6 ms·
Intel Foundry demonstrates first Arm-based chip on 18a node
- dlojudice 1y agoVery unlikely to happen but Intel could release an Arm chip with native x86 translation. Arm and AMD IP would be needed but this would be the best chip for Windows
- mort96 1y agoI don't understand what the difference is between "an ARM chip with native x86 translation" and a dual-ISA x86 and ARM chip. And I don't understand why you'd want a dual-ISA x86 and ARM rather than just an x86 chip. You wouldn't get whatever CPU front-end simplicity advantages there are from ARM, since your front-end would get significantly more complex and consume significantly more transistors than with a normal x86 chip. And I don't think there's a market of people who want ARM for compatibility reason; any Windows software which supports ARM also supports x86. What they could do is to release an ARM chip with a slightly extended ISA to add the select features which are difficult to emulate in software, such as loads and stores with the memory ordering guarantees x86 provides but ARM doesn't. Apple does this AFAIK, and it's one part of why Rosetta 2 is so good. But any ARM CPU maker could do this.
- LoganDark 1y ago> I don't understand what the difference is between "an ARM chip with native x86 translation" and a dual-ISA x86 and ARM chip. Look at Apple's Rosetta 2 for an example. M-series Apple Silicon has special undocumented modes that mirror x86 architectural quirks that don't usually exist in ARM, in order to support AOT-translated machine code. The chip doesn't support x86 instructions, but it has the amenities to support x86 code. That could be what "native x86 translation" meant?
- cromka 1y agoAnd why wouldn’t Intel be capable of doing the same?
- LoganDark 1y agoI never said that?
- mort96 1y agoThat's what I suggested in my comment's last paragraph. I don't think that counts as "an ARM chip with native x86 translation", but really the only person who can say whether that's what dlojudice meant is dlojudice.
- astrange 1y agoFujitsu and Nvidia also implement (at least) TSO. https://threedots.ovh/blog/2021/02/cpus-with-sequential-consistency/ https://threedots.ovh/blog/2021/02/cpus-with-sequential-cons...
- murderfs 1y agoDenver does it because it was supposed to be an x86 CPU, but they couldn't get an agreement with Intel for patent licensing, so they pivoted into being the first available aarch64 CPU since decode was happening entirely in software.
- monocasa 1y agoWell, it has a simple hardware decoder for what would normally be the first stage of the jit.
- bee_rider 1y agoI wonder if ARM instructions could be translated to Intel’s uOps. Then everything except that translation could be shared. And, since programs consist entirely of one type of instruction for the most part, we could imagine that the chip should be able to stick to just doing one type of translation for the duration of a program run, rather than having to figure it out for each instruction. I’m not saying I want this, but it might be surprisingly not totally impractical.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- monocasa 1y agoA chunk of what you'd want (x86 alu flag generation) seems to be an extension that is incompatible with most of the arm architectural licenses which don't allow for custom extensions to user visible space. Apple is special here for reasons that probably aren't replicable.
- dlojudice 1y agoI think the core question is whether hardware-accelerated translation could be meaningfully faster than software like Rosetta 2/Prism while avoiding the full dual-ISA complexity you're describing. Rather than literally implementing both instruction sets, it might be more like an ARM chip with specialized translation units and the extended ISA features you mentioned (memory ordering, etc.). Intel's unique position with x86 IP could make this feasible where others can't, but whether the engineering effort is worth it for what might be a short-term market advantage is debatable.
- threatripper 1y agoIf we assume that intel gets successful with 18A with their x86 processors, would they even have the money to finance the node after that? And the node after that which gets exponentially more expensive? In the past x86 raked in enough money to burn a lot of it on new fab tech but non-x86 has grown immensely and floods TSMC with money. The problem for intel is that their fab tech was fitted to their processor architecture and vice versa. It made sense in the past but in the future it might not. For the processor business it may be better to use TSMC for production. For the fab it may be necessary to manufacture for many customers and take a premium for being based in a country in need. So, a split-up may be inevitable and this fabbing a competitive ARM chip surely helps in attracting more customers. Customers who may pay a premium for political and security reasons.
- blackoil 1y agoApple, Nvidia and US govt can provide the required funds if they have confidence in its ability to deliver. These companies will benefit from breaking current monopoly of TSMC.
- cromka 1y agoAmazon and Google probably as well?
- zimpenfish 1y ago> Apple, Nvidia and US govt can provide the required funds if they have confidence in its ability to deliver. Given Apple's history with Intel's ability to deliver, I'm guessing the confidence there isn't high.
- walterbell 1y agoAre you referring to 5G radio modems or another chip?
