8 ms·
Peanut allergies have plummeted in children
- aerostable_slug 1y agoBusiness idea: Allergen Aerator Generate a miasma of benign pestilence in your child's crib, mimicking the protective inoculations provided by early exposure to peanuts and other potential allergens, "farm" air, and the like. It could be packaged with Flonase for sneezing parents and an 'essential oils' scent dispenser to cover the barnyard smell. Use AI to tailor the precise blend of aerosolized rodent feces and tree nut dust to optimize your child's immune system, and et voila: funding!
- johnea 1y agoOr, of course, people could just go outside, with and/or without their babies 8-/
- hangonhn 1y agoFor food allergies, they already make powders that contains various different allergens that you can expose your kid to starting at a certain age. And like sibling comment said, you can just also just take them outside and let them be kind of outdoorsy.
- ErikCorry 1y agoMiasma is a very bad idea because https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45647737 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45647737
- alex_c 1y agoDisappointed this link has nothing to do with Dwarf Fortress.
- boredgargoyle 1y agoI heard Toady One will be implementing the allergy mechanics soon (time being relative)
- woah 1y agoJust get an overly affectionate dog that gets into the garbage from time to time
- mauzy 1y agoBizarre that this is the top comment as this would drastically increase the frequency of peanut allergies and, more than likely, end in multiple deaths. Research strongly suggests that the key is that the child eats peanuts before being exposed via other vectors (skin/lung) to avoid allergic reactions. Arisolizing the relevant proteins around infants is essentially fast tracking allergic reactions.
- 4gotunameagain 1y agoIt is not bizarre, this place is like reddit or the news. Things seem plausible, until once in a while the discussion is something in your area of expertise, then you realise how full of shit everyone is. At least here we have some exceptions, with some deeply knowledgeable people. But to offset that we have software "engineer" hubris.
- bodiekane 1y agoI smirked at the parent comment, and it didn't even slightly occur to me that someone might interpret its intent as serious and literal until I saw your comment.
- michaelt 1y agoIn my experience HNers are extremely credulous. As far as I can tell, there's no level of satire so heavy-handed and unsubtle that it won't get a reply taking it seriously. If anything, the more obviously ridiculous your suggestion, the more urgently HNers want to disagree.
- alliao 1y agojust buy some asian snacks... i've never seen an asian kid allergic to peanuts, when we first heard peanut allergy thought it was a skit
- croes 1y agoSurvivorship bias?
- evanjrowley 1y agoAKA evolution
- croes 1y agoNot necessarily. How high is child mortality compared to the US?
- viraptor 1y agoThey trade it for 5% infants with egg allergy https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/pai.14211 https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/pai.14211
- alliao 1y agofascinating findings between ultra processed food consumption.. Figure 1 is insane!
- IncreasePosts 1y agoOr Israeli: Israel presents a unique experiment because you have people from different genetic populations from different parts of the world collecting in Israel(eg Sephardic jews from Spain, Ashkenazi from central Europe, Mizrahi from Asia, etc). Something interesting is that peanut allergies in Israel are far lower than for Jews living in Spain, central europe, etc... One of the most popular snacks in Israel? Bambas - peanut butter puffs.
- 1y ago
- sfgunn 1y agoCompeting with a $2 bag of Planter's? Not so crazy if you corner the market. Now that's SaaSing baby!
- politelemon 1y agoThis is needs consumer staying power in order to secure the funding. I recommend selling the blends in DRM locked plastic pods and have the device only be operable from a mobile app. The mobile app's purpose would be to gamify the aerosol dispensation by grading it on timeliness, targeted direction and force of the spray, as well as streaks that get posted to social media for a sense of foamo.
- ThePowerOfFuet 1y ago>and et voila et = and, so just _et voilà_.
- evereverever 1y agoThe kids I see that have peanut allergies lived in bubbles. It seems like it is self-inflicted but I have no scientific evidence.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- foxyv 1y agoThere are a ton of studies that indicate that early exposure to peanuts reduces incidence of peanut allergies. I'm not sure about other allergens. https://publications.aap.org/pediatrics/search-results?page=1&q=Peanut%20Allergy&fl_SiteID=1000005 https://publications.aap.org/pediatrics/search-results?page=...
- peterfirefly 1y agoAnd yet peanut allergy is rare in Europe. Pretty strange.
- rimunroe 1y agoI thought peanut allergies were roughly as common in Europe as the US, and a quick web search seems to back this up: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6021584/ https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6021584/
- pfannkuchen 1y agoI think peanuts are eaten less commonly in Europe? Maybe it just doesn’t come up as much?
