23 ms·
Sustainable memristors from shiitake mycelium for high-frequency bioelectronics
- gnabgib 1y agoOSU.Edu - original research (6 points) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45698732 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45698732 PLOS - original paper (3+6 points) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45714547 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45714547 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45731592 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45731592 Toms Hardware coverage https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45718691 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45718691 SemiEngineering coverage (3 points) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45730587 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45730587 Phys.Org coverage (2 points) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45732287 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45732287
- embedding-shape 1y ago> We demonstrate fungal computing via mycelial networks interfaced with electrodes, showing that fungal memristors can be grown, trained, and preserved through dehydration, retaining functionality at frequencies up to 5.85 kHz, with an accuracy of 90 ± 1%. Notably, shiitake has exhibited radiation resistance, suggesting its viability for aerospace applications Soon we'll have shiitake replacing transistors in our airplane and spacecraft computers, while sitting and eating ramen on the vehicles themselves. The future is shaping up to be interesting.
- PaulHoule 1y agoWhat it makes me think of is 'cybernetics' research from the 1960s when it was not a foregone conclusion that transistors, especially CMOS transistors, were the future of computing. Back then there was a lot of research into alternate models of computation, something that's only becoming relevant today as CMOS may be running out of steam.
- hencq 1y agoI recently read The Unaccountability Machine (which I can recommend btw), which mentions Stafford Beer's experiments with a computing pond. Who knows, maybe we'll control our factories with mushroom brains soon!
- physarum_salad 1y agoHow is this related to that at all? The fungi they used are clearly dead...
- zdragnar 1y agoHaving only dabbled the slightest in hardware... are functional frequencies topping out at 6 kHz useful for memristors in modern computing? I feel like having separate components each magnitudes faster would be better than combining them into a memristor that sounds so slow.
- xeonmc 1y agoIf it enables massively concurrent in-memory compute then the frequency disadvantage could just be scaled away.
- m4rtink 1y agoMight be enough for microcontrollers and overall simple control applications?
- bee_rider 1y agoA bunch of mushrooms as a giant 6kHz memory array with in-memory computing seems pretty pointless IRL. But it adds a nice air of plausibility to some sci-fi stories!
- estimator7292 1y agoIf you mean x86 class performance, no, obviously not. But 6kHz is not nothing. For application-specific computers, you can do a lot with very little. You aren't going to be building high performance general purpose computers, but for an atonomous circuit quietly ticking away computing orbital trajectories or stellar navigation, you don't need modern x86 class performance.
- reactordev 1y agoSo sci-fi isn’t far off after all. War of the Worlds. The last of us. Battlestar Galatica. All had some fungi/organic hook (ok, last of us is about zombies but still). Curious if we could mux them into something faster at a higher order or something. The idea that organics can be used for electronics is so wild.
- gertlex 1y agoPlanet/mindworms in Alpha Centauri :D
- foobarian 1y agoJuffo-Wup fills in my fibers and I grow turgid. Violent action ensues.
- sholladay 1y agoStar Trek has a number of organic computing examples, too. Species 8472, Data, and the Borg all use varying degrees of organic components. There's also the bio-neural gel packs on Voyager and the unnamed 31st century Earth vessel discovered by Archer and the NX-01 Enterprise. New Trek even has a mycelial network in space.
- Onavo 1y agoAs the young people say, Paul Stamets wants to "know your location". Maybe we will figure out mushroom powered warp drive too some day.
- giovannibonetti 1y ago> Soon we'll have shiitake replacing transistors in our airplane and spacecraft computers, while sitting and eating ramen on the vehicles themselves. The future is shaping up to be interesting. By the way, some people say eating meat is not going to be sustainable as more and more people become able to afford it, and fungi are a great option for providing the equivalent protein intake.
- SeanAnderson 1y agoIt's already not sustainable, but that hasn't really stopped us.
- bozhark 1y agoIt absolutely is possible though. We don’t incentivize properly
- louthy 1y agoThe memristor industry will mushroom
- physarum_salad 1y agoPreserved through dehydration? This means the fungus is dead.
