6 ms·
DDoS Botnet Aisuru Blankets US ISPs in Record DDoS
- Groxx 1y agoI'm honestly kinda curious why nobody's blocking these IPs from sending data near the source. Like, I can come up with plenty of possible reasons, and reasons why it could potentially be very bad if ISPs started cracking down on this, but I don't actually know any reasons. Are any talking about why / why not? It seems like this whole insecure-IoT-device thing would probably dry up pretty quickly if people's internet was cut off when one was detected. They can then turn around and lambast / sue / etc the company that sold it, putting pressure on the source of the problem. Right now there's no reason for sellers to do anything at all to ensure security, afaict. So... not actually arguing in favor of it, but definitely curious about any stated ISP / core networking system's stated reasons.
- bombcar 1y agoThere's no economic incentive for YOU (as the proximate ISP) to do anything about it, it would cost money, and cost you customers. Any idea why they don't fix it?
- martinald 1y agoOf course there is. If you've got all your internet egress tied up with DDoS attacks from your network it is a big problem.
- bombcar 1y agoI think we’re just starting to see attacks that big - which might start some practical mitigations (or they’ll just upgrade transit).
- toast0 1y agoMost eyeball networks have a lot of inbound traffic and not very much outbound, but interconnections with other networks are almost always symmetric, so there's a lot of room for excess egress before it causes pain to the ISP. When I ran a large web site that attracted lots of DDoS, it didn't really seem worthwhile to track down the source and try to contact ISPs. I had done a lot of trying to track and stop people sending phishing mail under our name, and it's simply too much work to write a reasonable abuse report that is unlikely to be followed up on. With email, mostly people seem to accept the Received headers are probably true; with DDoS, you'd be sending them pcaps, and they'd be telling you it's probably spoofed, and unless I've got lots of peering, I'm not going to be able to get captures that are convincing... so just do my best to manage the inbound and call it a day.
- Groxx 1y agoYes, you generally see this kind of thing start from the pain-feelers and move up the chain to the pain-causers. So why hasn't that happened? These are clearly damaging to many, and ISPs are apparently doing next to nothing to prevent it, and it has been extremely clear for a while now that it's going to just become a bigger and bigger problem.
- Hikikomori 1y agoHow are you going to get an end customer to track down whatever device of theirs was hacked?
- pixl97 1y agoAs the ISP you don't care, you just cut off their connection to fix it. Said user will have to contact a local service to come out and find it.
- Groxx 1y agoMade even easier by almost everyone running their local network off the ISP's hardware. Before they get cut off, have the router take a snapshot of what's using what ports, then go hunting.
- bombcar 1y agoAs a power user I don't know any way of even checking if I'm involved in a botnet. Is there something like that out there? Something that routers could install to monitor and report?
- Hikikomori 1y agoMaybe Pi-hole and look for weird lookups? Home routers wont have anything useful, I can see bandwidth and log NAT etc on my Ubiquiti though.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- userbinator 1y agoAre there ISPs that don't charge customers for the amount of bandwidth they consume? Even "unlimited" has been ruled by courts to not really mean "unlimited", after all.
- fukka42 1y agoYes, most if not all of them. Is it different in the US?
- bombcar 1y agoMost non-mobile ISPs will let you get pretty high on bandwidth usage before they flag you; and since DDoS are almost always relatively low-levels of bandwidth (on the source) it's unlikely you'd get flagged.
- Hikikomori 1y agoMost in Europe doesn't. Back when I first got 100/100 fiber I uploaded almost 30TB in a month and the only complaint I got was from the torrent site.
- Mindless2112 1y ago> “The outbound and cross-bound DDoS attacks can be just as disruptive as the inbound stuff,” Dobbin said. “We’re now in a situation where ISPs are routinely seeing terabit-per-second plus outbound attacks from their networks that can cause operational problems.” ISPs are starting to feel the pain, so perhaps in the near future they will do something about it.
- dloy 1y agoPerhaps, or perhaps not. Maybe if we held them accountable they would?
- kibbel 1y agoA large part of the article is dedicated to this, noting how disruptive it is to other services and customers, and listing a few countermeasures (detection and blocking at the ISP level, detection and blocking at the router level, and educating customers on not buying vulnerable IoT trash).
- Groxx 1y agoNot really? At best it's "DDOS prevention sellers are having trouble" and "ISPs say they're doing fine". The vast majority of the article is talking about the various kinds of malware causing this, and how some have been "fixed" by stopping the individuals running it (which clearly doesn't work very well, new ones just fill the void). Or this: >“The crying need for effective and universal outbound DDoS attack suppression is something that is really being highlighted by these recent attacks,” Dobbins continued. “A lot of network operators are learning that lesson now, and there’s going to be a period ahead where there’s some scrambling and potential disruption going on.” Uh. No. That's gross negligence if they are only starting to think about it now - the trend has been clear for over a decade, and the IoT threat has been obvious since day 1 and even blasted over public news for the past few years. Their status is pretty much only one of: incompetent, malicious, or they have had plans but haven't acted on them fast enough or strongly enough for [some reason], and that reason isn't something I've seen. Surprises happen, prevention costs money and time, and there are plenty of reasons why everyone isn't already prepared for everything, so I think "incompetent or malicious" is pretty rare.... but what are those reasons?