- viraptor 1y agoEurope is as much a location as the US. Eating habits in Finland are very different than in Spain. So any generalisation here will have people disagreeing. That said, I are lots of peanut butter sandwiches for lunch. It was normal.
- Bender 1y agoHave there been any studies on crop-swapping changes such as legumes <--> cotton? Only asking as there were some theories about excess herbicides and pesticides from cotton leeching into the ground and getting absorbed in high amounts by legumes from seasonal crop-swaps.
- ludicrousdispla 1y agoI'd like to see that, as the current studies seem too convenient. Or at the very least, compare peanut butter from 2005 to peanut butter from 2025.
- ErikCorry 1y agoEating peanuts reduces allergies, but getting peanuts on your skin increases allergies. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0091674916002888 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S009167491... Or maybe in your lungs. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8429226/#R7 https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8429226/#R7
- modeless 1y agoYes, and this is one reason why eczema is correlated with allergies, because it allows allergens to pass through the skin more readily. And it's probably also a reason why babies put everything in their mouths; they're training their immune systems.
- nkingsy 1y agoSo you’re saying I should’ve eaten the cat that lived in my apartment when I was a baby?
- random3 1y ago:)))
- modeless 1y agoIt's possible that if you had more cat dander in your mouth when you were a baby that you wouldn't have developed an allergy. Or, more likely, if you had more mouth exposure to other natural microbes that occur outdoors and around animals, then you would have fewer allergies overall. That is well supported by the evidence.
- legitster 1y agoOne of my conspiracy theories that I loosely hold is that the majority of the fears that we have been sold on allergies was a direct result of marketing efforts by the inventors of the Epipen. Anaphylactic shock is extremely rare. And even in cases of anaphylactic shock, it's only fatal in an even rarer number of cases (which makes sense, anaphylactic shocks is a biological reaction of your body to save itself, not kill itself). We really don't know how many lives emergency epinephrine has saved, but it may have only been necessary in less than 1 out of 50 cases. However, it benefitted the manufacturer to overemphasize the prevalence of dangerous food allergies and the risks of shock and encourage doctors to prescribe them in increasingly more "just in case" cases". It's in this world that parents and doctors alike became insanely cautious and paranoid about introducing allergens. Conveniently, we saw the rise of simpler, more highly processed baby and childrens' foods at the same time.
- tredre3 1y agoI could get onboard with your theory that Epipens are overused (or at least over prescribed). But I really don't agree that when someone can't breath we should "wait and see because it's the body trying to save itself", though. Children of Gen X and Millenials have been ruined by their helicopter/bubble parents, they have allergies and that's that. Future generations can and must learn from their mistake, but we can't force allergic people to simply grow out of it. We're not talking itchy throats here.
- margalabargala 1y agoPer TFA, it's mainly children of Boomers and Gen X and the trend is now reversing with Millenial children. Add allergies to the list of things Millenials killed I guess.
- canucker2016 1y agoIt's partly due to certain doctors deciding to tell parents NOT to give peanuts to kids until much later. Even after peanut allergies spiked 3x, they wouldn't change their recommendation - until they had studies to prove the recommendation they were giving was wrong (which they based on no study, "let's try banning peanuts for toddlers..."). see https://www.preventallergies.org/blog/why-are-peanut-allergies-on-the-rise https://www.preventallergies.org/blog/why-are-peanut-allergi...
- teejmya 1y agohttps://web.archive.org/web/20251020152903/https://www.nytimes.com/2025/10/20/well/peanut-allergy-drop.html https://web.archive.org/web/20251020152903/https://www.nytim...
- kazinator 1y ago[flagged]
- MeetingsBrowser 1y agoFood allergies have pretty noticeable physical symptoms.
- Aloha 1y agoI attribute to my robust immune system to the amount of dirt I ate as a child, I was a digger in the school yard, and I liked playing in mud - while being a thumb sucker well into elementary school.
- gnerd00 1y agothe word is "soil" :-D
- MeetingsBrowser 1y agoMost peanut allergies are noticed during infancy. Advising infants eat more dirt is probably not a good solution to reducing peanut allergies on the whole.
- pinkmuffinere 1y agoHave you tried it though? (just kidding)
- themafia 1y agoI've tried giving infants advice before. For a being with very little gained knowledge they are amazingly skeptical. Haven't been able to win one over yet.
- gregschlom 1y agoI know you're being facetious but I wanted to say, a friend of mine's kid recently got diagnosed with elevated lead levels in his blood, likely caused by eating contaminated dirt from their backyard. So... test before you try it, I guess?
