9 ms·
Abandoned land drives dangerous heat in Houston, study finds
- inetknght 1y agoSolution: put green spaces with solar panels. Fairly cheap to do, contributes to cooler temperatures, and contributes to renewable power. Alas, bunches of people would rather see a rotting city instead of solar panels.
- shortrounddev2 1y agoLand value tax would fix this
- tirant 1y agoHow? If it’s not profitable nor possible to build anything profitable right now, making it more expensive via taxing will make the situation worse.
- larsiusprime 1y agoBecause a revenue neutral implementation lowers taxes on net on improved active sites that do something with land, and raises it on net for vacant abandoned sites that do nothing, shifting the incentive to do something with the land or sell it to someone who will.
- fuzzfactor 1y agoTexas already has exorbitantly high property taxes, more than most, that's why perfectly good buildings are often torn down. Nice buildings where that would not happen in other states. Because it allows the appraisal value to plummet and the owner to continue to own the property when nothing other than a drastic reduction in this yearly siphoning (which never stops increasing) will do. Remember the purpose of property tax to begin with is for the owner to lose the property in case they are not as wealthy as someone else who might be interested someday. Or in case the property itself can not provide more than enough income to pay the tax in a timely way. Another problem is that taxes were always high but they didn't actually start skyrocketing until a few decades ago, after one of the key stabilizing anti-Carpetbagger laws which prevented home equity loans, was repealed. And the sky's the limit whenever untapped wealth is unleashed, to be audited and appraised. So it's been kind of a race between property appreciation, available equity to borrow against as values increase, versus tax rates and appraisals trying to capture more of that in ways that can only result in owners becoming less whole that it ever has been. Revenue-neutral or not, anything that makes it worse makes it worse.
- rafabulsing 1y agoA land value tax is based on the value of the land only, with no input from whatever improvements are or are not built on it. So, with a proper LTV implementation (i.e., one where LTV is the only tax incurred on real state), there would be literally no tax incentive to tear down a usable (but unused) building. You would be paying the exact same amount of taxes on an empty lot as on a high end modern building on that same lot.
- fuzzfactor 1y agoWhat you say does make sense because it's got to be better than what things have evolved into in so many misguided places. But I forgot to add that the amount of revenue from property tax is only intended to act like collateral damage :) When you do the math it turns out anytime you start taxing anything but commerce, it is unsustainable because it accrues and accumulates disadvantage to the taxpayer until it is overwhelming. Plus the higher that taxes rise above absolute insignificance, the more likely a major upset occurs from just a slight lapse in overall prosperity, re-balancing to the further disadvantage against those who can afford it least. And that doesn't include the pulling of political strings by those who benefit most from that type activity. You don't sensibly tax people just for existing, even at 3/5 the amount per head. Likewise their property unless it is involved in commercial activity, nor wage income since the employer is the commercial enterprise they should have that all covered like it used to be when things were not so predatory. But they tax "rooftops" like a lot of other places based on square footage and now in Houston there has been some recent influence to demolish unoccupied buildings more so for appearance sake to the world for the upcoming World Cup as an excuse more than anything else. It appears the actual demolition of truly abandoned buildings can not be accelerated without blurring the lines between actual abandonment and merely unoccupied to some degree or another. But appearances can be deceiving. The big thing is there's enough people much wealthier than those who have the properties now, who want them either way, demolished or not. Under threat of forced demolition those having buildings suitable for rehab would need to sell for less than they would have otherwise. Who cares about the poor sellers who have been paying taxes on the buildings the whole time, working toward a financial turnaround? The idea seems to be to incentivize new buyers to have better opportunities by preying on previous owners' misfortune. OTOH, as soon as any property has had any nonproductive structures removed, its appraised value and tax levy drops like a rock, making it way more attractive for the same type buyers who could have already obtained all the lots having buildings they are willing to rehab. The new buyers can then afford many more vacant lots for potential future construction, which had always been a non-bonanza prospect otherwise, and with the newly lowered taxes afford to wait and see which might be a bonanza to build on someday. A lot more so than the previous owners. If a lot of this happens at the same time, then the market for reclaimed lots like this will have downward price pressure too until the effect runs its course. Too bad for the little guy either way.
- shortrounddev2 1y agoSomething is more profitable than nothing, always
- appreciatorBus 1y agoif it’s truly not profitable or possible to use the land, then the land value tax would be $0.