- MartijnBraam 1y agoThis does happen, but it seems to depend on the ISP. In the Netherlands I've seen ISPs block the internet connectivity when they've detected infected devices, sometimes they send a letter before blocking and some ISPs seem to dump your internet connection in a captive portal. In all these cases it's been enough to call the ISP after finding the problem and you're connected again minutes later.
- TZubiri 1y ago> They can then turn around and lambast / sue / etc the company that sold it, putting pressure on the source of the problem Or just unplug the culprit. But the key seems to be that the device continues working. Ideally you would just shutdown or disconnect the device. If fridge is infected, the fridge can still fridge, but it no longer has internet privileges.
- quantummagic 1y agoAny device that participates in a DDOS needs to be recalled by the manufacturer, mandated by law. Make it potentially economically crippling to sell a vulnerable device, and security will be taken very seriously. Frivolous uses of tech, won't be worth the risk.
- DaSHacka 1y agoThis just in: every computer manufacturer forced to recall every single computer model they've ever sold because some users use weak passwords. I can't wait for all of them to switch to IOS-ified devices incapable of installing alternative operating systems or programs, as that would be the inevitable end solution for all these manufacturers if this was implemented.
- quantummagic 1y agoMaybe that's a good thing; relying on users to choose good passwords is a cop-out. Systems should be safe-by-default. And owners losing their system if it participates in a DDOS, would add to the incentives to stop the nonsense. It persists because perpetrators, and those who unwittingly abet them, feel no consequences.
- DaSHacka 1y agoAt that point, you should force the pain on the individual themselves. Why should all of us be handicapped because there's a couple morons that can't set decent passwords and connect their devices directly to the internet? Even if the device removed the capability for passwords and used key based authentication, connecting it directly to the internet means if there's ever a vulnerability, all that was for naught anyway.
- martinald 1y agoThis really is a function of two things: 1) (Mainly) the huge increase in upstream capacity of residential broadband connections with FTTH. It's not uncommon for homes to have 2gbit/sec up now and certainly 1gbit/sec is fairly commonplace, which is an enormous amount of bandwidth compared to many interconnects. 10, 40 and 100gbit/sec are the most common and a handful of users can totally saturate these. 2) Many more powerful IoT devices that can handle this level of attack outbound. A $1 SoC can easily handle this these days. 3) Less importantly, CGNAT is a growing problem. If you have 10k (say) users on CGNAT that are compromised, it's likely that there's at least 1 on each CGNAT IP. This means you can't just null route compromised IPs as you are effectively null routing the entire ISP. I think we probably need more government regulation of these IoT devices. For example, having a "hardware" limit of (say) 10mbit/sec or less for all networking unless otherwise required. 99% all of them don't need more than this.
- devwastaken 1y ago1gb upload is extraordinarily rare.
- saagarjha 1y agoIt’s not; most places that give you gigabit fiber will give you a symmetric connection.
- vitaflo 1y agoMost places do not have fiber.
- Dylan16807 1y agoWe know. The problem is that the above comment said "extraordinarily rare" which is a very different and incorrect threshold.
- ls612 1y agoThis is probably technically true but very misleading. Fiber penetration in the US has been consistently rising for over a decade now and it is not at all uncommon to have either Google Fiber, Fios, or a local fiber provider available to you in a big city. I bet within the next decade most places will have gigabit fiber available.
- spatley 1y agoSeems pretty clear that the US needs strict regulation on any device connecting to the internet. * no default password * * no login if not on the local wifi or wired ethernet *
- dehrmann 1y agoI'd rather the industry standardizes on some sort of guest network and proxy/hub. It could even ship with hardware from ISPs. Separating the network buys you a lot of security, and running everything through a proxy makes it easier to inspect data and creates a standard hook for using abandonware.
- DaSHacka 1y agoMany manufacturers are already moving there of their own accord. I really don't think we'd need some legislation to fix this problem.
- Eji1700 1y agoEhhh I can see it. The right attack at the right time could directly or indirectly kill people, and that’s ignoring the fact it can cause economic havoc. Having the entire internet function on a “pay or be nuked” threshold that could easily get much worse if companies like cloudflare become less ethical (not that they’re saints).
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- bikelang 1y agoAre there any practical ways to monitor my home network traffic and detect if any devices on my network are compromised?
- userbinator 1y agoYour ISP should give you a bandwidth usage meter.
- skinner927 1y agoHaha. My ISP barely gives me an Internet connection
- dylan604 1y agoYou can rest assured your ISP can produce the graph. If your graph reaches a certain shape, they'll start shaping your traffic for you to something they prefer all while charging you the normal rate.
- tylerflick 1y agoNot sure about monitoring, but I always put any device I don’t trust on a jailed LAN/AP.
