13 ms·
NoPassword
- aleprok 14y agoThis is dumb idea and requires that you open your email to login to a site that you want to use. Faster is just typing your username and password and pressing the login button. Anyway browsers make this even faster by storing the username and password.
- roymabookie 14y agoAlso you are kind of putting all your eggs in one basket...
- aleprok 14y agoSorry, but I do not see anything bad at saying "this is dumb idea" different would have been if I had said "This is fucking stupid idea". Anyway my negative points kinda were earned. :(
- JoachimSchipper 14y agoI do not necessarily disagree with you that I'd prefer a username/password, but please be nicer than "this is a dumb idea" - someone spent quite a bit of time making this work.
- endianswap 14y agoI find it amusing that a page discussing passwords/security would throw a couple of SSL certificate warnings when loading it.
- cypherpunks01 14y agoIt's all green for me on chrome. What's causing the issue for you?
- grimboy 14y agoNot sure but perhaps it could be this: http://jimmyzimmerman.com/blog/2011/03/positivessl-untrusted-connection-in-firefox.html http://jimmyzimmerman.com/blog/2011/03/positivessl-untrusted... ?
- peterwwillis 14y agoOn top of that, the SSL server supports compression, session tickets and insecure ciphers, so that's three possible attacks to try. What's REALLY weird: my browser is showing a different cert than OpenSSL is. My browser shows it's signed by PositiveSSL, but when I connect with 'openssl s_client' I get this: depth=0 C = --, ST = SomeState, L = SomeCity, O = SomeOrganization, OU = SomeOrganizationalUnit, CN = ip-10-119-98-53, emailAddress = root@ip-10-119-98-53 verify error:num=18:self signed certificate verify return:1 depth=0 C = --, ST = SomeState, L = SomeCity, O = SomeOrganization, OU = SomeOrganizationalUnit, CN = ip-10-119-98-53, emailAddress = root@ip-10-119-98-53 verify error:num=10:certificate has expired notAfter=Feb 24 01:08:21 2012 GMT verify return:1 depth=0 C = --, ST = SomeState, L = SomeCity, O = SomeOrganization, OU = SomeOrganizationalUnit, CN = ip-10-119-98-53, emailAddress = root@ip-10-119-98-53 notAfter=Feb 24 01:08:21 2012 GMT Not only is it self-signed, it's expired. I actually don't know what the fuck is going on here.
- tedunangst 14y agoserver name indication?
- pharrington 14y agoThe self-signed cert is from alexsmolen.com, not nopassword.alexsmolen.com.
- peterwwillis 14y agoAh, so it's using the servername TLS extension. I forgot that some people use that now :)
- jeffreylo 14y agoGreat work implementing what was discussed here: http://notes.xoxco.com/post/27999787765/is-it-time-for-password-less-login http://notes.xoxco.com/post/27999787765/is-it-time-for-passw... For previous discussion: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4308190 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4308190
- cypherpunks01 14y agoDoesn't this need some kind of browser plugin to set your cookies with? Most websites don't have secret token URLs that will log you in, right? What about sites that issue cookies per-IP? Maybe I'm misunderstanding the mechanism here, would love clarification.
- agscala 14y agoHuh? No, you don't need a plugin to set cookies. They will just email you a link to a page that presumably has a timeout and will set your session cookie so that you get logged in.
- arnarbi 14y ago> Most websites don't have secret token URLs that will log you in, right? That's what they are proposing. Every time you log in they send you a one-time secret token URL by email.
- peterwwillis 14y agoYou put an e-mail in the box, click Submit, it sends you an e-mail with a link to click. You click the link, it brings you to a page that sets a cookie for you (key '_logged_in', value 'SOMEKEYSPECIFICTOYOUREMAILADDRESS'). Browse the site with the temporary key linked to your e-mail address. When your browser closes the cookie is gone. If you want to log in again, repeat the process. Now, here's why this is a bad idea: e-mails are not secure. They are sent willy-nilly around the internet in plain text through multiple mail relays. All one would need is to sniff traffic on a network segment that the mail travels over and you'd have a hell of an easy time collecting login info. This is why the passwords sent over e-mail are supposed to be temporary, and why most good password reset forms ask for additional confirmation details before they let you reset the password. You might think the above process would be secure if the link they send you is de-activated the first time you click it, but anyone could just keep sending more e-mail login requests and collecting the e-mails. The whole thing is pretty not-secure.
