8 ms·
Regarding the Compact
- smrtinsert 1y agoIs there any precedent in US history for what the administration is asking of the nations top universities? Incredible they have to deal with this.
- hexis 1y agoYes, the federal government of the United States has always attached conditions to federal funding.
- laidoffamazon 1y agoNot like this, no, and it has never shaken down schools like it has at Columbia or Harvard. As much as I despise these institutions and their undergrads this does nothing to punish them and everything to increase the power of this current corrupt executive.
- bee_rider 1y agoWhy specifically the undergrads?
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- laidoffamazon 1y agoThey hate the rest of us that didn’t get into elite schools and are permanent members of the upper caste of this country. Graduate school admission is more purely meritocratic on if you can do research but even that isn’t great.
- fedsocpuppet 1y agoIs this like a humiliation fetish at this point? This is seriously unhealthy. We don't hate our friends that didn't a go to an eLiTe school because we're not sociopaths. Not sure why I'm even trying since you seem pretty dead set on this, but it's just a lot easier to go through life without made up enemies.
- laidoffamazon 1y agoPeople that go to elite undergrads think the rest of us are a lower inferior caste. I don’t know how that’s even something you can deny. You’ve clearly expended a lot of effort to segregate yourself from the likes of people like me or people that go to SJSU because we don’t have “merit” or “potential”
- fedsocpuppet 1y agoI can deny it because it's obvious bullshit lol. I don't think that way and neither does anybody I know from MIT think that way. This is reality versus your imagination. If there's anyone I look down on it's my classmates who could've worked anywhere and still went to palantir... I can't claim 100% aren't assholes, but the vast majority realize the luck and arbitrary nature of it. Are you going to be stuck in decision day sadness mode for the rest of your life? Life is too short
- laidoffamazon 1y agoI've asked people at MIT this repeatedly. They all say they came to MIT for the peer group. Peer group = people that are not _like me_. They shut up quick when I challenge them on that point though, or ask what the difference between them and me is. Even the non-assholes sometimes genuinely don't realize there's an entire parallel world beneath them with zero privilege or respect that made $150k out of undergrad instead of $500k.
- pastel8739 1y ago
- dragonwriter 1y ago> Yes, the federal government of the United States has always attached conditions to federal funding. Sure, but that's a very high level of abstraction. At a lower level, it is far less common (if precedented at all) for the federal executive to attempt to unilaterally impose conditions that violate the Federal Constitution and would require those subject to the conditions to violate federal civil rights law.
- ReptileMan 1y agoDear Colleague letter.
- magnio 1y agoWhile the current climate is not comparable, I find the actions and general attitude of the current US government similar to that during the McCarthy era. Which led me to this very interesting article from 1965: https://www.thecrimson.com/article/1965/6/17/the-university-in-the-mccarthy-era/ https://www.thecrimson.com/article/1965/6/17/the-university-... In it, the author described the attacks on specific personnels and public villainification of Harvard. More tellingly though, the author wrote the article for students in the 60s, who, growing up a mere decade after, most likely considered the events "an aberration which could not have lasted", and that, "the whole [McCarthy] period has an air of unreality". Those who did not know history are bound to repeat it. Unfortunately, no amount of textbooks and historical resources seems to be sufficient to impart lessons to subsequent generations, and we are bound to repeat it after a few cycles.
- DrewADesign 1y agoAssuming lack of knowledge is the reason authoritarian tendencies show up periodically dismisses the fact that a lot of people think it’s a good thing. There were neo nazis right after wwii. They didn’t forget — they wanted it.
- 01HNNWZ0MV43FF 1y agoYeah that worries me. The Nazi party ended on paper, the flags were taken down, but there is no military defeat that really changes the minds of the losing faction. They just went covert, stopped saying the quiet part, and waited.
- esseph 1y agoWe won the war but never learned as a group how to handle the ideological problems.
- DrewADesign 1y agoThat feels oversimplified. A lot of people would think people that oppose Nazis are the ones with the ideological problems. Who defines what a problem is in our society? The majority or some skewing of it. This is the problem that politics is supposed to solve, and then the problem that the electoral college was supposed to safeguard against. How do we avoid the tyranny of a demented majority? Aligning to a specific moral code? … like a theocracy? I can’t think of any way that doesn’t immediately instill the tyranny of a minority in its place. We in the US have been very arrogant in assuming we’ve found the solution to all this when all it took was a few decades — a flash-in-the-pan, really — of consistent, strategic bad faith by the political rulers to undermine the whole thing.
- NoImmatureAdHom 1y agoYes, the Biden Administration's promulgation of a Title IX interpretation that, among other things, would have compelled certain kinds of speech: https://speechfirst.org/case/title-ix/ https://speechfirst.org/case/title-ix/ One example of many: it would have been a punishable offense to refuse to use someone's preferred pronouns.
