12 ms·
Wealth tax would be deadly for French economy, says Europe's richest man
- jonathantf2 1y agoThanksgiving would be deadly, says turkey
- vallejo 1y ago..nd there it is, turkey-brain. Just like that, back to knee-jerk binary [0,1].
- saubeidl 1y agoPutting away the cheese would be deadly for the economy, say local mice.
- chmod775 1y agoAfter spending months searching for a french citizen who could comment on this issue without any conflict of interest, we have finally located this man.
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago…you’re talking about The Guardian? This is rage bait.
- octopoc 1y agoDon’t billionaires normally buy newspapers, media and even politicians and let their voice be heard that way? By contrast this is refreshing, vulnerable and…kind of cute. Oh that all billionaires were this undevious.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- amelius 1y agoDoesn't have to be binary. Just make it like a volume knob. Turn it up, slowly, see what happens. If bad things happen, turn it back down.
- primitivesuave 1y agoIn this case, "bad things happening" is an exodus of the ultra wealthy, which is not so simple to reverse.
- chmod775 1y agoIf your economy is based on producing things of real value rather than management of wealth, this is a good thing.
- vorpalhex 1y agoHow do you think the money to produce things (buy machinery, front costs, etc) comes about?
- chmod775 1y agoComplete nonsense. You don't need ultra-wealthy for that. Also many vehicles for the less-wealthy to pool wealth exist.
- vorpalhex 1y agoLike what? What other funding methods exist? Do they work? What are their downsides?
- chmod775 1y agoDo you believe the vast majority of investment happens because someone like Elon Musk personally goes around to give every little venture money? Here's a non-exhaustive list of ways the wealth of multiple people can be pooled: creating a joint account, investment clubs, general/limited partnerships, LLCs, crowdfunding platforms, and syndicates (you're on the website of one right now). There's also government-backed pooling/funding vehicles and banks engaging in various forms of investment, funding, loans. Any existing corporation is also capable of investing themselves.
- Narann 1y ago> LVMH owner Bernard Arnault, who could take €1bn hit, says proposed 2% levy ‘aims to destroy liberal economy’ I don't know why what Bernard Arnault says is on HN, he has no competencies in economy. No dumb rich-hate here, simply that Bernard Arnault is definitely not best person to talk about the subject.
- freedomben 1y agoI don't know anything about him personally, but if he's that rich then I'm certain he has a highly paid team of extremely expert and well-informed people that are giving him his information. I take what he has to say with a grain of salt since he has such a massive self-interest in this, but still worthy of examining his arguments
- creer 1y agoTo argue that Bernard Arnault is clueless in economics is beyond absurd. He did not inherit this wealth. He did start with a family operating business, yes, but nowhere near his life result (and "the job" not even complete yet). He grew his group entirely in one generation - and so, yeah he has a pretty good grasp of economics. Biased, sure - like most of the french population where being opinionated is normal. Clueless, no.
- pphysch 1y ago"The economy" is a relative term that might as well be substituted for "my personal interests" in 99% of cases. Few people care about "the economy" writ large, they just care about their little corner of it. This applies to both rich and poor.
- sebastianconcpt 1y agoThe perfect functional synonym of tax is: Friction. Its understanding having proportion in mind is: How strongly you're breaking the economy.
- 0_____0 1y agoIf that's a pure and whole definition, then having no taxes at all would surely result in the best economy possible, yes?
- SAI_Peregrinus 1y agoOnly if this metaphorical friction is universally bad for an economy. There are lots of cases where real friction is quite necessary, such as the brakes on a vehicle. Metaphorical economic friction is also often useful & necessary, to prevent an economy from careening off a cliff.
- saubeidl 1y ago"Friction pays for infrastructure"? It's clearly not a synonym.
- sebastianconcpt 1y agoWould you say that you would actively resist or embrace understanding Austrian Economics before assigning weight value to your "clearly" there?
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> perfect functional synonym of tax is: Friction In the same way fundraising for a start-up is friction. Nations are exercises in economies of scale.
- guywithahat 1y agoTo be fair, France implemented a wealth tax in 1989 and it ended up costing them more in lost tax revenue than they raised. This is the story of most countries that implement a wealth tax (such as Netherlands, Sweden, etc), and is why they end up removing them. Not only do many consider them immoral, they tend to cost the government tax revenue and simply don't work.
