6 ms·
Mamdani says he would phase out NYC gifted program for early grades
- pinewurst 1y agohttps://archive.ph/ioSa4 https://archive.ph/ioSa4
- acjohnson55 1y agoBold move to take this stance when he would have caught very little heat for saying he wouldn't change anything. But I think he's right in that gifted education doesn't mean much in the earlier years. It mostly selects for children of means with anxious parents.
- deburo 1y agoI wouldn't based any policy based on people's opinion IMO. There has to be a cost/benefit study to base your decision on. Anyway kids can be pretty smart. It wouldn't surprise me to learn that this program is beneficial even that early in life.
- acjohnson55 1y agoOften times, educational programs are put in place without rigorous study, based on opinion. And the program design space is so large that it is hard to have a clear conclusion on an entire concept, like early gifted and talented programs. My perspective is that the mos important thing in the early grades are that kids are engaged and not being held back. But there are many ways to address this.
- afavour 1y agoPutting aside a second the debate about diversity... gifted and talented admission tests at four years old strikes me as far too young. Having witnessed my own children and their peers grow I simply don't believe that passing a test at Pre-K is a useful marker of some innate talent, rather it's clued-in parents making sure their kid is able to jump through required hoops.
- rayiner 1y agoIQ is pretty stable from preschool onward: https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/apa.16925 https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/apa.16925. Especially in identifying low and mid-IQ kids (i.e. people who won't benefit from gifted education).
- dmitrygr 1y agoThat is WHY gifted ed is being killed. Harrison Bergeron
- LUmBULtERA 1y agoThat paper, which follows 106 people born in Denmark from 1975 and 1979, says there may be correlation coefficients of 0.48 or 0.50 for IQ groupings between ages (1) 4 and (2) 14 and 44 years. 0.48^2 is 23%, 0.5^2=25%, so if you accept everything else about this, this would mean 23%-25% of variance in the older years may be explained by IQ at 4... that strikes me as not enough to make your conclusions ("IQ is pretty stable from preschool onward) even if the rest of the study is concluded to be accurate.
- dmitrygr 1y ago> Having witnessed my own children == "Having witnessed my own friends, I simply do not believe that people who can juggle exist." . Gifted kids exist. I see friends' kids who read at 4 and they absolutely do not need to be stuck in a class with kids who still chew on their toys. The fact that you have not seen those does not mean they do not exist. As a second example, I was able to read before I was 4 and multiply 2-digit numbers before I was 5. Luckily schools did have programs that challenged me. I would have been much less lucky, had I been a kid in Mamdani's NYC...
- wbl 1y agoI mean many of the kids who read at that age do chew things still.
- 1y ago
- 57986422798542 1y ago[flagged]
- limpbizkitfan 1y agoYeah this is reasonable, they really shouldn’t sort kids for opportunities in early grades. Instructors shouldn’t have to focus on whether or not a kid needs more opportunity but on the kids who are falling behind; kids who are falling behind shouldn’t be treated as defects
- borski 1y agoThe kids who aren't falling behind but are bored often eventually fall behind, because they did not have enough opportunities to grow and explore. It's not only those who are failing that need help. (And I agree they shouldn't be treated as defects) But gifted kids do exist, and they have all sorts of existential questions and concerns that other kids don't tend to worry themselves about. Unaddressed, these kids end up miserable, depressed, and anxious... which is why it's important to pay attention to them too. Whether Kindergarten is the right age is a different question, but to imply that only those failing need help is simply untrue. Individualized education would be ideal, but close to impossible, for obvious reasons.
- slackfan 1y agoA classic "but are you brave enough to hate the poor" move.
- philipallstar 1y ago> which became a symbol of segregation in public schools I cannot believe NYT readers would fall for such partisan editorialising.
- John23832 1y agoSomeone has read Outliers[0] obviously. I personally don't think that it is a big deal. Giving kids until 3rd grade to actually "settle" and demonstrate ability is a good idea. Equal opportunity until we can decide as a society who is eligible for "more practice". Though, in reality, the rich and able will give their children more practice regardless, so they will reap more of the Gifted and Talented slots when the time comes anyways. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Outliers_(book) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Outliers_(book)
- greenie_beans 1y agomy mom taught gifted education. what they teach to gifted kids should be taught to every student
- borski 1y agoNot every student could absorb it at that level. And that’s okay.
- greenie_beans 1y agodepends on the age, but hard disagree!
