22 ms·
Intel's "Clearwater Forest" Xeon 7 E-Core CPU Will Be a Beast
- devmor 1y agoHow is the "e-core" scheduling going these days? I am not an Intel guy, but I remember reading about it causing a lot of issues for multicore workloads and people having to explicitly pin processes away from those cores.
- jeffbee 1y agoThis isn't a hybrid design. It's a gigantic Atom. There are interesting core scheduling questions with a CPU this large, considering its 4-way-shared L2 design and profusion of thermal domains, however these issues are so complex that no system I've ever heard of — certainly not Linux or Windows — attempts to optimize it.
- api 1y agoThese are intended to run a lot of VMs, so you could pin VM cores to CPU cores strategically to keep the same VM in the same zone. These are mostly for cloud work loads. I wonder how they'd work for AI compared to a GPU? That's all about memory bandwidth so I'm guessing the GPU would still win unless it was an AI type that is more compute-bound.
- xattt 1y ago> … gigantic Atom I did see mention of Ponte Vecchio. It seems like Intel is getting closer to its Larrabee vision of massive MP low power chips (which were 486 cores in the shelved 2010 project).
- addaon 1y agoP54 (pentium) cores, not 486. Separate U and V pipes, etc.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- ac29 1y ago> It's a gigantic Atom. While Intel's E cores share some history with the Atom line, they have almost no resemblance to the Atom line you might remember from the netbook days. In fact, Intel hasnt made a consumer Atom in a decade (there are still Atom processors for the embedded market). The first E cores came out a few years ago with performance similar to Skylake and performance has only increased from there. Intel's first Xeon E core processor from last year even outperformed the some of the big core Xeons from the year before: https://www.phoronix.com/review/intel-xeon-6780e-6766e/10 https://www.phoronix.com/review/intel-xeon-6780e-6766e/10
- adrian_b 1y agoThe E-cores are just rebranded Atom cores. The evolution of the Atom cores has been continuous in the series ... Silvermont, Airmont, Goldmont, Golmont Plus, Tremont (also included as E-core inside Intel Lakefield), Gracemont (from Alder Lake/Raptor Lake/Alder Lake N/Amston Lake), Crestmont (from Meteor Lake/Sierra Forest), Skymont (Lunar Lake/Arrow Lake), Darkmont (Clearwater Forest). All the cores of this series have been designed in succession by the same team and the improvements between them have been incremental. These cores have always been intended as competitors for various Arm Cortex-A cores, e.g. Goldmont Plus for Cortex-A75, Tremont for Cortex-A76, Gracemont for Cortex-A78, and now Darkmont/Skymont for Neoverse V3/Cortex-X4. Before Tremont, these Atom cores were used only in homogeneous CPUs. In recent years only those sold for industrial applications have retained the brand "Atom". The most recent CPUs branded as "Atom" have been launched last year. For now, it does not matter whether one refers to any of these cores as "Atom" cores or as "E-cores", because either name refers unambiguously to the same cores. "Atom" seems preferable, because it is more clearly Intel-specific. One could refer as "efficient cores" to cores in CPUs made by others. The first E-cores were the Tremont cores of Intel Lakefield, which was launched in Q2 2020, which were paired with Ice Lake cores, and which had a performance much less than Skylake cores. Only the next generation of Atom cores a.k.a. E-cores, Gracemont, has reached performances comparable with Skylake. While Gracemont was first launched in Alder Lake, later it has become widely available in Atom-branded CPUs.
- jeffbee 1y ago"Consumer Atom" is now, and has been for years, contradictory. The Atom brand has long been reserved for Xeon-equivalent customers while the lesser implementations of the same idea now calls itself Pentium or Celeron or, my personal favorite, just "Intel Processor". Incredible marketing. Anyway as you note these are excellent cores, and having 576 slightly wimpy cores in a box is an idea worth considering.
- roboror 1y agoIt's was fine like a month after the first e-core chips launched, certainly handled better than AMDs split ccd vcache which still needs to be pinned.
- blueaquilae 1y agoThis <insert next gen> will be a beast!
- hnuser123456 1y agoIf anyone was confused like I was, it's (Xeon 7) (E-Core). It'll have 288 cores. The Diamond Rapids Xeon 7 P-core chip has 192 cores.
- Neywiny 1y agoThat did take me a beat. 7 cores? Must be pretty fast...
- sirn 1y agoThis is more of a successor to the Xeon 6E (Xeon 6700E / Sierra Forest-SP), which had 144 cores. There was supposed to be a 288-core variant (presumably Xeon 6900E / Sierra Forest-AP), but they never released it to the public. I was looking forward to it since Sierra Forest-AP was supposed to support a 2-socket configuration (from motherboard spec). That's 576 physical cores in a single server!