- bentcorner 1y agoA lot of home routers will give you a traffic graph - if yours doesn't you can either find one that does or flash/build one. I currently run opnsense which has an ok graph out of the box, I haven't fiddled with it to see if there's something fancy I could do here. I also used to use IPFire which was slightly clunkier but had a nicer usage graph.
- butlike 1y agoAren't cisco machines compromised by default by design? I imagine all of them are at this point. I wouldn't worry too much about it.
- lgeek 1y agoThis is very challenging, in about one year the biggest recorded DDoS attack has increased from 5 Tbps to almost 30. Almost all of the DDoS mitigation providers have been struggling for a few weeks because they just don't have enough edge capacity. And normal hosting companies that are not focused on DDoS mitigation also seem to have had issues, but with less impact to other customers as they'll just blackhole addresses under larger attacks. For example, I've seen all connections to / from some of my services at Hetzner time out way more frequently than usual, and some at OVH too. Then one of my smaller hosting providers got hit with an attack of at least 1 Tbps which saturated a bunch of their transit links. Cloudflare and maybe a couple of the other enterprise providers (Gcore?) operate at a large enough scale to handle these attacks, but all the smaller ones (who tend to have more affordable rates and more application-specific filters for sensitive applications that can't deal with much leakage) seem to be in quite a bad spot right now. Cloudflare Magic Transit pricing supposedly starts at around $4k / month, and it would really suck if that became the floor for being able to run a non-HTTP service online. Something like Team Cymru's UTRS service (with Flowspec support) could potentially help to mitigate attacks at the source, but residential ISPs and maybe the T1s would need to join it, and I don't see that happening anytime soon.
- TZubiri 1y agoI'm surprised that the best response to ddos is not blocking traffic, but just handling it.
- BobaFloutist 1y ago> has increased from 5 Tbps to almost 30 That's nearly a pint, or over 2 daL!
- koakuma-chan 1y agoBig botnet has nothing better to do than DDoS Minecraft servers?
- shermantanktop 1y agoThis is what I wonder. Must be fascinating to engineer such a massive distributed system, but at some point there’s no added value from another bazillion hosts in the network.
- thenthenthen 1y ago…to sell ddos protection to the minecraft server admins, basically extortion.
- dylan604 1y agowhat about as an demonstration of their capabilities for someone else?
- crummy 1y agoI guess if they go after bigger targets they draw unwanted attention? Seemed odd to me too.
- userbinator 1y agoI'd rather there be periodic DDoS attacks, than a locked-down highly-regulated internet. Don't forget that infamous Franklin quote, and what Stallman has been warning us about for the past few decades. I can already see the authoritarians salivating every time something like this happens.
- dylan604 1y ago> I can already see the authoritarians salivating every time something like this happens. Tinfoil hat theory says they do this intentionally so that the users demand stricter access willingly. Always better to have someone think it is their idea
- Bender 1y agoMy tinfoil body-suit suggests this is how CDN's came to be. People's websites were hammered and extorted indirectly by friends of insert CDN startup here. The tin-foil body-suit also suggests the end goal was to hover up all the data and sell it to the government and/or the highest bidder.
- kylecarbs 1y ago9gigsofram was prolific in the "Minecraft Server era" (2010-2016). Source: Server Owner's Chat
- qiqitori 1y ago[flagged]
- zdw 1y agoThis doesn't seem very loving.
- rectang 1y ago> “The problem is, even if those infected IoT devices are rebooted and cleaned up, they will still get re-compromised by something else generally within minutes of being plugged back in.” In the year 2025, we should understand that such devices are defective. They should become bricks and companies that continue to sell such defective merchandise should fail.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- fukka42 1y agoAbsolutely not. They should be patched and fixed.
- rectang 1y agoSo they get to ship a dangerous device that harms innocent third parties because they cut corners, but we’re supposed to reward them by doing the work to secure the devices they couldn’t be bothered with?
- danparsonson 1y agoPatched and fixed by the manufacturer, was surely what GP was suggesting. Bricking the devices doesn't punish the supplier as much as it punishes the consumers.
- rectang 1y agoMany of the companies that sold these devices have already bitten the dust, so they aren't even around to fix anything.
- dylan604 1y agoJust wait 6 months, and the IoT vendor will go out of business and shut down the cloud servers which will effectively brick the device.
- unit149 1y ago[dead]
- sreekanth850 1y agoNo evidence, just a wild guess, Aisuru might be tied to DDoS mitigation folks.
- old_bayes 1y ago"A spokesperson for Comcast responded, 'Currently our network is not experiencing impacts and we are able to handle the traffic.'" In other words, attacks coming from our own IP's are not our problem ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
- cynicalsecurity 1y agoIsn't OVH known for offering relatively good anti-DDoS services? Why did they boot them?
- burnt-resistor 1y agoISPs should be regulated to require alerting and disconnecting users with compromised devices. Furthermore, device manufacturers should be regulated and held accountable for comprised devices. This also implies forbidding sale of noncompliant devices, which requires regulation of platforms and logistics supply chains to prevent counterfeit and dangerous goods from being sold.
- thoughtsyntax 1y agoOur smart homes are becoming dumb weapons in the wrong hands.