6 ms·
The Gentle Seduction (1989)
- Recursing 11mo agoTitle should have (1989)
- deleted 11mo ago[deleted]
- melling 11mo ago“It'll take at least a hundred years for us to get to Singularity” We’re only 37 years into the story. The woman would only be in her early 60s. With revised estimates, The Singularity is now less than 20 years away.
- solenoid0937 11mo agoI hope you're right but I'm skeptical. ASI in 20 years? Are we even on the right track to AGI, or are LLMs a red herring?
- davedigerati 11mo agoAGI via LLMs: No. The AI will need a natural understanding of the real world (the physics you and I live within) and ability to self-modify it's training (ie learn), so we're working on hybrid AI architectures which may include LLMs, but not rely on them. And imho Yes we are solidly on track to AGI <5 yrs 8)
- mashally 11mo agoI really liked the story; the technology can indeed change our mind gradually and make us accept things we once refused. This actually made me ask: how do we rearrange our ideas based on that?
- GinsengJar 11mo agoThat was an intensely compelling read.
- achille 11mo agoSpoilers: https://areweseductionyet.pages.dev https://areweseductionyet.pages.dev
- Mistletoe 11mo agoExtreme longevity with a none is kind of depressing.
- enneff 11mo agoWhy? Life for an individual is long enough IMO. Death means renewal. Our children are better than us.
- Hammershaft 11mo agoEven besides our selfish impulse to live the 'why' is clear. If death is inherently a bad loss, then the longer life extension takes the worse it is.
- Mistletoe 11mo agoI like being alive and I like myself.
- solenoid0937 11mo agoI've had this bookmarked for years. It is my vision for the future. It is more relevant now than ever, when techno-pessimism is on the rise, and people are forgetting the incredible technology that makes their quality of life real - and could guarantee the lives of billions in the future. I'm in my 30s and probably won't live to see this future. I only hope cryonics can get me there, but I doubt it - so much information is lost.
- crashabr 11mo agoI would recommend re-reading The Ones Who Walk Away from Omelas as a companion story then. Maybe you'll get to underhand techno-pessimism as something more than the the result of people "forgetting the incredible technology that makes their quality of life real".
- bc569a80a344f9c 11mo agohttps://clarkesworldmagazine.com/kim_02_24/ https://clarkesworldmagazine.com/kim_02_24/ Why Don’t We Just Kill The Kid In The Omelas Hole by Isabel Kim. My favorite short story of 2024, and very much worth reading if you’re at all familiar with LeGuin’s original story.
- filoeleven 11mo agoThank you for sharing this! Having just read it now, it's quite short (~5 minute read) and I also recommend it.
- JumpCrisscross 11mo agoI haven’t read any of this work. Where would you start?
- bc569a80a344f9c 11mo agoThey’re both short stories, less than 10 minutes to read. If you’d like to read novel length LeGuin, “The Left Hand Of Darkness” and “The Dispossessed” are excellent. Much of her most lauded work shares a universe, but each novel stands alone and doesn’t share relevant characters, let alone protagonists. Edit: „The Ones Who Walk Away From Omelas“ can be read at https://shsdavisapes.pbworks.com/f/Omelas.pdf https://shsdavisapes.pbworks.com/f/Omelas.pdf
- hosh 11mo agoI ended up skimming a lot of it, though I closely read the beginning and the end. This is not a vision of humanity I agree with. Technology is not the only path towards expansion of consciousness, even though in this day and age, it appears so. The wonders, marvels, and growth described in this story can be experienced through other means. To act and build as if it is the only path is, in my opinion, deeply misguided. Probably not the most popular stance in this crowd.
- solenoid0937 11mo agoReading the beginning and end is like eating just the buns off a burger and declaring it bland and tasteless. Part of the magic of this story is that it can change what you agree with (as it did for me.) Not saying it will do the same for you, but it is a compelling vision; I can't think of other ways to get there without getting unscientific.
- hosh 11mo agoI am familiar with NLP and persuasion techniques, and when I started feeling it creep in as I read this story, I started skimming. I have learned that a compelling vision alone does not mean it is correct or even wise. The analogy is not correct. I know that burger is rich in taste and marvelous. It is also my opinion that it is an illusion, and lacks substance. There is so much more to the cosmos than science, though I get that this is the current preoccupation of our civilization. Maybe one day, people will expand their consciousness beyond science the way the main character expanded her’s to communicate with aliens. Until then, I recognize I am in the minority here in HN with this view.
- GolDDranks 11mo agoWhere in the story does NLP (I guess you mean "Neurolinguistic programming" and not "Natural Language Processing") factor in?
- hosh 11mo ago
- binary132 11mo agoThe shadow image of this story should be explored just as thoroughly and “seductively”: the incremental descent of humanity into abominable serfdom, witless hypnosis, and hedonic escapism from an increasingly hopeless tomorrow. Just because someone paints a nice (or frightening) picture of something doesn’t mean it must be accepted. It can merely be contemplated.
