10 ms·
15-Fold increase in solar thermoelectric generator performance
- gaborcselle 1y agoThis new solar thermoelectric generator (STEG) traps heat on one side and cools the other, making electricity from the hot-cold gap via the Seebeck effect. Unlike solar panels, which need direct sunlight, STEGs can use ambient heat and scattered light. That’s why they still work in shaded or cloudy areas—any temperature difference can generate power. Today they’re only ~1% efficient (vs. ~20% for solar), but the new design is 15× better than earlier STEGs. They won’t beat solar panels yet, but could be useful in spots where panels underperform.
- eden-u4 1y agoso they are basically using a similar idea to that of a stirling engine in thermoelectric generator or they use a different mechanism to produce energy?
- kalx 1y agoThey both use heat. But stirling converts mechanically, whereas STEM converts energy to electricity «directly».
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- vasco 1y agoTwo materials (often n-type and p-type semiconductors) are joined at two junctions, one junction is heated and the other cooled. The temperature difference makes charge diffuse from the hot side toward the cold side, and this charge is what turns into the seebeck voltage they describe. It was just very hard to get anything meaningful out of this because you can't easily get such a temperature difference. If you've read of the peltier effect, it's the same thing as this, just in reverse.
- blackjack_ 1y agoI did data collection for a paper looking at the Seebeck effect in magnetic insulators about ~10-15 years ago, and it seemed like everyone in the whole physics department considered spintronics pretty dead. It feels great to see some big promising applications coming out of the field.
- hatenberg 1y agoIt’s explicitly part of Chinese science and technology strategy to think outside the box and it’s what’s pushing them forward on areas like semiconductors as well. Given the massive advantage in talent they’ve built up while the Us reverts to Drill Baby Drill we know how this ends. Eventually the Us with push for atmospheric dimming to “fix” the negative externalities of their approach which had the nice side effect of degrading solar …. FMl
- znpy 1y agoYou’re being downvoted but i don’t think you’re entirely wrong. China has been pursuing some stuff that the western world had essentially abandoned, getting interesting wins (eg: thorium reactors).
- braiamp 1y agoHe's wrong in the "why" tho. It's not that they must think outside the box, it's that they _must_ not all focus on a single point of research. I'm pretty sure that they are also pursuing popular research topics, because it would be pretty bad if they fall behind for not doing the obvious.
- idiomat9000 1y agoCompetition is great.
- stuaxo 1y agoSolar and batteries will keep getting cheaper, its going to get harder to maintain fossil fuel use under those market conditions.
- fulafel 1y agoPV panels work in shaded or cloudy settings (at reduced power of course).
- newswangerd 1y agoWould it be possible to do both on a single panel? In other words, put photovoltaic cells on the sunny side and thermoelectric generators on the shady side.
- IshKebab 1y agoBut do they actually out-perform solar panels in any situation yet?
- hinkley 1y agoSome of the cooling tricks could likely be used on standard PV, since overheating affects efficiency.
- Animats 1y agoIt's not a good solar power source, but could the technology be adapted to heat sinks? Maybe they could license the technology to CoolerMaster.
- addaon 1y ago2x the radiative + convective heat dissipation for a passive aluminum heat sink seems like as big a deal as its use in this particular application.
- ehnto 1y agoI agree, it has quite broad application!
- enslavedrobot 1y agoFemto second laser processing is probably not a scaleable process.
- nullc 1y agoyour cell phone display was probably cut with a fs laser, is a less exotic process than you think.
- enslavedrobot 1y agoUseful for cutting in a line (although fs pulse length is overkill for most applications), not so efficient for surface modifications over large areas. For enhanced absorbance, alternative technologies that come to mind could be electrodeposition with additives that preferentially bind specific crystal faces, nanoimprint lithography+etching. I was personally involved in developing an electroless deposition technology that created "black gold" that had broadband absorbance across NIR and visible wavelengths. That sucker was black, and easy to make!