- indemnity 1y agoProbably Intel’s fumble when Apple asked them for better performance per watt for the laptop CPUs and whether they wanted the iPhone CPU business back in 2006.
- testdelacc1 1y agoAssuming they’re telling the truth, they’ve successfully built one chip from that fab. That’s good, but it doesn’t mean the fab is capable of manufacturing at scale while turning a profit. They need an external customer for the fab so they can iterate and work out the issues. It’s anyone’s guess if someone trusts intel to manufacture on their behalf instead of sticking with an established player. They’re stuck in a chicken and egg situation - can’t reach high yields without a customer, but a customer only wants to sign up if the yields and future deliveries are guaranteed. Intels only hope might be that someone, not naming names, coerces an established company to sign up.
- ExoticPearTree 1y ago> They need an external customer for the fab so they can iterate and work out the issues. I guess you mean Intel to iterate using its own money to get the customer's chip right, no?
- baq 1y agoThat's too pessimistic. In general, customers don't want to be dealing with a monopolist and foundry customers are no different. It's in everyone's interest to solve the unproven process problem, so if Intel has evidence that the process isn't bust, customers will find a product which can be used as a pipe cleaner for mutual benefit.
- YetAnotherNick 1y agoSpecially companies like Nvidia for which the gross profit margin is so high their risk of losing TSMC is higher than risk of losing money.
- nxobject 1y agoApple is similarly paranoid about single-sourcing -- off the top of my head I'm not sure whether their top-end M-class chips are currently fabbed by both TSMC and Samsung, or just TSMC>
- nxobject 1y agoRandom question: where did the ARM core design come from?
- unwind 1y agoIntel are believed to hold an Arm architectural license [1] as far as I know, they have made Arm-based things in the past. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ARM_architecture_family#Architectural_licence https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ARM_architecture_family#Archit...
- stephen_g 1y agoIf they didn’t have one already they would have presumably acquired one when they bought Altera - they had SoC FPGAs that have ARM cores hooked up to an FPGA fabric. They have since spun off Altera but I imagine they’d still have a license.
- monocasa 1y agoI'm not sure Altera would have had an architectural license. You don't need that to hook a hard core up to your fpga fabric.
- chasil 1y agoIntel's first exposure was the purchase of DEC StrongARM in the 90s, although that particular product line was sold to Marvel.
- notherhack 1y agoNit: Marvel makes comics. Marvell Technologies (two l's) makes chips with ARM CPUs in them, mostly for datacenter gear.
- robotnikman 1y agoI remember one of my first PC builds had a RAID card with a Marvell controller. I can still visualize the logo on the POST screen
- sylware 1y agoIt should be RISC-V... who is in charge at Intel?? Is this related to the rumors of softbank (ARM) money injection in Intel?
- FirmwareBurner 1y ago>It should be RISC-V... who is in charge at Intel?? Why should it be that? What are your arguments?
- sylware 1y agooh, you are new to HN, because you would not need to ask such question if you were reading HN in the last few years... You can start on risc-v wikipedia page and/or on the official risc-v web site.
- nullpoint420 1y agoI would say they’re smart to invest in ARM over RISC-V for the time being. It was hard enough to get the industry to support x86 and ARM64. I mean the Windows transition is still not fully complete, and they’ve been trying since Windows 8.
- sylware 1y agoI would say otherwise. The future, if sane, is certainly not with a PI locked ISA like ARM all over again (look at x86). Actually, it looks like a super bad move from intel.
- magicalhippo 1y agoFrom the article: Why is Intel manufacturing an Arm SoC as a reference platform? Probably because it's trying to attract external customers, and there's a whole lot more companies building Arm SoCs than there are firms pitching x86-64 processors. They're not trying to build the next best thing. They're trying to attract customers.
- rbanffy 1y ago
- 1oooqooq 1y agowhy only apple and Nvidia are left buying from foundries. is the market for cpu/gpu that bad? zero innovation and other players even in niche markets?
- sidewndr46 1y agoIntel pays for TSMC to produce their chips as well
- neogodless 1y agoHave you heard of AMD? You know... the company with about 25% of CPU market share (at least in PCs) these days? https://www.tomshardware.com/pc-components/cpus/amds-desktop-pc-market-share-hits-a-new-high-as-server-gains-slow-down-intel-now-only-outsells-amd-2-1-down-from-9-1-a-few-years-ago https://www.tomshardware.com/pc-components/cpus/amds-desktop... They have 17% overall according to this chart which includes Apple. https://www.accio.com/business/best-selling-cpus https://www.accio.com/business/best-selling-cpus Read up on this young startup, as I think they are going places!
