9 ms·
Ghost kitchens are dying
- anotherhue 1y agoDrop shipping, but for food - what did we expect?
- rkomorn 1y agoIt doesn't work that badly if your food is good, but I guess the problem is it often isn't. Delivery certainly isn't unpopular.
- JohnFen 1y agoThe emergence of ghost kitchens, more than anything else, is what got me to stop using food delivery services. They made it impossible for me to have enough trust, so I switched back to ordering from real restaurants that I physically go to.
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> made it impossible for me to have enough trust Copy the address into your maps app and look it up on street view.
- kjkjadksj 1y agoCould be a few years stale. Some of the ghost kitchens even operated out of real restaurants by another name. E.g. higher quality sitdown place shoveling out burgers and fries out the back door.
- JohnFen 1y ago> Some of the ghost kitchens even operated out of real restaurants by another name. Yes, that also blew my trust in the whole thing.
- MangoToupe 1y agoWhat happens if you change to "pickup"? Does the place just disappear?
- noahlt 1y agoYou end up standing in line with a bunch of delivery drivers who all know the drill and are on the clock, and you quickly learn you cannot be polite if you want to get your food.
- hamdingers 1y agoNo, you just go pick it up and save some money. I live a short bike ride from a CloudKitchen location and pick up from it often. Hard to beat birria and bao buns in the same stop even if they're nothing to write home about.
- JohnFen 1y agoI don't see why I should bother. It's easier and better just to order from real restaurants that people go to to eat.
- BeetleB 1y agoFor traditional restaurants, what percentage of orders are for delivery (using Doordash, etc)? Excluding pickups where the customer comes and picks it up himself. I can't imagine it's even close to 50%. I don't know the patterns of regular folks, but for me the prices in general have crept up enough that's it rare I want to try some new place - unless I get multiple strong personal recommendations for it. You can forget about paying extra for delivery to home!
- HankStallone 1y agoWhen I worked for Dominos in the late 80s, it was a lot like this sounds. No dining room, though customers could walk in and order in a small vestibule. The place was as efficient as possible, just ringing phones, an assembly line, cooler and ovens, storage and cleaners in the back, and delivery drivers running in and out. There seems to be something special about pizza that sets it apart from everything else, that made it seem reasonable to order it delivered from a non-restaurant even back then.
- jerlam 1y agoIt worked because Dominos was a brand name, people knew what to expect before ordering, and they picked up their own food instead of letting a overworked disinterested gig driver deliver it.
- narcraft 1y agoDominos delivered. Pizza has been delivered since the dawn of time.
- jerlam 1y agoThe pizza was delivered by an actual employee of the pizza place, and there might be a small delivery fee and a tip. Now the gig companies add a delivery fee on top of the inflated menu prices, then ask for a tip before the order will even be picked up. The fees can be 80% or even higher than the in-store price.
- FearNotDaniel 1y agoPlenty of Chinese takeaways, and a good few “Indian” establishments (takeaway/delivery only, no restaurant) have operated in the same way, without chains or brand names, for decades, at least all over the UK. Many great quality, many poor, but that was part of the fun of moving to a new area, figuring out the good ones from all the menus that got shoved through the letterbox. Before that, of course, the fish and chip shop is an ancient institution, though they rarely delivered.
- 1y ago
- etblg 1y agoThe points the article make come close to my gripe with ghost kitchens but don't quite cover it: they feel like scams and when I've accidentally ordered from a ghost kitchen it was by design a terrible experience. I'm talking like, you order a 15$ main that is called "creamy pasta with prosicutto" and when it shows up its buttered spaghetti with a couple stamp-sized bits of ham. Ordering from actual restaurants come with some of the downsides the article assigns to ghost kitchens, like cold food and weird presentation, but ghost kitchens never seemed to reach the bar of "food someone would actually order, even if it was teleported to them instantly".