- georgeburdell 1y agoTexas has some of the highest property tax millages in the U.S. they’re closer to a land value tax than most other places
- ProllyInfamous 1y agoYes, but anybody with considerable land has it deeded "agricultural" so they effectively don't follow the Georgian tenants of Land Value Tax's basic theory. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Land_value_tax https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Land_value_tax For example, beekeeping as a hobby is expensive (you will never recoup in honey sales)... but in many states "worth it" for the agricultural exemption, alone.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- potato3732842 1y agoThis land isn't "abandoned". Nobody is sitting on vacant RE in Texas and getting fucked by sky high TX property taxes for the fun of it. It's fundamentally a long bet that basically the same people (demographically if not often individually) who are complaining about this will turn around and pass legislation that makes development even more onerous and therefore makes their existing cheap 30-60yo building with a simple uninterrupted parking lot and un-engineered drainage ditches (the typical form vacant commercial RE seems to take) even more valuable.
- pessimizer 1y agoThis doesn't make any sense. Allowing people to build infinite height towers with no parking instantly makes land worth far more, and the people that pay for this "movement" are all large-scale landowners. Holding land and keeping it trash is an investment; they're sure that pouring money into YIMBY groups will eventually make them a fortune, and the fact that they're leaving the land trashed will just help YIMBY arguments. The people who fight it are the people who actually live there. You know, the "demographics."
- immibis 1y agoThe idea is to drive up demand for land in general, and then make your piece of land the valuable one. Please note that we don't live in a perfectly efficient market.
- potato3732842 1y agoYou can't build an infinite height tower with no parking if the market doesn't support it. You need to be building that in a neighborhood of half infinite height towers to make it make sense. But there are no neighborhoods like that because we have regulated incremental development out of existence. There is no gradual redevelopment anymore because nobody can afford to get kicked in the dick by huge amounts of of compliance cost bullshit (all of which the useful idiots and those with financial motive are more than capable of justifying in abstract, no one droplet feels responsible for the flood and all that) to just take an incremental step. The only way to make the math make sense is to go whole hog, seek a variance and put up something huge and make back the costs. This is why it "looks" like local residents care. They'd be fine with triple deckers organically filling in as well as subdivisions, back lot houses, etc, etc. They just don't want a N-over-1 in their suburban neighborhood. This is exacerbated by the fact that anyone who could be living in such a place at such a time when that conversation is happen is rich enough to have no other real problems.
- trentnix 1y agoI’d bet the farm the land in question is Ag value land. Property taxes are significant in Texas relative to most states, as there is no income tax. Consequently, it’s hard to sit in property indefinitely if you’re paying taxes on its fair market value. But land that is classified by each appraisal district as “Ag” is only taxed on the value it derives from agricultural activity. Consequently, you’ll see large plots of land in the middle of the suburbs and the city that are bailed for hay or that contain a corn field. So then the owner is only subject to pay taxes on the amount the hay or corn produced. This is meant to protect and encourage agricultural operations, incentivize the maintenance of rural land, and shield residents that are subject to being overtaken by sprawl. But it’s also used to protect land investment, including large ranches owned by hedge funds and foreign nationals. If the land is sold and developed, some back taxes are owed when the land is no longer city considered Agricultural. But that gets passed on the purchaser and is rarely assessed against the seller.
- Polizeiposaune 1y agoThe second paragraph of the article attributes the hot spots to abandoned buildings and parking lots; vacant lots with vegetation are not the problem.
- trentnix 1y agoI’d like to see how the land is classified, regardless. If it’s genuinely urban land, it should be taxed heavily enough to make it hurt if it is appraised correctly. It’s possible this land is subject to delinquent taxes that, in Texas, incur significant interest. Also, I’d want to know about zoning to see if the city has restricted the use of the land. Zoning is a double-edged sword as well.
- sandworm101 1y agoIf land is actually abandoned, taxation makes no difference. Land with abandoned biuldings can often cost more to redevelop than green fields (asbestos remediation, buried oil tanks etc). An owner dies, a holding company folds, and land sits vacant. Tax it all you want, nobody is around to pay. Of course the city or other government can take the land, but they dont want it either.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- bob1029 1y agoI recently moved to the more forested biome just north of Houston and the difference in the actual temperature is remarkable. The city core area inside 610 loop is sitting at 77F right now. My back porch is right at 68F. I am not even 60 miles away. The hottest temperatures get to be about the same, but the trees don't hold heat like the concrete does. It falls off so much faster up here. It seems you can cool these houses with barely half the HVAC capacity that the other ones tend to require. Which is wild because the power grid up here is also much cheaper.