- leandrocp 14y agoAlex, It´s giving me an error: We're sorry, but something went wrong.
- bryanlarsen 14y agoGreat idea. 99% of website accounts I create are only accessed once or twice to purchase something or to leave a comment or get access to something. I use KeePassX to generate passwords for most of those, but most people use passwords that are either repeated, insecure or forgotten.
- m8urn 14y agoAlthough this concept certainly has its flaws, I could see it being useful for something where it was a site that most people would rarely log in. But for a store, I'd prefer having my credit card in the hands of something more secure.
- bryanlarsen 14y agoEvery web store has a "reset password via email" feature, so this is no less secure. In fact it's more secure, because this way you would receive email notification every time somebody tried to log in as you.
- smickie 14y agoThis is really great. There's quite a few places where I'd love to sign-in like this. The one area where I think it would fall down is logging into web apps that have multiple points-of-entry. Such as chartbeat(phone app and website). I don't see how you would be sent a link to log into an iPhone app. Or could you be sent and email with multiple links: one that goes to the site, another that flings you into an app? The best implementation would be if web apps offered this in the preferences area with a check-box saying: "Enable NoPassword" (so you don't offend any traditional password lovers or confuse people that just might not understand it).
- fishtoaster 14y agoThis is a neat idea. There are plenty of sites that I only use once or twice a year, or ever. I'm not sure how widely this will be adopted, though, since most sites tend to cater to the people that access them frequently. Also, as a user, you can accomplish this same thing by just using a common username across all your 1-off sites, along with a gibberish password that you reset every time you want to log in.
- smoyer 14y agoIt's great to have a library for this ... I first encountered a service using this type of login with www.wasitup.com (sadly now down) in 2010 and never had an issue with logging in, though it was indeed necessary to open an e-mail when using a new computer. Thanks!
- zapt02 14y ago" We're sorry, but something went wrong. " :(
- javery 14y agoMy bank starting texting me a one-time password which at first I thought was weird - but now I like it better than actually having to create and save a password. Seems like a nice natural extension of this for more secure things.
- apawloski 14y agoAs some will point out, SMS is generally insecure because of the possibility of snooping vulnerabilities. An even more secure way to implement one-time passwords is through an HTOP[1] smartphone app. The crypto is seeded once and then never has to communicate over the network to generate an OTP. Only the person with physical access to your phone can generate a password. I know when I was with USAA, they allowed you to generate one-time passwords using this method. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Time-based_One-time_Password_Algorithm http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Time-based_One-time_Password_Al...
- javery 14y agoThe concern is that in the 2 seconds it takes me to type the password in someone will intercept it and beat me to it? This is way safer than email.
- apawloski 14y agoI don't understand why you downvoted me -- my point is perfectly valid. "The concern is that in the 2 seconds it takes me to type the password in someone will intercept it and beat me to it?" The concern is that someone will snoop the password before it even gets to your phone. SMS snooping/MiTM has been demonstrated before [1]. Time-Based One-time Password algorithms are safer because they are not vulnerable to the aforementioned probems -- they never touch the network. "This is way safer than email." I never said it wasn't? [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IMSI-catcher http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IMSI-catcher
- javery 14y agoI didn't down vote you.
- laserDinosaur 14y agoSo I have to log into my email to avoid logging into the site? Isn't that the exact same thing, yet now I have to include a few extra steps in between?
- chustar 14y agoThe thing is I'd log into my email anyway to check for new messages.
- numbsafari 14y agoIf it is the kind of site for which you are willing to keep a cookie around, then you'll only have to get a new link from your email whenever your cookie expires or if you explicitly log out. Otherwise, you are correct.
- jkubicek 14y agoAnecdotally, everyone always has their email open anyway (I do, everyone I work with does, my family aways does), so the extra step of checking your email is trivial.
- laserDinosaur 14y agoUnless you use a different account for junk websites than you do your day to day email. I have my work email open all day, but not my personal email, which is also different to my spam email account I use for trials or junk websites. If I need to have 3-4 different email accounts open just to manage my sessions, I could see this being a massive pain. Also if I sign up using my work email to a work related service (so I can use it at work), I might not have access to it at home.