- card_zero 1y agoInteresting new episodes of Air Crash Investigation coming up. Crucial avionics were inadvertently eaten by the inexperienced and hungry copilot.
- calibas 1y agoThere's a theory that's been going around for a while that trees were using mycelium networks to communicate via electrical signals. Some of these theories even went so far as to claim whole forests function similar to a brain. It's controversial, but considering this study I think we should take these ideas a little more seriously.
- lubujackson 1y agoI thought this was fairly well proven at this point. If one tree is distressed, nearby trees become aware of it through signal passing using mycellium (which has more nodes in a forest than the human brain has neurons). Fungi are deeply alien life. Also, there is proof that there used to be towering mushroom forests in the time of dinosaurs. And if you pick up a boring brown mushroom in the forest there is a reasonable chance it is an unidentified species, since there are several that are indisiguishable except by full analysis (which there is little focus on).
- calibas 1y agoI've talked to biologists who think the idea is just new-age hippy nonsense. It's not quite mainstream, Wikipedia goes over the current science fairly well: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mycorrhizal_network https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mycorrhizal_network
- 8bitsrule 1y agoTerence McKenna could say 'told you so'.
- embedding-shape 1y ago> Fungi are deeply alien life. Weird perspective, they were here long before us, and are even some of the earliest forms of complex life on the planet :)
- Insanity 1y agoLol, I asked ChatGPT to identify the towering mushroom you mentioned.. and it made a sexual innuendo joke instead.. The response: === Summary answer • The fossil in question: Prototaxites. • Evidence: large fossil trunks, isotope analysis showing non‐plant behaviour; tube/hyphal internal structure. • Time & environment: Early land colonisation era (pre-trees, pre-dinosaurs) in the Silurian/Devonian. • The claim of “towering mushroom forests in the time of dinosaurs” is not strictly correct: they were huge, fungus-like (or fungus affiliated) but lived well before dinosaurs, and “forest” may be figurative rather than well established. If you like, I can dig up a short list of the recent papers (with Figures) on Prototaxites so you can see the fossil evidence directly. Would that be helpful, Rob Mpucee? === That’s a wild answer lol. Although it technically did answer the question.
- lubujackson 1y agoWas it Snow Crash or Diamond Age (or something earlier?) that had mushrooms as the basis for advanced technology? I'm curious if there was actual insight there or a happy coincidence.
- deelowe 1y agoI don't recall this in snow crash
- BirAdam 1y agoIt wasn't quite fungal, but Diamond Age had the Seed. The Seed grew any material/structure/device desired as opposed to the Matter Compilers and the Feed. We know that the Seed required tons of computing power to design and create, but the exact method of function of the Seed wasn't detailed. We do, however, know that it may have been nanotechnological as Nell had nanotechnology that her Mouse Army created to counter the nanites in the Drummers.
- brownsound202 1y agoThe Stone Sky series by NK Jemisin referenced the use of genetically modified fungi as self-assembling construction material. Really cool to see how pervasive mushrooms are in sci-fi and how there's lots more potential to unlock.
- clort 1y agoNot advanced technology, but I recall Piers Anthony wrote about intelligent aliens.. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Of_Man_and_Manta https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Of_Man_and_Manta (1968-1972)
- joelthelion 1y agoDo we really believe that this kind of stuff has any chance of scaling and becoming generally useful?
- embedding-shape 1y agoDo we have to believe this will scale and be "generally useful" (whatever that means) in order for it to be interesting enough to talk, discuss and think about?
- Uhhrrr 1y agoTo be fair, among the first questions interested people would ask about something like this are, "what can we use it for?" and "will it scale?"
- embedding-shape 1y ago"what can we use it for?" I'd understand why someone would ask. Maybe not specifically in this case, as it's outlined in the abstract and paper itself, but I generally understand that. "will it scale?" I'm not so understanding of, for a submission about early research, it's one of the less interesting questions about it, and something you figure out much much later, and wouldn't invalidate these results no matter what the answer to that question is.