- surgical_fire 1y agoThe Netherlands still has a wealth tax.
- riffraff 1y agoItaly implemented a wealth tax on investments (savings account, stocks, bonds) more than years ago, and it doesn't seem to have caused any loss in revenue. They tend to be removed because the richer people convince the poor they need to be removed.
- richwater 1y agoYea Italy's economy is doing great. /s
- hermitcrab 1y ago>they tend to cost the government tax revenue Is that actually true though? Or just something a mouthpiece of the wealthy has put out in some shonky report?
- guywithahat 1y agoYes, as far as I'm aware that was the primary motivation Macron had to remove the wealth tax in France, as with most other countries. The argument is even a small wealth tax is actually an astronomically high tax (a 2% wealth tax is approximately equal to an additional 50% capital gains tax), and so rich people are highly motivated to move their money out of the country or to a form of investment which isn't taxed. Wealth taxes tend to raise basically no money compared to what they wanted, and in return there is less investment in the country hurting the economy. https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2025-10-03/wealth-tax-in-france-uk-or-new-york-city-it-s-a-bad-idea https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2025-10-03/wealth... -> https://archive.ph/jhxzr https://archive.ph/jhxzr
- lefrenchy 1y agoI will take motivated reasoning for 300 Alex.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- bgwalter 1y agoThe usual argument at the bottom of the article "the wealthy will leave" only applies if you let them take their money with them. If you can sanction Russian oligarchs, you can sanction French people who got rich in France and then flee or move their money elsewhere. And that does not even include the number of rich families who own vast amounts of real estate which they cannot take with them. If the argument is "they'll increase the rent" then implement rent caps (and crack down on fake renters who run AirBnB ops or sublet).
- gred 1y ago> let them take their money with them The image of taxman as thief has never been clearer.
- myrmidon 1y agoIt seems clear to me that something needs to be done if we want to avoid growing wealth/income inequality pretty much globally. Wealth tax is just one approach, but even top income tax rates used to be much higher in the US, and you could argue that politicians since LBJ and Reagan have failed the median citizen completely in that regard (nice visualization: https://mystack.wyman.us/p/tax-brackets-and-rates-1913-2024 https://mystack.wyman.us/p/tax-brackets-and-rates-1913-2024). Wealth tax seems a step in the right direction.
- Retric 1y agoIncome taxes are heavily dependent on what’s classified as income. In the US we explicitly have a carve out for long term investment returns into a separation category making simple arguments around the top tax bracket irrelevant. Add some other deductions to what counts as income and sudden the rate becomes all but a joke.
- myrmidon 1y agoI do agree that sidestepping income taxes is too easy in the first place, but that is on legislators, too (and lowering those top tax brackets is just unhelpful in any case). I find the notion that you should pay less tax on capital gains asinine, too; it makes no sense to me that people should have to pay less tax on income that they didn't even work for. My belief is that people were blind to growing income inequality and flawed taxation schemes because there was enough growth to paper over the resulting issues, but this stops being the case. Specifically housing, I'd argue, has not become so expensive because of greedy construction workers (or immigrants, or regulation) but because average homeowners have to compete against an increasingly wealthy upper-class that sees real estate as a pure investment/rent extraction mechanism.
- hermitcrab 1y ago>It seems clear to me that something needs to be done if we want to avoid growing wealth/income inequality pretty much globally. World War II was pretty effective at redistributing income (among those that survived). Lets hope it doesn't take World War III.
- yardie 1y agoAs a former resident of France, here are the headlines I observed through the years: The wealthy abandoned France in 2000 and moved to Switzerland. They abandoned France in 2009 and moved to... Switzerland. They abandoned France in 2014 and moved to... Russia. They abandoned France in 2020 and moved to... USA. For nearly 2 decades there has been this steady rollout of the news saying the wealthy will abandon there socialist-democratic country for somewhere else. But most of them tend to stick around. A few abandon their dumb project and find their way back even.
