7 ms·
> They also got me reported to HR by the manager of the XROS effort for supposedly making his team members feel bad I've only seen John Carmack's public intera
by Aurornis 1y ago
> They also got me reported to HR by the manager of the XROS effort for supposedly making his team members feel bad
I've only seen John Carmack's public interactions, but they've all been professional and kind.
It's depressing to imagine HR getting involved because someone's feelings had been hurt by an objective discussion from a person like John Carmack.
I'm having flashbacks to the times in my career when coworkers tried to weaponize HR to push their agenda. Every effort was eventually dismissed by HR, but there is a chilling effect on everyone when you realize that someone at the company is trying to put your job at stake because they didn't like something you said. The next time around, the people targeted are much more hesitant to speak up.
- randall 1y agometa was a weird place for a while. because of psc (the performance rating stuff) being so important… a public post could totally demoralize a team because if a legend like carmack thinks that your project is a waste of resources, how is that going to look on your performance review? impact is facebook for “how useful is this to the company” and its an explicit axis of judgement.
- aprilthird2021 1y agoBut... That's not an HR violation. If something a team is working on is a waste of resources, it's a waste. You can either realize that and pivot to something more useful (like an effort to take the improvements of the current OS project and apply them to existing OSes), or stubbornly insist on your value. Why is complaining to HR even an option on the table?
- fluoridation 1y agoComplaining is always an option. The problem is that HR actually takes the complaint seriously.
- firesteelrain 1y agoOne could argue that if it’s not in your swim lane, you just let it fail. And if you aren’t that person’s manager, you tell them the code or design that you are reviewing and thus the gatekeeper is not adequate. Politely. You said your part and no need to get yourself in trouble. Document and move on. If the company won’t listen then you move on. No need to turn it into a HR issue.
- spydum 1y agoFully agree with this point we all know as engineers this shit is nails on the chalkboard.
- alanbernstein 1y agoCarmack's swim lane was exceptionally wide. My understanding was that this sort of criticism was actually his main job duty.
- gafferongames 1y agoImagine being a meta engineer and not taking Carmack's advice seriously. Why the fuck is he even hired there if you are not going to listen to him. Dude has forgotten more things about game development than you will ever know...
- dedup-com 1y agoThere were quite a few of high-caliber individuals with equally impressive resumes in the organization to match Carmack's wisdom and ego.
- Tostino 1y agoThe metaverse has really showcased that. They finally have feet now, right? Only light fun. I'm just a little perplexed at their progress and direction over the past 7-8 years. I don't understand how they can have so many high caliber people and put out...that.
- bongodongobob 1y agoJust because something isn't an HR violation doesn't mean it's not wrong, rude, or unprofessional. Society is not a computer program. Being tactful is important to well adjusted people.
- lll-o-lll 1y agoHard disagree. Being tactful is only relevant when dealing with people, criticise an idea, a project, a solution as much as you like. Intellectual debate is the fire from which genuinely good ideas are forged.
- LPisGood 1y agoUnfortunately people have ideas, projects, and solutions that they care deeply about. Like it or not, some tact when dealing with these things goes a long way.
- lll-o-lll 1y ago> Unfortunately people have ideas, projects, and solutions that they care deeply about. This is true of course, but this is also true for the “search for truth” in science. Do we fail to point out the flaw in the reasoning of someone’s life's work for fear of offence? The truth is the higher ideal that must be strived for! In the same way, an idea is only good once it has been challenged. It may fail and dissolve, it may survive, it may morph into something that can no longer be assailed. This is the forgers fire, and it is necessary. I know this isn’t as black and white as I’m painting it, but the ideal is still something worth striving for.
- LPisGood 1y agoYeah, yeah all that’s true. Ideas are better if they’re challenged, etc. but the fact is people don’t like being challenged. Also, software engineering is a field where there’s rarely some ideal truth we’re trying to achieve, and indeed even in science, people do often fail to point out flaws in reasoning for fear of offense.