- spindritf 14y agoIf you use gmail, you can be logged in to multiple accounts at once.
- Kesty 14y agoThe idea is nice, but I see a couple of problem with that kind of implementation: 1) You don't have/won't access your email account on that computer (ex: Internet Cafe) 2) Spam filters that may delay the mail and so will delay the ability to log in. (ex: Grey Listing) 3) Changing your email account (ex: Work Email to personal email)
- chustar 14y agoThe thing is when I used internet cafes, the first thing I would always open would be email. 2 and 3 and really valid though.
- DrCatbox 14y ago"The thing is when I used internet cafes, the first thing I would always open would be email." Seriously? Intenet cafes are the least secure computers to give your email and password to. Sure for junk and spam-email accounts, that you dont care about anyway. But logging in to your personal email account on an internet caffe!? Thats madness.
- prof_hobart 14y agoInternet cafes aren't the only place. Our work doesn't allow access to external email - as one part of an attempt to avoid data leakage - but has no problem with a small amount of browsing sites like HN.
- redox 14y agorailscasts also uses an email link for a login
- eCa 14y agoI hope that Mozilla Persona[1] (or similar) will solve this problem soon. [1] https://login.persona.org/ https://login.persona.org/
- mmahemoff 14y agoI think it's an admirable goal, but they have a huge task ahead to convince both developers and other browsers to pick the standard up. Realistically, I expect most people/services will converge on Single Sign On via one of Twitter, Google, Facebook, and maybe a couple others. Hopefully all offering 2-factor authentication. So you'll only need a handful of passwords anyway.
- knighthacker 14y agoI agree with you. Those big names, for better or worse, became the identity store on the internet. Most websites tend to support at least one of them if not all of them.
- callahad 14y agoWe do, too. Please try Persona out and let us know what does and doesn't work for you. We're trying to solve this thing once, for the whole web. Also, if you've been waiting for Persona to hit "beta" before trying it out, well, check back Thursday morning. :)
- voltagex_ 14y agoDoes this use a Mozilla Services Account? If so, your password reset function hasn't been working for a year...
- gambler 14y agoAre there any plans or thoughts in regards to adding some way to implement it on a website without using JavaScript? You control the browser, so it shouldn't be difficult to do. For example, you could define a special URLs for login and logout actions. (E.g. persona:action=login&onsuccess=encoded_url1&onfailure=encodedurl2 ). I don't know about others, but it would make me much more willing to give a try.
- jpswade 14y agoThis works well for mobile.
- chustar 14y agoIt would be interesting if you could integrate a mail handler to this service so that you could simply email them to request a session.
- muxxa 14y agoWhen I'm on an untrusted computer, e.g. in an internet cafe, I typically try to avoid logging into webmail. E.g. I'll first put files I want to print into Dropbox and then log into that instead, (the consequences of an attacker getting access to my Dropbox are less grave than an attacker accessing my email account). This extra precaution is not possible with this NoPassword scheme.
- dougbarrett 14y agoThat's my exact thought. An idea solution is to check your mail on your phone, open a link that is essentially a second layer of authentication where you can login by clicking on the link in your mobile device, then refresh the page on the desktop and you'll be logged in. I still see this cluttering up my inbox, they would need to be deleted right away...for me it's just easier to type in a password.
- grinich 14y agoThe consequences of an attacker getting access to my Dropbox are less grave than an attacker accessing my email account. Can you be specific as to why? If you use Dropbox for personal information, I'd assume it would be similar.
- zokier 14y agoEmail is basically master key for all accounts.
- bradwestness 14y agoOnce someone has access to your e-mail, they can reset your password and log into anything that you used that e-mail to sign up for. With Dropbox, all they'd have access to is whatever files you happen to have in your Dropbox at the time.
- shawabawa3 14y ago1 reason would be that you can reset your dropbox password with your email, but you can't get your email password from dropbox (unless you store something silly like passwords.txt in dropbox)
- kennu 14y agoMakes me wonder, if emails and SMS messages start to carry more and more plaintext passwords (and links) providing direct access to everything, how will their security hold up in the long run? I don't think they are inherently very secure channels.
