7 ms·
How to make metals from Martian dirt
- nine_k 1y agoIn short: they just heated some (simulated) Martian dirt, and this alone was sufficient to produce liquid iron, and then liquid iron-silicon alloy. No huge quantities of carbon were required. This is quite surprising to me. Making steel, with controlled carbon content, would be quite another challenge. Carbon is readily available on Mars, but only in the form of CO2.
- staticautomatic 1y agoIron would be fine since there’s basically no atmosphere to oxidize it right?
- Yoric 1y agoIsn't steel also much stronger?
- foota 1y agoIron is a lot heavier than steel and probably weaker too (IINAMS, ask your material scientist)
- adrian_b 1y agoBy "iron", I assume that you mean "cast iron", as pure iron is hardly used for anything. Cast iron is lighter than steel, not heavier, because of its higher carbon content. However, objects made of cast iron are indeed heavier than similar objects made of steel, and this is what you must have in mind, because the objects made of cast iron are always made thicker, both because cast iron is weaker, which requires greater thickness for the same strength, and because it is harder to make thinner objects by casting than by forging.
- foota 1y agoTIL, thanks!
- dmurray 1y agoNo, steels have 4-6x higher tensile strength (and better performance in other related properties) than raw iron. [0] They're not just preferred over iron for their corrosion resistance. And note that even what we call "cast iron" - a material that reasonably could be preferred to steel for some industrial purposes - is an iron-carbon alloy that in fact has more carbon than steel[1]. [0] https://www.texasironandmetal.com/strength-of-steel-compares-to-strength-of-other-metals/ https://www.texasironandmetal.com/strength-of-steel-compares... [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cast_iron https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cast_iron
- rolph 1y agooxidation is a chemical process, [LEO says GER] that which Loses Electrons is Oxidized, that which Gains Electrons is Reduced. it isnt always oxygen that does this, a difference of RedOx potential allowing redistribution of electrons is all you need. mars has a perchlorate problem thus carbon compounds are converted to carbonate via Oxidation when encountering ubiquitous perchloate mineral deposits. its toxic to carbon based biochemical forms, and destructive to carbon materials, such as carbon fibre; carbon nanotubes; carbon steel; even a lot of keypads. ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Pesky Perchlorates All Over Mars: https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.340.6129.138-b https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.340.6129.138-b
- XorNot 1y agoWe learned it as OILRIG: oxidation is loss, reduction is gain
- PaulHoule 1y agoSteel has between 2% and 0.05% carbon, that's not really a lot, particularly when you consider martian colonists will want materials like sugar and polyester that have a much higher carbon content. [1] There are numerous ways to fix carbon from CO2. If you can grow plants you can make a char out of them which what people used to use to reduce iron and add carbon as an alloying elements. There is a huge amount of research on turning CO2 into CO so that it can be mixed with H2 (then they call it syngas) and then build up larger molecules such as methane, methanol, gasoline, fats, etc. https://news.mit.edu/2024/engineers-find-new-way-convert-carbon-dioxide-useful-products-0327 https://news.mit.edu/2024/engineers-find-new-way-convert-car... It's not a question of being able to do it but instead doing it better, cheaper, harder, faster, ... The funny thing about reduction of iron (and many metals) is that it can be done with either of the two ingredients of syngas, CO [2] or H2 and either way you get the oxide CO2 or H2O as a byproduct. If space colonists think that volatiles are precious they'll practice chemical cycling, turning those back into reactive CO or H. On the moon or asteroids I'm pretty sure people would think either C or H2 is precious and wouldn't waste it, I am not sure about Martians (e.g. if you can get CO2 out of the atmosphere it might not seem like a crime to vent it) [1] people think "technology" and they think "metals" but actually a lot of what you want is made of carbon, hydrogen, oxygen and nitrogen (CHON) [2] what a blast furnace uses
- nine_k 1y agoYes, the problem is likely not in getting enough carbon (though a kiloton of steel would require several tons of it), but rather having a mass production process advanced enough to precisely control it. Almost all heavy equipment would have to be bootstrapped on Mars, mostly from the inevitably subpar local materials, and ith access to energy that's worse than on Earth: no fossil fuels, no hydro-energy, much less sunlight.