- toss1 1y agoTHIS: >>"food someone would actually order, even if it was teleported to them instantly". The article states >>Quality control became impossible. Shared kitchen facilities meant that one staff member prepared food for multiple brands simultaneously. No ownership. No accountability. Just assembly-line cooking with zero connection to customers. I'm not sure if it was impossible or if management never actually prioritized it, not bothering to understand what an actual customer would want. How much of it is the stupid management assumption that they can "just make a dish generally meeting description X on the menu" and deliver that and it'll be ok? «— Real question, did mgt fail at the product specification level, or was QC just as a practical matter, impossible? On the economics, it really seems 30% for delivery is insane. It seems that same 30% might exceed the cost of the physical restaurant. And when it adds a 15-45min delay while homogenizing and cooling the meal, it seems an impossible problem. Maybe if the 30% transported it instantly and losslessly... Probably good this soulless idea will die. Too bad so much perfectly good capital was squandered on it instead of better ideas
- ori_b 1y agoThe selling point was efficiency, not quality. It follows that the result wasn't quality.
- jeffbee 1y ago> Just assembly-line cooking with zero connection to customers. And this is how it works in many (not all) American airports. Local restaurants put their brands on the signs, but the food is prepared by probationary employees of Acme Baggage Displacement And Cafeteria Management Corp.
- syntaxing 1y agoThe main issue was that they relied on food delivery to sustain its model. I’m not going to pay $50 in food and $20 in tips and fees. Like anyone sane, I call in my order and pick it up myself. This idea died because of this missing link. I would entertain it if you have a pickup booth in a lobby.
- leetrout 1y agoAnd you just re-invented Chinese takeout as experienced in major cities! One of my favorite dumpling shops in Brooklyn just had 2 tables... everyone just carried it out and back to home / work. And I think it worked well for them.
- tptacek 1y agoI believe all of this but: Food that travels well requires different recipes, different ingredients, different packaging. This doesn't ring true, given the popularity of DoorDash and the fact that most of those restaurant menus are in no way optimized for delivery. Having lower-quality multitasking staff serving multiple restaurants from the same prep and equipment seems like an obvious way to lose quality. But simply streamlining the process of getting a menu onto delivery? That seems like a solved problem.
- pavel_lishin 1y ago> the fact that most of those restaurant menus are in no way optimized for delivery. Are you sure they're not?
- tptacek 1y agoYes, I am sure about this claim that I am making. Are there restaurants that do optimize for delivery? Certainly. But DoorDash covers most restaurants in my area (and it's a big area --- Chicagoland) and most of those menus are identical to the in-person menu.
- kevinmchugh 1y agoI saw this the other day: https://www.reddit.com/r/chicagofood/comments/1na3fer/comment/ncr7sr3/ https://www.reddit.com/r/chicagofood/comments/1na3fer/commen... So some places are optimizing their fries for delivery. I've also noticed some restaurants are better at adapting the packaging, like punching out ventilation so fried products don't steam themselves in transit. Lawrence Seafood (which rules) did that for a side of tempura we got this weekend. But I agree in large part. I wouldn't order fried chicken delivered via door dash in any event. People doing that are optimizing for something other than quality.
- tptacek 1y agoThe increasing prevalence of battered fries as a consequence of DoorDash is such a cursed thing.
- timhigins 1y agoIt would be really nice to have a tag on HN to filter out LLM-generated, or at least partly AI-generated content like this. If an article makes it to the front page despite being AI-generated it probably has some interesting points or ideas, but it's unfortunate that people seeem to choose the speed and style of LLM writing over the individual style and choice that made the writing of yesteryear more interesting and unique.
- cj 1y agoIt would be nice if you shared some supporting evidence rather than turning a guess into a definitive statement.
- npinsker 1y agoIt's clearly AI, both from the image (look at the text) and the vacuous nothingness of the ChatGPT-speak.
- cj 1y agoIf you believe that, it’s best to flag the submission and move on rather than pollute the comments. This is the equivalent of posting “this is a badly written article”. It doesn’t add any value.
- antonvs 1y agoIf an article is badly written or AI-generated, there's value in that being pointed out in the comments. It can save people wasting time, and ideally, discourage people from posting low quality content. That's a large part of the point of a site like this.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- cj 1y agoIf the community upvotes AI-genraated content to the front page, I don't see why it should automatically be penalized. (I respect your own opinion, which is why I suggest flagging the submission). But clearly there's a reason it was upvoted if it's on the front page. Why ignore that fact... clearly the community thinks these articles have value if they're upvoted. (Also, "it's AI, bad article" is just a weak complaint that can't be proven right or wrong - if you dislike it, share why you dislike it, e.g. lacking specific information, shallow depth, something other than "don't like it because AI")
- userbinator 1y agoThey grew during the pandemic, for obvious reasons. Now that that's over, it's no surprise that they're dying off.
