9 ms·
"Six strikes" Internet warning system will come to US this year
- masukomi 14y agoA prediction: Members of Anonymous (or similar) will hack the home wifi of every congressman/woman related to this, and cause them to receive six "educational alerts" and then get cut off. Soon thereafter the law will change or die.
- redthrowaway 14y agoThat's not a bad idea, but I highly doubt congresscritters would be cut off. A simple phone call would likely get them exempted.
- Natsu 14y agoI don't know where things stand with this program, but back in the days when MediaDefender's email was leaked, one of those laid out a policy of not going after politicians and the like.
- redthrowaway 14y agoPerhaps fittingly, Anonymous has a similar policy of not going after journalists. Don't bite the hand that feeds you...
- tokenizer 14y agoHmmm. I'm from Canada, and therefore have no opinion on this but, has this been in the news at all until now?
- k3n 14y agoIt's news to me! It probably just took a backseat to SOPA/etc. and was likely tabled at that time, only to resurface now that those efforts have been unsuccessful.
- pyre 14y agoIt's been in the news several times before, many of them via ArsTechnica as well.
- sp332 14y agoYeah it's come up a few times over the past year. http://www.hnsearch.com/search#request/submissions&q=six+strikes&sortby=create_ts+asc http://www.hnsearch.com/search#request/submissions&q=six...
- fjorder 14y agoPay attention. What's implemented in the U.S. will be pushed heavily by U.S. lobbyists in Ottawa next. e.g. After the DMCA and associated acts in the U.S. were passed, U.S. lobbyists went to work in Canada. The result was a series of bills that were delayed and ultimately not passed by the recent series of minority governments. To ramp up pressure on Canada, the U.S. added Canada to it's piracy "priority watch list" along with countries like China. Piracy is practically non-existent in Canada as compared to China, but that list was never about where piracy is actually happening! Canada will likely never be taken off that list unless we completely obliterate our own film and TV industries and turn the CBC into a re-broadcaster for HBO. Now that there's a majority government, the successor to those failed bills, Bill C-11, is now in the process of being passed. It cleared the House of Commons in June. This bill contains some truly bad legislation on digital locks. i.e. If media has a "digital lock" such as the half-assed encryption on DVD's, it is illegal to circumvent those locks even for fair-use or educational purposes. e.g. Ripping a DVD to your laptop so you can watch it on the plane without bringing along an external DVD player is now illegal because you had to use software that breaks a digital lock to do so. For more on this, read: http://www.michaelgeist.ca/content/view/6544/125/ http://www.michaelgeist.ca/content/view/6544/125/ Canada will see it's own 6-strikes legislation soon enough.
- k3n 14y ago> [...] but in no way was missing a July deadline a missed deadline Thanks for clearing that up, Ms. Doublespeak.
- luu 14y agothe new program is meant to educate account holders and younger users about the perils of downloading unauthorized content What perils? Later in the article, lawsuits are mentioned, but the whole thing is pretty vague. Putting aside both the legality and morality, doesn't this policy seem odd? If there's nothing wrong with what people are doing, then there's no need for this at all. If people are doing something wrong, shouldn't there be legal censure, or something? Not just a warning about some mysterious "perils of downloading unauthorized content"? What premises could you possibly have that would make the correct conclusion "warn people 5 times and then take some vague and indeterminate action"?
- sp332 14y agoThe perils are mainly getting sued for copyright infringement. I'm all for copyright even if the current scheme is insane. The legal problem is that no one can tell if the content is authorized or not. Maybe it's fair use, maybe I legitimately bought it, or maybe it's similar enough to another video that the bot got confused. Sending a warning is just a way to sidestep the judicial oversight that a legitimate legal action would entail.
- ninnypants 14y agoI've been wondering how they would tell if it was legitimate as well. There are some easy checks that would indicate that it was coming from a legal source like the site it's coming from, but what if I'm downloading from my dropbox account or from a remote backup. How is legitimacy determined then. Do I just get a strike for completely legal activity.
- wmf 14y agoIn general, Hollywood movies are not legitimately available over any P2P system. P2P monitoring companies can't see your Dropbox, so that's not a concern. Also, you can challenge strikes if you think they're in error.
- ninnypants 14y ago
- stephengillie 14y agoIs there US governmental oversight of this program? Or is it just a business arrangement between numerous copyright holding companies and ISPs? It looks like the latter. After an end user has received all 6 strikes, they could be sued or the ISP could cut them off. Nothing prevents someone from being sued before completing all 6 strikes, and a user could possibly complete 6 strikes and receive no penalty. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copyright_alert_system https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copyright_alert_system
- sp332 14y agoIt has been specifically designed to avoid regulation. The ISPs opt-in, there are no prescribed penalties, there are no legal notices or anything that would involve the courts.
