10 ms·
How Not to Buy a SSD
- senectus1 1y agoHad the same issue with a Crucial drive from amazon. looked just like the real thing but for some small discrepancies. Performed like an absolute dog and the SMART data was waaaay off. amazon just refunded me the whole amount and I pulled it apart to see what was inside: https://imgur.com/a/NUSuuEh https://imgur.com/a/NUSuuEh quite annoying, though also amusing.
- Cervisia 1y agoThere is nothing obviously suspicious with what's inside. The SATA form factor was designed for HDDs; solid-state drives usually are not much larger than a M.2 drive. These flash part numbers look like Intel. This is actually plausible; until 2018, Intel and Micron had a flash partnership. And while their Crucial brand has some good high-end drives, they are also willing to sell absolute bottom-of-the-barrel trash. What are these discrepancies, and what's off in the SMART values?
- senectus1 1y agoyeah sorry i dont have those deets anymore.. I remember they gave a lot less information than another one of the same make model and size.. I also remember the official FW refused to see the device. It was 2 years ago.. so thats all i have :-P
- cm2187 1y agoIn fact I opened a failed 3.84TB SAS SSD recently and it looked fairly similar.
- dlcarrier 1y agoRun f3fix on it, and you can use whatever portion of it is real to store low-value data, like Linux ISOs, that you could re-download if you lose, but are convenient to have locally.
- Ekaros 1y agoPretty much what is expected from lower capacity SSD. Flash memory does not take that much space. And if you are not at top of range you do not need to populate all grids.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- cm2187 1y agoebay is inundated with those fake retail SSDs. Designed to look like WD (https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/306437612011 https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/306437612011) or Samsung (https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/396854754678 https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/396854754678), but without the logo. Internally they contain maybe 100GB of flash, a controller that pretends to have 4TB, and they brick themselves when you write 1 byte more than the underlying capacity. Ebay doesn't police that. Haven't seen that for enterprise SSDs yet.
- FreeTrade 1y agoThose fakes are a real scourge. People lose their data in addition to their money. Very easy to spot fake listings but the platforms allow them to proliferate. I consider the platforms to be criminally culpable because of the wilful neglect.
- dotancohen 1y agoHow do you spot the fake listings?
- cm2187 1y agoThese ones are fairly obvious as though they adopt the same model name and colouring than the original, they do not show a Samsung or WD brand. I suspect they do that to avoid giving standing to these companies to sue them. If the distributor (ebay) doesn't care, and the buyers are individuals who will not sue, they act pretty much with impunity.
- FreeTrade 1y agoThe lowest hanging fruit are the ones with too good to be true prices.
- dotancohen 1y agoIs there some software to give these drives a test drive, before putting them in use?
- jchw 1y agoIn general I am afraid to buy storage devices except directly from the vendor at the moment. I've heard that there's also lots of fraudulent HDDs being sold with botched SMART data, even on Amazon, even marked as "New", even sold by Amazon. Scary proposition unless you're dying to test out your RAID array redundancy.
- doawoo 1y agoI wanted to upgrade my NAS with some 12TB drives and two of them in the box from Amazon had been powered on (according to the SMART data) for over a year! Thankfully got my money back.
- unsnap_biceps 1y agoI've moved over to almost exclusively buying from B&H. They generally have similar prices to other vendors and they manage their own inventory directly with manufacturers, so no concerns about fraudulent hardware.
- zargon 1y agoMe too, for the same reason. Also if you use their store credit card, they give a discount equal to the sales tax.
- brudgers 1y agoYep, and living in CA that’s almost 10%.
- qingcharles 1y ago10.25% here! I need their store card. Jeesh, I remember the days of no sales tax on other-state transactions. The golden days.
- Moru 1y agoI'm curious with what you mean with "Even sold by Amazon". The last few years I see nothing but reports of cheap fake products over Amazon. Years ago I ordered some T-Shirts to test and they were all fake versions that barely survived the first wash. Haven't ordered anything since then.
- crinkly 1y agoI usually buy second hand enterprise SSDs off eBay. No one bothers to fake them and they last longer than the consumer ones even if they are a few years old.