- this_user 1y agoHow large is their headcount these days? And how many actually useful products have they launched in the last decade? You could probably go full Twitter and fire 90% of the people, and it would make no difference from a user perspective.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- kranke155 1y agoFacebook has literally done very little in terms of new breakthrough products in a decade at least, and Bytedance has apparently just beat them on revenue.
- shortrounddev2 1y agoMasters of doom portrays carmack as a total dictator of a boss. Doom Guy by John Romero seems to back this up
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- pinoy420 1y ago[dead]
- leoc 1y agoMasters of Doom does seems to want to, however accurately or not, set Carmack up as the antagonist of its story against Romero as the hero sometimes. I think that readers just largely didn't notice that since Carmack's heroic image was already so firmly established. In fact some of the early-ID stuff really does seem to raise some questions. (Was Tim Willits mostly Carmack's protégé, for instance?)
- shortrounddev2 1y agoyeah and Doom Guy takes a lot of issues with Masters of Doom. You get the impression that MoD was looking to create a McCartney vs Lennon story and stretched the truth to do so (there are several factual errors in the book). In Doom Guy, though, Romero says that after he left iD, he heard from others still working there that the company had become something of a dictatorship under Carmack, and that within X months (I forget how many), half the company had quit. Romero also qualifies several times that they were all in their early/mid-20s and didn't have the requisite life experience to be handling business situations well
- howdyhowdy123 1y agoHehehe. I have talked to John Carmack a few times. He's super harsh and has zero filter or social niceties (Azperger's level, not that he is, but just sayin'). If you are not used to it or understand where it's coming from, it can be quite a shock. Or at least he was, many years ago. Maybe he's changed.
- thepryz 1y agoI can see that. Sadly, there are a lot of people in the world who simply don't know how to deal with people who can be direct, if not somewhat abrasive, in their communication style. Their intent can be noble, well-intentioned, and not meant to offend. They simply don't beat around the bush or worry about whether your fragile ego will be bruised when they make an observation. I've had to coach people and help them understand the entitlement involved in demanding that everyone adjust and adhere to their personal preferences and communication style. In my experience, it's about seeking to understand the person and adapt accordingly. Not everyone is willing to do that.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- techpineapple 1y agoFor another take - what’s the game theory here? If I’m kinda sensitive but also hyper-ambitious, I acknowledge that Facebook has 1. Some of the highest pay in the industry. 2. Ultra-competitive environment. 3. Low moral principles. Seems like the strategy would be to use every lever at your disposal to manipulate your environment, rather than leave and risk getting paid less.
- thepryz 1y agoExpecting that you can change people, in my experience, is quixotic. What you can change is yourself and how you interpret and respond to events around you. If I understand the hypothetical you've proposed, my advice would be for you to adapt and learn to be less sensitive rather than have you believe that you can manipulate the environment, or worse, directly manipulate people. It's possible that you could be a positive influence for change, so I don't want to completed discount any effort there, but I also think it's worth being realistic about what you can actually affect.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- markus_zhang 1y agoI have mixed feelings about this. In one part, JC is someone I look up to, at least from the perspective of engineering. On the other hand, putting myself in the shoes in someone who got the once in life chance to build a new OS with corp support for a new shiny device…I for hell would want to do this.
- WD-42 1y agoExactly! It seems very narc-y. Just let me build my cool waste of company resources, it's not like Zucky is going to notice, he's too busy building his 11 homes. Imagine being able to build an operating system, basically the end-game of being a programmer, and get PAID for it. Then some nerd tells on you.
- markus_zhang 1y agoI'm not sure if you are trying to be /s, but yeah that's basically what I'm trying to say. Definitely better than working on those recommendation systems. Damn, I'd pay to work in some serious OS/Compiler teams, but hey why should they hire me? Oh well...Yeah I'm doing a bit of projects on my side but man I'm so burnt out by my 9am-5pm $$ job + 5pm-10pm kid job that I barely have any large chunk of time to work on those.
- WD-42 1y agoNot sarcastic at all. I'm in the same boat. I've been trying to get into contributing to Redox, but at the end of the work day when the kid is finally asleep it's hard to motivate.