- peterwwillis 14y agoThey're not secure. SMS and e-mail are sent unauthenticated and unencrypted and can be intercepted in many different ways.
- numbsafari 14y agoFor this reason, the link/code being sent should have an expiration attached to it, as well as being single-use. This doesn't avoid any number of different scenarios. Too bad we don't all use PGP for email...
- sneak 14y agoIf users could be trusted to maintain a key pair (PGP), then we wouldn't need to use email to do authentication.
- sneak 14y ago> SMS and e-mail are sent unauthenticated and unencrypted and can be intercepted in many different ways My SMS are encrypted with A5, and my email (gmail's inbound smtpd) is (usually) encrypted with TLS. Of course, I always check with TLS as well. It's not quite as bad as you seem to make it out.
- tedunangst 14y agoI think people put way too much faith in inbound TLS. My mail server has some bozo self signed cert and nobody has ever failed to send me an email. Meaning: either nobody is using TLS to deliver mail or they use TLS and ignore all cert failures. Either way, about 99% less secure than you think it is.
- arnarbi 14y agoNow, cue the browser plugin to which you give access to your gmail (via OAuth), that handles this transparently.
- rickmb 14y agoI like it. Especially because theoretically it can be mixed with other, conventional authentication schemes, so it can be made completely optional and used at will, just like sites currently mix password + several OAuth providers. It's pretty much the ideal scheme for all those sites you don't visit regularly (and many of us, despite knowing better, use the same password for...).
- asdfaoeu 14y agoDefinitely a neat idea. Could also just email them a reusable link except that would leave the credentials in your browser's history unless there is a way to avoid that.
- jedbrown 14y agoTerrible idea. A reusable link is as bad as emailing a plaintext password and not requiring a reset afterward.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- m8urn 14y agoThis is an interestimg idea and surely has it's place, but how you implement it is critical. For example, you would want SSL for the entire site to ensure the cookie is always protected. You would also need to make sure that the token and session management is solid. Of course to really make it secure, you would want all smtp connections between you and the user to use SSL, which you cannot guarantee. One test I always use for new authentication schemes is would the NSA be able to compromise your account if they wanted? In this case I would definitely say yes. Still, this would be excellent for sites that only have you login to set preferences, etc.
- mylittlepony 14y agoY u no use LastPass? I've been using it for more than a year and never had a problem. Today, I only know 3 passwords, one for each of these: LastPass, full disk encryption in my PC, and the login in my PC.
- bryanlarsen 14y agoYou use LastPass, but 99% of the web doesn't. This proposal makes a web site both easier to use for those users, and more secure.
- mylittlepony 14y agoYes your proposal is good, I was talking to the commenters, sorry.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- Sami_Lehtinen 14y agoBad solution, email is slow and unsecure. I also have always hated identities linked to email in anyway. It's wrong way and that's it. Also allowing password recovery via email is dangerous, because email isn't secure either. Email is secure if you use GPG, and in that case it would be better to login by signing nonce with your private key and returning signature to site, which can verify it against your public key.
- rdwallis 14y agoI use a one time password system for magicscroll.net There's a lot of peace of mind in knowing that my users' passwords won't ever end up on pastebin but overall I regret the decision. I get a couple of emails a week from users who don't understand how it works. If I had to do over I'd choose openID.
- taf2 14y agoWe're sorry, but something went wrong.
- chmike 14y agoFor none critical information and just a mean to identify a user account, this is a good idea. In such system, The weakest link is the mail system, but this is not worst than what is done today. Replace mail by an sms code or whatever equivalent.
- Koldark 14y agoThe user experience is so different, I think using it would push users away from the different experience.
- mistercow 14y agoThis is how hi-games.net has worked for years, and it's a clever implementation, but I wouldn't want my bank to use it until we replace email with something, you know, secure.
- moeffju 14y agoWe did this on Toptranslation.com as an alternative to the normal password-based login. The thinking is, since password resets go to your e-mail, anyone who has control over your mail or mail server can get into your account anyway. It's a tradeoff between user (mostly enterprise customers') convenience and security. Since all orders made through the system require another confirmation, we decided it was worth not having to handle the "I forgot my password" support tickets. Haven't had any problems with it, I think it makes sense for low- to medium-security authentications.