- CowOfKrakatoa 1y agoCould you share which models do you aim for?
- crinkly 1y agoUsually whatever half decent Samsung, Micron or Intel ones are available. I have a 10 year old Intel one in one of my machines and it's still 95% health.
- dlcarrier 1y agoI did get a used fake M.2 drive once. Likely the seller had bought a fake drive, used it for a while, then dissatisfied upgraded to something else. It possible the seller didn't know it was fake, but I doubt it.
- thisislife2 1y agoI hear this a lot online - buy used enterprise stuff online, it'll be cheaper and lasts long (at least you get your money's worth). But when you start to explore the online market for these used enterprise hardware, you find that nobody really sells it for cheap any more, at a price that makes sense to buy it. For example, if a new enterprise class SSD is $250, you may find a used one for $125. But then, brand new consumer SSDs of the same capacity are also available for $125 with warranty. At that point, it doesn't make any sense to buy used hardware, enterprise or otherwise, with no real guarantees of how usable it is. I feel the used hardware markets has also been cornered and monopolised by a few sellers, and you really have to hunt hard for a true bargain. (Maybe on Craigslist?).
- crinkly 1y agoI'm in Europe. It turns up cheap here. You do have to hunt for it but I bag 1.92TB disk for $70 a pop usually. I have 5 already.
- tomoiaga 1y agoeMag is full of fake SSDs. Don’t ever buy from sellers, only if sold by eMag directly or from a reputable seller that you know. And it’s not only SSDs. This has been going on for many years and yes, when you give in to promotions like 70-80% the price of an original you usually get a fake.
- stroebs 1y agoI’d also like to point out that those Kingston A400’s are notoriously terrible and had a firmware bug that caused the behaviour you describe if you don’t update it before it happens. I purchased 10 genuine new from a verified vendor and 6 had to be RMA’d within the first year.
- bakugo 1y agoYep, I have one of these too and the speeds on it are unbearable. It's one of the cheapest "brand name" SSDs you can get for a reason.
- ryankrage77 1y agoagreed, I don't think the drive is fake, they're just that bad. Only SSD I've ever had fail spontaneously on me (the one other SSD failiure was my fault for accidentally unplugging it during a firmware update).
- randpx 1y ago> _ actually a failed or RMAd genuine 128GB Kingston SSD who got its firmware modified by a third party_
- jonathan920 1y agoWeight ... the weight...... it's so obvious
- yonatan8070 1y agoI recently got a new 4TB Seagate drive from the biggest computer/electronics retailers here, it was shipped in the worst way I've ever seen a hard drive shipped. An anti-static bag, inside of one of those slightly padded envelopes you get when you order an Arduino from AliExpress. Naturally, it had a big dent on one of the corners, and it started clicking the moment I plugged it in. It was replaced with a working unit iunder warranty, but still a rather unfortunate buying experience.
- encrypted_bird 1y agoWhat was the name of the retailer?
- yonatan8070 1y agoKSP https://ksp.co.il/ https://ksp.co.il/
- nfriedly 1y agoWhen I click that I just get a giant error page from cloudfront saying that I have been blocked. Do they block all non-Israeli IPs or am I special?
- darkhorn 1y agoI am blocked too.
- yonatan8070 1y agoGood question, I haven't tried to browse from abroad, so I have no idea, but it could be the case since they only operate in Israel. I don't have a VPN to test, but I did ask ChatGPT [1] to try browsing it from its IP and it also failed. Afterwards I asked it to tell me what it sees from https://icanhazip.com https://icanhazip.com, and it returned `74.7.36.81`, which is in London according to [2] [1] https://chatgpt.com/share/e/68a9670d-d44c-8008-9a78-0d89662bcce2 https://chatgpt.com/share/e/68a9670d-d44c-8008-9a78-0d89662b... [2] https://whatismyipaddress.com/ip/74.7.36.81 https://whatismyipaddress.com/ip/74.7.36.81
- precompute 1y agoVery cool website! I like the theme picker and the extensive but easily navigable articles and tags.