- 01HNNWZ0MV43FF 1y agoAre you injured if you can't misgender someone?
- NoImmatureAdHom 1y agoCompelled speech is a bright line the U.S. has, so far, managed not to cross. We should be trying as hard as we can not to cross that line. You may not see the harm in this particular instance, but establishing "we'll just force them to say it and punish them if they don't" as a tool in any government's toolbox is a very, very bad idea.
- dem_bones 1y ago[flagged]
- kjksf 1y agoYes, to the extent that any violation of constitution injures me. Forcing me to say things I don't want to say under threat of punishment violates first amendment. It's been litigated and so concluded. The fact that it's the 1st amendment indicates that founding fathers thought that it is indeed the greatest injury us government can inflict on us citizens.
- throwup238 1y ago> The fact that it's the 1st amendment indicates that founding fathers thought that it is indeed the greatest injury us government can inflict on us citizens. By that argument the greatest injury that they were addressing was a weak central government that couldn’t provide for the security and financing of the state. It’s literally called the first amendment because the Bill of Rights was an addendum to the constitution.
- boplicity 1y agoRemember, fascism is not an ideology or philosophical idea. It is a system of government. Gaining control of academia is a core part of this system. I applaud MIT for standing up to this. I hope the other universities involved also resist. We'll see.
- zamadatix 1y ago> I hope the other universities involved also refuse to resist I think you may have meant "refuse and resist" (or something similar) in your comment, based on the first half.
- boplicity 1y agoSorry! Fixed!
- tencentshill 1y agoThe nine universities include: Vanderbilt University Dartmouth College the University of Pennsylvania the University of Southern California Massachusetts Institute of Technology the University of Texas at Austin the University of Arizona Brown University the University of Virginia
- laidoffamazon 1y agoI didn’t realize UA was here - even UVA and UT as more egalitarian institutions are a weird set to include.
- etchalon 1y agoUT is, for better or worse, still in Texas. And Texas has yet to discover a Trump/MAGA initiative it doesn't embrace.
- runako 1y agoThis is a motley list. I am guessing the criteria for inclusion was an administration staffer (or their offspring) was not able to secure admission.
- svat 1y agoContext (as I didn't know about this earlier): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Compact_for_Academic_Excellence_in_Higher_Education https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Compact_for_Academic_Excellenc... (current version: https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Compact_for_Academic_Excellence_in_Higher_Education&oldid=1316104606 https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Compact_for_Acade...). I liked the “These values and other MIT practices meet or exceed many standards outlined in the document you sent” line.
- etchalon 1y agoWhat a ridiculous document.
- cs702 1y ago> The document also includes principles with which we disagree, including those that would restrict freedom of expression and our independence as an institution. And fundamentally, the premise of the document is inconsistent with our core belief that scientific funding should be based on scientific merit alone. > In our view, America’s leadership in science and innovation depends on independent thinking and open competition for excellence. In that free marketplace of ideas, the people of MIT gladly compete with the very best, without preferences. Therefore, with respect, we cannot support the proposed approach to addressing the issues facing higher education.
- runako 1y agoIn a way, the overreach in the compact made this an obvious (though not easy) decision. Obviously, an independent university cannot agree to government-mandated pricing or censorship of faculty members. Similarly, government intrusion into grading practices and proactively threatening to use "lawful force" against minors are immediately off the table. That's all aside from the practicality of ongoing assessment, which would likely require something akin to commissars to monitor speech and discussions around grading. The universities are fortunate the administration is not more subtle.
- wavemode 1y ago> threatening to use "lawful force" against minors What's the context here?
- runako 1y agoThe text of the Compact: > Signatories commit to using lawful force if necessary to prevent these violations and to swift, serious, and consistent sanctions for those who commit them. Many students enter college as minors, so this is asking colleges to commit to using force against minors while only talking about hypothetical events.
- dem_bones 1y agoWhat's wrong with that? They're still covered by the law.
- runako 1y agoI'll make it simple in a few steps: 1. Many people have an aversion to harming children. This aversion is not universally shared, but it is a very common stance nonetheless. Children, especially, tend to have an aversion to being harmed. 2. Universities need to recruit children to leave their families and be governed by them (e.g. housing, food, etc.). 3. Parents of children are required to get approval for those children to go to the universities, so that the universities can function. 4. It is harder to recruit children to a university that has agreed that in vague circumstances it is ready to harm them. Note here that everyone already knows that there are sanctions for breaking the law, and that the university is advertising that it is willing to go above and beyond normal law enforcement procedures in hurting children. Does that clarify?