- fuzzfactor 1y agoWelcome to real Northern Living :) >On a scorching Texas afternoon, Something I'm very familiar with, and the drone data speaks for itself as far as what it's like in the hot sun of southeast Texas. Then how about at night? Those buildings can then act like heat islands that can take more than one night for the heat to dissipate too. Some cool off that much, some don't. Thermodynamics at work. Based on heated mass is how long it takes to cool back off to ambient temp by morning. Good air circulation can help a lot too. If everybody's roof is soaking up heat all day, the structures underneath that are being actively cooled at the same time are not expected to have nearly as much heated mass that needs to dissipate, and the only time for that might be at night. But maybe that same amount of heat was actively dispersed into the surrounding air all day by the air conditioning units of the cooled structures, plus some of the night. And how efficient are A/C units anyway? That's got to make a difference too so it's not just abandoned buildings but any time people are not running A/C even while dwelling there. At least the windows are open then. So the drone data on the buildings looks realistic so far, but everything else is just beginning to trickle in. Regardless, I'm just fine without A/C in the summer in Houston if I'm in a proper place like a 100-year-old home that was built for it. But I grew up in Florida when about the only places with A/C were supermarkets and banks, not even most college dorms or classrooms had it when I got there. You just sweat more in Florida, because it may not reach 100 Fahrenheit all summer but the humidity makes Houston feel like a desert by comparison, and it sure doesn't cool off as much at night like it does in Houston with its milder type of "Northern Living" :)
- joloooo 1y agoFancy way of say The Woodlands?
- andsoitis 1y agoGreenery not only lowers temperatures, it also creates a sense of calm, is more beautiful than concrete, and results in less crime. Plant.
- SapporoChris 1y agohttps://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6950486/#sec5-ijerph-16-05119 https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6950486/#sec5-ijerp... "Based on the 45 quantitative and qualitative papers summarized here, we can deduce that the presence of parks and other green space reduces urban crime."
- mixmastamyk 1y agoWould say blacktop rather than concrete.
- IAmBroom 1y agoWould say both. Concrete is a massive heat reservoir compared to greenery.
- mixmastamyk 1y agoWhen vertical. It’s a lot closer to white than asphalt.
- selimthegrim 1y agoTree cover has come way down in New Orleans after Katrina so the city is much hotter as a result
- ciconia 1y agoI've been having this idea of designing a neighborhood where the proportions of natural and built-up areas are reversed. Instead of having a basically artificial setting where trees live in little holes in the sidewalk, the basic setting is natural soil and vegetation, and the buildings are situated between and under the trees. This brings up a lot of other questions: what about water and sewage infrastructure, electrical and fiber? What about maintenance of the vegetation? But it seems to me like a really cool idea, maybe even within the setting of a single homestead, where the basic setting is a forest, with some buildings nested within it.
- jezzamon 1y agoYou haven't explained what you'd do for the car-based infrastructure, which seems to be the main problem here
- forgotoldacc 1y agoHaving a lot of buildings under trees brings up a big problem when heavy rainstorms, wind, or hail occur. Texas has all three. Old trees are particularly troublesome since heavy limbs can snap off with very gentle stimulation. It's nice to build a house under a tree. It's a bad idea to buy a house that was built under a tree.
- 3eb7988a1663 1y agoRemoving trees adjacent to a house is also surprisingly expensive.
- pbalcer 1y agoThis exists in many parts of the world. And is usually reserved for the ultra wealthy, especially if you want it to be near a big city. One famous example is Karuizawa.
- dlcarrier 1y agoOne of my neighbors has a sycamore tree that practically covers the entire house. It does look really nice, but I'm glad It's not my house, because the tree is constantly dropping debris on the roof, and if a branch fell of in a wind storm, it could do significant damage to the house.
- verisimi 1y agoOh lord... "Sir, your house is too hot, which makes you subject to the 'hot house tax'", coming to a road near you in 2028.
- wartywhoa23 1y ago".. and your smart watch detected that you've exceeded the methane footprint quota this month, here's your fine and please consider upgrading your greenhouse gas tier, otherwise we're disabling the bean buying flag in your CBDC UBI"
- Reason077 1y ago> “Houston is famous as an unwalkable city,” Ren said… “Google Maps said it was a five-minute walk from my hotel to a pharmacy, but it took me 30 minutes with no shade, no red lights and no safe place to cross,” This sounds like a Google problem as much as a Houston problem! But it’s amusing (and sad) to read about the Democrat mayor of Houston removing bike lanes and trying to ban electric scooters[1]. It sounds like they want to make the city even more car-centric, not less. [1] https://www.nytimes.com/2025/10/19/us/politics/houston-mayor.html https://www.nytimes.com/2025/10/19/us/politics/houston-mayor...
- alexpotato 1y agoReminds me of the quote: One of the best things you can have on your property is a large deciduous tree on the south side of your house. - In the summer, it shades your house (specifically the roof) so you spend less money cooling it - In the winter, the tree loses its leaves so you get more sunlight (again, on your roof) which helps heat your house when it's cold but sunny
- pfdietz 1y agoThis is becoming obsolete with roof-mounted PV. You'd want it exposed all year. The PV panels, with the air space above the roof, would also act as a bit of insulation.