- splitbrain 1y agoI recently bought two SSDs from Chinese brands I had never heard before. My thinking being that they were reasonably priced (a bit cheaper than name brands but not by much) and that probably no-one would fake no-name brands. Reviews seemed to be mostly genuine as well. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ so far they seem to work fine, we'll see.
- dotancohen 1y agoWhat do you store on them? What is your backup policy?
- splitbrain 1y agoI built a NAS off them. They're in a ZFS mirror and important stuff is backed up offsite.
- cm2187 1y agoI’d try to fill them to 30% to see if they survive before trusting them with my data.
- PeterStuer 1y agoAt the start of the eCommerce business, people flocked to Amazon because they had trouble trusting smaller retailers. These days it is the opposite. These brands went from trusted sellers to whitewashing marketplaces for the most dubious fraudulent drop-shippers by means of things like "sku-pooling" (you by design can not and never will know who shipped your specific item into the giant pool at Amazon). So now I shop at dedicated local outlets, and avoid the "marketplaces" like the plague.
- jmclnx 1y agoSame here, got burned from Amazon a HDD with broken pieces, luckily I got a refund. I vowed never to by tech items from Amazon again, you do not really know if you are getting new or some kind of refurbished item.
- dylan604 1y agoIf it's electronic, goes on me, or goes in me, it does not get purchased from Amazon
- Havoc 1y agoWorth pointing out that Amazon is mixed. Not everything is pooled. You can look at the "Dispatches from" field to tell whether its FBA or not
- YeahThisIsMe 1y agoThe one that only tells you whether it's shipped by Amazon (pooled) or directly from the seller?
- pavel_lishin 1y agoI'm not willing to do extra work for something that should just be standard.
- morninglight 1y agoAmazon's problems with fraudulent memory products were well documented in 2023 when GRC published their test results for a dozen such drives purchased from the site. In response, GRC developed a free program, called "ValiDrive", to scan and test drives for this growing problem. ValiDrive performs a quick, random-sequence spot-check across the drive's entire declared storage space. At every location it verifies the successful storage and retrieval of random (unspoofable) test data. https://www.grc.com/validrive.htm https://www.grc.com/validrive.htm The program has been extensively tested, is freely downloadable and comes from a well respected site with a long history in the security business. Steve Gibson announced this development in 2023 and it has been downloaded over 600,000 times. https://www.grc.com/freepopular.htm https://www.grc.com/freepopular.htm In addition to this effort, Steve has been creating an in-depth weekly podcast called "Security Now" for over 20 years. An archive of all 1039 podcasts and transcripts can be found online where they are freely downloadable. https://www.grc.com/securitynow.htm https://www.grc.com/securitynow.htm
- uyzstvqs 1y ago> The main problem now is that the product I bought now appears as a completely different product on that site, which is baffling, how can a product that’s been sold be “updated” with having a completely new photo, title, description, etc (now it’s basically a car Bluetooth adapter for 5 euros), which makes me unable to start the return process. It's to buy fake reviews. They "sell" something very cheap so fake reviewers can buy it and write a positive review. Once done, they change the page back to the actual scam. By the way, you should contact Kingston and notify them that you have a fraudulent drive. Chances are they'll exchange it for a new drive so they can investigate it.
- bullen 1y agoThe best SSD purchases of my life was the last Intel X-25E (64GB 45nm SLC with 100.000 writes per bit from 2011) I found on ebay ~2021. I ordered one first expecting it to be used or fake, but the packaging looked good (original and untampered) and the Intel disk software said it had only factory number of read/writes so I went all in and bought all the disks they had... 30x at $100 instead of the original $1.000 price tag. Still $3.000 sounds like an aweful lot when it's only 64GB disks, but I know how it feels when your OS drive corrupts and that's not something I want to keep experiencing over and over every 5 (if you are lucky) years. Now with a few (24/7 operation) years under their belt I can confidently say this was exactly "How to buy a SSD".