- xg15 1y ago> The company then announced it would sell or close every remaining physical location and pivot to "software only". What does that even mean? Sell an NFT image of a burger?
- eddythompson80 1y agoCloudKitchen was holding plenty of software hiring events near me few years ago. All these companies developed software to streamline the process of listing thousands of stores on all delivery apps, receiving orders, organize and manage kitchens assembly lines like how the orders are received, and dispatched to cooks, etc. Also they integrate analytics, cost tracking, supply chain management, and other random things like that. Basically for any PE or a billionaire who wants to larp as the next McDonalds or Starbucks, they don’t want to build everything from scratch. The kinda thing a regular restaurant is probably managing using a spreadsheet and a notebook.
- ggm 1y agoAsimov was fond of the trope that the future was starved of protein, and even america had become a land where people had to eat communally, and eat significant amounts of manufactured "zymoveal" protein, because real meat was scarce under population/land pressure. It was clear that "people didn't like it" Oddly, "cafeteria" cooking has sometimes been the best food I've eaten at the time. It very much depends on the circumstances and budget and your expectations. I've eaten like this in Leeds, London, Rome, France, Beijing. And not always in universities, the experience extends to factories, railways and even just the streetscape. The FSU had a preference for ground meat and sausages at a state level because it was easier to ensure as much as possible of the meat inputs became food outputs. [This is wrong: they didn't] The Khrushchev flats had communal kitchens. They were universally hated I believe. Ghost kitchens failed on lack of regulation and motivation to be the best they could be. There was never an intention to be "Jamie Oliver's ghost kitchen" Re-intermediating consumers away from direct food carries on. Uber eats and Panda are delivering food from restaurants all around me, and one of them is a chinese take-away eponymously called "A Chinese Take Away" -I think it's a hack on the search engine carried forward. I've eaten their floating market soup in the shop, it's fine. Most of their trade is carry-out.
- aleyan 1y ago> The Khrushchev flats had communal kitchens Khrushchyovkas did not have communal kitchens; I grew up in one [0]. Perhaps you are thinking about kommunalkas [1]? [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7935844 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7935844 [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Communal_apartment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Communal_apartment
- ggm 1y agoyes. I was completely wrong, thanks for the correction.
- tstrimple 1y ago> Oddly, "cafeteria" cooking has sometimes been the best food I've eaten at the time. Sometimes the lack of choice and lack of responsibility are relieving. It may not be the best meal, but you didn't really have much choice and you didn't have to get ingredients and make it yourself. That can go a long way.
- Animats 1y ago> Quality control became impossible. Shared kitchen facilities meant that one staff member prepared food for multiple brands simultaneously. No ownership. No accountability. Just assembly-line cooking with zero connection to customers. When food arrived cold or wrong, customers had no relationship with the brand to forgive mistakes. No loyal regulars. No servers to smooth over problems. Just angry reviews that destroyed virtual brands forever. No reason for repeat business. That's a straight quality control problem. It ought to be solveable. But that's hard to do. The trouble is, the whole food app industry is based on someone else dealing with the hard problems. The drivers aren't employees, and the restaurants aren't employees. If an app company gets into ghost kitchens, they are now in a business where they are clueless. Some try to avoid being responsible for the food by just being landlords for people who buy a station in the kitchen Bulk food prep is a solved problem. Every major hotel has it solved. There will be some senior people who went to a serious culinary academy. They look at food prep as a manufacturing problem, with batch quantity optimization, holding time limits, error tolerances on temperatures and quantities, and quality control points. It's factory planning. The first "Doordash Kitchen", in Silicon Valley, is near me. It's still operating, but I don't see many drivers there. > When food travels twenty minutes in a bag, quality suffers. You'd think that would be a solved problem in packaging and prep by now. Insulated containers are not rocket science.
- antonvs 1y ago> Insulated containers are not rocket science. You often want the opposite of insulation. Food continues to cook in the container, things get soggy, etc. Each dish and even ingredient can have different ideal packaging requirements. It's not something that really scales well. It's part of why menus like McDonalds' remained stable and relatively small over a period of decades. Notice how their fries are served in a specialty designed container that's open, which avoids them becoming soggy.