- borski 1y agoOh, I agree that at some age most kids can learn most things. What we’re talking about is learning some things much earlier than peers, and not all kids can do that; there are some kids who are simply accelerated in terms of learning, and if “unfed” that drive can quickly die.
- greenie_beans 1y agoi think we're on the same page there. my general thought is that all kids are capable of learning about different ways of thinking, which is what gifted education is all about. at what age level is a different issue. from my memory, my mom taught units on photography, civil rights history, problem solving, reasoning, creative writing, deconstructing things to make something new, etc. i think most, if not all, students are able to grasp those things, though maybe that's my bias as somebody who got that sort of teaching both at home and in public school. sadly, all the non-gifted students only got the rote lessons that prepared them for standardized testing, but i suspect average students would maybe enjoy more school more if they had a more gifted-like education. gifted kids aren't the only ones who get bored by school.
- tsoukase 1y agoAgree, but usually the gifted kid can solve the problems one or two years earlier than the average one.
- jajuuka 1y agoThe weirdly feels like a "can you believe he said that" piece. But he's not wrong. Having a two tiered education system from kindergarden that favors one group over another does not lead to good educational outcomes across the board. Nothing wrong with gifted or AP programs, but when they start right away and seem to be favoring one group over another that's a problem. Ultimately this is a minor issue though. Nobody is voting for a mayor based on their view of a gifted student program.
- fleventynine 1y agoI don't know about gifted programs, but anything that separates kids who don't want to learn from those who do is a good thing; far to much time is wasted in America's schools catering to bad behavior.
- o11c 1y agoAt this age it's probably not even about "want to learn" or "bad behavior" but "is capable of reading fluently" vs "can't read at all". Clearly there's a middle ground, but that doesn't mean the extrema don't need to be separated.
- A4ET8a8uTh0_v2 1y agoThis. Frankly, it is aggravating if not depressing that it is somehow issue that should be considered at a national level. It is an issue that it even is an issue.
- jajuuka 1y agoI think you're missing the point. This isn't separating children on "willingness to learn" but based on race.
- o11c 1y agoPeople absolutely will vote against someone because who's running on a platform of anti-intellectualism. Whether Democrats will vote for someone because of anti-intellectualism is an open question, but it worked for Republicans, so it's feasible.
- aappleby 1y agoI was a profoundly gifted kid - taught myself to read just before I turned 2, was reading lord of the rings and the shannara books at 5, deathly bored in public school because my parents couldn't afford private. To claim that gifted children cannot be distinguished from their peers at a very young age is flat out wrong.
- turtlebits 1y agoWho is claiming that? This sounds totally reasonable - for younger kids I believe socialization and play is way important than academics.
- aappleby 1y agoOther people in this thread
- erulabs 1y agoNo 20 month old “teaches themselves to read”. I’m sure youre gifted and it’s obviously insane to join this discussion period (who am I to change your self identity) but today has been a day full of allowing too many delusional people to be delusional.
- aappleby 1y agoYou certainly don't have to believe me, but that's what happened according to my mother. My mother was busy with my twin sister and didn't have time to read to me, so I would take all the Berenstain Bears books and sit down on the couch and try to sound them out. After a few weeks of that I told my mother that I didn't need her help because I could read now. She didn't believe me and had me read some other children's books - turns out I could.
- bxsioshc 1y ago[dead]
- Jensson 1y agoThe hard part is making bureaucrats identify gifted kids, not to identify them yourself. To a bureaucrat a kid that learned a lot on his own and a kid that had a lot of personal mentors to help them learn are the same thing, so both get put in gifted class, but out of those the kid that already is getting help doesn't need more that kid is already getting what he needs. But it probably isn't bad to put smart kids together with mentored kids, matching smart with rich is a good way to help both sides.
- busterarm 1y agoI went through NYC's gifted program in early grades. I grew up on rent control and food stamps. My closest school when I started, before the gifted program, was spending the majority of its resources on special ed programs and barely functional. The gifted program allowed me to attend much better schools. The gifted program was also the basis of what allowed me to even interview to attend (and eventually test into) NYC private schools. Because of class I would not have had that opportunity otherwise. In fact, at first these schools didn't want to deal with me -- we had to be very persistent over a couple of years just to get me in. Before the gifted program I was years ahead of my peers and barely getting an education in school. It wasn't without problems, but it definitely created opportunities I benefit from today that I otherwise would not have had access to. Gifted Program is not just a cheat code for kids of parents with means. The parents of means are already sending their kids to private schools and gave up on the NYC public school system decades ago.