- r00fus 14y agoThere's a difference between a one-time, quickly-expiring password (requiring reset on use) being sent on email, as opposed to having the password reside there in perpetuity. In one case the attacker needs full control during the password reset and in the other they can simply scour email for all passwords and get out - perhaps even without controlling the account - ie, transparent proxy + poisoned DNS would do the 2nd easily.
- duck 14y agopassword reside there in perpetuity It seems like you could easily handle this by making the link invalid after a certain time period, requiring you to request a new one. Which, is actually what a lot of password reset emails do currently.
- tlrobinson 14y agoThe emails contain single-use links. Each time you login you need a new email. http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4572031 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4572031
- moeffju 14y agoChanging account details or payment data or placing new orders requires separate confirmation via mail or phone anyway, so you'd have to have access to the email account for a chunk of time. If you can do that and prevent your mark from noticing the confirmation mails, you could have done the same with password reset emails.
- vxxzy 14y agoHow do I run an webmail service with this?
- twodayslate 14y ago> We're sorry, but something went wrong.
- hk__2 14y agoSo I have to check my emails every time I want to connect to your website? Seriously?
- alexsmolen 14y agoFrom my blog post: "Yes, logging in by waiting for an email and clicking a link does take longer than entering a password. But you should only have to do this once per device. Unless you’re constantly letting other people use your computers (and logging out of your email client each time), you’re golden." http://alexsmolen.com/blog/?p=194 http://alexsmolen.com/blog/?p=194
- kainio 14y agoYou need a password to get into your email account. + You have to open your email account every time you need to login into the website, it's a bad user experience. + What if you lose your email account password?
- alexsmolen 14y agoMost people have their email open, not only on their desktop but also on their mobile devices. Most importantly, you'd only do this once per device, unless you need to log out or clear your cookies. If you lose you email account password, you'd need to follow the email service provider recovery process. Gmail, Hotmail, etc. have significant resources dedicated to helping people with this.
- mapgrep 14y agoThis turns your email inbox into a giant password manager, except without the extensive storage encryption used by real password managers. Thought experiment: What are the possible unintended consequences of that? Just a few off the top of my head: 1. Easier for email hackers to detect sites where you have logins. (Controlling someone's email usually means controlling most/all logins, but it takes some digging to get a good list of vaulable logins. With this solution, most of the list is on the first page or two of the inbox.) 2. Harder to detect being hacked. (Previously, a hacker with email access would have to reset your passwords, and you will notice that at least some passwords have changed. Now the hacker just has to delete any incoming authentication emails after reading them.) 3. Losing a job becomes potentially more catastrophic. (Hope you didn't associate too many passwords with your work email, because IT wiped your account while security was escorting you out the door. And before you say only dumb people use work email for personal accounts, consider that part of the idea of this nopassword system is to help "dumb people" who fail to (for example) use password managers.) 4. Your email provider now has a nice easily mined record of what sites you log into most often. But, hey, I'm sure we can all trust Google not to use that information in a terribly creepy manner, right?
- tolmasky 14y agoIt would be interesting if email started adapting to this new use. For example, if we standardized around these login emails being sent from login@url.com, then you could set up a rule to automatically delete any email from login@url.com after 5 minutes. Over time, if this caught on, you could imagine this being standard practice by email clients vs. a custom rule. This of course only solves problem (1) that you mentioned and possibly(?) (2) partially. It occurs to me that this is kind of an interesting evolution of systems like 1Password, where the user experience is very similar: you have one password that gives you access to other passwords. Similarly here, your "one password" is your email password, and that gives you access to what is conceptually a new password on every login (vs a pre-generated one). I wonder if we couldn't solve 3 and 1 together by creating a "login email provider". For example, pretend dropbox wanted to offer this service. Dropbox gives you an @dropbox.com email specifically for logging into places. When a login email was sent to you, you would go to dropbox and navigate to the logins tab, which would have a very non-emaily interface showing you the last login links that were sent to you (again, auto deleted after 5 minutes -- and since this is not meant to be used as normal email there is no expectation for them to last longer). If websites only supported "known" services like @dropbox.com for this kind of login, then the (3) could be solved. Maybe to make things even clearer, the .login TLD could be used or something.
