18 ms·
Warp Drive May Be More Feasible Than Thought, Scientists Say
- jstalin 14y agoEngage.
- cryptoz 14y ago> The only problem is, previous studies estimated the warp drive would require a minimum amount of energy about equal to the mass-energy of the planet Jupiter. Uh, no. The "only problem" is that the concept relies on exotic matter, a hypothetical matter with 0 evidence for its existence (so far). See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exotic_matter http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exotic_matter
- randallsquared 14y agoWell, the Casimir effect generates a tiny amount of negative energy, does it not? Maybe that's how they think they can test it in the lab.
- sp332 14y agoActually the Casimir effect just reduces the "ambient" pressure, it doesn't create negative pressure. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Casimir_effect http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Casimir_effect Edit: Whoops, looks like it might work anyway http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Casimir_effect#Wormholes http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Casimir_effect#Wormholes Edit2: Actually I think that contradicts this http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wormhole#Raychaudhuri.27s_theorem_and_exotic_matter http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wormhole#Raychaudhuri.27s_theor... which makes more sense to me. Unless you have already curved spacetime, a Casimir effect is not enough to stabilize a wormhole.
- jerf 14y agoThere are places in physics where "negative mass" can briefly appear, but as I understand it, the quantity of such negative mass times the duration of the negative mass is a constant... and a very, very small constant to boot. It's a balancing term in QM interactions, not something you're ever going to hold in your hands. As I like to say, assume one impossibility in physics, and it's not surprising that you get other impossibilities as a result. Unfortunately, in practical terms, requiring Jupiter sized amounts of stable negative mass and requiring "Voyager" sized amounts of stable negative mass do not appear to be appreciably different in difficulty, both being totally impossible. I'd also point out that this article isn't even remotely unique. People have been tweaking the Alcubierre equations ever since they came out. Nobody has yet squeezed the "impossible" out of it, but each and every one of them has been accompanied by, well, basically this exact article. I support people trying to tweak them as a scientific Hail Mary, but I wish credulous science writers would stop writing these stories as if moving from "impossible" to "impossible" was some sort of huge step forward in practical terms.
- lukevdp 14y agoI agree entirely. The journalist in this article is giving the impression that this idea is more widely accepted than it actually is. It paints a picture of scientists agreeing on this when in reality it's a person or small group of people saying this. At the same time, this kind of research is cool, and is an important part of science. It's just misrepresented by publications.
- sp332 14y agoThat was my main problem with this article. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exotic_matter http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exotic_matter You could simulate the effect using metamaterials probably, but you couldn't break the real speed of light with it because you don't have real negative mass.
- iRobot 14y agoGot to start somewhere if we want a shiny starship
- hooo 14y ago> Uh, no. The "only problem" is that the concept relies on exotic matter, a hypothetical matter with 0 evidence for its existence (so far). See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exotic_matter http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exotic_matter There are multiple routes here though. They could also find an "exotic spaceship" that already has a warp drive.
- MBlume 14y agoFind one with a halting oracle on board and you're set.
- stcredzero 14y agoHow to fake an "almost" Halting Oracle. For one thing, it's not a Halting Oracle, it's actually an "oracle" that tells you if you have an unspecified bug. The "oracle" doesn't answer "trivial" questions, for an unspecified definition of trivial. In reality, the "oracle" just uses heuristics to determine if the program is complex enough, that any experienced developer would tell you that there's probably a bug somewhere. The "oracle" will only answer questions about systems that are really Production systems. The "oracle" will not answer questions about systems that use Formal Methods. If the above criteria are met, the "oracle" waits a random interval of time, flashing lights in complex patterns, then simply answers, "Yes."
- indiecore 14y agoThat'd be a good day.
- fungi 14y agoseems unlikley. if only we had some kind of improbability engine.
- jlgreco 14y agoI doubt an improbability engine would be good for much more than party tricks. An infinite improbability drive would be much more useful, but such a thing would be virtual impossibility...
- nostromo 14y agoThis appears to be the original paper: http://ntrs.nasa.gov/archive/nasa/casi.ntrs.nasa.gov/20110015936_2011016932.pdf http://ntrs.nasa.gov/archive/nasa/casi.ntrs.nasa.gov/2011001... and follow up: http://www.icarusinterstellar.org/daydreaming-beyond-the-solar-system-with-warp-field-mechanics/ http://www.icarusinterstellar.org/daydreaming-beyond-the-sol...