- SapporoChris 1y agoThe summer shade makes sense, but a tree without leaves in the winter does not provide more sunlight than no tree at all. We could also talk about the potential for the roots of the tree crawling under the foundation and wrecking it or the tree itself falling on the roof of the house. But it is a very nice quote if you don't think too much about it.
- giardini 1y agoAny tree will eventually extend roots beneath your foundation and do damage. They will shift and crack the foundation (unless you use pillar construction), break pipes and structures and will penetrate your sewer lines. If you're lucky you will kill them before they do any severe damage. Though it sounds absurd, rather than a tree, it might be better to put up a shade (i.e., two poles and a sail cloth between them) to block the lith/heat. It would definitely be cheaper than having a tree although your neighbors might not like it. A tree must be trimmed annually once it reaches a certain size; eventually it must be removed. But then a new problem arises: the dying tree roots, which extend entirely across and below the land, and which had previously remained placidly underground and invisible, now begin to rot, swell and rise irregularly everywhere. They thrust upward at random ruining the lawn's former level appearance. You can no longer mow your lawn: the lawnmower strikes the rising roots and either breaks the blade or the lawnmower stalls. The surface is no longer level. You can let your lawn lie fallow for 20 more years until the roots rot completely or... ... you pay someone enough to remove all the roots and fill them in with soil, then re-level and re-sod the lawn. That likely triples the cost of removal. Trees look great - from a distance. It is a tribute to the old "pier and beam" construction techniques that their use evades these problems somewhat by allowing you to raise/lower the piers in response to tree growth/intrusion, thus maintaining a level house (so your grandkids can play marbles on the wood floor in the living room). Root barriers may be a reasonable solution too, but they must be maintained. I am unfamiliar with their success rate. I recently saw an 11-story high-rise whose foundation is endangered by the "nice trees" that were planted at its base to form a park for the building's inhabitants decades ago. The trees are moving everything: the building, the streets around the building, *everything!! Imagine having bought a condo in that buiding! What a disaster.
- tensorlibb 1y ago[dead]
- armenarmen 1y ago“Low-income communities lack trees and green space,” I lived in 3rd Ward Houston for years, it was very well treed. As were most of the other inner loop “hoods”
- jeffbee 1y agoThe gradient should be pretty obvious here https://www.google.com/maps/@29.7512376,-95.5104388,10129m/data=!3m1!1e3?hl=en&entry=ttu&g_ep=EgoyMDI1MTAxNC4wIKXMDSoASAFQAw%3D%3D https://www.google.com/maps/@29.7512376,-95.5104388,10129m/d...
- wartywhoa23 1y ago[flagged]
- mmooss 1y agoCan you name a time this has ever happened?
- metalman 1y agoI use this https://weather.ndc.nasa.gov/goes/ https://weather.ndc.nasa.gov/goes/ as my go(es) to weather "app", billion dollar live sat feed on my phone, for lots of things, other than just local weather,including general investigation into *stuff™ such as finding citys, of which huston is easy, cause it glows in the infrared like nothing else, with the major ring roads and highways clearly visible from geosyncronous orbit at I think a 1 km/pixle resolution, in hot dry high pressure weather huston is clearly an oven. today is cloudy there, but watch for "better", ha!, weather
- ChrisMarshallNY 1y agoWhen I was younger (in the 1970s), I lived in the DC area (East Coast, USA). The summers were always tough, but they weren't obscene. We also got some really cold winters, with lots of snow. During the 1980s, there was a huge development surge, all up and down the East Coast. Basically, the whole coast got paved. The summers really seemed to get crazy hot, and we stopped getting extreme winters.
- IAmBroom 1y agoSome of that is climate change worldwide. Crazy snowbound winters were a thing of my childhood in the Midwest, and also in southern Pennsylvania where I now live. Neither see those extremes anymore.
- luxuryballs 1y agoI went into a “bamboo maze” the other day and it was wild how dark and cool it was under all that dense bamboo, it grows super fast, they should plant bamboo forests on the vacant lots to promote cooler air.
- rurban 1y agoI lived there. The rich districts have enough trees, from above everything looks green. A giant forest. I lived on the 15th floor overlooking River Oaks, and it was fantastic. But the poorer districts are concrete all over, and nobody will care. As I worked as city planner before I tried to get into a district council once, but no chance. That was Ted Cruz' district
- kazinator 1y ago> Abandoned buildings and paved lots do the opposite, raising land surface temperatures by as much as 20 degrees Fahrenheit. Because nobody is there pouring tons of water and chemicals to produce a lush lawn, ironically. Lack of lawn becomes bad!