- markus_zhang 1y agoI get it man. It’s really tough. How old is your kid? Mine is a 5 years old boy and he doesn’t seem to need a lot of sleep but a huge amount of companionship which really bugs me out. In theory, it’s better to sleep early, get up around 5 and get 2 hours of quality time, but man he sometimes gets up around 6:15 and earlier, and I found it difficult to get good sleep anyway, so I tried to switch to 2 hours of night time, but he wants to sleep with me for 30 mins around 9pm before going to my wife’s bed, and I usually fell sleep sooner than he did… Girls are much easier to raise. They sleep earlier and don’t fight too much, as far as I heard from friends.
- zoeysmithe 1y agoSorry but if you know his story, seen candid videos of him, or talked to the people around him, he's a Linus-level "I'll say what I want" type. There weird hagiographies need to go. Carmack is absolutely not known to be kind. I have no idea what happened here but the idea that's he's this kindly old grandpa who could never, ever be rude or unprofessional is really out there.
- lll-o-lll 1y agoAnd stupid. Like it or hate it, a non-nonsense, direct speaking, but fair and objective boss is the one you want. No one is served by failure; not the people at the top, nor the people at the bottom. There is a difference between “this project is not going to work” vs “these people are incompetent and the project should be cancelled as a result”. The former needs to be said, the latter is a HR violation.
- dedup-com 1y agoCarmack absolutely 100% percent did not say "these people are incompetent". What he said boils down to "these people are world's best experts on writing operating systems and they'd love to write a new one from the scratch but I strongly believe that writing a new operating system is not the best path forward."
- lll-o-lll 1y ago> Carmack absolutely 100% percent did not say "these people are incompetent". Sorry if I wasn’t clear; this was the point I was actually trying to make. Direct and to the point should not a HR incident make. I was trying to contrast with something that would.
- theshackleford 1y ago> I've only seen John Carmack's public interactions, but they've all been professional and kind. You don't know someone or how they really behave because they are a public figure.
- nrp 1y agoI’ve been on both the same side and the opposing side of debates with him, both in person and over internal discussion threads. His public persona and private behavior match. I viewed it positively, though per the topic of the thread, not everyone did.
- theshackleford 1y agoThat’s very different than simply observing someone in public. Which is what my post was referring too to and so it remains accurate. FWIW I like carmack from what I have seen publically (and Romero, who I have interacted with) but I wouldn’t pretend to know who either of them really are from my observation of them.
- lokar 1y agoI saw the same thing at Google. A distinguished engineer tried gently at first to get a Jr engineer to stop trying to do something that was a bad idea. They persisted so he told them very bluntly to stop. HR got involved. I even found myself letting really bad things go by because it was just going to take way to much of my time to spoon feed people and get them to stop.
- LPisGood 1y agoWhat kind of thing is bad enough that it warrants multiple discussions without the junior engineer getting the hint that it’s a bad idea?
- knorker 1y agoA junior engineer can make an API that can basically live forever as tech debt. (Especially if it's an "API" persisted to disk)
- lokar 1y agoI can’t say much without it being clear who it was, but a critical low level thing. And the Sr was generally a very nice person who did not give much weight to levels, willing to engage with anyone.
- dagmx 1y agoJohn can be quite blunt and harsh in person, from everyone I know who’s interacted with him. If he doesn’t believe in something, he can sometimes be over critical and it’s hard to push back in that kind of power imbalance.
- stephc_int13 1y agoCarmack is a legend and I admire his work, but he seems to believe his own legend these days (like a few others big-ego gamedevs) and that can lead to arbitrary preferences being sold as gospel.
- spydum 1y agoI'm sure that's true but I've worked with a lot of engineers that are of this caliber and as long as you can form a coherent logical explanation they will bend they're way more open than you expect. But you got to put in the work to make that argument. They won't take it on faith
- stephc_int13 1y agoIt is an entirely different thing, gifted, highly experienced and confident in his assertions is quite frequent, but the cult-like following and status of personalities like Carmack or Blow can seriously alter their own self perception and importance.
- Aeolun 1y agoOf course it can. It’s hard not to assume you are right if everyone keeps telling you so. I can’t really fault them for that. The challenge is to continue being right more often than not.