- periodjet 1y agoThis seems like a reasonable response by MIT. I’m struggling to understand where the core disagreement lies though. Would someone who is opposed to this “compact” care to explain their view? I’m not interested in baseless name-calling (“fascist” etc) but I am interested in cogent reasoning. I didn’t read the compact itself, but I did read the wikipedia article about it, and it seems to be a very positive set of criteria (safeguarding individuality and merit, protecting against the formation of ideological monoculture, protecting against hostile nation-state actors, etc) It’s bizarre actually, because these institutions should be doing all of these things already. I don’t know what to make of the fact that they aren’t.
- mtalantikite 1y agoRegardless of what is in the compact, it's important that our educational institutions have independence to run themselves as they see fit. To make funding conditional to a set of demands by the government takes away that independence.
- jtbayly 1y agoHe who pays the piper... This is why a couple of conservative schools don't accept any sort of federal money. Liberal schools might be considering doing the same. Otherwise, yes, an independent school can do what they want. If you want to be truly independent, you have to be willing to walk away from the money. Anybody that gives money can attach conditions to it, including the government.
- kjksf 1y agoThat is obviously the case that federal money comes with strings and strings curtail independence. What you seem to imply that there should be no strings. Which is a position you can have but it has never been the case. To wit, one of the things this compact wants is an enforcement of civil rights act and Biden admin did the same thing: > The most important stipulation during the Biden administration attached to federal funding for universities was compliance with Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964. This law prohibits discrimination based on race, color, or national origin in any program or activity receiving federal financial assistance, including discrimination against Jewish students through antisemitic harassment or hostility on campus. Universities that fail to adequately address such issues risk federal investigations by the Department of Education's Office for Civil Rights (OCR) and potential loss of funding. > Following the October 7, 2023, Hamas attack on Israel and subsequent campus protests, the administration opened over 100 Title VI investigations into universities for alleged antisemitic discrimination—more than in the entire previous four years combined. This included guidance like a May 2024 "Dear Colleague" letter to colleges outlining examples of prohibited conduct, such as denying Jewish students equal access to education or tolerating harassment.
- dartharva 1y agoFrom MIT's financials (https://facts.mit.edu/operating-financials/ https://facts.mit.edu/operating-financials/): Operating Revenue: $5.07B, out of which - Federal funding (sponsored support): $2.30B Operating Costs: $4.78B, out of which - Sponsored research expenditure: $2.10B Additionally, they seem to have $24.57B worth of endowed funds and get gifts and pledges of net ~$0.6B every year. Looks like they can wane off their dependence on federal funding if only they tried. They don't have to deal with idiot politicians.
- kjksf 1y agoIn theory they could but in practice they don't want to. No company wants to loose $2B a year of free money. Suddenly loosing 45% of revenues would be devastating. And yes, MIT is a company. They have a CEO (under a different name), a board of directors, thousands of employees and they provide a service for a fee. No one that works for MIT wants to loose that money. Not CEO, not board of directors, not employees. Maybe they'll put ideology first and $2B second but I doubt it.
- dekhn 1y agoEndowed funds are restricted- the donors can place constraints on how they are spent. They are not fungible and cannot reliably used to pay for a wide range of things that are currently paid for by federal funding. Personally I would love to see the richest people in the nation contribute a lot more to universities in the form of unrestricted funds, to give these universities some options when it comes to being dependent on federal funding. But I guess you don't get rich by giving unrestricted funds to universities.
- pastel8739 1y agoI really find it surprising how often people bring up endowments as if they are a resource that can be spent. The purpose of an endowment is to produce revenue via investment income; that investment income is already reflected in the operating revenue under "Investment return to operations". MIT cannot and should not spend their endowment beyond this investment income; doing so would jeopardize the long-term viability of MIT.
- NoImmatureAdHom 1y agoI am affiliated and have been affiliated with several top universities, including the two in Cambridge, MA. I'm an academic. I say that because this stuff directly affects my career prospects. The Compact itself can be found here: https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/10/Compact-for-Academic-Excellence-in-Higher-Education-10.1.pdf https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/1... It's short, I ask that you read it before commenting. It's too bad MIT has taken this stance. I think the Compact is overall an obviously reasonable, good-faith effort to improve universities in the United States. The one area I'd change a bit is the specific mention of "conservative" ideas: "...purposefully punish, belittle, and even spark violence against conservative ideas." It's entirely fair because these universities do purposefully punish, belittle, and even spark violence against conservative ideas. But it's not what I'd want in such a document because next time around it could be "liberal" ideas, or "communist" ideas, or... Everything else seems on the nose. I would hasten to remind you that the threat is not "we'll force you to do this stuff", it is "if you want federal funding, you'll do this stuff". Which seems fine to me. Much of the document is merely trying to actually enforce the Civil Rights Act of 1964.