- Animats 1y agoMcDonalds has a sizable R&D operation in Chicago, called Speedee Labs, to figure out things like that. Does anybody in the "ghost kitchen" industry?
- mastazi 1y agoAnecdotal: Due to lifestyle factors, in my family we use Ubereats often, probably 4-5 orders per week on average. I have never placed an order from a restaurant that I don't actually know beforehand. Maybe I haven't been there in person, but I know the name of the restaurant and I remember where is it and maybe someone I know ate there. The only time I go completely blind is if I'm traveling. But that's like 1-2% of my total orders. And, in that case I usually stick to known chains or maybe I ask what's a good restaurant around here, then find it in the app. I suspect it's not so uncommon to order from restaurants one already knows, rather than taking risks? If that's the case, then ghost kitchens are going to have a very hard time getting their slice of the market
- JohnFen 1y ago> Maybe I haven't been there in person, but I know the name of the restaurant and I remember where is it and maybe someone I know ate there. A big part of the problem is that just because it has the name of a real and known restaurant doesn't mean that the food you order through delivery apps was made there.
- mastazi 1y agogood point, at the time I wrote this comment I was halfway through the OP article, later I finished reading it and realised the same kitchen can actually work for a range of restaurants and chains. Initially I thought it would just be some made up name on the delivery app, as opposed to a recognised brand.
- jacknews 1y agoIsn't the main problem that the kitchens are shared and the restaurants are just popup brands with no loyalty built up? I don't think you need an actual sit-down location to succeed, but you do need full control over what you produce and to spend time building trust and loyalty.
- ergocoder 1y agoEating out in US or any developed western civilization is so expensive that everyone in those civilizations think cooking is a basic skill. I don't understand why there is no good cheap option. In Japan, I could go to a low-tier shop. It would cost $1-3; the food is decent with taste, and it fills my stomach. In US, $1-3 would be the min amount of tips.
- ehnto 1y agoI think cooking is a basic skill for self sufficiency, if things go wrong in society. Living in dense cities it can be easy to forget how many dependencies you rely on, it's a complex chain of logistics. But I sure do miss the convenience and cost of Japan. Cities in Japan feel like they are made for people to live mostly outside of their house. Whereas it is so expensive to do normal city stuff in many western cities, it costs too much to participate every day.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- deathanatos 1y agoFor starters, $1–$3 probably wouldn't cover the ingredients for most dishes. A single bell pepper, for example, is ≈$2. Ground beef for 1 is ≈$4. … I, and everyone I know, can cook? Do cook. There's no way to eat out every night…?
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- bigger_cheese 1y agoI suspect it is to do with the amount of pedestrian traffic passing through an area. When you have a high population density there is an increased amount of foot traffic in the area you can charge less per individual serving because you have a higher overall volume of traffic. Where I live in Australia the cheapest food tends to be Kebabs which congregate around pubs. There is a high amount of students walking (stumbling) home after a night out etc so they can afford to be cheap since they get so much foot traffic coming through.
- aurizon 1y agothe basis of ghost kitchens started with one restaurant being cloned by the same restaurant to serve as a preparation nexus for their own menu to get local coverage and gain economies as the restaurant ramped up. Later pirate restaurants that were clones that copied the menu and snapped up the order - often assisted by delivery companies that had the stats. Later these grew larger, multi menu clones, often with 3-6 restaurant clones in one spot. Then someone got greedy, and the rents for these spaces destroyed their economic basis, and the city got greedy, rubbing their oily hands together to get taxes, levy code shit etc. The original restaurants lawyered up and the ghost kitchens became anonymous - and Oh yes, COVID was over
- hamdingers 1y agoI live near a CloudKitchen location and I use it often. I always pick up on my bike, so I'm skipping a lot of the expense of delivery. The pickup is locker-based which is easier to deal with than a restaurant where you have to get someone's attention. The variety is great because my partner and I can get wildly different things and I need only make one stop. Ours is stocked with the standard set of generic "restaurants" plus serves as a "location" for several real local restaurant chains and even a food truck. The generic stuff is passable but uses cheap ingredients, the partnered restaurants seem to have fine quality control and use the same stuff they use elsewhere, so I find them to be quite good. Picking up myself I don't experience the cold food issue others complain about. It does such brisk business every time I'm there I have a hard time believing this specific one is dying. I hope it's not.