- rich_sasha 1y agoI sometimes wonder if you could make a much safer nuclear plants with TEGs. There would be next to no active processes and moving parts, no pumps and coolant and circulation. Use nuclear magic to make the hot side, cool with ambient temperature. No doubt this would be less energy efficient, but perhaps you reap so much savings by not having to worry about water circulation that it's worth it.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- jkkr 1y agoNuclear plants sometimes aren’t even worthwhile at their current efficiency. Even if TEGs simplified things mechanically, you’d still face the problem that nuclear often can’t compete (with renewables) in direct a comparison (setting aside overall strategy for base load and stuff).
- iTokio 1y agoYes I wonder if with the current trend, solar might become the real alternative, less expensive, less risky. But to be fair, you have to consider your « aside », because nuclear has the tremendous advantage of working when it’s cloudy, dark and you need the energy the most in the winter. I do not think that we can just compare the prices, or maybe we should also add the cost of storage (that is going down too) for solar. But currently a mix is probably the pragmatic approach.
- kristopolous 1y agoIt's going to be solar + wind + battery. That's where the economics are at. Sodium batteries are just coming online now https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sodium-ion_battery https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sodium-ion_battery - lithium is getting phased out. Nuclear can't compete. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Levelized_cost_of_electricity https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Levelized_cost_of_electricit... Maybe in some far off future nuclear will have a role... But the global energy investment markets paint a very clear picture: solar + wind + battery is the way.
- zerof1l 1y agoCould you combine them with solar panels?
- mgiampapa 1y agoSure, solar panels get wicked hot and are more efficient when cold, so attaching something to scavenge heat from them, bonus hot water and a little electricity are all wins until you factor in the cost of doing so and realize you would get 10x the return on adding a few more panels.
- glenngillen 1y agoWe have passive thermal heat tubes on our roof to heat our pool. It works amazingly well. I want to put PV on our roof, but that’d mean having to pull up those tubes first and replacing our pool heater with something electric. Turns out there’s companies that do hybrid systems! Water is used to cool the PV, increasing the efficiency of the panels in the process, and then the heated water is used wherever you need it. Unfortunately it seems there’s only a couple of providers, it’s rare to find installers that do it, and it’s ssuuuppppeeerrr expensive relative to the normal options. Such a shame. I wish there were more options here. It seems like a great approach.
- hankman86 1y agoWe just did the opposite and ripped up our solar hot water system. We have a metal roof and a salt water pool. Problem is that these systems can and do leak. Salt water on a metal roof makes creates rust. With photovoltaic panels being dirt cheap, we decided to rather heat our pool with a heat pump that is powered by our own electricity.
- nullc 1y agoIt's more claim than reality. The addition of water radically increases install costs (the main cost driver!) and dramatically reduces reliability. If you fully price it out you'll find it's more cost effective to just spam more PV and use a heat pump, unless you've reached space limits.
- scheme271 1y agoI wonder if the improvements for the aluminum heatsink might be applicable to other situations like cpu/gpu heatsinks or other places where cooling is needed. It seems like it might be economical.
- MadnessASAP 1y agoI caught that as well. Further reading it looks like they had a ~2x improvement over a flat aluminium sheet (Which itself performed worse then the bare TEG). And of that improvement about half came from radiative cooling. So my very hot take is that a conventional forced air finned radiator treated with this laser process would show an improvement, it is unlikely to be economically viable versus just using a bigger radiator (at desktop/server CPU/GPU scales). At laptop scales it might be more viable given space constraints.
- iTokio 1y agoCars are an obvious application. Some parts get very hot, and any electricity produced without engine or fuel add to range / efficiency.
- bilbo-b-baggins 1y agoDoesn’t 15-fold mean multiplied by two 15 times, or 32,000x not 15x? I feel like someone should have caught that before publication.
- alwa 1y agoI’ve not heard the term used that way—I’ve always understood it to indicate a multiple. But now that you’ve said it, the idea of -fold as “folding something in half” is interesting to think about!
- Waterluvian 1y agoI imagine folding too. But then we couldn’t ever achieve more than maybe a twelve-fold increase.