- heyrhett 14y agoWarp speed is only 1/10th the speed of light. As far as some news about faster than light travel, refer to: http://xkcd.com/955/ http://xkcd.com/955/
- ChuckMcM 14y agoWell if you read the paper the effective speed is 10c, not .1c. They postulate 'boosting' the effective speed by contorting space-time around the craft, see this quote in the paper: "assume the spacecraft heads out towards Alpha Centauri and has a conventional propulsion system capable of reaching 0.1c. The spacecraft initiates a boost field with a value of 100 which acts on the initial velocity resulting in an apparent speed of 10c. The spacecraft will make it to Alpha Centauri in 0.43 years as measured by an earth observer and an observer in the flat space-time volume encapsulated by the warp bubble. "
- rickmode 14y agoSo if I understand right, the warping does not affect the "internal" speed of the spaceship in relation of the universe outside of the warp bubble. Maybe someone much better with maths and physics can answer this: will the 0.1c speed have a noticable relativistic age-slowing effect for the travelers compared to their Earth-bound friends?
- smallblacksun 14y agoThe time dilation effects don't become large enough to have significant affects on aging until speeds significantly higher than .1C. For example, to age at 1/2 normal rate, you would need to be going ~0.86C. This site has a calculator to play with: http://www.1728.org/reltivty.htm?b0=0.1 http://www.1728.org/reltivty.htm?b0=0.1
- ChuckMcM 14y ago1.005 seconds vs the observer at rest [1] So 157 days on the ship (.43 years) would be 158 days back at home. [1] http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=time+dialation+at+.1c http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=time+dialation+at+.1c
- CWIZO 14y agoAs much as it pains me to say this, but I think we have to invent some more advanced weapons before we start poking our heads out of our galaxy. Don't get me wrong, this is fantastic and I'm all tingly from excitement (this is the first time I've read about warp drives in the context of real science) ... but like I said, taking a stroll trough the galaxy with our bombs and finding a hostile alien world. Well we'd be screwed. Just food for though here; this is from the Halo universe, where the timeline goes something like this: humans invent "warp drives", they colonize other worlds, soon this colonies start to rebel which leads to a massive space civil war. Later the aliens arrive and set to destroy all of humanity. Now, if it waren't for the civil war, humans would have no experience in space combat, and they wouldn't have developed more advance weapons which would later allowed them to defeat the alien threat.
- aeturnum 14y agoI think that developing "advanced" weapons in isolation would be an exercise in futility. If there's a race that's experienced in interstellar war out there, their weapons would be much more refined than ours. You can't create any product independent of its context. If we were to meet a hostile alien race, unless they were at a similar developmental stage (which seems unlikely), we'd be at their mercy either way due to the extent of the other side's settlements.
- Ygg2 14y agoSeeing how if we use our warp drives to 'colonize' space, other creatures would have far more to fear from us than we from them (think Independence day with roles reversed). If a space faring species encounters non-space faring species, the one with warp is probably (not necessary) in the better position. Even without the weapons, FTL drive implies a magnitudes greater technology than anything a non-FTL race would have. In fact atm we might be the most dangerous creature out there, so in future (if we get that far) I probably see human species branching out into several subspecies and then waging endless war against each other. Halo is a work of fiction, not a real life based drama. We'll probably be lucky if we find anything more interesting than a microbe. First encounter will probably be more like Solaris than Halo. We'll most likely find an organism that we can't even perceive as one. So no, we don't need guns in space. Best weapon in space is Newton's second law (i.e. Kinetic bombardment). Cheap and easy to set up, hard to defend if your target is in a gravitation well.
- johnnymonster 14y agoHow about we first build a space ship that travels anywhere near the speed of light?
- jerf 14y agoThis is all but a necessary step. If you work out the conventional rocket equations assuming a perfect translation of mass into momentum, to get to appreciable fractions of lightspeed still requires absurd amounts of propellants. At the moment we haven't even got a faint idea as to how we might obtain such total conversion. That's why there's so much interest in designs where you don't carry your fuel with you, like laser-driven solar sails and such.
- goldfeld 14y agoI assume travelling near speed of light with conventional physics is impossible, since the ship's mass would crush itself as it increased infinitely. Warp drives, on the other hand, seem to work by moving space-time, not the ship. So in theory the ship is left intact, without the people inside feeling any acceleration whatsoever.
- palmtree3000 14y agoI'm fairly certain that wouldn't be an issue. Relativity means that any (let's say non-accelerating, to keep us within the context of special relativity) reference frame is just as good as another. In the spacecraft's reference frame, it's chilling out, and a bunch of stars off a ways are moving really fast, but they don't really affect it. It is an interesting problem though; I'm not really sure why it can't crush itself...
- spullara 14y agoAside from the light from stars directly in front of them that becomes hard gamma rays at high speeds.
- acqq 14y agoInfinite Improbability Drive http://hitchhikers.wikia.com/wiki/Infinite_Improbability_Drive http://hitchhikers.wikia.com/wiki/Infinite_Improbability_Dri...
- Rickasaurus 14y agoWhy, I always get my science from Yahoo news.
