3 ms·
Private equity firms are snapping up mobile home parks, driving out residents
- nocoiner 1y agoAlthough it’s mentioned in the article, I’m surprised that the author didn’t place more emphasis on the different set of state laws that typically apply to mobile homes given their status as (theoretically) moveable property. The relative ease of eviction compared to real property (houses, condos, things without wheels) is probably the primary factor for the private equity investment thesis. It’s a material driver of the economics of these investments and substantially reduces the risk profile of the generally marginal tenant base.
- seg_lol 1y agoAnyone who has been under a mobile home will know that they pretty much only move once in their life.
- paleotrope 1y agoThis. Once they are on a property they aren't going anywhere until they get torn down and replaced. Mobile, they are, once.
- jauntywundrkind 1y agoNothing in America is left un-exploited. Incredibly tragic to see yet another sizable contingent of Americans, often particularly vulnerable ones, squeezed by capital. What foes. Private equity is such a vicious foe to mankind. Hostis humani generis: this profit motive corrupts our world, erodes at humanity, in every way it can. Just once, I'd like to see amalgamated capital try to improve the lot of the world, help humanity along. But no, never: always the swirling draining negative to suck life from the world.
- anonym29 1y ago[flagged]
- tmnvix 1y agoI was thinking about war-profiteering and the private companies that lobby for endless wars lately (think Du Pont, Rockeller, Halliburton, etc). It causes untold damage to humanity. It occurred to me that this sort of thing is absent in the Chinese economy as far as I'm aware. Yay capitalism?
- ahmeneeroe-v2 1y agoEndless wars pre-date capitalism. Western defense companies are hardly capitalistic. They are as "planned economy" as it gets. China is wildly capitalistic in many aspects. Maybe Chinese companies don't lobby for war because they are so bad at war that they can't see a route to profitability?
- bdangubic 1y agopretty cool to assume that china must be “bad at war” vs. thinking that you can be a lot more profitable in peace :)
- fc417fc802 1y agoIt's a valid question. Presumably a given company will do what is most profitable for it whether that's lobbying for peace or war. It's worthwhile to try to understand what the differences in either circumstances or policy might be that led to an alternate outcome.
- ahmeneeroe-v2 1y agoBad reading comprehension.
- legitster 1y ago> Private equity is such a vicious foe to mankind. The boogeyman we have made out of private equity is pretty silly. It's not like being purchased by a publicly traded corporation is that much different, or even just a private buyer.
- netsharc 1y agoJohn Oliver, 6 years ago: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jCC8fPQOaxU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jCC8fPQOaxU I guess PE firms have realized that putting humans into debt that they have to work endlessly to repay is very profitable.
- jameslk 1y agoHousing as an investment vehicle is ultimately the problem. Those who buy into it expect prices to keep going up, like any good investment. If rising prices falter, there’s big rippling consequences, especially for those whose net worth is mostly their house value, bought with debt. On the other side is those who need shelter, who don’t have unlimited income to afford the price of something that rises faster than they earn. It doesn’t seem like a sustainable system.
- socalgal2 1y ago> housing as an investment vehicle is ultimately the problem. No, lack of supply is the problem. If there wasn't a lack of supply then housing wouldn't be an investment vehicle. Nimbys and over regulation has made it impossible to build which creates the lack of supply which is what drives the price up and makes the incentive to invest.
- holoduke 1y agoThere will be always lack of supply of housing. Its such an essential thing that it never becomes unused or unwanted. The combination of bad regulations where banks can give extremely high loans is the biggest issue. I would not be surprised if mortgages of 60 years will be possible where your total down payment is 4 times the actually price of the house.
- fc417fc802 1y agoNot true. As an overly simple thought experiment consider what happens to the market if a government were to dictate the construction of two units of housing per capita. The issue is lack of supply. That is enforced by zoning, which is ultimately dictated by politicians, who know they won't get reelected if they make policy changes that gut a significant portion of their constituents' savings. It's a fairly straightforward example of systemic dysfunction with no obvious solution.
- socalgal2 1y agoPlenty of places in the world with an oversupply. Lots of examples in China China (like the USA) didn't let the market handle it. China built without letting market demand dictate supply. USA did the opposite, didn't builders meet supply. They try, they try all the time to built more, they get stopped by nimbys and over regulation.