- 1oooqooq 1y agoAMD won't buy from Intel. and I'm quoting the article.
- neogodless 1y agoBut the article talks about Apple and Nvidia buying from Intel. You said "foundries" (plural) and clearly TSMC has other customers.
- mrbluecoat 1y ago> Intel is effectively saying "Hey, we can make Arm chips!" Makes sense since they were once popular in the NUC space and Apple has shown high-end ARM has a market.
- cameron_b 1y agoI understand the part where Intel is trying to get external customers interested in the output of their fab by exhibiting an implementation of an ARM processor. In the past I understand that they did some custom implementation of Xeon cores for hyperscalers, but the meat and potatoes was the chip they designed. Do we take this to mean that the current leadership assess the value proposition -of Intel- to be in the /making/ of the chips, akin to TSMC, and not in the /designing/ of them, as in all past seasons at Intel? I suppose a key factor here is how far from reference this chip is. If they mean to innovate in ARM ISA territory, that's a development to ponder. But if this is a "we can also make those things" statement, I'm hearing bears in the woods.
- dagmx 1y agoThe fabs need external customers not just intel to be profitable. The custom designs for hyperscalars don’t count as external customers, they’re just part of Intels own production set. And since nobody but AMD or VIA can make x86, it has to be ARM or other ISAs instead. The article title is a bit clickbait since ARM is the eventuality of having external customers. The real key point is that they have made chips that aren’t their own at all.
- theFco 1y agoAs I understand it, Intel's strength was in manufacturing their own design in their exclusive (and most advanced) process. So the advantage was being vertically integrated. State of the art processes are too expensive these days. x86 CPUs alone cannot sustain them. Specially, when AMD builds their CPU also with state of the art processes. So by becoming a foundry, Intel may be able to have state of the art fabs and use it in their own designs of x86 CPUs, GPUs, etc.
- chasil 1y agoThe use of standard cells for a process somewhat opens it for outside users. The 80386 was the first use of standard cells for x86, which also introduced "automatic place and route" via a graduate student project named "Timberwolf." https://www.righto.com/2023/10/intel-386-die-versions.html https://www.righto.com/2023/10/intel-386-die-versions.html
- qwertytyyuu 1y agoToo bad they fired the ceo that made it happen
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 1y agoIt's going to be fun in two years when Intel is golden child again because TSMC has bomb damage and Taiwan is blockaded.
- dannyw 1y agoOr perhaps the E-Core team continues their strides and the design side becomes competitive again. AMD used to be uncompetitive after all; tides can change, and I think people are dooming too much. Intel still has a chance. Part of Intel’s problem is their ‘P Core’ team absolutely sucked for a decade.
- j_walter 1y agoNo one has doubted Intel's tech...its their manufacturing that is the problem. Anyone can make one successful chip from a wafer...making 80%+ yields is an entirely different problem to crack.
- HAL3000 1y ago> TSMC has bomb damage and Taiwan is blockaded For anyone familiar with Chinese culture, history, and mindset, and who views China through that lens rather than a Western one, the probability of this is lower than the probability of Intel’s collapsing entirely in the next two years. “Supreme excellence is to subdue the enemy without fighting.” “Victory without unsheathing the blade.” “If swords are clashing, strategy has already failed.”
- mrguyorama 1y agoChina is building rather innovative invasion barges. Their plan is to invade. Or at least, that's a plan they are spending significant resources on because it's in the top five plans.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- gjvc 1y agoSomeone moved Intel's cheese, and they didn't go after it until it was too late. Nobody is going to be switching their ARM-based chip provider from TSMC or anyone else (with whom they've only just built up enough trust) to even thinking of changing. Without a track record of delivery, intel is just there to be used in leverage with price negotiations with TSMC.
- dannyw 1y agoThere’s a lot of market for ARM chips. I can totally see the likes of Mediatek giving Intel an explore if the costs are right.
- hereme888 1y agoIs Intel's 18A actually 1.8 nm, or is this one of their usual marketing terms?
- j_walter 1y agoEverything for the past few generations of nodes have not been actual dimensions but more of an equivalency. TSMC nodes are no different.
- newam 1y agoProcess names are all marketing, at every company, not just intel. The process name has no relationship to the physical features of the transistors.
- Havoc 1y agoI really hope they manage to pull something out of the hat here. Own a bunch of AMD shares so cheering for them naturally...but we don't need a monopoly in CPU space.
- jonbiggums22 1y agoIt would be bad for x86 in general if Intel just disappears. They supply a ton of chips for businesses still and TSMC isn't going to replace that overnight.