- bayindirh 1y agoSounds like a UltraSPARC-T1, all over again. A processor stuffed with efficiency cores for cloud loads. Makes sense.
- ksec 1y agoThe upcoming Zen6c will have 256 Core per socket, and dual socket gets you 512 Core. Since the Zen 6c support SMT while E-Core doesn't, the Zen6c would support 1024 vCPU in a single server! I am looking forward to Zen6C vs Xeon 7-Ecore. Wondering about the cost / pref.
- sirn 1y agoIt's still mind-blowing to me to think that a decade earlier this would have been a few racks. Now it just fits within 1U or 2U. What an insane world we live in.
- ksec 1y agoIndeed! Now with Up 2-4TB of Memory, and 1-2 PB of SSD. All inside 1-2U. By 2030 we will have server with 1000W CPU. We are fundamentally close to be limited by cooling.
- Blackthorn 1y agoAfter Intel released a microcode update that turned my processor into one that retails for $100 less, I don't really trust claims or even benchmarks until they're > 1 year old. Intel also, as far as I'm concerned, owes me $100.
- ndriscoll 1y agoDoesn't microcode need to be reloaded each boot? Can't you just not load the update?
- metadat 1y agoCorrect, they are typically applied through the BIOS. Not to be confused with Intel IME. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intel_Management_Engine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intel_Management_Engine
- Hikikomori 1y agoAlso through windows or Linux. Or is that not done anymore?
- doubled112 1y agoIt's still done this way too. https://wiki.archlinux.org/title/Microcode https://wiki.archlinux.org/title/Microcode
- jeffbee 1y agoI am not sure why you tried to draw a distinction between the BIOS and the IME in that regard. The IME also stores its firmware in the SPI flash alongside the rest of the platform firmware.
- atVelocet 1y agoThere two ways: Update the BIOS/UEFI which includes an updated microcode. Via software at runtime after each reboot (Windows/*nix).
- guestbest 1y agoIntel made some really good low power gpus with good driver support. How are their gpus coming along for LLM support of local first?
- dfsegoat 1y agoVery curious about this as well. Though I would say the fact that they were not involved with OpenAI on gpt-oss is not a good sign. (OAI partnered with Databricks, NVIDIA, Dell, bunch of MSPs. etc.)
- chucky_z 1y agoIncredibly good. A lot of main GPU board partners are making LLM-focused boards. There was a few previews on Gamers Nexus from... Computex I think? I wanna say lots of memory, dual GPU boards that looked very well built for local LLM usage.
- transpute 1y agoWith unified memory?
- Gracana 1y agohttps://www.servethehome.com/maxsun-intel-arc-pro-b60-dual-gpu-48gb-at-computex-2025/ https://www.servethehome.com/maxsun-intel-arc-pro-b60-dual-g... It's two B60 GPUs on a single x16 PCIe card. Nothing unified.
- BoredPositron 1y agoWorking with the vram of both gpus on the same card is aeons faster than taking a system ram roundtrip.
- transpute 1y agoLooks like they are independent x8 GPUs on bifurcated x16 PCIe slot.
- DiabloD3 1y agoSo, its just a clone of current gen Zen5C products, and will fall behind Zen6-based products.
- adrian_b 1y agoThe Darkmont cores of Clearwater Forest are almost identical with the Skymont cores of Lunar Lake, Arrow Lake S and Arrow Lake H. The only significant difference is that they are made with the Intel 18A CMOS process instead of a TSMC "3 nm" process. These Darkmont cores have a performance very similar with the Arm Neoverse V3/Cortex-X4 cores and lower than the performance of AMD Zen 5 compact cores. However, for applications that do not use vector operations, the Darkmont cores have a better performance per die area than Zen 5 compact. For many applications, a 288-core Clearwater Forest will have a lower performance than an 192-core Turin dense, but for some applications it will be faster and the low area per core will enable Intel to sell it for a lower price than Turin dense. It remains to be seen when will be the launch of Zen 6 in 2026, but it is likely that it will be a few months after Clearwater Forest.
- Sesse__ 1y agoIt is difficult to call Intel's E-core server chips a “clone” of Zen 5c. Sierra Forest was announced before Zen 4c, and they're actually designed-for-area cores instead of just resynthesizing the same chip with a different library (which is the thing you do if you suddenly need a small core, but don't have time to make a proper one) and less cache, like Zen 5c is. If it's a clone if anything, it's of Arm's “little” strategy.
- wmf 1y agoThe thing is, AMD keeps designing chips the "wrong" way (due to smaller R&D budget) yet they keep winning.
- DiabloD3 1y agoAnd Intel keeps designing chips the "right" way, and they keep digging their own grave. Its almost like Intel spends more money on PR and stealth marketing than they do R&D.
- baq 1y ago"how many N100 minipcs can you pack in 1U?" turns out the answer is "lots"
- adgjlsfhk1 1y agoIIUC these cores are a lot better than n100. They're 2 generations newer and have some fairly significant improvements.