- justsomehnguy 1y ago> I can confidently say this was exactly "How to buy a SSD". More like "How to spend $3k and think you did something". For this amount what you spent you could get any, literally any SSD, use only 64Gb and be fine for decades. Or use more than 64Gb and be fine for... decades anyway. You literally could buy a server class mixed workload SATA drive with a DWPD of 4. https://www.solidigm.com/products/data-center/d3/s4620.html https://www.solidigm.com/products/data-center/d3/s4620.html And quite amusingly, any modern SATA SSD runs at the top of SATA3/SATA600 specs, with ~500MB/s for read and write: Sequential Bandwidth - 100% Read (up to): 550 MB/s Sequential Bandwidth - 100% Write (up to): 500 MB/s Random Read (100% Span): 85000 IOPS Random Write (100% Span): 48000 IOPS While Intel® X25-E Extreme SATA Solid-State Drive is SATA2/SATA300 and runs at 250MB/s at reading: Sustained sequential read: up to 250 MB/s Sustained sequential write: up to 170 MB/s Random 4 KB reads: >35,000 IOPS Random 4 KB writes: >3,300 IOPS https://download.intel.com/newsroom/kits/ssd/pdfs/Extreme-SATA-SSD-ProductBrief.pdf https://download.intel.com/newsroom/kits/ssd/pdfs/Extreme-SA...
- bullen 1y agoYou would think that, but I also have Samsungs industrial 3.5TB drives and they are flaky at best. Eternal growth does not exist, SSDs peaked in 2011 for durability without complexity. Just like DDR3 has the lowest CAS latency with ok bandwidth and longevity. DDR4 actually breaks after 10 years. DDR2 probably lasts more than 100 years. Think about that, any device manufactured in the coming 50 years will be outlived by 32-bit Raspberry 2! You just need a bunch of older SD cards and distributed storage so that you don't loose data.
- gnyman 1y agoTom's had a good article on this problem recently. https://www.tomshardware.com/pc-components/hdds/seagate-spins-up-a-raid-on-a-counterfeit-hard-drive-workshop-authorities-read-criminals-writes-while-they-spill-the-beans https://www.tomshardware.com/pc-components/hdds/seagate-spin... (the title is also ~p~fun)
- tux 1y agoThis also happens a lot on AliExpress most storage devices are fake. Some 64gb flash drives, sd cards or 320gb 2.5 mobile hdds are okay. But you should run f3 test on any new drive you buy.
- morninglight 1y agoValidrive - Free from Gibson Research Quickly spot-check any USB mass storage drive for fraudulent deliberately missing storage. https://www.grc.com/validrive.htm https://www.grc.com/validrive.htm
- BlueTemplar 1y agoI can't believe mixing a store and a marketplace on the same website still isn't illegal. Pick a lane !
- runjake 1y agoI've bought two counterfeit drives on Amazon -- one in 2024, and one in 2025. One sold by Amazon. Another I thought I was buying from Amazon directly but came from a seller. They looked completely, COMPLETELY legit. Enough that I initially doubted OEM support when the drives failed and I contacted them and they pointed out my drive's serial number doesn't even match the legit's format. They weren't even relabeled from a lower tier model. The saving grace is that I have Prime, so getting refunds was relatively easy after a couple quick back and forths.
- Sayrus 1y agoWhat's crazy to me is that a small retailer selling counterfeit goods would be sued hard if not investigated for fraud. But Amazon can keep doing it without worries.
- lazide 1y agoThey help the sellers do crazy shell games to avoid consequences (also to game reviews!). It’s quite impressive.
- Havoc 1y agoNot just fakes that but I'm also finding consumer ones seem to die a lot... I ended up building a NAS from 2nd hand enterprise SSD plus optanes. Cheap, fast & resilient. Normally not so keen on 2nd hand storage, but the combination of enterprise (tons of endurance) plus full mirrored is an acceptable risk to me. And (also mirrored) optanes for metadata and small files means everything feels super snappy
- npn 1y agoI have bought like 20+ used enterprise ssds from taobao (for my various PCs). Only a single one dies because I forgot to add the heat-sink. I think the most important thing is how trustworthy the seller is.