- bananapub 1y ago> obviously reasonable, good-faith effort to improve universities in the United States I really find HN to be a truly surreal place at this time.
- BrokenCogs 1y agoDon't underestimate the wealthy and their moral ambivalence
- NoImmatureAdHom 1y agoI think you probably don't understand just how batshit crazy universities had gotten.
- wrs 1y agoThe purpose of a university is to expand knowledge, which is itself not a “conservative idea”. A university that can’t “belittle” obviously false ideas like “the earth is flat” or “evolution isn’t real” or “the climate isn’t changing” just because they’re popular with whoever’s calling themselves “conservatives” at the time is not capable of functioning. You’re picking out the quote that reveals the entire document for what it really is, and choosing to ignore it.
- nis0s 1y agoThis tells you who really wears the pants in the relationship. Western nations are screwed because their bedrock is enlightenment, but their adversaries have no such ideals to be held up to. The rule of law that many such organizations enjoy in the West would be denied to them in places their faculty members defend. It’s important to reflect on what works well while trying to fix what doesn’t; discourse often neglects or downplays the former.
- necovek 1y agoWho are these adversaries you speak of? How have they attacked the US of A? As an example, for a long time, spiritual and scientific enlightement was the calling card of the Warszaw pact countries: they just couldn't figure out how to earn money off it (free university education and intensive scentific curiculums in primary and high schools were common). For China today, they are thoroughly convinced they are doing the same by restricting access to "bad information" (like "Western nations" are now starting to do with eg. porn, and did similar stuff with "fake news" during the pandemic) — the difference being that they did figure out how to earn money while doing that. In the Middle East, people die and kill in the name of their version of "enlightenment". Now, not saying there never was any enlightenment in the Western world, but it was built on slavery, exploitation and being first to many an industrial improvement (like using coal or oil to drive progress, that the whole world now suffers for). Yes, I'd rather live in a "Western" country than any of the "adversaries", but they are only a risk to our way of life if we do not believe it is the right, enlightened way. Because if it is, we are willing to pay for it. Are we?
- nis0s 1y ago> Yes, I'd rather live in a "Western" country than any of the "adversaries" It’s important to reflect on why you say this because when push comes to shove, the moral relativism rings a hollow tone. The preceding parts of your post are just part of the education instilled in you from having been exposed to enlightenment-influenced frameworks.
- necovek 1y ago
- dem_bones 1y agoIt sounds like MIT basically agrees with the Compact except for a few minor details. Unfortunate they didn't quote any specifics on what these are.
- aquova 1y agoI think they completely disagree with the entire document, this is as kindly worded but complete rejection as they could make it.
- dem_bones_ 1y agoMost of the document seems reasonable though.
- aquova 1y agoRegardless of what's even in the document, the core issue is the administration effectively attempting to punish universities who do not agree to whatever standards they dictate. Not because anything actually against any enacted state or federal law, or even standards set out for every university, but based on policies the executive can arbitrarily decide for a handful of schools. That's why you're seeing such push back. As for the document itself, it's a bit of a mixed bag, with a lot of subtle gatchas to make it sound enticing on the surface, but more sinister the closer you look. I honestly like some of the proposed tuition changes, but there's some language regarding enrollment that I find problematic. However, since the whole thing is being given to them with the threat of a knife hanging over their head, you're going to see a lot of universities be opposed to this.
- BrokenCogs 1y agoDoes it? The entire Compact document is contradictory. "We don't want diversity initiatives unless they benefit the white American and conservative thought." "We want only the best and brightest to be let in, unless they are foreign or female." MIT is clearly rejecting it diplomatically
- 1y ago
- anonymousiam 1y agoBecause nobody (including the link from president.mit.edu) included the text of the Compact, I'm linking it here: https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/10/Compact-for-Academic-Excellence-in-Higher-Education-10.1.pdf https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/1... After a quick skim, I don't see an issue. Is the opposition to this based upon any rational argument, or is it just "Resist Trump"?
- mostlysimilar 1y agoGovernment forcing institutions to conform to a specific ideology. > Signatories commit themselves to revising governance structures as necessary to create such an environment, including but not limited to transforming or abolishing institutional units that purposefully punish, belittle, and even spark violence against conservative ideas. > Institutions commit to defining and otherwise interpreting “male,” “female,” “woman,” and “man” according to reproductive function and biological processes.
- benjaminsky2 1y agoI read the whole thing. Seems pretty fair to me, including the section prohibiting discrimination against conservative ideas. With all the coverage I expected something crazy.