- jadbox 11mo agoI am not an optimist nor a pessimist, but I think it's good to understand proper balance for well-being. If this story was interesting, you may also find Whispering Earring a counterbalance to this story. https://web.archive.org/web/20121008025245/http://squid314.livejournal.com/332946.html https://web.archive.org/web/20121008025245/http://squid314.l...
- Recursing 11mo agoimho https://gwern.net/doc/fiction/science-fiction/1995-egan.pdf https://gwern.net/doc/fiction/science-fiction/1995-egan.pdf from 1995 is an even better exploration of the same theme For more on why I'm skeptical it will end this way, see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Existential_risk_from_artificial_intelligence#History https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Existential_risk_from_artifici... I don't see why machines should keep biological life around, since they'll be much more efficient
- WithinReason 11mo agoEfficient for what? What reason has AI to exist?
- moffkalast 11mo agoWell our purpose is to turn low entropy into high entropy, that's what drove the existence of life. If machines can do it faster then they'll win out eventually.
- tekne 11mo agoIt's interesting: on balance life increases entropy. Yet it also produces pockets of ultra-low entropy; states which would be staggeringly, astronomically unlikely to be witnessed in nature. So perhaps what life does is increase entropy-entropy -- the diversity of entropy, versus a consistent entropic smear -- even as it increases entropy...
- 11mo ago
- FrustratedMonky 11mo agoFound this similar to ending of Parthenon. Show on netflix. The ending does something similar. Worth watching, the last 2-3 episodes really ramp up to 11. Also. "The Last Question" by Isaac Asimov. I really thought there was going to be a 'let there be light' moment at the end.
- aspenmayer 11mo ago> Found this similar to ending of Parthenon. The title is Pantheon, and the show is itself based upon a series of short stories in a shared universe by Ken Liu. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pantheon_(TV_series) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pantheon_(TV_series) https://kenliu.name/blog/book/the-hidden-girl-and-other-stories/ https://kenliu.name/blog/book/the-hidden-girl-and-other-stor...
- FrustratedMonky 11mo agoThank You. I didn't know there was a book. From the blurb it looks like the series incorporated a lot of the short stories. Liked it enough I'll also read the book and compare.
- a022311 11mo agoI read the whole thing and I think it's useful to view this topic under a different lens. The most astonishing part for me is that it was written over 30 years ago! I'm a bit grateful that science today isn't nearly that advanced. It would be cool to be able to explore the world like the main character, but then again it seemed so sad and miserable. I share her sentiment from the beginning of the story: I don't want to be immortal. Living a short, happy life is much better than being miserable forever even though you have everything you could possibly imagine. I think death should be treated as a gift and not something to be afraid of (of course I'm probably too young to say this, but this is how I feel currently). It's another motivation for us to enjoy our lives in a meaningful way and not waste them.
- solenoid0937 11mo agoHaving near-death experiences has made me much more scared of death. I realized I do not want eternal nothingness and nonexistence. I like existing, loving, etc. I do not think death adds any value. It certainly does not motivate me in any way. I don't do things because I will die, I do things because I want to. Most of the time I am not thinking about death at all. When I do, it is only with a sense of sadness/dread. > Living a short, happy life is much better than being miserable forever IMO this is a false dichotomy. You could also live an immortal happy life in this scenario.
- dinkleberg 11mo agoWhen people talk of life extension and us eventually achieving immortality, it is always "relative immortality" though. Maybe we develop the technology to regenerate our bodies and we could live for thousands of years. Maybe we can transfer our consciousness and minds into computers and maybe live for quite a bit longer than that. But the time scale of the universe is unfathomable. Even if we lived for millions of years, it would be a drop in the bucket. And that time would still come to an end and we'd reach that same state of eternal nothingness and nonexistence.
- PaulHoule 11mo agoI think "seduction" as in Baudrillard https://monoskop.org/images/9/96/Baudrillard_Jean_Seduction.pdf https://monoskop.org/images/9/96/Baudrillard_Jean_Seduction.... which has a great intro about how "the more liberated people think they are talking about sex the less liberated they are" and towards the end anticipates the arc that video games will follow back when Pong and Space Invaders were state of the art. Funny enough when I got obsessed with seduction as a topic in 2021 and read that book as part of my curriculum I went down a side track in theme park design.
- unionjack22 11mo agoComments like these, aside from the brilliant technical answers and dives, really highlight the value of HN. What a lovely Sunday read I shall have—I’ve been getting distracted by the phone and world news. Reading Baudillard and Debord should help reestablish what’s noise and what isn’t. Thank you.
- robocat 11mo ago> Baudrillard Certainly it has some extremely unmodern statements... The masculine, by contrast, possesses unfailing powers of discrimination and absolute criteria for pronouncing the truth. The masculine is certain, the feminine is insoluble. [snip] just as there is no other femininity than that of appearances. Reads like bullshit to me - but I'm an engineer type with no skills in humanities or French.