- evanmoran 1y agoIt’s this exactly. Gifted programs help many kids who wouldn’t have been able to access other options. If you close them rich people will simply go private, and the rest of the people who can’t afford 45k/year will be back where they started.
- jnwatson 1y agoSmart kids can be a distraction as well. It certainly would have benefitted me to enter G&T at Kindergarten instead of 3rd grade. Much of my first grade was spent separate from the other kids doing 5th grade workbooks.
- nis0s 1y agoThere’s not enough empathy for the gifted and talented weirdos who get bullied by their peers at a pre-school age for being differently abled. But I don’t know enough about the program in question to say whether or not it really was for gifted students, or just for those whose parents happened to pull some strings, regardless of the parent’s income or wealth status.
- borski 1y agoIt was a lifesaver. I went through it. I remember, distinctly, going from 'why am I here with all these other kids who just want to stare at the wall or play with G.I. Joes or stack rings' to an immense sense of relief when there was a bit more structure, a bit more freedom to choose what to do, etc. But more importantly, when I wanted to understand or ask about some existential question, my teacher didn't say "oh that's cute kid, don't worry about it, just go be a kid and play with your friends." They took me seriously, chatted with me through my questions, and treated me like I wasn't a complete idiot, even though I was a child. That made all the difference. And even more importantly, asking those questions didn't make me a pariah; instead, the other kids had those questions too, and we all learned from each other and grew. If this sounds a bit absurd, I assure you I knew it then; I literally wrote about it in my journal in second grade.
- tstrimple 1y agoMy experience both personally and via my children is it's little more than a few more worksheets during the week. There is very little actual teaching going on. Just segregation from peers and more busywork. I was personally distracted by new busywork for a while because it was at least different than what I was experiencing in class. But I didn't learn more because of it. The only real difference was in high school where you can take actual accredited college classes in place of class with the normies. Everything before that was just to distract us so we didn't interrupt "normal" classes with our boredom. After witnessing my wife work as a para-professional with special needs kids on a volunteer basis, the biggest thing anyone could do to improve overall educational achievements is to get them the fuck out of "normal" classrooms. There is very little reason for a non-verbal fourth grader to be taking classes with fourth grade "peers". While their presence may engender some empathy in fellow students, it is often the biggest distraction in the classroom and schools don't have the desire or resources to actually address special needs children in a way to not be disruptive. And I'd extend this further. It would be far better for everyone in this country if the bottom of the bottom was left behind (from an education, not a safety net standpoint) and the average could advance in pace with the more advanced students. And I say this as a flaming leftist. I have zero issues with additional funding being applied to help special needs children learn and adapt to the world as we have to experience it. But I have a major problem with the slowest of society dictating the educational attainment of the average (or above average) member of society. No Child Left Behind means we have to run at the pace of the biggest fucking moron in our class. It shouldn't just be exceptional children with engaged parents who are able to escape that.
- onetokeoverthe 1y ago[dead]
- burnt-resistor 1y agoObvious smear hit piece. But what are the delivered value of G&T programs to students? I never saw anything material from CA's GATE in the 80's-90's. Is NYC's program different? They seem like (probably not, but it's a risk) smart people inventorying programs but more likely they are bureaucratic money pile movers. In a bigger picture of something perhaps different, shouldn't we offer investment in the top ~1-3% of kids with alternative schools that don't hold back their potential that will likely ultimately benefit us? If we're not committed to developing, attracting, and retaining brains, then we're setting up a brain drain.
- ivanamies 1y ago>I never saw anything material from CA's GATE in the 80's-90's. N = 1, CA's GATE program in the 2000's changed my life. "Being special" was a powerful motivator for a younger version of myself. >shouldn't we offer investment in the top ~1-3% of kids with alternative schools that don't hold back their potential that will likely ultimately benefit us? N = 1, what I needed as a child was a more G&T version of CA's GATE. I responded best to competitive sports and long hours of math and science problems. I won't comment on NYC politics or the article.
- Cornbilly 1y agoPaywalled. What does the NYC gifted program entail at those ages? For myself growing up in rural middle America, gifted in elementary/Jr high school was just a special activity once a week, not really anything that separated me from my peers.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]