5 ms·
It's funny to me that in portraying Indiana as a "blank state" he's highlighting one of the most beautiful parts of the state (the route through the Dunes along
by tptacek 1y ago
It's funny to me that in portraying Indiana as a "blank state" he's highlighting one of the most beautiful parts of the state (the route through the Dunes along the Michigan lakefront; if you've seen "Road To Perdition", you know what that area looks like). It's not important to the article, a complete tangent, but I can't not call that out.
- curl-up 1y agoHaving been to Greenland recently, I found his description of it similarly flawed.
- joecool1029 1y agoIn what way/ways?
- curl-up 1y ago> The first thing you notice when you land in Greenland is there are no trees or grass. There is snow and then there is exposed rock. This is only true of the area around the airport. Even his pictures further into the article show how misleading this description is. I was actually very surprised how little snow/ice there was. Now when I think of Greenland, I think of something similar to [1]. Of course, in the winter, it's a completely different story (I was there in July). But he was there during the warm period as well (as is obvious from his photos). > The city itself sits in a landscape so dramatically inhospitable it makes the surface of Mars look cozy. If you look at a map, you will notice that Nuuk is at the same latitude as Reykjavik. There's a common meme about Iceland being green and Greenland being icy, and that's definitely true if you compare inland or northern Greenland with Iceland during summer (during winter, both are icy and dark), but hiking around Nuuk is a very "green" experience. Yes, there's a ton of mosquitoes, but nature itself is very inviting. I did not get any of the "inhospitable" vibes he mentions. > But again even riding the bus around it is impossible to escape the feeling that this is a fundamentally hostile to human life place. The sun is bright and during the summer its pretty hot, with my skin feeling like it was starting the burn pretty much the second it was exposed to the light. It's hard to even dress for, with layers of sunscreen, bug spray and then something warm on top if you suddenly got cold. This whole section is just overblown BS. All in all, I enjoyed it a lot. Compared to Iceland, it's definitely a lot less "user friendly" and you need to prepare better, but I have never been to a place that is less affected by humans, and in our age, that is something worth experiencing. [1] https://truewindhealingtravel.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/08/52256390354_67a2f0a190_k-1170x768.jpg https://truewindhealingtravel.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/08...
- noelwelsh 1y ago>> The first thing you notice when you land in Greenland is there are no trees or grass. There is snow and then there is exposed rock. > This is only true of the area around the airport. Even his pictures further into the article show how misleading this description is. At least as far as trees go, Greenland is reasonably famously lacking in trees (if you are the kind of person who cares about such things). All chopped down by the Vikings and only now are a few sections of forest being regrown. Iceland is basically the same. A few links: - https://www.globalforestwatch.org/dashboards/country/GRL/ https://www.globalforestwatch.org/dashboards/country/GRL/. "In 2020, Greenland had 0.00 ha of natural forest" - https://www.reddit.com/r/geography/comments/14notoe/the_progress_of_tree_growing_in_greenland_its/ https://www.reddit.com/r/geography/comments/14notoe/the_prog... - https://greenlandtrees.org/ https://greenlandtrees.org/
- curl-up 1y agoAgreed, I failed to mention this detail, thank you for adding. But hopefully you agree that his description paints a completely ridiculous picture.
- ARandomerDude 1y agoI’ve never been to Greenland or (to my knowledge) met anyone who has. What is/was your experience like?
- curl-up 1y agoI tried explaining in the other comment here. In summary, it's beautiful, raw nature, that's different from anything else I've seen. It takes some preparation, but I haven't experience any of these "sun will kill you and ice will kill you too" vibes that the article suggests. It felt like one of the last places on Earth not affected by humans (at least directly through resource exploitation, as it definitely is affected by the warming - but that's another discussion).
- bradgessler 1y agoUnfortunately the dunes and lake are not visible from that stretch of I-94. Southern Indiana is another beautiful part of the state. It's mostly rolling hills with lush green forests and farms.
- tptacek 1y agoYou don't have to drive it on I-94; in fact, for many years it was faster not to, because of insane bottom of the lake traffic. You can take the Dunes Highway instead (and then keep off 94 up the Michigan shore; there's good stuff up there).
- bradgessler 1y agoI need to do that next time I’m driving between Chicago and Michigan. I haven’t seen the dunes there yet and I bet it’s incredible.
- tptacek 1y agoI'm speaking up for Indiana here but honestly if you're looking for those dunescapes and beaches, western Michigan is the better bet. Road To Perdition was filmed around Saugatuck, just an hour into Michigan; that part of Michigan really is worth a trip to see (you'd want book a place to stay up by the lake for at least a couple days; it's not so much a sightseeing deal as a chill-out-by-the-lake deal). The whole stretch though from Chicago up to Traverse City is basically where Chicago vacations.
- bradgessler 1y agoI have done that! Reminded me of some dunes I scaled in Jordan.
- scheme271 1y agoCheck out sleeping bear dunes park in Michigan especially if you can get out to the islands. Also Three Oaks Michigan is also a nice spot to stay and explore for a day or two. Journeyman distillery and a few nice restaurants are located there.
- internet2000 1y agoYeah I didn't open this link to see Indiana catching stray bullets. Does a disservice to this article.
- bell-cot 1y agoI prefer to see that part as an up-front, honest disclosure of his biases and negativity.
