6 ms·
It's fun to speculate on what will happen when driverless cars become mainstream. Essentially, the question boils down to: "What would happen if every car owner
by olalonde 14y ago
It's fun to speculate on what will happen when driverless cars become mainstream. Essentially, the question boils down to: "What would happen if every car owner in the world suddenly had a 24/7 personal driver?"
- 7 year old kids can now own and "drive" a car.
- Need a lift? Ask your dad/friend to send his car to pick you up.
- Forgot your laptop at home? Send your car back and ask your flatmate to put your laptop in the car.
- Leaving New York for some vacations in Miami? Take the plane and pick up your car whenever it arrives.
- Want to take a nap? Pull down the windows and windshield curtains.
- Traveling abroad for a few weeks and don't know what to do with your car? Set it to taxi mode and profit.
- tobyjsullivan 14y agoAssuming 6315 waking hours per year and 540 hours a year spent in a car, I would say a 9% increase in productivity for the average American. Numbers from: http://answers.google.com/answers/threadview?id=392456 http://answers.google.com/answers/threadview?id=392456 http://hypertextbook.com/facts/2002/PatrickLi.shtml http://hypertextbook.com/facts/2002/PatrickLi.shtml
- modernshoggoth 14y agoAverages are nice, but I'll be interested to see what happens to the workforce that depends upon them entirely, as mentioned above: truckies, taxis, FedEx, etc. I say, leave it for a year to lull the companies into a false sense of security, then tax the hell out of companies using them for a few years to pay for some re-education for the old employees.
- tetomb 14y agoWhy on earth should the responsibility (of those that will become redundant) fall on the early adopters of a new technology? If I had become a fax machine expert would it be fair to charge a tax on those that began to use email to support me? People should take responsibility for themselves and their own actions.
- BinaryAcid 14y agoYou should be used to this kind of talk by now. It's the modus operandi of socialism and the Democratic party. Who ever heard of personal responsibility?
- toomuchtodo 14y agoLet them eat cake?
- Jach 14y agoLet them bear the consequences (unforeseen or not) of their decisions.
- toomuchtodo 14y agoHow dare that person get cancer, become unemployed because of unforseen shifts in the job market, etc. Social safety nets exist for a reason. You may opt out by moving somewhere else if you would prefer not to participate in a society with said safety nets. I say this as someone in a $200K/year+ household. People who preach personal responsibility are oblivious to the realities of the world.
- tetomb 14y agoWell every one knows that becoming severely ill is a possibility for anyone, that's what insurance is for. Can't afford insurance? Give up unhealthy habits to lower your rates, get a better job, look after family so that they will support you if you need help. Get made redundant due to unforeseen shifts in the job market? Educate yourself, get a better job, work harder. Innovate, invent, think, mow your neighbors lawns. Use your brain and don't embark on a dead end career. I agree that some social safety nets are needed for a civilized society (No one that is ill should go without out treatment if they don't have any money etc) but at the same time there are limits and I think paying for people who lose their jobs because of new technology is way past that line. We need to encourage people to be smarter, not dumber. "People who preach personal responsibility are oblivious to the realities of the world." I live in South Africa and government handouts do nothing but keep the poor oppressed and uneducated. They are used as a tool for control by populist politicians. People will have more children just for another R250/month from the government instead of creating value. Socialism is a huge threat to everyone everywhere. It keeps the populous dumb and gives governments way too much power. Please don't preach about the realities of the world from your $200K/year+ household pedestal. Socialism is obviously working out great for you.
- DannoHung 14y ago> - Leaving New York for some vacations in Miami? Take the plane and pick up your car whenever it arrives. Alternatively, in say 20 years or so, going to Miami which would take 21 hours (at 65-70 mph), could probably be done on an overnight sleeper-car (at probably something more like 120-130mph). Even a cross country trip would only take a day or so at such a rate, and with a few strategically placed stops, you could have a nice week long cross country trip at a fraction of the normal cost. Here's a few negative thoughts though: These driverless cars might significantly increase road usage and wear since driving becomes less of a burden. Suburban sprawl could grow out of control since it's no longer necessary to either have public transit options or be attentive to have a long commute. Some people might even choose to buy automated RVs instead of homes, decreasing a sense of community and investment in place.
- Retric 14y agoFully automated cars let's you have all sorts of crazy solutions in the 200+ year time-span. Think 100% electric high speed trains that let cars 'board' at highway speeds. Evacuated underground tunnels for low drag long distance high speed trips. Hybrid Maglev cars that rocket down the highway on a cushion of air while being inductively charged. Even things as simple as highways without road signs of any kind.
- aptwebapps 14y ago"Evacuated underground tunnels for low drag long distance high speed trips." That's interesting because while I've heard of and thought about the concept of a vacuum tube train that could go ridiculously fast, I didn't think of a merely low-pressure tunnel that ordinary cars (with pressurized compartments, anyway) could use in flexible manner. You wouldn't go 15,000 mph, but you could do several hundred pretty easily.
- hammock 14y ago> Alternatively, in say 20 years or so, going to Miami which would take 21 hours (at 65-70 mph), could probably be done on an overnight sleeper-car (at probably something more like 120-130mph). Believe it or not we already have this. It's an Amtrak train between DC and central Florida. You are a passenger aboard the train but your car comes with you! http://www.amtrak.com/auto-train http://www.amtrak.com/auto-train
- daenz 14y ago> Traveling abroad for a few weeks and don't know what to do with your car? Set it to taxi mode and profit. CarBnB
- aptwebapps 14y agohttps://www.whipcar.com https://www.whipcar.com https://relayrides.com/list-your-car https://relayrides.com/list-your-car There may be others, not sure.