- BrenBarn 1y agoA business trading on a name without some kind of sunk cost that incentivizes them to protect that name should be a red flag for consumers. It's the same thing that's made Amazon a surreal morass of brands like DYBOOP and BIPLOZA. If a ghost kitchen can shut down and reopen with a different name just by clicking a few buttons and not actually have to move their kitchen or anything, the whole concept is totally untrustworthy. There was an interesting local example of a place that started out trying to be more or less a ghost kitchen but wound up being forced by success to become a real eatery. It had the endearingly utilitarian name "Pizza Online Company". They had no phone nor any in-house delivery system. You could order online or in-person to pick up, or via GrubHub/Doordash/etc., and that was it. Initially they had no eating area, just a tiny space big enough for three or four people to stand and wait for their orders. But the pizza wasn't bad and it was (at least at first) remarkably cheap. It undercut Domino's prices by at least 25% while being much better quality. The place became popular. And sure enough when a place becomes popular people start wanting to go there. They added a small counter with stools to the waiting area. They didn't have space for more than that inside, but when it wasn't enough they took over some of the strip-mall walkway outside the front door and made it into a patio with seating for 8-10 people. Unfortunately it closed abruptly a couple years ago, apparently due to some kind of family emergency.
- aitchnyu 1y agoThe modern version of "mob's money laundering Pizzeria becomes wildly popular legit Pizzeria" is boring.
- gorgoiler 1y agoI completely agree with your point about food quality being borne from the economic incentive of protecting an initial investment. However, I always thought the DYBOOPs and BIPLOZAs of this world existed on Amazon because of a glut of Chinese manufacturing expertise outpacing any ability to do proper branding and marketing. My QSMYYUYE grill stove, CYEER steel plates, and SUNYAY telescopic bug sprayer are all well made and reasonably priced commodity objects.
- BrenBarn 1y ago
- jjani 1y agoPretty low quality article. In plenty of countries ghost kitchens are thriving. Yet it provides no US-specific reasons for why they're dying there.
- sltkr 1y agoDon't just sneer. Give some details. In which countries are ghost kitchens thriving? How do they avoid the failure modes described in this article? Is it possible they are simply behind the curve?
- djmips 1y agoLow quality food is eventually going to catch up to you. People have to want to re-order. I think this article does a bad job of explaining why ghost kitchens are failing - to me it sounds more like a scam where they barely made the effort to actually make a good product and tried to make a quick buck - take some of that investor money. The concept, I feel, can work.
- jjani 1y ago> In which countries are ghost kitchens thriving? Much of Asia. > How do they avoid the failure modes described in this article? My suggestion was that this is exactly what a meaningful article on this topic would mention, as clearly the failure modes aren't universal. I'm not the one writing articles about it. > Is it possible they are simply behind the curve? Au contraire, ghost kitchens were already more of a thing here before COVID.
- strken 1y agoI don't know if "ghost kitchens are dying" means much. The commercial model of a ghost kitchen as an assembly line for low quality low price high throughput food delivered by expensive couriers on demand is dying, yes, and good riddance. However, when you think about it, a big chunk of the catering industry operates as a ghost kitchen. It's well known that caterers go bankrupt at lower rates than restaurants. We had a local success story called 1800 LASAGNA where a man cooked and delivered exactly one item to customers and met with a lot of success. He then opened a restaurant, which is now in voluntary administration because it was losing so much money. Catering works. I can't help but feel this is one of those "tech industry reinvents the bus" stories, where ghost kitchens lost because catering (and low-seating restaurants like pizza joints) already existed and had a massive head start. It's not that the core idea was bad: the core idea was great, it was just already out there.
- 827a 1y agoI suspect that the problem is the tech industry itself; the companies that were supposed to cut out the expensive, bloated middleman became expensive bloated middlemen themselves, which is why when you order a Starbucks Frappe and a lemon cake on Uber Eats you pay $8 to Starbucks, $7 to Uber, and $3 to the driver. Meanwhile, all that caterer has to do is answer the phone; substantially more lean.