- PaulHoule 1y agoEveryone who's seriously considered space colonization has come to the same conclusion that Eric Drexler did -- you need to have some kind of system that can make absolutely everything with as small a population supporting it as possible. You've got the problem that there's nothing that could manufactured on Mars that would be worth bringing back to Earth. If a Martian colony was dependent on Earth for anything it would expect to get its resources cut off at any time, and even if you can get spare parts and stuff from Earth the turn-around time counting the synodic period and transit time will always be several years. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Martian_Way https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Martian_Way I think it could be possible with some combination of synthetic biology, fermentation, flow chemistry, 3-d printing and such. It's a good northstar for research into "advanced manufacturing" which could come in handy here on Earth.
- ACCount37 1y agoIt's a given that if you're taking space exploration seriously, you need ISRU. You can't ship everything to Moon or Mars from Earth - you need to learn how to process and refine local materials. This is the key advantage of going to Mars or Moon surface, as opposed to operating a space station. A space station exists in a vacuum. Surface bases have access to local materials. Sadly, very few planned space missions have this kind of ambition. That recent proposal US had about putting a nuclear reactor on the Moon was at least a step in the right direction - if you're bringing an entire reactor, that means you're establishing a permanent base, complete with an industry that would generate the demand for power.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- ChuckMcM 1y agoPretty neat. This would certainly make for an interesting Mars mission should SpaceX want to try it, land a lander, have the lander process regolith into iron chunks, create a pile of chunks. All good threshold goals. What ever happened the asteroid mining folks? They have a similar problem, albeit with very little gravity and no atmosphere, but their metals are in theory worth a lot more (platinum, gold, silver, Etc.) There was a similar idea/proposal for extracting aluminum from Lunar regolith, also a good space mission for private interests. Once you've got basic metals you can make more interesting things, with iron you can make reinforced concrete which would be an interesting building material on Mars I suspect.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- thaumasiotes 1y ago> There was a similar idea/proposal for extracting aluminum from Lunar regolith, also a good space mission for private interests. With the asteroids, I assume the idea is to bring enough platinum and gold back to Earth to offset the costs of getting them from space. That doesn't sound especially realistic, but in the right circumstances I guess it could be. With aluminum on the moon or iron on Mars, that will never happen. You'd have to want to use those materials on location. So what would the value be of producing aluminum on the moon?
- jacquesm 1y ago> So what would the value be of producing aluminum on the moon? Building more rockets? Interesting detail: there isn't enough oxygen there to cause aluminum to immediately be covered with a skin of aluminum oxide. I wonder what the energy cost of an extraction process for aluminum on the moon would be. At the same time I would hate to see the moon mined, that's one piece of common property that we should maybe try to preserve unless we have no other alternative, not just for commerce.
- PaulHoule 1y ago
- aj7 1y agoI have a fairly generic reaction to this. Make metals at the top of Everest. Then we’ll talk.
- adastra22 1y agoYou’re right, that is a generic reaction. And completely ignorant of the different chemistry, environment, and context.
- wiml 1y agoReally? Seems like building a manufacturing capability on Everest or Antarctica or a Saharan dune sea would be easier in every single way.
- adastra22 1y agoWhile there is a lot that could be said about this at the object level, the correct answer is “so what?”
- margalabargala 1y agoYou're right, it would be easier in every single way. It would also be different enough that it's not a useful or meaningful comparison. You might as well say "bake a cake while standing on stilts, then we'll talk". By the way, humans have been mining, and on-and-off purifying, iron from the Saharan dune sea for a thousand years. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zou%C3%A9rat https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zou%C3%A9rat
- aj7 1y agoOK. As a warmup exercise, make metals at the top of Everest. Then we’ll talk.
- gsf_emergency_2 1y agoYou can get regolith simulant from Amazon, please do try this at home https://www.themartiangarden.com/ https://www.themartiangarden.com/ https://www.amazon.com/Regolith-Simulant-Authentic-Martian-Replicant/dp/B0D94YYYG7 https://www.amazon.com/Regolith-Simulant-Authentic-Martian-R...