- orenmazor 14y agoInteresting. you're basically sort of taking the password part out of two-factor authentication. (I know its not exactly that)
- k3n 14y agoAnother glaring issue: they make the assumption that email === webmail. While this may be mostly true, the fact is that many still use POP email, and so what, you're to setup a POP account on whatever machine just so that you can access a website? Just let me remember my simple PW, thanks.
- debacle 14y agoIf you're using a POP service that doesn't provide a webmail interface in 2012, something is wrong.
- jrabone 14y agoI run my own mail server from colocation. I have so far refused to provide webmail because I can't find an implementation that isn't a constant stream of security holes, in exactly the way that Courier / Exim aren't. Any recommendations? I won't use PHP or MySQL on grounds of taste and decency.
- debacle 14y ago> I won't use PHP or MySQL on grounds of taste and decency. Good for you. http://roundcube.net/about http://roundcube.net/about http://www.zimbra.com/ http://www.zimbra.com/ http://www.squirrelmail.org/ http://www.squirrelmail.org/
- k3n 14y agoAre you being cheeky? At least 2 of those are PHP-based...
- drivebyacct2 14y agoThis technique hits the front page once every other week. With the same flaws. Use BrowserID. It's better than this and it paves the future towards actually being able to truly transition away from passwords.
- TazeTSchnitzel 14y agoYou mean Mozilla Persona? :)
- drivebyacct2 14y agoWell BrowserID is the protocol, Persona is Mozilla's implementation. You can use BrowserID without using Persona.
- zobzu 14y agostill annoying. i prefer browserid: zillion emails, one password =p or password managers
- elchief 14y agowhat's wrong with OpenID again?
- icebraining 14y agoRegular people don't get it.
- elchief 14y agoSeems to work okay on Stackexchange. Even the English and Home-Brewing versions!
- icebraining 14y agoOh, when you said OpenID, I assumed you meant the UX concept (the idea of logging in with an URL). since that was the level being discussed here. SE does use OpenID, but it's essentially just a backend technology, which is irrelevant to the user; they can login with an integrated third-party service (Google, FB, etc) or even with a password (by choosing the SE provider).
- dkokelley 14y agoI think it is interesting that a good portion of HN users are quick to point out the security issues in a scheme like this, considering the fact that this is basically the current security model with the intermediate steps removed. The only thing that makes it different from logging in to my bank is that if I try a bank password reset I might get asked what my mother's maiden name is.
- Coko 14y agoHasn't craigslist been doing this for awhile now? For those worried about the hassle/security of checking email to sign in to a website, there could just be two methods of login. One is the proposed NoPassword, other is the traditional username/password, and leave it up to the user to choose.
- d0m 14y agoI'm actually using this strategy more often than I would like to admit.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- tlrobinson 14y agoI don't think you understand. Your email address is not a secret, but I sure hope access to your email is secret. This scheme sends you an email with a single use link to login.
- drunken_thor 14y agoI keep asking users about this login process and passphrase instead of password. Most users seem to feel suspicious of the email login because most users have already been trained to not entirely trust their email. I don't think that this could become an accepted authentication method simply because of that
- tlrobinson 14y agoRegardless of whether this will be accepted, users need to be retrained. Any site that offers a password reset via email already effectively lets you login via email. Users should be aware of this so they can be more careful with their email (picking a decent password, ensuring they logout on public computers, etc). IMHO everyone should be using two-factor authentication for their email.
- amccloud 14y agoAnother similar application but to you mobile instead. Acts like a physical key. http://launchkey.co/ http://launchkey.co/
- astangl 14y agoAmong other problems, have to put up with delays imposed by greylisting, if your email server does that.
- PlanetFunk 14y agoCombine this with google authenticator for 2 step auth?
- sherwin 14y agoOne big problem with this approach: what happens when your email is down? Does a website really want to tie its availability to that of Gmail / other web mail services?
- sicxu 14y agoThere are security issues with this approach. However, I wouldn't mind if a site offers both traditional login and email based login. Then, I, as a user can choose which is the most appropriate.
- leostera 14y agoWouldn't it just make life easier for all of us to use auth via apps? I know that right now different providers use different layers of shit for their own purpose but there's gotta be a common ground for all of them that we could leverage for the sake of getting passwords out of the game for the most part of it.