7 ms·
> The interesting question to me is: what happens when AI can not only implement but also playtest -- running thousands of iterations of your loop, surfacing wh
by zahlman 1y ago
> The interesting question to me is: what happens when AI can not only implement but also playtest -- running thousands of iterations of your loop, surfacing which mechanics keep simulated players engaged?
How is AI supposed to simulate a player, and why should it be able to determine what real people would find engaging?
- yonatan8070 1y agoGame companies already collect heaps of data about players, which mechanics they interact with, which mechanics they don't, retention, play time, etc. I don't think it's much of a stretch to take this data over multiple games, versions, and genres, and train a model to take in a set of mechanics, stats, or even video and audio to rate the different aspects of a game prototype. I wouldn't even be surprised if I heard this is already being done somewhere.
- sbarre 1y agoYeah there's no way Microsoft isn't already using all their aggregate metrics (trillions of data points I'm sure) from their first-party studios and making a "What good looks like" training set.. Whether that set is actually useful is a separate issue but someone is trying this over there for sure.
- tialaramex 1y agoAh yes, the huge game companies, definitely outfits I would associate with producing fun games I haven't seen before and not churning out Existing Franchise N+1 every year with barely perceptible differences and higher prices each iteration.
- yonatan8070 1y agoMaybe "fun" isn't the right word, "engaging" or "addicting" is probably what they use internally.
- uncircle 1y ago> Game companies already collect heaps of data about players, which mechanics they interact with, which mechanics they don't, retention, play time, etc. Yes, that's how games like Concord get made. Very successful approach to create art based on data about what's popular and focus groups.
- georgeecollins 1y agoI think you are saying data is no substitute for vision in design. Completely agree! At Playdom (Disney) they tried to build a game once from the ground up based on A/B testing. Do you know what that game was? No you don't because it was never released and terrible. I think what the previous comment meant was that there is data on how player play, and that tends to be varied but more predictable.
- mlyle 1y agoYah. I think an AI playtester that could go "hey... this itch that lots of players seem to have doesn't get scratched often in your main gameplay loop" or "there's a valley 1/3rd of the way into the game where progression slows way down" or "that third boss is way too hard". AI/fuzzers can't get far enough in games, yet, without a lot of help. But I think that's because we don't have models really well suited for them.
- MangoToupe 1y agoIsn't Concord massively unpopular? I'd think that's a terrible example Edit: yup, it shut down nearly a year ago
- SpecialistK 1y agoI think it was a sarcastic example - in other words, all the data and metrics and trend-chasing in the world is not a replacement for human vision, creativity, and risk-taking.
- fluoridation 1y ago
- georgeecollins 1y agoWe did that on a game I worked on over ten years ago. It was a mobile game and we knew that it was very important to player retention (and interest in multiplayer) to have the first multiplayer interaction be "fun". So we would simulate the first person you played against as though they were another human. Based on play data of other humans. Because you only played them once you didn't think you were playing a bot. Where we used AI (machine learning, not LLM) was in terms trying to figure out what kind of human you would want to play with. We also used machine learning to try figure out what cohort of players you were in so we could tweak engagement. Where LLMs could really shine, in my opinion: Gamers love to play people, not AI (now). People are unpredictable, they communicate, they play well but in ways a human could (like they don't have superhuman reflexes or speed). You can play all kinds of games against AI (StarCraft, Civilization, training of all kinds of FPS) but it isn't fun for long because you see the robotic patterns. However, an LLM might be able to mix it up like humans, talk to you, and you could probably make it have imperfect reaction time, coordination, etc. That would really help a lot of games that have lulls in human player activity, or too much toxicity. I would be shocked if some games aren't doing this now. It seems like it still be hard to make a bot seem human, and it probably only works if you sprinkle it in.
- ryoshu 1y agoHumans prefer humans over bots in multiplayer. Even if you dumb down LLM-powered-bots, there's no sense of accomplishment on beating a bot that can be dialed up-or-down. And the social aspect... maybe some amount of gamers want to talk to bots instead of humans in a pvp match. Curious on the numbers there.
- Mouvelie 1y agoCould never prove it, but would bet money that Marvel Snap for example is doing it right now. Edit : oh yeah. A quick google search proved it : https://marvelsnapzone.com/bots/ https://marvelsnapzone.com/bots/
- AlienRobot 1y agoGame developers will try anything before they actually write automated tests for their games.
- nine_k 1y agoWhen you tweak game mechanics several times every day, keeping the tests useful is a large task. Basics can be tested. Map integrity can be tested. Most "normal UX" is hard to test, and even main functional tests tend to drift. (Source: a short involvement in actual gamedev recently.)
- greesil 1y agoOne can still write unit tests. I have been told from a couple different game devs that it's more because of release deadlines, and the cost of a bug is usually pretty small.
- pton_xd 1y agoThere are some game systems that lend themselves to unit testing, like say map generation to ensure that the expected landmarks are placed reasonably, or rooms are connected, or whatever. But most game interactions are just not easily "unit testable" since they happen across frames (eg over time). How would you unit test an enemy that spawns, moves towards the player, and attacks? I'm sure you could conjure up any number of ways to do that, but they won't be trivial, and maintaining those tests while you iterate will only slow you down. And what's the point? Even if the unit-move-and-attack test passes, it's not going to tell you if it looks good, or if it's fun. Ultimately you just have to play the game, constantly, to make sure the interactions are fun and working as you expect.
- chaps 1y ago> How would you unit test an enemy that spawns, moves towards the player, and attacks? You use a second enemy that spawns, moves towards the "enemy", and attacks.
- 1y ago
- gmadsen 1y agobecause it has millions of examples of that in its training data?
- bozhark 1y agoMake the same engagement metric as people do; try to break it
- eru 1y ago> How is AI supposed to simulate a player, and why should it be able to determine what real people would find engaging? Games have goals, and players are prone to 'optimising the fun out of games', by doing some save strategy over and over again to reach that goal, even if it's not fun. Think eg grinding in an RPG, instead of facing tough battles with strategy and wits and the risk of failure. Even if AIs are terrible at determining what's engaging, you can probably at least use them to relatively quickly find ways that you accidentally opened that let players get in the way of their own fun.
- mzl 1y agoI've heard several talks about how some companies make AI systems that are designed to play as similar to human players as possible. This has been crucial for them in order to play-test levels in order to balance the game. And note, this is not AI as in asking an LLM what to do, this is more classical machine learning and deep learning.