- freedomben 1y agoMy kids love to play in sand, and one time I found my kid playing with "rocks" in the sand before realizing it was a favorite shitting ground for the neighborhood cats
- 1y ago
- tokai 1y agoPeanut allergies is one of those things I have only seen in American pop culture and media. Like anxious kids breathing in a brown paper bag. I know people have peanut allergies all over the world. But the significance of the allergy is definitely different in the US than most other places imo.
- XorNot 1y agoMy son's daycare in Australia doesn't allow peanuts or eggs due to allergy management concerns so I don't think this is an American thing? I had a friend in high school who had a peanut allergy and had an epipen. "breathing into a brown paper bag"? An anaphylatic reaction is literally a life-threatening event requiring prompt medical intervention. It's not "anxiety".
- lanyard-textile 1y agoPoster is talking about two different phenomenon.
- XorNot 1y agoIn which case it's even more weird because again: an anaphylactic shock is a life-threatening event that will kill you without prompt medical intervention. The epipen is _literally_ just to keep you alive long enough to get to the hospital. And funnily enough, the breathing in a paper bag is _absolutely_ a recommended treatment for anxiety attacks by doctors. My father is one, and had my wife do it when she had a panic attack during a particularly rough airplane landing recently. So again: it's a standard and normal thing, which is in the regular medical parlance. The reason to do it is your trigger to breathe is based on CO2 acidity, not oxygen - you can't detect O2 (hence why inert gas asphyxiation is a huge hazard) but can detect CO2. But if you start shallow breathing very rapidly you end up in feedback loop. Rebreathing the air ups the CO2 content, which encourages the body to take deeper breathes, which in turn helps with the anxiety and ensures you do get enough oxygen (since you can wind up passing out, and low O2 wipes out the reasoning center of thought very quickly).
- atleastoptimal 1y agoCommon sense thinking wins again. The entire genesis of an allergy is your body treats a benign particle as a pathogen due to not recognizing it. The #1 way to precipitate this is to keep the body from ever encountering this particle until well beyond its initial phases of immune development. Are there other modern conditions born from the same "zero-tolerance prevention leads to unintended consequences due to failing to provide the body a robust means to develop"?
- strbean 1y agoMaybe drug policy and the opioid crisis?
- dr-detroit 1y ago[dead]
- taeric 1y agoI don't know that I agree this is the reasoning, here? Seems far more likely, to me, that there are other environmental factors at play. I'm almost certainly indexing too heavily on the ideas in birch pollen cross reactivity. But I see basically no reason not to think that same process generalizes quite well into a lot of the things we used to gladly pollute into our environments. And yes, I know we can still get better at pollution management; but I think people should probably acknowledge just how much progress we have made. Especially in the US. Our air quality is amazingly clean today compared to just 60 years ago. Strikingly so.
- hulitu 1y ago> The entire genesis of an allergy is your body treats a benign particle as a pathogen due to not recognizing it And why the body does not recognize it ? Because it is tainted. Putting all kind of pesticides and other substances on plants does modify the "original".
- ErikCorry 1y ago[Citation needed] for a pesticide connection. Unless you are an insect, most pesticides are harmless for you. And for those that are not, nobody has proved a connection to allergies.
- tkuraku 1y agoMy son has a peanut allergy. He was deemed very severe. He started treatment daily peanut doses. Starting at 5 mg. He is now eating 4 peanuts a day and counting. Zero issues with exposure now. If you have a kid with a peanut allergy find an allergist who will desensitize them.see https://www.palforzia.com/ https://www.palforzia.com/
- kelnos 1y agoDo be careful, though. My nephew (now 4 years old) has/had several food allergies. Some he's ok with now, but for some the desensitizing process resulted in several ER visits.
- sidgriciouus 1y agoHow is a 5mg peanut dose created?
- Dan_- 1y agoThe immunologist’s office weighs these tiny amounts and sends you home with a few weeks’ supply. As you progress and the margin of error becomes less dangerous, you get to weigh it yourself.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- more_corn 1y agoScience works
- moogly 1y agoI remember the misdiagnosis studies back in the day also. https://www.newscientist.com/article/dn11859-peanut-allergy-is-misdiagnosed-in-many-children/ https://www.newscientist.com/article/dn11859-peanut-allergy-... https://www.thelocal.se/20100224/25174 https://www.thelocal.se/20100224/25174
- smsm42 1y agoExperts discover peanut allergies are mostly caused by experts.