- solatic 1y ago> Meanwhile, all that caterer has to do is answer the phone; substantially more lean. Real innovation will come when it becomes genuinely feasible for the caterer to run their own server, with some FOSS ordering system, such that there is no middle-man anymore who can jack up prices, only utility companies.
- bruce511 1y ago>> some FOSS ordering system I don't mean this cynically; but basically what you are suggesting is that some group of volunteers spend their time and effort to build out a substantial part of the business's infrastructure for free. So basically, as long as they can get the critical business software part for free, the business becomes feasible. The short answer is "this probably won't happen". FOSS isn't some magic wand that makes software appear. And if there was someone determined to make this their pet project, they would need to work closely with a kitchen to understand their requirements. It would likely work well for that kitchen (until the free labor went off and got a real job) but would need a lot more work to become "generic" to the point where a second kitchen could use it. And more work for a third. Building business systems, and keeping them maintained as the world changes, is a huge amount of work. (I've been building them for 35 years.) It's really not feasible to do it in "spare time".
- BhavdeepSethi 1y agoA lot of folks took the bet on CloudKitchens because of Travis. Even after raising $850m, CloudKitchens has never ran liquidation event for employees afaik. I wonder how they attract/retain talent in that scenario.
- baron816 1y agoIt drives me insane that the VC industry threw so much money towards delivery in so many ways (restaurant delivery, meal kits, ghost kitchens, etc), when that’s the part that matters the least. If I were to do a startup, it would be a food company that leverages drive thru. Optimize everything to maximize throughput on the drive thru by only accepting orders ahead of time (maybe even days ahead of time so that the establishment knows exactly how much food to order and prepare). The food is ready and can be dropped right into the person’s car as soon as they pull up. People are fine with driving around, especially if it’s on the way home from work or close to where they live. What they don’t like is going to the grocery story, cooking the same three basic meals they know how to cook, cleaning, and eating the same leftovers for five nights in a row. I can’t believe VCs and startup founders failed to realize the driving part was not the thing people were willing to pay a premium for at scale. They want cheap, tasty, diverse, that’s more convenient than cooking, but doesn’t need to be dropped off at their doorstep.
- Terr_ 1y ago> so much money towards delivery in so many ways It makes more sense if you see it as emerging from a meta-strategy of: Create a national middleman platform; become monopolistic by operating at a loss; trap both sides while raising fees to extract rents. The other options you're talking about aren't mustache-twirlingly exploitative enough to appeal to those investors. It would be too easy for Local Hungry Dude and Local Eatery to have a friendly chat when picking up the food, and then cut-out the (unnecessary, unproductive) middleman for future meals.
- _sys49152 1y agoleverages drive thru = real estate is expensive
- dolmen 1y agoMenu presentation, ordering, payment is also a service those companies provide. That part definitely scales. But they wanted a larger share of restaurant business.
- mrtesthah 1y ago>What they don’t like is going to the grocery story, cooking the same three basic meals they know how to cook... I personally am not fine being force-fed excess salt, sugar, low-quality oils, and other ingredients over which I have no control, ultimately leading to my risk of death increasing by 50%. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33775622/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33775622/
- geuis 1y ago@dang can we please stop changing titles that are originally informative and match the original post? I understand for cases where the submission titles are substantially different than the original. But it doesn't make sense when the original title is more informative than the altered one that mysteriously gets moderated into existence some time after the link is submitted.
- dang 1y agoThe submitted title was "Ghost Kitchens Are Dying. Here's the $15B Lesson Every Restaurateur Must Learn." Since "Here's the $15B Lesson Every Restaurateur Must Learn" is obvious linkbait—I would even say shameless linkbait—this seems like a perfectly standard title edit to me. From https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html: "Please use the original title, unless it is misleading or linkbait"
- dash2 1y ago> Approximately 7,606 ghost kitchen operations remain active across the United States5. This sounds substantial until you realize how many have closed, pivoted, or failed in the past two years. The article says this but never actually says how many have closed or failed. The only evidence it provides is that some operators have shut down. But that could be industry shakeout. So, are ghost kitchens actually doing?