- baq 1y agoFirst, look at what they’re shipping, then decide the likelihood of them being right. Maybe you know something they don’t; it’s actually very likely. But maybe what you think matters actually doesn’t at all and ultimately they’re right. In either case, they were shipping, so best to listen and be prepared if you disagree.
- wilg 1y agoIt is very much not an objective discussion if you are discussing whether it makes sense to develop a new operating system.
- knorker 1y agoHow is it not?
- wilg 1y agoBecause it's a judgement call about how you weigh and weight various factors, it's inherently subjective.
- knorker 1y agoIt's hard, but it's not subjective. There are many factors on whether to use a one handed or two handed backhand in tennis. It's subjective which one feels better, but there exists an objective answer to whether it makes a particular player better or not. And just because it's hard and experts can get it wrong, doesn't mean expertise means nothing and "it's all subjective". The fact that there exists a right and a wrong definitially means it's objective. And for the business, or the project, there is a right and a wrong, on whether to build an OS or not. Even if it's very hard to predict, and not feasible to A/B test.
- wilg 1y agoNo, it's subjective because there is no right and wrong. The business goals themselves are subjective. There is no right answer to whether you should build an operating system. Very related to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Is%E2%80%93ought_problem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Is%E2%80%93ought_problem
- knorker 1y agoSo you're saying there's no right and wrong decision on whether to make your own OS because Meta has not decided whether it's a public corporation with fiduciary duty or a kindergarten for OS hobbyists to have unproductive wasteful but fun projects in? So that's like saying there's no right or wrong answer on whether to leave your 15th floor apartment a normal morning via the stairs, or by jumping out of the bathroom window. Yes, actually, there is. Unless your goal is to go splat. "Will this make the product better", "will this make the product deliver sooner", "will this be a net positive to the company's bottom line" are all objective, though hard, questions. > Very related to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Is%E2%80%93ought_problem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Is%E2%80%93ought_problem Nonsense. The company already has many many oughts already. Otherwise words mean nothing, and the "right answer" to an interview question about hashmaps is to strip naked and start humping the trash can. And on my tennis analogy, it's objective that one way or the other allows a gives player to win more games. So we can call it "better". Even though you can still argue whether you "ought" to try to win.
- jamra 1y agoI followed his posts internally before he left. He was strict about resource waste. Hand tracking would break constantly and he brought metrics to his posts. His whole point was that Apple has hardware nailed down and it’ll be efficient software that will be the differentiator. The bloat at Meta was the result of empire building.
- Fade_Dance 1y agoI remember watching Carmack at a convention 15 years ago. He took a short sabbatical and came back with ID Tech 3 on an iPhone, and it still looks amazing well over a decade later. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=52hMWMWKAMk&t=1s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=52hMWMWKAMk&t=1s This is a guy who figures that what he wants to do most with his 3 free weekends is to port his latest, greatest engine to a Cortex-A8. Leading corporate strategy? Maybe not. But Carmack on efficiency? Just do it.
- markus_zhang 1y agoImpressive. JC is always one of the engineers I look up to and read up to when depressed. John Carmack, David Cutler, Tom West, Cameron Zwarich, etc. There are about maybe 50 of them.
- Fade_Dance 1y agoCarmack and Jim Keller for me. Hardware engineering for the latter!
- markus_zhang 1y agoHW is kinda too magical for me at this age :)
- jkestner 1y agoWhere are the good war stories on Keller?
- chem83 1y agoThis is what got Lucovsky pushed out. He wanted to build OS from scratch and couldn't see past the technical argument and acknowledge the Product's team urgency to actually land something in the hands of customers. Meanwhile, he left a trail of toxicity that he doesn't even realize was there[0]. Interestingly, he was pulling the same bs at Google until reason prevailed and he got pushed out (but allowed to save face and claim he resigned willingly[1]). [0] https://x.com/yewnyx/status/1793684535307284948 https://x.com/yewnyx/status/1793684535307284948 [1] https://x.com/marklucovsky/status/1678465552988381185 https://x.com/marklucovsky/status/1678465552988381185
- jayd16 1y agoIf you're in high leadership, even just being pessimistic can be a massive morale killer. It doesn't mean that going to HR is the right call but I could see how someone would vent that way.
