5 ms·
> Soon, McDowell told us, there will be up to 5 satellite reentries per day Starlink’s next-generation V3s, which will require Starship to launch, weigh in aro
by JumpCrisscross 1y ago
> Soon, McDowell told us, there will be up to 5 satellite reentries per day
Starlink’s next-generation V3s, which will require Starship to launch, weigh in around 2 metric tonnes [1]. (They’re currently “around 260 and 310 kilograms” [2].)
“Every day, Earth is bombarded with more than 100 tons [91 metric tons] of dust and sand-sized particles” [3]. So we’re talking about a 2 to 10% increase in burn-up by mass. (Not accounting for energy, which natural burn-up has more of, or incomplete burn-up, which reduces the atmospheric effects of artificial mass.)
Broadly speaking, we don’t seem to be in a problematic place in respect of the atmosphere. Where improvement may be required is in moving from splashdown, where we sink space junk in the ocean, to targeted recovery.
[1] https://starlink-stories.cdn.prismic.io/starlink-stories/Z3QOWJbqstJ986KD_StarlinkProgress-V11_Low-Res-compressed.pdf https://starlink-stories.cdn.prismic.io/starlink-stories/Z3Q...
[2] https://www.teslarati.com/spacex-elon-musk-next-gen-starlink-satellite-details/ https://www.teslarati.com/spacex-elon-musk-next-gen-starlink...
[3] https://www.nasa.gov/solar-system/asteroids/asteroid-fast-facts/ https://www.nasa.gov/solar-system/asteroids/asteroid-fast-fa...
- Y-bar 1y agoAsking from a place of ignorance on my part, but does the chemical composition of the satellites versus asteroids/dust have any adverse effects?
- SoftTalker 1y agoThe satellites are mostly metal and silicon I would guess, not too different from asteroids.
- bwestergard 1y agoIf someone has the time, I'd love to see the total amount of lead added to the atmosphere by burning up satellites compared to the amount from other anthropogenic sources.
- adastra22 1y agoRough napkin math would be negligible impact. The amount of lead in a satellite is very small, if not actually zero. The amount of lead added by burning coal is about 30 tonnes per day.
- everforward 1y agoThere is almost definitely a small, negligible amount of lead in the solder in them. Eg NASA requires a small (single digit I think) percentage of lead to prevent tin whiskering.
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> almost definitely a small, negligible amount of lead in the solder in them Emphasis on negligible. Assuming 0.07 to 0.28 ppm lead [1] in meteoroids, space is dosing us with half to 2 kg a year [2]. [1] https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/001670376090079X https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/001670... [2] https://earthsky.org/space/tons-of-extraterrestrial-dust-fall-to-earth-each-year/#:~:text=Bottom%20line%3A,each%20year. https://earthsky.org/space/tons-of-extraterrestrial-dust-fal...
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- cubefox 1y agoI guess we can just read the article: > The researchers found particles containing the rare elements niobium and hafnium. They also found a significant number of particles contained copper, lithium and aluminum at concentrations far exceeding the abundance found in space dust.
- perihelions 1y agoIt's postulated that the high aluminum content of satellites (for perspective, Bennu samples are only 1% Al), as oxidized Al2O3 particles in the stratosphere, catalyze chemistry that destroys ozone. But that's far from a quantitatively meaningful problem, at the current scale. This source[0] says satellite reentries are about about 12% of the space industry's contribution to ozone depletion (the big one is chlorine from solid rockets), which in turn is 0.1% of the entire anthropogenic contribution; i.e. satellite reentries are ~0.01% of the total. https://www.space.com/spacex-starlink-reentry-pollution-damage-earth-atmosphere https://www.space.com/spacex-starlink-reentry-pollution-dama...
- schiffern 1y ago>0.01% of anthropogenic ozone depletion The sheer percentage increase in stratospheric AlO is still alarming.[0] Satellite reentries in 2022 (ie mostly pre-megaconstellation) were already raising stratospheric AlO levels by 29.5% above normal levels (with satellites adding 'only' 17 t/year), but megaconstellations could raise that to ~480% above natural levels (360 t/year). This isn't a rounding error, it's a non-trivial change in chemical composition across the entire globe, and effecting a complex and poorly-understood part of the climate system. What could go wrong? What else can this effect (as usual, discovered belatedly) beyond ozone? Hopefully it's nothing! But I guess we're gonna find out... [0] https://agupubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1029/2024GL109280 https://agupubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1029/2024GL10...
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> Satellite reentries in 2022 (mostly pre-megaconstellation) were already raising stratospheric AlO levels by 29.5% above normal levels Those findings are simulated, not observed. Hence "potential." > it's a non-trivial change in chemical composition over the entire globe, and effecting a complex and poorly-understood part of the climate system. What could go wrong? Perhaps a lot. Perhaps not much. It's a good question to study. But if this is an issue, it's solvable--carbon composite satellite structures could use a boost in demand and funding.