- k310 1y agoMobile home parks are predatory. Unlike a traditional home, "owners" own only the home and pay an exorbitant land rent each month. So, unlike a traditional home where the land appreciates and you maintain the home, you get in effect, the worst of both worlds. You get zero land equity for rents approaching mortgages (YMMV. They are very high in desirable CA locations.), and still pay to maintain the home. Of course, private equity firms love the idea. Price-fixing among park owners happens. [1] Some comments [2] Pro's and Cons[0] I live in a double-wide manufactured home in the country, and own the land, quite a bit of it (sharpens chain saw ) Spare you the details. [0] https://www.luxwisp.com/pros-and-cons-of-land-lease-communities/ https://www.luxwisp.com/pros-and-cons-of-land-lease-communit... [1] https://www.classaction.org/news/class-action-alleges-mobile-home-community-cos.-conspired-to-raise-lot-rental-prices https://www.classaction.org/news/class-action-alleges-mobile... [2] https://www.reddit.com/r/povertyfinance/comments/s0jh8a/whats_the_catch_with_mobile_manufactured_homes/ https://www.reddit.com/r/povertyfinance/comments/s0jh8a/what...
- codeddesign 1y agoHow is this different than owning a house or a condo? A house you still pay property tax on the land. A condo you still pay an association fee. Both of which generally go up continually every year. This is also not a surprise that they don’t own the land. At any time they can move their mobile home, unlike a house or condo. They fully know what they signed up for.
- k310 1y agoI pay about $2000 a year for property tax (It's in the boondocks). That's it. A land rent may be a big chunk of that every month. It varies a lot, so run the numbers. A Condo owner owns the land and pays property tax and HOA fees, which can be steep, so there's land appreciation. Why pay so much every month to get zero land equity and zero home maintenance? Run some numbers. I did sometime back. And don't forget, these are microscopic lots. Barely room for a couple of storage shelves under a car awning. The references say that the mobile homes depreciate, so they're not even worth moving, and landlords charge anyway. I linked to very short ones that bring up key issues.
- 1y ago
- legitster 1y agoIt's hard for me to rag on the opportunists when the opportunity is there. PE firms don't magically make something profitable - they're just scooping up underpriced/undervalued assets and extracting the value off of them. That said, the extent that PE firms are willing to scrape the bottom of the barrel for things to make a buck off of is becoming shameless. My dad ran a mobile home park for a while, and let me tell you - the idea that it's some sort of sustainable investment vehicle even at maximum extraction is ludicrous. It's just further evidence that the markets are flush with more capital than they know what to do with. We have a massive savings glut due in no small part to inequality and our aging population. And failure to deal with it at a policy level will just continue to grow the affordability crisis.
- YouAreMammon 1y ago[flagged]
- jmclnx 1y ago20 years ago In my area, a an owner of a mobile home part wanted to kick everyone out, sell the land do developers. The land is worth a lot due to its location very near a "tier 1 city". The residents contacted the AG and the AG and State forced the owner to sell to the residents. Which happened. When I drive by that park now, even now it looks 100x better then it did before they bought it. Hopefully the same happens to these parks.
- kylehotchkiss 1y agoThat's an incredible outcome. I don't think it'd be an option for every park in the country (tier one indicates they probably were better off financially).
- thankyoufriend 1y agoWashington State Housing Finance Committee has worked with residents to help them buy the land and turn it into a housing co-op, in partnership with ROC Northwest. That company also helps private businesses convert to worker-owned businesses. If we really love democracy as much as we claim here in the USA, let's bring it to where we live and work :)
- kylehotchkiss 1y agoThis article praises mobile housing too much. For a lot of people, this is substandard living conditions. Yes, there are nicer parks, but that’s not the norm across the country. In my opinion, states should convert the zoning for all mobile home parks to multifamily (apartment complexes), and require developers to give each of the residents their own paid for unit. Then the land is more productive and the previous owners are upgraded to a higher quality living experience. (I live in southern CA and many parks are located on land that would be very very well suited for large apartment complexes)
- zrn900 1y agoAnother case of "Capitalism bettering the lives of everyone"...