- dash2 1y ago> Approximately 7,606 ghost kitchen operations remain active across the United States5. This sounds substantial until you realize how many have closed, pivoted, or failed in the past two years. The article says this but never actually says how many have closed or failed. The only evidence it provides is that some operators have shut down. But that could be industry shakeout.
- kelnos 1y ago> Shared kitchen facilities meant that one staff member prepared food for multiple brands simultaneously. No ownership. No accountability. Just assembly-line cooking with zero connection to customers. It's funny because it's not like (normal) restaurants don't exist where they have crazy-big menus with a wide range of choices and cuisines. Certainly some of them are kinda mediocre, but many are actually pretty great, and you can get a solid dish regardless of what you pick. Some pride themselves on their ability to make basically anything, and make it well. A ghost kitchen where the same staff works for several different "restaurants" simultaneously can work just fine, assuming actual training, and an effort to create quality recipes and use quality ingredients. But I can easily see how a lack of a sense of ownership among the assembly-line-style staff could make this dicey. If you're making random dishes for a random set of "brands" (a brand among many that was plucked out of a hat, complete with AI-generated food images and descriptions), you're probably not going to take much pride in the quality of your work. And I do think the author has a point about connection; certainly a connection to customers is no guarantee of quality, but I think it's a much harder sell to inspire that quality without it.
- gorgoiler 1y agoI feel the author could do more to separate “restaurants” from “takeout”. These are surely two very different market sectors. Johnny’s Pizza might have a couple of bar stools and chilli flake shakers but they’ve always been 90% focused on delivery. Chez Johnny on the other hand has always been about an in-house bistro dining experience. Ghost kitchens were always about the former. The author touches on margins being eaten up by the delivery hegemony which feels like a much more important point. The handful of online ordering marketplaces are the app/play stores of this part of the economy and I can believe that they are far too greedy and powerful. Yet would the economy tolerate a much more diverse marketplace for connecting cooks, drivers, and customers? One of the only things holding the whole system together is shitty drivers and crappy kitchens being weeded out by the major marketplaces. If drivers could just hop between apps there would be no way to filter out the rogues? They also bring up quality issues with packaging and delivery. To that extent, food delivery feels like healthcare where one cannot reasonably be expected to shop around for a surgeon to see your legs back on. When you order a meal you can’t just hope for the best knowing that if the food arrives cold and demolished then you’ll be able to get a refund and try somewhere else! Regulation here would help: your municipal certificate could not only rate food hygiene but also your ability to hit a reasonable p99 turnaround from order to order-up!.
- nerdsniper 1y ago> would the economy tolerate a much more diverse marketplace for connecting cooks, drivers, and customers? I envision some kind of government-run or mandated exchange where drivers can certify/onboard at any number of uber/lyft clones, and customers can sign up for any number of uber/lyft clones. Any request placed will be sent to the exchange and the cheapest price from a service that the passenger is willing to use is selected. This would primarily squeeze the margin of uber/lyft. That margin is what competitors can offer up to drivers for higher wages and passengers for lower prices. It's pretty wild to me that Uber/Lyft still manage to capture 25-60% of the "value" of each ride, when the overwhelmingly largest value they provide is derived from network-effect lock-in (essentially rent-seeking). Maybe drivers could set their minimum wages per mile/estimated time, and passengers could avoid companies with business practices they don't like (inadequate background checks, paying wages too low, sponsors the wrong sports team). This exchange would have to be enforced with anti-trust or just statute/regulation.
- burnt-resistor 1y ago1. Did any of them insource their own delivery? This seems like where they lost most of their money. 2. Did they adopt checklists and double-checking supervision to ensure food-safety, uniformity, and correctness? 3. Did they use quality ingredients rather than the cheapest shit Sysco sold that day? 4. Did they right-hire enough competent, sufficiently-paid staff so that churn wasn't 100% per 4 months? 5. Did anyone there ever run a successful restaurant storefront to multiple-location chain before? (Restaurants of any sort are the hardest, most grueling, tending to be risky businesses around. My grandfather became a mechanic rather than take over his father's French restaurant after going through the trouble of training to become a chef.) I'm going to make a giant leap and assume most of these were "no" and they failed horribly on execution by focusing on the wrong things.