- mcrider 1y agoThere’s a good recent book series about this by Daniel Suarez called Delta V (in the first book they process regolith from an asteroid; in the second book its on the moon; presumably the unreleased third book is on Mars).
- comechao 1y agoOn the topic, the ANTHROFUTURISM YouTube channel is excellent for learning about building on the Moon using regolith: https://www.youtube.com/@Anthrofuturism https://www.youtube.com/@Anthrofuturism
- bruce511 1y agoThere is the small detail of heating the regolith to 1400c. It's not very clear where that energy comes from (at least not at scale). Burning fuels seems to be out. So I guess nuclear or solar? Mars solar is weaker than earth, but I guess let's of panels plus lots of batteries could work. Sorta. Not sure it produces "tons" of material very quickly. Nuclear is the other option. But would rely on fuel from earth. Not to mention that building a reactor big enough to sustain a colony, plus industry, would be challenging. And of course landing fresh uranium on Mars would be risky. (It's heavy, and any accident would render a chunk of Mars radioactive for quite some time.) Oh, and the reactor would need to be air-cooled not water-cooled. But, I guess, yay regolith?
- strken 1y agoCan't you eventually mine and enrich uranium on Mars itself?
- bruce511 1y agoIt's possible, although unlikely, that there are mineable deposits of uranium on Mars. There are trace amounts, but its unlikely that minable deposits formed.
- chii 1y agowhy is there unlikely to be mine-able uranium deposits? It's not like there's some geological process on mars that strips it away (presumably).
- MangoToupe 1y agoI think the implication is that uranium likely exists in low density and cannot be easily extracted without a great deal of chemical processing and disposal of waste product (rather than deposits of uranium a la natural reactors: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Natural_nuclear_fission_reactor https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Natural_nuclear_fission_reac...)
- 1y ago
- teleforce 1y ago>Swinburne and CSIRO researchers have successfully made iron under Mars-like conditions, opening the door to off-world metal production. Not trying to be pedantic but really curious, it should be off-earth not off-world, right? Off-world meaning that the iron production is made by alien not human.
- zokier 1y agoGoogle defines (citing Oxford Languages) offworld as: * away from earth or (in science fiction) from a place treated as the native world. * involving, located in, or coming from a place outside one's native world or planet. While Wiktionary defines it as: * (chiefly science fiction) Not on Earth. * (chiefly science fiction) Away from Earth. https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/offworld https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/offworld To me that sounds like Mars would qualify
- HPsquared 1y agoBeing assigned to Mars will be the new "sent to Siberia".
- IAmBroom 1y agoFun Fact: There is a 0% chance we will go to Mars this century! Elon's hyperloop is more realistic, and RFK Jr's medical theories are safer than the journey would be.
- FL33TW00D 1y agoWould you like to place a bet on it?
- tiahura 1y agoGo and stay is 0.
- IAmBroom 1y agoYes, I should have specified that, as that's what I meant. I'm not sure of the point in sending a human there and back without a colony, but that wouldn't stop us if we find an emotional reason. The poor astronaut will die young after their return, of course, but that's true for many occupations already. Not surprised at the downvotes I got. "We're going to live out there! Soon!" is baked into us by every TV show, movie, and book around us, it seems. But it is nowhere as easy as "2001: A Space Odyssey" promised. Not even as easy as "Space 1999".
- _diyar 1y agoWould you be willing to enter a 100'000'000-to-1 bet? If we make it before the century, you make me a millionaire and if we don't I'll give you a dollar. Should be within your risk tolerance given you think the chance is 0.
- IAmBroom 1y agoI'll introduce you to the concept of rounding off digits soon. There is a 0.0% chance you understood that.
- sulandor 1y agolack of touching grass seems to be a prohibitive factor; besides the radiation
- moralestapia 1y agoThis is so exciting. I really hope Musk succeeds in bringing humans to Mars so all this tech-tree can finally be unlocked!