- mtgx 14y agoThe Obama administration did play as a "mediator", but you're right. This system is specifically designed to avoid regulation, because they know they wouldn't get that regulation. This way they can sidestep it by "partnering" with the ISP's and carriers.
- mtgx 14y agoI have the feeling this will end up very bad for Americans, much like the patent system, and then there will be a decade or more before anyone even tries to revert it.
- rm999 14y agoYou make it sound like this is official government policy or a law, but it's just an agreement between some private companies. Copyright holders can already can communicate with ISPs and ISPs can already shut off someone's internet. My ISP used to forward me copyright violation notices periodically (it was my roommate's doing), and claimed they could shut off my internet after three of them. This six 'strike' policy seems lenient in comparison.
- nitrogen 14y agoYou make it sound like this is official government policy or a law, but it's just an agreement between some private companies. Not just any private companies. These are agreements between private companies whose size and influence gives them a unique position of control over peoples' lives; such a partnership, negotiated with the involvement of the white house, might as well be official government policy or law.
- bediger4000 14y agoCorrect. Due to Government policies on broadband and telecomm in general, effectively no competition exists in most urban areas for broadband access. So, these 6 (or so) ISPs can make an abusive "6 Strikes" copyright regime into de facto national law.
- acabal 14y agoI don't get it... why do the ISPs even bother opting in? Isn't it just time and money spent on basically making their customers angry, and for what benefit on their part? Why spend money on something that provides no obvious benefit, and many negatives, to the company? I know some ISPs are also content providers, so I get that one. But what about the rest?
- MaysonL 14y agoBit-torrented videos probably constitute a significant fraction of their bandwidth. If this is cut down significantly, their equipment costs will be less, possibly with added revenue as well. If they accidentally happen to flag Netflix videos, then pass the popcorn. (I wouldn't be surprised if class action lawyers are already gearing up).
- smsm42 14y agoTheir equipment costs would be less, but their income would be way less. The only reason I pay for the channel as wide as I have is to be able to stream video, download stuff, etc. For reading email and commenting on HN, I'd be good with fraction of that bandwidth. In my book, trying to have the customers to reduce the consumption of goods they are selling is insane, but then again, in copyright world sanity is an obstacle, not a requirement.
- jiggy2011 14y agoYou can upsell people on the benefits of streaming legit videos as well. Especially if the ISPs come to an arrangement with content providers to sell access to their content as an add-on to the broadband service. They can also charge content providers a premium to deliver their content at a higher priority than content of other providers.
- smsm42 14y agoThe problem is legit video offering sucks. It is loaded with thousand of DRM hoops and constantly plagued by turf wars between content providers and delivery, so any given moment any content you enjoy can be gone because two suits somewhere couldn't agree about some royalty payment. If they ever took their collective heads out of their collective asses and offered me a convenient DRM-less subscription service that would enable me to enjoy my favorite shows and movies online without enduring inconveniences that makes one think it was designed by TSA - I'd be super-happy to use that and give my money to them. But the aren't doing it! Instead, they pump money into stupid anti-piracy schemes and starting a war on their own clients.
- jrockway 14y agoRemember that the big ISPs are owned by big content companies. If anything, forcing this issue on people is going to result in increased regulatory oversight, so I honestly don't see this happening.
- Aloisius 14y agoLuckily there are still smaller independent internet service providers out there. A mass switch from Comcast after people discover they are being spied on might wake them up.
- saryant 14y agoTo who exactly? I left Comcast due to their horrible service but that meant stepping down to a 6mbps DSL line. In the evenings Netflix can't even maintain a stream. I have a choice between two terrible providers. If you know of some amazing ISP we can all switch to, I'd love to hear it.
- dougbarrett 14y agoOne issue I see with this, is mobile ISP's could, or will abuse it. Last year, I got a phone call and e-mail from AT&T stating that if I didn't stop using my phone for tethering, I would be automatically "upgraded" to a DataPro 4GB data plan, which would override my "unlimited data" plan. The issue with this is, I was using my Android phone as a hotspot, and I was using it to watch videos from MSDN for work purposes because funny enough, AT&T's 3G network was faster than my work internet connection. My concern is, with phones and tablets blurring a line between mobile computers and desktop computers (with docks included), if the next phone I get in a few years comes with the ability to dock my phone to use a full desktop, is that going to count as tethering? Is "desktop mode" data plan going to be different than a "mobile mode" data plan? Will I be forced to finally give up my "unlimited data" plan on my phone? AT&T has tried numerous times to get rid of my data plan, and I know one of these days I'm going to get a bill and it's going to be gone, and I'll call AT&T and ask what is going on and they will just say "We don't offer that plan anymore, so you were moved to the most appropriate plan" just like they tried to do years ago. I could see since I am a "unlimited data" plan user, they could implement this six strikes plan, and use it any chance they can find until the inevitable happens.
