kind of taxi for an out of town trip (without any rail option) of 50-100 miles is way too expensive to consider, we'd sooner hire a car, if it was slicker and more convenient. But hiring a car anywhere but an airport terminal needs a trip to the hire place, and needs to start and finish when they're open to avoid spending an extra day or two of hire. Plus time taken on paperwork and insurance faff could easily be an hour.
- jandrewrogers 10mo agoWhen I was working for the automotive industry their models and projections suggested that ubiquitous self-driving cars would reduce the total market for cars to ~15% of its current size. As in, sales would drop by 85%. The addressable market for automotive OEMs is set to undergo a dramatic reduction in size. Few automotive companies have a coherent plan for how they were going to survive that existential risk.
- spwa4 10mo agoSorry, but at the current price of Waymo rides that just can't happen. They become more expensive than leasing a car at something like 8 rides per month (as in, get into a Waymo, expect to pay $60 per ride) Oh and this price was going up, not down.
- deeg 10mo agoI live in the city and as much as I'd like to be car free waymo doesn't do it (yet). I take frequent weekend trips that travel (I assume) outside of waymos range. Once waymo supports car rentals I could consider getting rid of mine.
- keeda 10mo agoI would hope so, but it's not yet clear if the economics pan out for large scale deployment. The ride is amazing, but the sensor-laden cars are also very expensive. The only sensible aspect of Elon's boneheaded move to remove non-camera sensors from Tesla models is the drive to reduce costs, because low costs are essential for mass adoption. Yes, sensors are rapidly dropping in cost, making the move even more boneheaded, but the theory is sound. Some Waymo exec claimed that they are seeing very encouraging unit economics, which gives me hope for mass diffusion, but we'll only know when the rubber actually hits the road (heheheh).
- dyauspitr 10mo agoLiDAR is actually quite cheap now.
- milkytron 10mo agoI wonder how they will impact traffic. Rideshare has already added traffic according to some studies I've read. Basically, instead of someone going from point A (current location with own car nearby) to point B (destination), Point A becomes the destination of the previous passenger, and point B and C were the previous points A and B. So a single trip adds one more leg. It might reduce the need for parking... potentially. But there will still need to be a certain amount of time dedicated to charging for these cars that requires parking. If private car ownership continues increasing in cost, and households become increasingly cost burdened (transportation is already the second highest cost for households), then I wonder how this will impact demand for housing in areas dependent on cars. Curious on the outcomes here. I think the best thing we can do for city transportation is increasing the number of viable transportation options. Waymo is one option amongst the options dependent on roads, but walking, biking, and transit should still be a priority so that we maintain competition amongst transportation modes.
- cman1444 10mo agoParking for charging can be done en masse though. For example, waymo could have a single large charging facility somewhere out-of-the-way. Small price to pay in my opinion. The parking gains are huge though. As adoption increases, parking demand for shopping centers, apartments, workplaces, etc. should all decrease. Say hello to higher density cities. Although I imagine it will take quite a while (decades) for these pressures to have a real effect.
- milkytron 10mo agoYeah I imagine it will be many decades. Simply because minimum parking requirements would have to be removed (which is unpopular in a lot of cities), and then redevelopment would need to take place based on demand and investment potential.
- londons_explore 10mo agoI forsee the cost of travel increasing quite a lot. Private cars will end up 2nd class citizens with 'waymo lanes' and sky high insurance costs, pushing everyone to self driving taxi services who have a really high cost per mile compared to your own car, since they have a huge debt to pay back to investors so will never get down to the $0.15 per mile that driving your own old car costs.
- tim-fan 10mo agoOn the other hand, insurance costs for robotaxis should be lower if they are able to drive significantly safer. Then the one I'm more interested / excited for: optimizing the fleet for the cargo. If most trips involve single passengers, then most cars can be small electric single seaters. This can further reduce insurance costs as well as fuel, maintenance and depreciation. I'd hope that's enough to offset the price of the sensors, compute hardware, and engineers to maintain the system. But yes paying back investors; not sure how long that would lead to elevated costs for riders.
- mekdoonggi 10mo agoIf the cars are commodity, wouldn't someone make a ton of money by making a cheaper/better model and undercutting? Seems implausible but then there are examples like deepseek.
- longitudinal93 10mo agoIf only they could be sold in the US https://insideevs.com/news/710364/byd-detroit-import-seagull-caresoft/ https://insideevs.com/news/710364/byd-detroit-import-seagull...
- mekdoonggi 10mo agoI definitely see a future where global transportation is powered by driverless Chinese EVs, except the US, which has driverless cars that are worse and 6x more expensive.
- londons_explore 10mo ago
- andsoitis 10mo agoWaymos are prevalent in LA.
- wiredpancake 10mo ago[dead]
- ProfessorZoom 10mo agoStill can't believe the prices are comparable to Uber, sometimes costing even more. It should be significantly less to the point it drives Uber out of business. Is Waymo close to bankruptcy, unable to be profitable, or are they just greedy?
- haunter 10mo agoThis is like the argument that ebooks should cost less than paper books. Not that I disagree but it's never gonna happen. more money > money
- apelapan 10mo agoThe cars are extremely expensive and they have a 100 billion investment to recoup. I assume they are still losing money on each ride.
- xnx 10mo ago> The cars are extremely expensive Compared to what? Most estimates put costs around $150K/vehicle and dropping.
- deleted 10mo ago[deleted]
- cucumber3732842 10mo agoThe $125k difference between that and a "uber quality" used car buys a lot of labor.
- array_key_first 10mo agoYes, labor can be shockingly cheap, especially if it's gig labor. You need A LOT of labor to outrun the capital investment.
- jaimex2 10mo agoAnd this is why Tesla will steamroll them in time. That and their cars are far more adaptable.