- dxyms 1y agoNo https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fold_change https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fold_change
- deathlock 1y agoI don't know if the engineering field has the same conventions, but in biology we use "fold" as it was used in the paper. When comparing the signal of two things, the fold change is how many times one is bigger than the other (basically A/B). If A is 15-fold higher than B then it's 15x B. What you described is the Log2 Fold Change (log2(A/B)), meaning that if A has a log2FC of 15 over B, its signal is 2^15 times higher, hence ≈32,000x.
- pixelpoet 1y agoI'm bummed that you're getting downvoted for what's IMO a very natural question, especially given that "times" is unambiguous and that folding naturally implies a doubling. But this is English, it's deliberately designed to not make sense (see also the modern definition of "literally"). mumbles something else about 2^15
- 1y ago
- syntaxing 1y agoI don’t fully get it, thermoelectric is relying on a surface temperature differential compared to the radiation temperature differential for solar panels. Wouldn’t the carnot efficiency of these panels significantly pale solar panels?
- iTokio 1y agoWell yes, but this is not a competing technology but a complementary one. You can use this to improve the efficiency of a regular solar panel and as a way to still produce electricity when there is less direct light but enough temperature difference.
- gsf_emergency_2 1y agoIt's hard to come close to solar cells' Carnot... I don't think they improved "efficiency" by much. That's why by performance they actually mean something like raw power output. TEG is notorious for having like microwatts per sq cm of output near room temp. Now they are a 100th to a 10th of PV "performance".. mildly disingenuous titling imho.
- Unirely01 1y ago[dead]
- bilsbie 1y agoI’m really excited for this technology to be used for solid state AC. I think we’ll get there one day. I’m even willing to accept a lot of inefficiency because new AC’s in the US can cost 10-20k now and you can need them as frequently as every 7-10 years. The whole industry is really getting absurd.
- quickthrowman 1y agoI’m not sure what you mean by solid state AC, peltier cooling? That will never be used for air conditioning, the theoretical max COP is 1 (1w of heat removed for 1w of input power) and a decent heat pump will have a COP of 4 (4w of heat removed for each 1w of input power). Most peltier coolers have a COP of .1, which makes a heat pump 40 times more efficient. It is impossible to make a solid state peltier cooler that is even 25% as efficient as a vapor-compression cycle heat pump at removing heat, therefore it will never gain traction in applications where a heat pump can be used. Over the lifetime of an air conditioner, the cost of the energy used to run the equipment will be larger than the cost of the equipment itself, so efficiency is important if you want to reduce your total cost of ownership. SEER ratings eventually have diminishing returns per dollar spent, but finding the most efficient unit per dollar is time well spent.
- bilsbie 1y ago> Over the lifetime of an air conditioner, the cost of the energy used to run the equipment will be larger than the cost of the equipment itself My point is this is rapidly becoming not true. Thanks for the info on the efficiency though. I’m still hoping we can figure something out. If not , we should switch to propane for the coolant. Way cheaper than whatever they keep making manufacture switch to.
- quickthrowman 1y agoWe are rapidly approaching the point where we have retrofitted all lighting to be LED and all motors to be driven by VFDs, eventually we will reach a point where we’ve maxed out efficiency and new power generation will need to be built, which will push energy costs up. Propane is cheap but it has a couple drawback. Flammability, and the refrigerant must be pure so no mercaptan can be added which means if there’s a propane leak, nobody will smell it. This is more of a problem for commercial and industrial units than residential.
- jijijijij 1y agoI presume this would be useful for thermal camouflage, since you could store the heat energy in a battery instead of diverting or diffusing it. I hope bleeding edge research sees the potential for aiding the climate crisis as ethically imperative over a military's niche technological advantage/cash.
- enslavedrobot 1y agoOnly skimmed the paper but this looks more like an advance in absorbing solar energy through laser patterning a metal than in more efficient thermoelectric effects. Laser patterning is a lot easier than improving thermoelectric device efficiency.
- fsh 1y agoThe authors carefully avoid giving any actual efficiency figures (or figures from which the efficiency could be easily calculated). Since they barely managed to power an LED under concentrated sunlight, it is probably safe to assume that the efficiency is extremely low. The reference point for the "15-fold" improvement is literally putting a Peltier element out in the sun. Looks like they really don't want their device to be compared to a photovoltaic cell.