- freehunter 14y ago>is that going to count as tethering? How about using DLNA to broadcast to a larger screen and a bluetooth keyboard for input when you chmod into Ubuntu on your Android phone? That's a reality right now even if it's not a popular choice. The smartphone data plans are ridiculously different from the laptop data plans, but... what if they're the same thing?
- dougbarrett 14y agoIsn't that essentially what the dock would provide? I don't have an android phone anymore, but the only way I could imagine AT&T would know I'm tethering is if Android added some header information that the network would sniff, almost like a dog tag. Or they read the user-agent headers per request and saw that it was a non-mobile browser making the requests...I would think that booting into Ubuntu would show the same results unless your spoof your user-agent, but then you might end up getting the mobile version of the site instead of the full desktop version...it's all just a big mess. If anyone knows how AT&T or other mobile ISP's would differentiate mobile traffic from tethered traffic, I would love to know. Also, I did have to unlock my device and put a new ROM on my phone to enable tethering.
- netmau5 14y agoI worry this is the step in between illegal downloads and making anonymity illegal. If they can flag you for downloading unpaid content, it won't be long before they flag you for circumstantial patterns leading to that behavior such as using TOR.
- chimeracoder 14y agoWe're already almost there. Try being truly anonymous on the Internet these days. It's near impossible. Most online vendors won't accept pre-paid credit cards. Many email providers require you to provide a phone number or another email address as "verification". Even posting on forums is difficult, because while Tor is decent for fetching data, some websites blacklist Tor IP addresses (or, even if they don't, there's a chance you may be sharing an IP address with someone who was banned from a forum).
- smsm42 14y agoOnline vendors don't accept pre-paid Visa? This is news to me. How do they even know - it's just a regular Visa card. I've used a number of such online (mostly ones I got in all kinds of promotions) and never had a problem - I didn't even think anybody could do that and I doubt Visa would allow you to do that - to reject pre-paid Visa card. Do you have any source to this claim?
- wmf 14y agoWhen they ask for a billing address and it doesn't match because the prepaid card doesn't have one?
- chimeracoder 14y ago> Do you have any source to this claim? Paypal, for one, makes no attempt to hide this: https://www.paypal-community.com/t5/About-My-Account/using-prepaid-visa-card/td-p/462071 https://www.paypal-community.com/t5/About-My-Account/using-p... While Paypal will accept it if you provide a Visa-verified billing address, not all will, and that would defeat the point of anonymity anyway. Visa and AmEx also forbid international payments on prepaid cards, and most merchants nowadays require a verified billing address. (This wasn't the case as recently as 2009). Remember that a prepaid card is not a credit card - there's no risk of you not paying, because they [Visa] already have your money and yet merchants refuse to take it. It's completely ridiculous.
- SeanDav 14y agoI predict a huge increase in uptake on VPN services and other privacy providers. I am seriously thinking of going full encryption for absolutely all my internet and email use. Getting so tired of "Big Brother" and his idiotic "Big Business" sidekick.
- thebigshane 14y agoIt feels weird (as a conservative leaning pseudo-libertarian) believing that Big Business is doing a far better job of screwing up the Internet than Big Brother. The next step will be prohibiting US-based services from providing truly-encrypted communication/storage.
- montecarl 14y agoBig Business is rather influenced by Big Brother in this case. In much of the US the telecommunications industry receives heavy funding from local and state governments to build out their networks. There might be much more competition (or not, who knows!) if it wasn't for the regulations, subsidies, and municipal monopolies that are granted. I'm not saying it would be better, but the telecommunications market isn't even close to a free market.
- thebigshane 14y agoBig Business is rather influenced by Big Brother in this case. I don't think Big Brother would be pushing so hard against copyright infringers if it weren't for Big Business lobbying, particularly Big Media. Big Brother is the accomplice, Big Media is the culprit.
- montecarl 14y agoIf you want to threaten others, best to use and influence the entity that is "allowed" to use aggressive force. If you had to threaten internet users one-by-one with guns, you might discredit yourself. Best to use Uncle Sam.
- 14y ago
- alttag 14y agoThe "trouble" with such a warning system is that at its base is he presumption of positively identifying the infringer. Sure, and ISP can say "such-and-such activity violates our ToS, and you're responsible for all traffic on your account", but identifying a particular individual's traffic (from a content-owner's perspective) seems to be difficult given the increasing frequency of IP-as-identification being tossed from U.S. courts. So, the biggest practical question in my mind is how they plan to reconcile penalties for individual infringers against the rights of the account holder.