- dontlaugh 1y agoN150 isn't much of an improvement, I don't expect one more generation to be a crucial difference.
- sirn 1y agoN150 is still using the old Gracemont core (same as N100, but with higher clock). From there, there is Crestmont (node-shrink Gracemont in Meteor Lake), and Skymont (in Lunar Lake/Arrow Lake), whose performance is already comparable to that of Golden Cove (12th Gen P-core). Chips and Cheese has written a very detailed analysis for Skymont[1] if you're interested. [1]: https://chipsandcheese.com/p/skymont-intels-e-cores-reach-for-the-sky https://chipsandcheese.com/p/skymont-intels-e-cores-reach-fo...
- DeepYogurt 1y agoCore generations not product. The n150 is a clock bumped n100.
- adrian_b 1y agoThe rumors are that there will be no true successor for N150. Instead of that, there will be a cut down variant of Panther Lake, named Wildcat Lake, with 2 P-cores and 4 E-cores. That will clearly have a much better performance than N150, including a much better Xe3 GPU, but it seems very unlikely that Intel will sell it at the low prices that made the N-series so attractive. I assume that Wildcat Lake will be priced similarly to N350, so it will be available in computers closer in price to $300 than to the $100 that can get you an N100 or N150 computer.
- zipy124 1y agoThe hyper-scalers are going to love this, since this has just brought down the cost per vCPU massively.
- ksec 1y agoNot really, these E-Core are 1vCPU, while other P-Core or Zen 6C core are 2vCPU.
- DrBazza 1y agoThat first paragraph made my head hurt. A lot of contortion to avoid saying 'Intel has slightly more than half the (edit) revenue in the server market'. I thought I'd find a chart, best I can do is here: https://www.techpowerup.com/322317/amd-hits-highest-ever-x86-cpu-market-share-in-q1-2024-across-desktop-and-server https://www.techpowerup.com/322317/amd-hits-highest-ever-x86... Intel's revenue (edit) is falling year-on-year, and AMD gaining. Does anyone have a better chart?
- ddtaylor 1y agoIntel was asleep at the wheel for a decade at best and realistically was just milking profits while sitting on innovation. Disgraceful. I'm team AMD all the way. I have no faith or expectation anything Intel does will matter. Maybe 10 years of them being irrelevant will convince them of their ways?
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- wmf 1y agoI think Xeon 7 is the first generation after they woke up. We'll see if it's enough.
- vlovich123 1y agoOnce AMD takes the spot, the lack of competition will encourage AMD to act in all the same ways you associate with Intel.
- immibis 1y agoIndeed, this already happened several times already and it just happens that we're currently at the peak of an AMD cycle.
- dkiebd 1y agoI find this comment surprising. They have always had better single-core performance than AMD at the same price tag.
- celeryd 1y agoI'm with you brother. Intel needs to fix their ways and I don't think a couple generations of playing second fiddle will be enough. Intel burns a lot of money on marketing hoping to trick people about how great their new shit will be (anyone remember when 14th gen was released?) and it ends up being hot air. I have no faith in this one either.
- _2d30 1y ago288 cores and 12 memory channels. If I did anything with this chip, I would probably just swamp its memory bandwidth and get no performance gains over a 48 core chip.
- jeffbee 1y agoThis is a claim you can easily confirm or deny, considering that 144-core, 8-channel implementations of the Xeon 6E exist in the marketplace today.
- hyperbovine 1y ago`make -j288` baby
- adgjlsfhk1 1y agoit also has .5gbGB of cache, and that's 12 lanes of ddr5-8000
- nullc 1y ago.5gb of cache for 288 cores is fairly limited. AMD 9684X from two years ago has 6x the cache per core, and also much more memory bandwidth per core. I'd really like to see more chips with 100+gb of eDRAM. Most things I've run that aren't memory bandwidth limited are already so fast...
- nullc 1y ago> 6x erp. 8x. math hard.
- buyucu 1y agoSomehow I doubt it. The last time I was excited about anything Intel did was the Xeon Phi. And Intel failed spectacularly to follow up on a very good idea. Intel simply can't innovate.
- watersb 1y ago288 "efficiency" cores. That each have 26 execution ports, can retire up to 16 ops per cycle.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- rpcope1 1y agoNow if only Intel would start packing their iGPUs (maybe more than one, or many for a high core count CPU like this) on their Xeon CPUs, you could basically build insane video streaming infra with little hardware (given how good the iGPUs are at things like transcoding on a watt for watt basis). This seems like a huge slam dunk slapping at least one iGPU on their Xeon CPUs like you used to be able to get...I have no idea why they stopped.
- wmf 1y agoThe few people doing video streaming can get Intel GPUs on PCIe cards and you can have as many or as few cards as you want.