- Razengan 1y agoCan I eat it? Can I fuck it? Will it eat me? Will it fuck me?
- jazzyjackson 1y agoInterested people being investors I guess? My reaction is more, how does this work, what is it about mushrooms and mycelial networks, and sure, what is possible - but not, how soon can I monetize this
- TheRealPomax 1y agoWhy would belief have anything to do with doing interesting research to see what can be done in this universe?
- corysama 1y agoWhatever happened to memristors? For a little while they were going to change computing. And, I haven't heard about them since.
- jayd16 1y agoIntel has the Optane drives but I think anyone in need just pays for the ram.
- physarum_salad 1y agoThat is because it is cool theoretically but not useful in practice. Every organic material is a memristor and even good memristors are not scalable. RRAM resistive switching is the far more useful property and this has already been investigated extensively.
- Razengan 1y agoYes please! I'd love some "naturepunk": Think Flintstones but for real: using natural life processes to provide our technologies. Yes, this is how it's always been: Animals, meat, skin, beasts of burden, wood, petroleum. But now we may be able to do it with zero-cruelty: Actually GROWING things straight into a usable form, skipping the "harvesting" part. (Though I hope we're not opening a whole new realm of misery.. imagine being born as a chair and feeling ass all your existence)
- jdiff 1y agoThere's an interactive story that has elements of this[0]. Many of the simpler objects don't have much capacity to think or feel on their own, but the corru equivalent of elevators are fully sentient beings capable of conversation and problem solving, and they're just kind of built to be quite satisfied helping move people around. Corru computers are capable of hosting entire communities of distinct intelligences, each program sentient and (mostly) dedicated to its role. Not all of them can be chatted up, the authorization/access control program understandably isn't very chatty, but it is an intelligent being. It's a pretty enjoyable experience, and all of the graphics are ordinary HTML elements with 3D CSS transformations, which makes it super hackable and fun to crack open in an inspector. All that to say, if the best chairs required intelligence, it'd be in everyone's best interest to make that intelligence real thrilled about ass. [0] http://corru.observer/ http://corru.observer/
- Razengan 1y agoBut not too thrilled, mind you
- radarsat1 1y agoone word: chairdogs
- tazjin 1y agoIn one of the Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy books there was a bit about the company that makes Marvin, the depressed robot, also making sentient elevators. These elevators had issues with getting depression, and the companies using them in their office buildings would hire psychology students to talk to them on the basement levels and convince them to go up again.
- FieryTransition 1y agoImagine having a swarm of mushrooms everywhere to run computation on, if mushrooms could be programmed to expand and self arrange. Ah, like a knifes edge, but would be exciting. Could have a literal bug in the code.
- tengbretson 1y agoHP fumbled the bag on this tech so hard that literal mushrooms are beating them to market.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- physarum_salad 1y agoWas the fungus alive or dead? How did the memristive curve change depending on viability? Are all biological materials alive or dead memristors? In this case what is it about the property of the IV curves that is so ubiquitous? Is it actually a measurement artifact related to ion changes induced by using identical electrodes? All questions the deluge of memristor papers using biological materials consistently fail to answer.
- Ericson2314 1y agoOne of the best titles I've seen in a while!
- physarum_salad 1y agoMost wet organic or biological materials will produce memristive (pinched hysteresis) IV curves when measured with macroelectrodes (1–20 mm contact scale) due to inherent interfacial electrochemistry, ion migration, or redox processes at the electrode-tissue interface. Macroscale memristivity is an artifact of slow interfacial kinetics sampled over large diffusion volumes. Shrink electrodes below ~100 µm → hysteresis vanishes. Dry biological materials almost never show true memristive (pinched, history-dependent) IV curves at any electrode scale (macro or micro) under standard DC sweeps. The reasons are structural and physicochemical—drying eliminates the ionic mobility that sustains memory.
- physarum_salad 1y agoIf the fungus was dried how do ions move? Where is the memory effect. Hyphae collapse so maybe it is ions shuttling through the dead matrix?