- wmf 14y agoIIRC you're allowed to use the open Wi-Fi defense one time (i.e. you can eliminate one strike). After that you've been "educated" so you cannot claim ignorance for any later strikes.
- mparlane 14y agoNew Zealand has a three strikes policy, I wonder what the 6 vs 3 implies. Maybe RIANZ paid more than the RIAA o_O
- CWIZO 14y agoI would like to hear from somebody living in a country that already has this kind of system in place. How does it work in practice? Do they catch every torrent you download for instance?
- wmf 14y agoIn France, "95 percent of people who have received a first-time notice of illegal sharing 'do not give rise to the need for a second notice,' that 92 percent of people who received a second notice cease illegal sharing, and that 98 percent of people who receive a third notice 'show the same trend.'" http://www.theverge.com/2012/9/11/3316158/graduated-piracy-response-france-hadopi http://www.theverge.com/2012/9/11/3316158/graduated-piracy-r... So yeah, telling people "don't get caught again" works.
- ecoffey 14y agoI feel like this article about how the Law views information and how Tech views it is germane. I think it is one of the best descriptions of this split, and what problems we'll have to overcome. http://ansuz.sooke.bc.ca/lawpoli/colour/2004061001.php http://ansuz.sooke.bc.ca/lawpoli/colour/2004061001.php
- mistercow 14y agoI have two hypotheses about this: 1. They're never going to roll this out and aren't actually putting any resources into it, but are simply hoping that they can stir up some news every few months as a cheap deterrent. 2. They are going to roll this out, and the primary target of it is kids downloading on their parents' connections, which would explain why they only seem to even be attempting to work with the largest ISPs. Obviously that would be ineffective at deterring anyone who pays their own ISP bill; those users could just move to a smaller provider. But if they're hoping to use parents as enforcers, it makes perfect sense.
- jiggy2011 14y agoI assume that this will be targeted at whoever pays the bill. The problem is that a lot of people especially families etc have more than one person using the internet even if you ignore issues such as other people breaking into your network without permission. Another problem is that bit torrent traffic is very difficult to block without effectively crippling the internet connection since modern clients seem to be clever about using encryption and trying different ports etc. I've tried blocking bittorrents on my router using it's feature for doing so, didn't work at all. This means that you might have a family with a shared internet connection where all of the kids are given internet access because they need it for schoolwork & keeping in touch with friends etc but maybe one of them simply keeps downloading copyrighted material despite being told not to. Identifying and preventing this behaviour might prove impossible and it's likely that the entire household suffers as a result.
- tonfa 14y ago(Went through all this stuff 5 years ago when it was passed in France, so I already went through most of the arguments/counter arguments) The argument is that they don't care, it is the fault of the account owner if they are not able to prevent "illegal" usage. Account owner should be able to install "something" (they were always vague) that would help him prevent people doing illegal stuff. By something we always thought it would be allowing ISPs to do DPI or something (and you would off course have to pay for it, because it's a service they offer).
- jiggy2011 14y agoI'm not sure if DPI would help much if the torrent connections are all encrypted. Perhaps you could do something by profiling connections, for example if a particular computer has a large amount of connections open to a large number of IP addresses. But then again in theory you don't have to download very much to trip over this, downloading 6 separate 4MB MP3 files could do it if you are very unlucky. The only thing I can think of would be to run everything through an HTTP proxy and then explicitly whitelist IP addresses of individual websites as and when you need them. Of course this would break stuff like XboX games and any legitimate use of P2P networking.
- w1ntermute 14y agoOh well, it's the ISPs' loss. I'll lower my internet plan by $20/month and rent a seedbox colocated in Europe instead. Problem solved.
- ojbyrne 14y ago"... but in no way was missing a July deadline a missed deadline." Just seems like this is the Copyright absolutionist's mindset in a nutshell. Nothing is what it seems like, it's what we say it is.
- sbierwagen 14y agoGood thing my neighbor only uses WEP encryption on their AP.
- icelancer 14y agoGood luck with this, idiots. I've cracked two WPA2 networks in my area and two WEP networks. Cancel their service; see if I care.
- quesera 14y agoAre you actually going to compete with these guys for the title of "biggest jerk"?
- daenz 14y agoThe point is raises is important. There is no law that you have to secure your network. If someone uses your network to pirate, do you get shut down? That's like demolishing a freeway because a criminal drove down it for his getaway.
- quesera 14y agoI agree that the point is important, but that problem already exists independently of this issue. To use your analogy, the guy I was responding to was saying: "if you make a law I don't agree with, I will break it and frame innocent people. See if I care." That's where it becomes a competition for the title.