12 ms·
There's a lot of food for thought here, and important points. But in one area, the author completely glosses over a crucial distinction: > why is it only docum
by crazygringo 14y ago
There's a lot of food for thought here, and important points. But in one area, the author completely glosses over a crucial distinction:
> why is it only documentation of sex crimes against minors that are being banned in this way? The lawmen are perfectly fine with a video documenting how a teenager is being stabbed with a screwdriver in both eyes, then murdered. ... why is the ban just related to anything sexual, and not to the bodily harm itself...?
There's a very important reason only documentation of sex crimes against minors is banned -- there isn't a big market for watching videos of murders. Virtually no one is going to go out and film themselves murdering people in order to satisfy a market for those videos.
But the reasoning goes that if child porn is legal, then this will actively encourage more child rape, etc., so that it can be filmed and distributed. Plus, even if we're really good against preventing the actual acts in the US, we're still creating markets for it in other countries, especially third-world ones. So children suffer.
But then there's another argument, that having child porn around is actually better than the alternative -- because potential molesters/rapists are able to satisfy their desire with existing videos. If they don't have the videos, then they go out and commit horrible acts. So, better to stick to the videos.
There are no easy answers.
- TazeTSchnitzel 14y ago>But then there's another argument, that having child porn around is actually better than the alternative -- because potential molesters/rapists are able to satisfy their desire with existing videos. In Japan, "lolicon" and "shotacon" (referring to (sometimes animated) pornography of underage (often pre-pubescent) females and males respectively) seem to be widely available, so that would be interesting to look into. I don't know if rates of child molestation are higher or lower, there.
- evoxed 14y agoActually possession of child pornography isn't illegal here either, and for that specific reason IIRC. Buying/selling or attempting to distribute are crimes though– basically it's like weed in Massachusetts. That being said I don't know the statistics on underage molestation but I don't think it would provide a very helpful model for the US.
- TazeTSchnitzel 14y agoOh, I didn't know that. That's very interesting. That might explain why Japan has, apparently, something like 30% of the world's child porn website (vaguely remembered probably wrong statistic)
- macchina 14y agoSame with Russia http://articles.cnn.com/2011-06-02/world/russia.child.porn_1_child-pornography-sexual-abuse-child-advocate http://articles.cnn.com/2011-06-02/world/russia.child.porn_1...
- guard-of-terra 14y agoOkay, but then why criminalize shots for which it can be proven that no child were harmed along the way? Talking mostly about children filming themself and the like.
- jwatte 14y agoIn the US (and Sweden) it's apparently illegal to possess /drawings/ of child porn. No child harm needed, only the potential for impure thoughts. Fundamentalists of any kind trying to impose thought crime is the real problem here. Fix that, and the rest will follow.
- sophacles 14y agoShock video sites that feature murders, dismemberment and other forms of crime on video for voyeuristic pleasure are a pretty big business. Perhaps not as big as child pornography woud be/is, but big enough that your distinction is a bit questionable. Further, videos of people getting murdered raise enough of an outcry that they get investigated/prosecuted much harder. Instances of child molestation are hidden, so there can only be public outcry in the abstract, leading to crazy laws that resemble witch hunts more than legal proceedings.
- Falling3 14y agoI almost commented about this... but then I realize I had no evidence whatsoever for any of those claims. Do you? http://www.snopes.com/horrors/madmen/snuff.asp http://www.snopes.com/horrors/madmen/snuff.asp
- mintplant 14y ago> All the fretting about it aside, not so much as one snuff film has been found. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Luka_Magnotta http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Luka_Magnotta
- noarchy 14y agoThis was the first that come to mind for me, as well. Living in Canada, this was front-page news not long ago, and for several days until his arrest in Germany.
- vacri 14y agoThat is an extremely old Snopes page, written at the dawn of the internet, when pictures were captured on film or tape, not in bytes. I recall reading that very page back then. It does say 'last updated 2006', but the most recent reference in 1999, and only seems to talk about famed snuff films to that date. To contrast, the main article gives a direct link to such a snuff film as snopes says doesn't exist. Shock sites also had things like the Taliban beheading videos. Snopes is clearly wrong on this one. I'm not sure how much 'big business' shock sites would have though - I can't see them selling much in the way of subscriptions, only monetising through web ads.
- ScottBurson 14y agoHere's a proposal. Mere possession should be legal, as Falkvinge argues. What should be illegal is purchasing child porn. You might reply that it might be difficult to prove that money changed hands, particularly in this brave new Bitcoin world. Fine. Let's say that possession of images that are known to have been sold to anyone at any time constitutes prima facie circumstantial evidence that the person possessing the images paid for them. Another objection might be that this law might not suffice for catching cabals of child pornographers who create and share images, but without money changing hands. Fine -- let's generalize the criterion to include any exchange of value, including in-kind exchanges. So trading images without monetary payment would still be illegal. (Of course, creating the images would remain highly illegal.) The outcome would be that the provenance of the image would matter. Possessing an image taken by oneself, or by a friend, possibly by the subject -- all these would be legal, so long as no other crime was committed in the creation of the image or in obtaining it. But downloading material that was being circulated on the Net would still be very dangerous -- the probability of picking up an image that someone had paid for (or bartered for) sometime would soon approach 100%. Let's call such images "tainted images". The provision that possession of a tainted image constitutes prima facie (i.e., rebuttable) evidence is important. It means that if you visit a Web site that pops up images of child porn, you haven't thereby committed a crime, so long as forensic examination of your computer supports your contention that this was accidental and not part of a pattern of behavior (e.g. there are only a couple of such images and they're only in your browser cache). Well, IANAL and I probably don't know exactly how the law should be phrased, but I think it should be along these lines.