- nessus42 14y agoYou can't have faster than light travel without violations of causality. And while the equations of General Relatively allow for universes where causality is routinely violated, the probability that we are in such a universe seems vanishingly small. E.g., just because you can violate causality does not mean that you can go back in time and kill your grandfather. If you were to try, something would stop you, as a universe in which you kill your own grandfather is not consistent with General Relativity. A universe that gives you the means to go back in time and try to kill your grandfather, but then somehow always thwarts you, would be a very strange universe indeed. Edit: To whoever down-voted me, have you taken any classes on General Relativity? I have. In any case this is from Wikipedia: Causality is not required by special or general relativity[citation needed], but is nonetheless generally considered a basic property of the universe that cannot be sensibly dispensed with. Because of this, most physicists[who?] expect that quantum gravity effects will preclude this option.[citation needed] An alternative is to conjecture that, while time travel is possible, it never leads to paradoxes; this is the Novikov self-consistency principle. The "Novikov self-consistency principle" is the the one that states that you could try to create a time paradox, but that you would never be able to succeed. I.e., the universe would be a very strange place!
- stryker 14y agoI feel like a lot of people here misunderstand the speed of light as a cosmic speed limit. The speed of light as a speed limit is a local constraint. On a larger scale there is no such speed limit. Just because you travel faster than light on a non-local scale does not mean you break causality. For example, light "travels" more slowly through water than vacuum. Well, actually, photons travel at c always -- it's just that light gets bounced around by water molecules, getting absorbed and reabsorbed many many times before arriving at the destination. It's like driving to a destination as opposed to running to it. If the roads are curvy enough, the runner will win because he is not constrained by roads. Could it be that the Alcubierre drive gets past the roads of empty space in a way light cannot? For a better example, consider the expansion of the universe. Link: http://curious.astro.cornell.edu/question.php?number=575 http://curious.astro.cornell.edu/question.php?number=575. I quote: The fact that galaxies we see now are moving away from us faster than the speed of light has some bleak consequences, however. Astronomers now have strong evidence that we live in an "accelerating universe," which means that the speed of each individual galaxy with respect to us will increase as time goes on. If we assume that this acceleration continues indefinitely, then galaxies which are currently moving away from us faster than the speed of light will always be moving away from us faster than the speed of light and will eventually reach a point where the space between us and them is stretching so rapidly that any light they emit after that point will never be able to reach us. In other words, vacuum fills in between us and far away galaxies faster than light can traverse it. Again, locally, the derivative of position with respect to time is c, but the universe is able to "cheat" by messing around with the definition of position. If the Alcubierre drive messes with the fabric of the universe in a similar way, I don't see any reason why it cannot succeed. Here's a related link: http://curious.astro.cornell.edu/question.php?number=56 http://curious.astro.cornell.edu/question.php?number=56. I quote: Technically speaking, the speed of light limit only applies when you are in an "inertial frame" -- that is, sitting where you are, without any forces acting on you, and measuring the speed of an object that moves past a ruler and clock that you are holding in your hand. Across the large distances in the universe, however, we have a very different set of circumstances. No one is in an inertial frame, because everyone is being accelerated with respect to everyone else, due to the universe's gravitational field and the fact that the universe is expanding. In effect, the universe's expansion isn't really due to galaxies moving "through space" away from each other, but rather due to the stretching of space itself, which isn't governed by the same limits that we are. I'm not sure whether the Alcubierre drive contradicts causality, but if it does, I highly doubt that it is because of the arguments presented on this forum.
- olalonde 14y agoIf this is really possible, it should increase the probability of having been contacted by advanced extraterrestrial civilizations. Maybe we're really alone after all :( http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fermi_paradox http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fermi_paradox
- outworlder 14y ago> An Alcubierre warp drive would involve a football-shape spacecraft attached to a large ring encircling it. Obligatory Star Trek reference. This seems close enough: http://www.ex-astris-scientia.org/schematics/surak-timur-nivar.jpg http://www.ex-astris-scientia.org/schematics/surak-timur-niv...
- dholowiski 14y agoExotic matter = Magic?
- jayfuerstenberg 14y agoAt this point I'd settle for impulse and artificial gravity. That should be most of what is needed to get people to Mars and the moon.
- gotrythis 14y agoI skimmed through the responses, which seemed to be all about the execution, with little or no discussion or debate questioning if this is a good thing or not. Even more than the idea excites me, I hope this fails miserably. We're at the Avatar stage of our evolution, not Star Trek. I think this says it best: (no affiliation) http://www.facebook.com/ResurrectingtheGoddess/posts/396076033792108 http://www.facebook.com/ResurrectingtheGoddess/posts/3960760...
- powertower 14y agoI don't understand how the warp-bubble would itself travel through space-time faster than C (it's effects are inside of it), only that the space-craft traveling through that warp-bubble would. But the space-craft is stationary / in the center of it?