- recursive 14y ago> Leaving New York for some vacations in Miami? Take the plane and pick up your car whenever it arrives my car? Like I own the car? Why would you own a car? Who takes care of the maintenance? Just kidding. But seriously, if self-driving cars were a thing, I can think of very few reasons why any normal people would own cars.
- bps4484 14y agoI agree, it could definitely be a situation where owning a car is like owning a plane. Sure, some people do it as hobbyists, but why would you when there are extremely efficient (computer operated) and inexpensive (no taxi driver, 100% uptime except for filling up/charging) taxi services that can take you around. Especially as more people use them (thus reducing wait times) I could see taxis being usable/profitable even in the suburbs.
- seanmcdirmid 14y agoYes, exactly! If the cars could drive themselves, they would probably be more like taxis without the drivers. We no longer need parking lots because the cars are constantly in use, that will free up a lot of space and mirror what already happens in dense urban areas (which depend on taxis, public transit, parking is very $$$). The cars will wear out in a couple of years from constant use (or maybe not if electric?), but we won't need as many of them. Rush hour commutes are a problem, but road capacity is limited anyways and peak pricing + mass transit + car pooling can lead to a workable solution. Eventually, since all cars are automated, safe highway speeds could be increased dramatically (reduce space between cars, more predictability, reroute and reduce speeds to prevent full stop bottlenecks). Accordingly, you won't even be able to enter the highway in manual mode.
- waterlesscloud 14y agoI wonder, since cars also have a large social signalling aspect, at least in many societies. I guess that can still be maintained, with various levels of luxury in taxis/rentals/however it works. But then where will all that social signalling money go? I guess since it's mostly financed money anyway, that capital will have to seek other venues? Will consumer debt drop due to this? Or will something else pick up the slack?
- mahyarm 14y agoI think eventually, car ownership will go down significantly, since companies managing fleets of electric cars can do it far more efficiently than private ownership of long range cars. Uber is faster than walking to the car you parked half a mile away. There's always 'free parking' for your large house party in the city. You can also create small cargo only cars for small deliveries like that laptop situation. It's far more efficient from an energy/vehicle cost/liability stand point. Amazon prime 'local' might just replace stores from a pure efficiency standpoint. The number of total cars neccesary will decrease and the large amount of real estate devoted to cars will decrease significantly. Car maintenance costs will decrease with predictable schedules, and economies of scale that come with fleets.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- nradov 14y agoCar sharing only works well for urbanites without children living with them. The rest of us keep a lot of stuff in our cars: strollers, child seats, spare clothes, shopping bags, diapers, pens, ski racks, toys, first-aid kits, etc. Even with computer driven cars I'll still be willing to pay a lot to avoid the hassle of loading and unloading every day.
- aptwebapps 14y agoWhat if you kept all your car stuff in some sort of modular compartments that could be easily loaded and unloaded? At the moment there isn't much incentive to do so, but that might change with this scenario. What I'm getting at is while your argument seems sound, and may in fact prevail, when you change one piece of the puzzle sometimes other solutions become possible.
- anamax 14y ago> What if you kept all your car stuff in some sort of modular compartments that could be easily loaded and unloaded? Where am I going to put these containers when I don't have a rental car? Lugging them back and forth to the house is not a practical option.
- DigitalJack 14y ago7 year old kids can now own a guided missile. 7 year old kids can be kidnapped in hacked vehicles. Statewide gridlock due to DDOS. Just looking at the flip side.
- bicknergseng 14y agoThink about those for a minute. I rather doubt a self driving car in the hands of a 7 year old could possibly be more dangerous than a manual car in the hands of a 7 year old. It's fairly trivial to keep kids from using an iPhone inappropriately. A simple password would easily stop it, or we can keep using physical keys. 7 year old kids can be kidnapped in non hacked vehicles. It's considerably easier to track down a stolen car from 2012 with OnStar than one from 1992 without. Relavant HN article from today: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-19660765 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-19660765. I don't see why DDOS would be the attack of choice for vehicles, but say it were to happen. DDOS attacks happen. They can be defended against (see http://blog.cloudflare.com/65gbps-ddos-no-problem http://blog.cloudflare.com/65gbps-ddos-no-problem). For the foreseeable future cars will have manual overrides, and I can't see any attack or series of attacks, no matter how horrifying, resulting in 32,885 deaths over the course of a year. Certainly there are many scenarios and details to consider, but the typical objections seem to be red herrings, strawmen, or just totally bogus.
- mseebach2 14y ago> Statewide gridlock due to DDOS. Modern cars are 100% dependent on computers, yet this doesn't happen. Why would it begin happening in the future? Note that the Google car is designed to be autonomous, it has no dependencies on external systems - there is nothing to DDOS. Yes, you can blind/obstruct it's sensors in a variety of ways, but it's much easier to just aim a laserpointer to a driver's eyes today.
- hnriot 14y ago"Traveling abroad for a few weeks and don't know what to do with your car? Set it to taxi mode and profit." - come back to a completely trashed car that you just paid $50k for.
- repsilat 14y agoWe have insurance for that. And I imagine people's emotional investment in their cars will be less when they don't drive them themselves.