- Xophmeister 11mo agoA chilling vision of the future, where phone books and checkbooks still exist ;) I have the impression that nanotechnology was very in vogue for science fiction around the late-80s and early-90s…and yet, these days, it’s seemingly disappeared; both as a sci-fi trope and, AFAIK, an area of industrial/medical R&D. Why is that? Did it just atrophy, perhaps combined with unmet expectations, or did we discover some limit that makes the technology infeasible?
- gcanyon 11mo ago<spoiler> I really enjoyed the story (pretty sure I've read it before, but many years ago, so it's fuzzy) and I know it's not key to the plot, but I really want to know how Jack failed to survive.
- GolDDranks 11mo agoIt is implied in the beginning: he expects to die before the singularity because of a tendency of heart problems in their family.
- gcanyon 11mo agoHA -- I recognized that I had read the story many years before, and didn't even notice that led me to skimming some at the start.
- Isamu 11mo agoThat’s interesting, they use the Singularity to refer to technological explosion in general rather than specifically AI becoming super intelligent. This seems to predate the AI usage. >"Singularity is a time in the future. It'll occur when the rate of change of technology is very great--so great that the effort to keep up with the change will overwhelm us. People will face a whole new set of problems that we can't even imagine." A look of great tranquility smoothed the ridges around his eyes. "On the other hand, all our normal, day to day problems fade away. For example, you'll be immortal."
- layer8 11mo agoThe first recorded use seems to be by Stan Ulam in 1958, who was paraphrasing John von Neumann: https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/19940022856/downloads/19940022856.pdf https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/19940022856/downloads/19... “One conversation centered on the ever accelerating progress of technology and changes in the mode of human life, which gives the appearance of approaching some essential singularity in the history of the race beyond which human affairs, as we know them, could not continue.”
- ahazred8ta 11mo agoIn the early 20th century, philosopher Pierre Teilhard De Chardin proposed that we are mentally evolving toward something transhuman and divine, but he didn't spell out a rapid transition. So the concept was sort of there, but von Neumann put it in a technological context.
- Sharlin 11mo agoYudkowsky has argued that there are three major "schools" of technological singularity: https://www.yudkowsky.net/singularity/schools https://www.yudkowsky.net/singularity/schools
- jarbus 11mo agoDidn’t realize we could post short stories on here. This one was really nice :) I wrote a similar sci fi short story set in the near future if anyone is interested: https://jarbus.net/blog/growth-and-decay/ https://jarbus.net/blog/growth-and-decay/
- dahart 11mo agoI wonder if Ray Kurzweil was inspired by this story, or if there was some other futurist who inspired them both. I had a sort of déjà vu reading this, having been at Kurzweil’s Siggraph keynote in 2000. He was predicting this very scenario - the singularity would bring nanobots that make humans immortal. His talk made an impression on my young mind. It wasn’t until later that I realized Kurzweil was just peddling the fountain of youth, and was somewhat unscrupulous about it… He has been pitching the idea that human longevity is accelerating. For example, scroll to the very bottom of this essay and check out the plot: https://www.writingsbyraykurzweil.com/the-law-of-accelerating-returns https://www.writingsbyraykurzweil.com/the-law-of-acceleratin... Looks plausible for a minute, but when you start to think about it, you realize he has conflated longevity with average lifespan, and that it cannot possibly be a mistake, he’s not that ignorant or careless. The plot is missing data points that were easily available when it was made, data points that would completely contradict the trend line he put in the graph. Turns out human longevity hasn’t really budged for ten thousand years, but average lifespan has changed a lot, due to infant mortality and sanitation and vaccines and lower infant mortality and less war and more science. I think a lot of the graphics in that article are equally sketchy when you look a little closer, and a lot of his predictions from 2000 are already orders of magnitude off, so I have no trust in anything Kurzweil writes or predicts. But given the state of the earth today, maybe it’s a good thing that significant longevity or immortality isn’t just around the corner? It’s a fun thought experiment and a nice story though.
- Magi604 11mo agoWhat a though-provoking story to read with my coffee. I've often had the thought that I will probably just miss the singularity due to my age, but people like my nephews will have a greater chance at experiencing it.
- littlestymaar 11mo agoThis is quite dystopian to say the least, and what's even more dystopian is that there are powerful people who feel like this is a goal somehow…
- drillsteps5 11mo agoWhat a wonderful way to start my Sunday, to distract from the antics of the rich and powerful, and to pay attention to things that matter. I found it curious that a novel published in 1989 refers to the future immortal being going through crude pre-singularity historical records and comparing them to cobweb ("An analogy to cobwebs made her smile for a moment."). I thought Berners-Lee wouldn't launch his first "World Wide Web server" for another 2 years, no?
- korse 11mo agoWhat is really interesting is how many times this story has been posted previously without getting any traction? Why is this time different? The poster, current geopolitical/technical climate or...