- mseebach 14y ago> let's generalize the criterion to include any exchange of value, including in-kind exchanges > Possessing an image taken by oneself, or by a friend, possibly by the subject -- all these would be legal If you're a prosecutor and you can't find anything in an average teenage text-exchange that constitues a quid-pro-quo ("I'll show you mine if you show me yours"), you simply aren't fit to do your job. And then we're back to square zero. How about this: it's an indisputable fact that exchanging bits online (with the copyright holder's permission, of course) has no victims, don't make it illegal. Producing child pornography very much has victims, and should be illegal with the full force of the law. Managing money originating from illegal activities is also illegal, so paying for the production, or acting as any kind of middleman, would be too.
- Falling3 14y agoIsn't the easy answer virtual child porn? I really see no reason why this is also illegal except it makes people feel icky. This allows potential rapists to satisfy their desires without harming any actual children.
- ricardobeat 14y agoWhy should everyone be "satisfied"? What if a similar percentage of the population has a knack for fresh brains? Maybe that is what all those zombie movies are about: crime prevention.
- Falling3 14y agoThey should be satisfied if it comes at no harm to others and the alternative is harming others. Isn't that kind of a no-brainer?
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- jeltz 14y agoWho is harmed by "virtual child porn"?
- jtheory 14y agoNot the virtual children, certainly. Possibly the viewers, IF (research needed) giving them the ability to watch detailed scenarios of abuse -- possibly with willing "children" -- raises the possibility that they'll abuse a real child and ruin both the child's life and their own. That's an important "if"; I don't know the answer, but I will at least say it's a bit sad we don't have more people calling for research on "what things actually prevent child molestation from happening" -- we just have people calling for harsher sentences, or broader laws, or more sex offender registries.
- Falkvinge 14y ago> There's a very important reason only documentation of sex crimes against minors is banned -- there isn't a big market for watching videos of murders. Ahem. Fox News, CNN, al-Jazeera, BBC, ... The market for videos of murders (wartime or criminal) is IMMENSE.
- jeltz 14y agoAnd despite there being a huge market for depictions of murder thee has as far as I know never been anyone producing a snuff video for the money. People like Luka Magnotta either keep the videos for themselves or upload them for free.
- geon 14y agoA "market" doesn't necessarily involve monetary compensation. It can be a trivial as "likes", pageviews or peer recognition. THere is a very real market, possibly bigger than the child porn market. That there are websites dedicated to gore videos is proof of this.
- jeltz 14y agoIndeed, I should have been more clear. What I meant that despite there being a huge market very few are encouraged to commit these crimes to satisfy the needs of the market. The market is mostly based around crmies that would have been happened anyway. There are some exceptions like possibly Luka Magnotta who while he did not do it for the money might have done it for the attention. But people like him a rare.
- jlgreco 14y agoDistributing videos of criminal acts for popularity does seem to be rare. However distributing videos of acts of war (or terrorism, or freedom fighting, or whatever you want to call it) for popularity (propaganda) seems to be immensely popular. Youtube and especially LiveLeaks are full of these videos. Everything from IR videos from helicopter gunships blowing up people at night to telephoto video footage of snipers shooting people driving along roads.
- lywald 14y agoThe abused kid has a right to privacy... A moral right. Legally, I don't know. But it is morally wrong to override that right. Even if it means saving more kids (and I don't believe it does). Just... Find another solution.
- zerostar07 14y agoBut child porn is already relatively easily accessible for free via anonymous networks, maybe we could find stats whether this lead to increase or reduction of the volume that is circulating. One thing that then legal ban does is it adds to the taboo factor that makes this stuff more desirable. I think the bigger issue is that people still don't have frank discussions about sexual matters even in the west.
- unconed 14y agoFalkvinge makes an excellent rebuttal to your point. There IS a huge market for videos of violence. It's called the evening news, and they are all over that shit.
- rimantas 14y ago> there isn't a big market for watching videos of murders. This market is already saturated. Just count how many murders you see on TV every day.
- tyciol 14y agoThis links into his 'follow the money' theory. If people were doing this, you find out who is earning money from doing the abuse, and you jail them. Same with those who are funding it. People who download music for free on pirating sites aren't supporting the music industry. So I don't see how people who simply receive the data (or even send it free) are supporting it. Flooding the 'market' with free information saturates it to the point where people would not want to pay money for it. Or if they did, the amount they'd want to pay would be so low that it would decrease incentive for people to offend for purely monetary reasons. People who would offend for non-monetary reasons would do so anyway, and legalizing the material would aid in tracking down the distribution network to patient 0.