- icyfox 10mo agoWaymo is such an interesting case study. For most other ~AI deployments you have strong public reaction to the proliferation of slop, non-human failure modes, cost cutting at the expense of quality, etc. But I haven't met a single person who doesn't like the experience of Waymo. They ended up cracking the code on what I suspect people really want: - consistent car quality - safety of the drive (conservative driving and potential fear of drivers) - no randomly chatty driver All of those feel like a breath of fresh air especially when stacked up against the current state of Uber & Lyft rides. People really just want consistency. I don't actually think you needed AI to get there (I've had occasional rides in black cars that provided the same experience). Waymo was just right time, right place, right price.
- pjc50 10mo agoThere's a lot of complaints about externalities, especially when a power cut stopped all the vehicles in a city recently.
- icyfox 10mo agoI'm not commenting on the externalities. For that I'd also cite economic impact, job loss, occasional emergency services issues, etc. I'm saying the experience when you yourself are taking a ride. I haven't met a single person who's said "this sucked - I'm going back to Uber".
- seanmcdirmid 10mo agoI think parent was talking about how users of the service were very satisfied with it, not about externalities.
- holler 10mo agoMy first and only Waymo ride was super sketch. Car slowed down to ~5mph in a 35mph zone and stayed that way for 5+ minutes as other cars were swerving around us. Felt like it was going to come to a complete stop in the middle of the road, I prefer real humans.
- x86x87 10mo ago
- amelius 10mo agoThe US would benefit much more from a good railroad system. Everybody can drive a car. They have solved the wrong problem.
- xnx 10mo ago> They have solved the wrong problem. Human drivers kill >30K/year.
- hobofan 10mo agoSo displace human drivers with public transportation?
- xnx 10mo agoPrecisely, Waymo is a form of public transportation.
- triceratops 10mo agoBuses driven by a robot are cheap public transportation.
- mailund 10mo agoI've heard this argument a lot, but is the bus driver really more than a rounding error on the balance sheet of the transportation company? I have no experience in this field, but I would imagine the infrastructure for buying and maintaining a fleet of busses, creating a route network, dealing with ticketing, dealing with disruptions, etc, etc, makes up most of the costs around running a public transport company?
- hobofan 10mo agoI think the benefit to transportation companies would not just be about salaries, but also about predictability in staffing. I've experienced a few times in the past that a strong flu season causes specific bus lines to be serviced with reduced frequency due to staffing shortages. But concretely, regarding the staffing costs, if I roughly read the financial report section correctly, it looks like for the Berlin transport agency, salaries make up half of all expenses[0]! Given that that's such a big portion, I think autonomous buses could likely unlock a lot of mobility in big cities by having more flexibility in creation of additional bus routes (as you don't have to consolidate multiple routes into one because you have to pay drivers for each). [0]: https://www.bvg.de/dam/jcr:67ef63fc-3fd1-4e95-aae6-2ab8c8c2b46c/BVG-Geschaeftsbericht-2023.pdf https://www.bvg.de/dam/jcr:67ef63fc-3fd1-4e95-aae6-2ab8c8c2b...
- tapoxi 10mo agoWhy would I use Waymo if an Uber/Lyft costs the same? If it gets in an accident, who pays my medical bills?
- dfxm12 10mo agoFor the latter question, ask your insurance company. I'd be surprised if they care specifically that waymo was involved. If you don't have insurance, ask a lawyer what your options would be in that situation.
- xnx 10mo ago> Why would I use Waymo if an Uber/Lyft costs the same? Safe, clean, quiet, private, predictable, no tipping, etc.
- spike021 10mo agoClean? I took a waymo in SF a few weeks ago that smelled extremely strongly of cologne or perfume and I almost couldn't breathe. I've also been in one with like hair and stuff on the seats and door. It's not like humans don't still ride in those cars.
- spongebobstoes 10mo agoin a waymo there are fewer parties involved. this should make you feel more confident in getting the bill paid, and knowing who will pay it
- OkayPhysicist 10mo agoThat first question is wild to me. Having to share a space with a questionably vetted stranger is one of the primary downsides to rideshare apps. Privacy and comfort are huge bonuses.
- Jblx2 10mo ago>Privacy Waymo cameras permanently record everything that happens in their vehicles, right?
- nthdesign 10mo agoI was at a conference in Phoenix in November and took seven Waymo trips during my stay. Four of those were fairly long (20-minute) trips. I preferred Waymo to the Uber/Lyft experience because it felt private. It was just me and my colleagues in the car, no strangers. It also felt futuristic and novel, which I'm sure will wear off. We experienced no weird or erratic driving, with one minor exception... Waymo always followed the speed limit. On a major road where the speed limit was 40mph, other cars were zipping around us at 55mph+. And, one parking lot had 5mph speed limit signs posted. As you can imagine, Waymo was the slowest vehicle in that parking lot by a wide margin.
- Thorentis 10mo agoDo they have microphones inside the car? How do you know? That "feeling" of privacy probably encourages people to talk more openly, which if there are microphones inside...
- keiferski 10mo agoI’d say about 30% of the time I take an Uber, I have an interesting conversation with the driver. The best instance of this was about a decade ago, when the driver was a guy from Syria, and he explained the ongoing civil war there and the various factions as we drove 45 minutes across LA. Self-driving cars are just one more way everyone becomes isolated from each other, I guess.
- lern_too_spel 10mo agoAnother 30% of the time, the driver is making calls to the DMV or spouting conspiracy theories during the drive. I enjoy talking to strangers casually when I can easily walk away, but I don't enjoy being forced to talk to strangers casually over a half hour ride.
- josefritzishere 10mo agoDont let your cats outside.
- leoh 10mo agoRIP KitKat :( I work at Alphabet and I think it’s sad that KitKat died