- 1y ago
- svmt 1y agoBloomberg ran a piece about this in March: https://www.bloomberg.com/graphics/2025-space-orbit-satellites-pollution/?accessToken=eyJhbGciOiJIUzI1NiIsInR5cCI6IkpXVCJ9.eyJzb3VyY2UiOiJTdWJzY3JpYmVyR2lmdGVkQXJ0aWNsZSIsImlhdCI6MTc1OTc3NDMzMCwiZXhwIjoxNzYwMzc5MTMwLCJhcnRpY2xlSWQiOiJTVkxQME5UMVVNMFcwMCIsImJjb25uZWN0SWQiOiI2QzJFRUEzQjg0NDc0NjIyOThDMTA4NjFDNUExNUUwNyJ9.vCAdj_kZrKPo-a-QyGCkXFXlX-ktK3Tymu3c3qg0nNw https://www.bloomberg.com/graphics/2025-space-orbit-satellit...
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- nicce 1y agoThere is a limit how much satellites LEO/GEO can hold unless every satellite has perfect dodging system. Called as Kessler syndrome [1], and one estimate is around 70k satellites. So it is a race who can get the most satellites orbiting, because after a certain point, there is no "space" anymore, and anyone who tries to launch after that point, will be blamed for destroying the satellites of the others. Winner takes all. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kessler_syndrome https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kessler_syndrome
- dgs_sgd 1y agoI’m just a layman, but why can’t they increase the orbital radius to solve this problem? Like, if the current “layer” is too full, have the new satellites orbit further out?
- nemomarx 1y agoLow orbit is how star link is able to achieve their connections, isn't it? I think of they moved to normal telecom orbit the performance would be like normal satellite internet too
- peterfirefly 1y agoThey originally planned to be about 1100km up. They are currently about 550km up. Plenty of possible layers in between... Another 500 km won't affect latency much. It'll be around 3 more ms per round trip.
- nemomarx 1y agoThat's not a bad latency addition, you're right. Good note
- parl_match 1y agovery simple explanation but there's a few issues radio bandwidth: higher frequencies travel a shorter distance and provide more bandwidth. so you get frequency contention and also you need your sats to be physically closer latency: the further a sat is, the higher the latency. not an issue for text messages. a huge issue for phone calls and general internet tasks. the further you "push" your sat "back", the worst the user experience is there's other issues too, like geostationary vs geosynchronous and coverage and exposure.
- wat10000 1y agoA 2-10% increase seems like a hell of a lot. Human CO2 emissions are well under 10% of natural CO2 emissions, and yet that additional amount has been enough to increase the atmospheric concentration of CO2 by over 50% and substantially alter the planetary climate. CO2 in the atmosphere is at a vastly larger scale than mass falling in from space, so that doesn't mean this is a problem, but that percentage certainly seems to indicate that the question should be studied further.
- ogig 1y agoI hear 10% increase on a global constant and that doesn't sound like peanuts. If we increase 10% each few years that might be a problem? I don't know anything about whatever field studies this but given that LEO constellations born yesterday even that 2% increase in stuff coming from the skyes sounds significant to me.
- JumpCrisscross 1y agoShort answer is we're still theorizing. Models suggest we might see accumulation. But we might not, or it might not accumulate at relevant altitudes. (Current LEO satellites burn up before hitting the ozone layer.)
- shizcakes 1y agoedit: okay I misunderstood what everyone meant
- organsnyder 1y agoI don't see anyone worrying about planetary mass. I'd be more concerned about atmospheric effects.
- palata 1y agoIs that what you say when you litter? "I don't see a problem with plastic in the ocean, it came from the Earth in the first place".
- lxgr 1y ago> please recall that the mass of de-orbiting man-made satellites came from the earth in the first place. Then again, so are CFCs, CO2, radioactive materials... Just because some elements naturally occur on Earth doesn't mean we're completely insensitive to where they end up. (That said, I have no idea if atmospheric Aluminium is actually a problem or not.)
- VBprogrammer 1y agoI was watching a video the other day which happened to mention that sodium lasers are used to create artificial stars, used for calibration of adaptive optics in ground based telescopes. This works because one particular layer of the upper atmosphere is rich in sodium due to impact with sodium rich debris. Obviously it requires a more scientific analysis but it does seem to me that burning a lot of shit on the atmosphere might be problematic.
- cowpig 1y agoWhy is a 2-10% increase a small amount? What increase would be too much?
- benjiro 1y ago> (They’re currently “around 260 and 310 kilograms” [2].) v1.5 is like 300kg, the v2.0 mini (ironic as its far from mini compared to its predecessors) are 800kg. The V3's are the one's that need StarShip to deploy. But the current launch platform can take 21x v2.0 Mini's per launch vs the 60x v1.5's they did before. Taking in account that the v2.0 Mini's are way more capably on a kg/capacity. And the tech keeps getting better. SpaceX does not really need Starship, that is more or less a bonus at this point.
- perihelions 1y ago> "SpaceX does not really need Starship, that is more or less a bonus at this point." Starship is the moat SpaceX needs to be developing today to stay ahead of where the Chinese competition will be in 5-10 years.
- skatingaway 1y agoMoats are for direct competition. China is not a competitor to spacex because the US government is spacex’s largest subsidy/customer. Put another way: nasa won’t be using Chinese rockets. Unless they bribe trump. Which could happen.
- marcus_holmes 1y agoNASA ended up using Russian rockets because the Space Shuttle program got politically awkward. There is definitely a world where they'd use Chinese rockets.
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> China is not a competitor to spacex because the US government is spacex’s largest subsidy/customer SpaceX has loads of international launch and connectivity customers. China undercutting SpaceX would significantly compromise its prospects.
- matthewdgreen 1y agoSee the first comment in this thread about aluminum oxide and the ozone layer. It’s not so much the amount, but what it is.