- abstractspoon 1y agoEasy come, easy go
- Fire-Dragon-DoL 1y agoDid anybody actually open a ghost kitchen that served great food or are they just trying to scam? The problem seems to be the product,so it's essentially a scam. If the product was good,I don't see a problem with a place that's just a kitchen. The restaurants in north america seems to be all in parking lots anyway,might as well be home instead
- pllbnk 1y agoIronically, some (if not all) of the biggest companies in that market force their employees to work from offices, so they lose that potential consumer base right away.
- grimblee 1y agoI've always ordered from restaurant I actually walked in before and knew, so I'm not really surprised by this
- floppiplopp 1y agoI know capitalism and I don't always get along, but it's so good to see its desire for profitability and the need to protect investors actually kill a business that needs killing. Nice.
- mooreds 1y agoI think the food trucks fulfill the idea behind ghost kitchens of an easy, low-risk way to start a food business. They also share some of the flexibility, because you do have the option to move locations. But they have the additional benefit of a physical location so you can get profitable orders that you don't pay the UberEats tax on as well as build brand recognition.
- palmotea 1y ago> Ghost kitchens promised lower costs. The math never worked. Delivery apps charge restaurants up to 30% commission fees5. Ghost kitchen operators add rent plus percentage fees on top. Equipment repairs and maintenance create constant expenses. Marketing costs multiply when you have no storefront presence. > Layering these costs together, restaurants discovered a devastating truth: there wasn't enough money left for anyone to make a profit. So is that true of working with delivery apps, generally? All of those points are also are true of regular restaurants with a storefront, except the last one about marketing expenses. Are the delivery apps just surviving parasitically on restaurants that would be better off without them?
- JohnFen 1y ago> Are the delivery apps just surviving parasitically on restaurants that would be better off without them? Yes. At least according to the restaurants themselves.
- duxup 1y agoGohst kitchens just sound like a big corporate version of the usual story where someone without much knowledge decides that they're going to open a restaurant ... and discover that the restaurant business is REALLY HARD. They seemed to think they cut out a lot of costs, they were mistaken ... and then they partner with delivery companies who jack up the costs. >Ghost kitchens promised lower costs. The math never worked. Delivery apps charge restaurants up to 30% commission fees5. Ghost kitchen operators add rent plus percentage fees on top. Equipment repairs and maintenance create constant expenses. Marketing costs multiply when you have no storefront presence. Meanwhile there's no loyalty from customers because what is there to be loyal to? Nobody in the chain here cares about quality ... I get the wrong order or bad food, there's nobody to fix it, and I probably never do it again. It would be interesting to know what these companies had for a business plan / where they thought the numbers were going to pan out.
- csa 1y agoA buddy of mine is an executive at one of the successful ghost kitchen companies. I asked him about this article. His comments: - They aren’t dying. Most of them are just not run well, and there isn’t a widely-known “playbook” to use to spin one up. - Demand is high. Supply of what people want does not meet this demand. - Lots of people use ghost kitchens to chase fads or to try to get rich quick. These rarely work long term. - Profitable ghost kitchens are well-run kitchens (or restaurants without a front of house). - His abbreviated playbook for ghost kitchens that work: prep everything (nothing cooked to order), finishing and assembly should be the only thing done when the order comes in, every order should be done within 5 minutes (this blew my mind) so that it will get to the customer within 20 minutes, make sure your images look exactly like the food you will deliver, get packaging that makes it so that food can be delivered and still look good, advertise (promote) in the apps when you open, and cut back as organic sales and reorders start rolling in, master one location first and then scale out with a provable system, add additional compatible brands (e.g., cakes expanding to cupcakes or cookies) later in the life cycle with a similar development process (but in the same kitchen). - There is a truckload of restaurant kitchen workers who love good ghost kitchen work — high pace, limited menu (relatively speaking), no front of house staff to deal with, etc. - When a ghost kitchen hits product-market fit, labor and food costs can be sub-20% of revenue each (this is insane, imho). Marketing starts at 25% of revenue and rapidly drops to sub-5%. Note that this is based on what they receive from the delivery companies, so percentage of sales is higher. - My friend can spin up a new location in 20 days and $10k from getting the go ahead to delivering food. That includes setting up the kitchen, hiring, training, and initial inventory.