- rvba 1y agoIf you are senior leadership and you find that your org has some people do useless side projects for fun (and tons of money) what delivers no value, your job is to solve this problem by reassigning or firing them. Facebook VR never needed a new OS in the first place. It needed actual VR.
- shistkye 1y ago> They also got me reported to HR by the manager of the XROS effort for supposedly making his team members feel bad This is one of the reasons I’m sick of working pretty much anywhere anymore: I can’t be myself. Appreciating people for their differences when they are humble and gifted is easy. I side with liberals, but I have a mix of liberal, moderate, and conservative friends. But there are only so many years of pretending to appreciate all of the self-focused people that could be so much better at contributing to the world if they could quietly and selflessly work hard and respect people with different beliefs and backgrounds. I’m happy for the opportunity I have to work, and I understand how millennials think and work. But working with boomers and/or gen X-ers would be so much less stressful. I could actually have real conversations with people. I don’t think the problem is really with HR. I think the problem is a generation that was overly pandered to just doesn’t mix with the other generations, and maybe they shouldn’t.
- fijiaarone 1y agoIf the younger generation is too pandered and can’t take criticism or honest feedback, thats the fault of the older generation.
- glaslong 1y agometa tends to keep people so on edge, with performance so heavily based on peer agreement, that it creates a sort of defensive toxic positivity a little bit a negative feedback at high level can domino quickly too. massive pivots, reorgs, the works.
- izacus 1y agoYeah, people getting really angry if you say anything bad about a product (!) is a depressing commonality in certain places these days. I got angry emails from people because I wrote "replacing a primary page of UI with this feature I never use doesn't give me a lot of value" because statements like that make "the team feel bad". It was an internal beta test with purpose of finding issues before they go public. Not surprisingly, once this culture holds root, the products start going down the drain too. But who cares about good products in this great age of AI, right?
- anal_reactor 1y agoWhen I compare workplace dynamics in the American company I work for with local company a friend of mine works for, I feel like I sold my soul to the devil.
- KaiserPro 1y agoI think the issue is, Carmack didn't talk like a "normal" facebook engineer. Supposedly you were meant to have you disagreements in private, and come to support what ever was decided. "hold your opinions lightly" The latest version of it was something like "disagree and commit". This meant that you got a shit tonne of group think. This pissed off Carmack no end, because it meant shitty decisions were let out the door. He kept on banging on about "time to fun". This meant that any feature that got in the way of starting a game up as fast a possible, would get a public rebuke. (rightly so) People would reply with "but the metric we are trying to move is x,y & z" which invariably would be some sub-team PSC (read promotion/bonus/not getting fired system) optimisation. Carmack would basically say that the update was bad, and they should feel bad. This didn't go down well, because up until 2024 one did not speak negatively about anything on workplace. (Once carmack reported a bug to do with head tracking[from what I recall] there was lots of backwards and forwards, with the conclusion that "won't fix, dont have enough resources". Carmack replied with a diff he'd made fixing the issue.) Basically Carmack was all about the experience, and Facebook was all about shipping features. This meant that areas of "priority" would scale up staffing. Leaders distrusted games engineers("oh they don't pass our technical interviews"), so pulled in generalists with little to no experience of 3D. This translated in small teams that produced passable features growing 10x in 6 months and then producing shit. But because they'd grown so much, they constantly re-orged pushed out the only 3d experts they had, they could then never deliver. But as it was a priority, they couldn’t back down This happened to: Horizons (the original roblox clone) video conferencing in oculus Horizons (the shared experience thing, as in all watching a live broadcast together) Both those horizons (I can't remember what the original names were) Were merged into horizons world, along with the video conferencing for workplace originally each team was like 10, by the time that I left, it was something like a thousand or more. With the original engineers either having left or moved on to something more productive. tldr: Facebook didn't take to central direction setting, ie before we release product x, all its features must work, be integrated with each other, and have a obvious flow/narrative that links them together. Carmack wanted a good product, facebook just wanted to iterate shit out the door to see what stuck.