- riffraff 1y agoSwitzerland does have a wealth tax[0]. The latest destination for some rich foreigners is Italy due to the lump sum tax on foreign income (200k) for the first 10 years of moving there. But Italy also has a 2‰ wealth tax since 2013 or so. All these news are always exagerated. [0] https://thepoorswiss.com/wealth-tax/ https://thepoorswiss.com/wealth-tax/
- Leherenn 1y agoAlthough wealthy foreigners in Switzerland were (and still are I believe) negotiating their taxes directly with the cantons. Wealth tax might not have applied to them if they qualified. See: https://www.efd.admin.ch/en/lump-sum-taxation https://www.efd.admin.ch/en/lump-sum-taxation
- hermitcrab 1y agoMillionaire flight is mostly myth: https://www.forkingpaths.co/p/does-taxing-the-rich-cause-millionaires https://www.forkingpaths.co/p/does-taxing-the-rich-cause-mil... And, like 'trickle-down economics', a very convenient myth for the rich.
- stego-tech 1y agoLiterally this. Studies repeatedly show this is an empty threat by the rich, because their wealth is intrinsically tied to the economy of their country of residence in most cases and therefore readily taxable while being difficult to move. This is why they bluster that they’ll leave: because they know they cannot, without forfeiting far more than they’d lose via higher taxation. It’s empty bluster.
- devoutsalsa 1y agoRegardless of how you feel about taxation, increasing taxes will not fix out of control spending.
- saubeidl 1y agoRegardless of how you feel about spending, decreasing spending will not fix out of control inequality.
- richwater 1y agoThere's nothing inherently wrong with inequality, unless you think everyone should have equal assets, enforced by violence (the government). The problem is the floor (cost of living, standard of living) is too low for too many people.
- devoutsalsa 1y agoI like the concept of of everyone should have enough. I don't know if it's achievable, but I think it's a good goal to strive for.
- danaris 1y ago> There's nothing inherently wrong with inequality If you're talking about a spherical economy in a vacuum, no, there isn't. When we actually turn our attention to the real world, we find that, in fact, there is. Because when the people at the top have sufficiently disproportionate power (and wealth is a kind of power), they use that power to increase the inequality by any means necessary. That includes, fairly prominently, redirecting resources that would otherwise have gone to ensuring the floor stays high to raising their own ceilings. So it's not a binary—either there is perfect equality or everything goes to shit—but the levels of inequality we have today are demonstrably bad for society.
- saubeidl 1y agoIt doesn't need to be perfectly equal. But to have some live in mansions while others sleep in cardboard boxes is immoral and unjustifiable.
- Poudlardo 1y ago*World's richest man
- omoikane 1y agoBernard Arnault is no longer world's richest man as of 2025, according to: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_World%27s_Billionaires#Annual_rankings https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_World%27s_Billionaires#Ann...
- yoyohello13 1y agoWhat we really need is strong worker protections and monopoly busting. A wealth tax is treating the symptom, not the cause.
- Gud 1y agoMy pet solution to wealth inequality is to distribute the wealth by printing shares in public and large private corporations and handing them out to the general population when the individual is born, but full control handed over gradually, from year 18-30. Of course combined with a general education in economics. I always thought it highly unfair and detrimental to society that some start from zero while a small number of people are handed everything to them. Please explain to me why my idea is foolish. Because I believe it will make society flourish.
- richwater 1y ago> Because I believe it will make society flourish. Consistently devaluing everybody else's investment (via new shares) is essentially just mandatory inflation, on top of existing inflation. Not to sound rude, but this is basic econ stuff. You can't just increase the supply of something and expect the value to keep increasing.
- sam_lowry_ 1y agoExactly! Inflation is a tax on poor already, so why not double-tax the rich via share dilution and Zucman tax.
- richwater 1y agoIf you think taxing the stock market only affects the "rich" you are severely out of touch or intentionally ignorant. 401k, defined benefit pension plans, etc are uses by millions and millions of middle class people.
- baseballdork 1y agoSure, lots of people are in the market. However, a very small portion of people own the overwhelming majority of the market. Top 10% owned 93% of shares in 2023. https://markets.businessinsider.com/news/stocks/stock-market-ownership-wealthiest-americans-one-percent-record-high-economy-2024-1?op=1 https://markets.businessinsider.com/news/stocks/stock-market...
- gorbachev 1y agoGotta love The Guardian editors for choosing the headline they chose.