- schmookeeg 1y agoThe charms of Indiana have been consistently lost on me over the years; it enhanced the article for me, and I read nearly his entire blog after his Greenland rantlet. I learned a few things. Different strokes I suppose :)
- Arainach 1y agoThen again, that stretch also has Gary. Having grown up in that area of the Midwest, I largely agree with the author's categorization, except that "people on their way to somewhere better who got tired and decided this was good enough" describes a LOT of the midwest, not just Indiana. Significant chunks of Michigan, Ohio, and Missouri, most of Iowa/Kansas/Nebraska, etc. If you read the history of westward expansion, "got tired and decided this was good enough" is literally true for how much of the area got initially settled (by white people)
- Waterluvian 1y agoI took a moment to realize there’s a place called Gary, Indiana. And that there isn’t just some guy who is so infamous that he’s just known as Gary.
- hinkley 1y agoClearly not a fan of musical theater. The Music Man ~~takes place in~~ repeatedly refers to Gary. Ron Howard sings a song called Gary Indiana in the movie version. He’s about waist high in that movie.
- Rendello 1y agoThe town's even referenced in Futurama: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=qUW1pabZpLE https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=qUW1pabZpLE
- 1y ago
- tedggh 1y agoThe Indiana Dunes is indeed one of the most beautiful unexpected places I have encountered traveling in the US. And Wagner’s have to be the absolute best ribs in the world.
- kubectl_h 1y agoThis is good to know, I have passed through Indiana a number of times on I-70 and I've found it to be particularly flat and boring. I know there are pretty places everywhere but that stretch has felt like exactly what he was saying, a place you have to get through to go somewhere else.
- ccleve 1y agoIrked me too. I'm running for state representative in House District 9, which covers much of that area. The district is drop dead gorgeous and it's growing rapidly. There's a lot here.
- tptacek 1y agoWhoah, neat, congratulations or whatever you say to that. Good luck! Were you already involved in local politics in the area?
- ccleve 1y agoyes, quite a bit
- throwup238 1y ago> whatever you say to that Illegitimis non carborundum?
- ccleve 1y agoThanks. That's exactly the right thing to say.
- forgotoldacc 1y agoPretty much everyone on earth is proud of their home area. I've never really been to a place where people didn't describe their home as one of the most beautiful places on earth. Earth has a lot of nice places. The flatness of Indiana can be calming and beautiful. But if you're driving on main roads, it's not very exciting, and it's not the kind of exciting people will fly across the world to see. And that was the point in the article.
- thevillagechief 1y agoI love my home town. I grew up there, and it was fine. I would never describe it as one of the most beautiful places on earth. I'm I proud of it? Only in the sense it's home and I have family there.
- losvedir 1y agoHeh, as someone who lives there (Northwest Indiana) that was a rough read. Then again, our state motto did used to be "Crossroads of America", so I guess that's kind of fair. These days it's the more aspirational "More to Discover".
- jb1991 1y agoAnd the southern part of the state is actually one of the most famous places in the United States for painters to retreat in the autumn as there are no trees as beautiful as you will find there. Calling some states good states and others not is just a silly thing to do anyway.
- jccalhoun 1y agoI bugged me too. I'm from Southern Indiana and when I hear people say "Indiana is flat" or "Indiana is boring to look at" all I hear them say is "I've only been to the Northern part of Indiana." There is a lot to shit on Indiana for but its natural beauty isn't one of them.
- mothballed 1y agoIt's likely people from west of the Mississippi. Indiana and other midwestern states have some awesome nature, but it's basically taken for granted by people from there because you grow up having your family show you all those places. Imagine if aliens showed up to a megacity, and declared there was no food anywhere -- a local would show them places called "restaurants" that actually have more varied and competitive tasty foods than about any farmland areas you'd find, but the aliens would think there's food only in the farmlands and declare the city worthless for finding something to eat. If you drive out west, you don't even have to look for them; astounding nature is evereywhere. End result is people from midwestern states appreciate the beauty of their state, but people who haven't lived there for years generally don't. Even after leaving the midwest, I have a high appreciation for the natural landscape, but that's only because I know where to go when I get there.
- kasey_junk 1y agoIt’s also problematic because that part of Indiana was geo engineered into a blank slate. It used to be a wetlands that rivaled the Everglades but was drained and filled in a massive (and controversial) public works effort.
- kyleee 1y agoGot any links describing this?
- kasey_junk 1y agohttps://www.turnstoneimpact.com/blog/on-this-date-october-15-1925 https://www.turnstoneimpact.com/blog/on-this-date-october-15...
- kyleee 1y agoThank you
- osigurdson 1y agoI've never been to Indiana but I don't like when people say things like this about other places. Yeah, these people are "too tired" to go anywhere else - right. I hope the author enjoyed channeling Hemingway for a bit but seriously what does he know about why people live there?
- Broken_Hippo 1y agoWould you rather hear about being too poor to go anywhere else? I'm from Indiana, lived there until I was 35 and family still lives there. "Too tired" is an apt descriptor, though. "Too Poor" or not having opportunities is generally good too, but you likely wouldn't see all of that while driving through. Most people just live there because they were born there and their lives are there. "why would you move here??" isn't an unusual question.
- osigurdson 1y agoI feel like that is a valid view from someone who lives there but, if you aren't from a given place, I'm not interested in your opinion. Also, "why would you move here?", how many places on Earth meet that criteria?
- 8bitsrule 1y agoImmediately reminded me of my first (and only) impression of driving that route. And of that old one-hit-wonder, R. Dean Taylor lyric "Indiana wants me ... Lord I can't go back there"...