6 ms·
Croatia just revised its digital nomad visa to last up to 3 years
- rafaelmn 1y agoAs a Croatian citizen working remotely - this would have been a much better deal pre-covid. Ever since we entered the eurozone and the EU funds started pouring in the prices skyrocketed (even compared to the rest of Europe, not just global inflation). Still worth looking into, but not a nobrainer like it was. Quality of life you used to be able to get for the mentioned 3.5k eur/month income was hard to get elsewhere in EU, but nowadays prices rose faster then the rest of Europe and quality of life stayed the same, a lot of other places in EU are competitive.
- johnny_reilly 1y agoI've just come back from my first trip to Croatia, and this rings true. It's a beautiful place but the prices are high! To quote one of the taxi drivers I chatted to "all the prices have gone up, but is okay; wages have stayed same" - deadpan
- rafaelmn 1y agoDepends on what you are looking at - but yes. Wages also rose considerably, below inflation, but still I think thats the same story as everywhere else. I think the main difference is that (in my opinion) Croatia used to be unbeatable for the price/quality of life ratio, nowadays it's probably slightly overpriced, but depends on what you value.
- willvarfar 1y agoIs the cost of living inflation relative to income fuelling the current shift to the right in Croatian politics? This was on the international news yesterday: https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cz60nyp3714o https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cz60nyp3714o
- Aeglaecia 1y agoif you want to travel down this conversational path you should probably choose a better example than people going to a rock concert of the country's biggest rock star , regarding the given example there are a few cans of worms to unpack that would result in massive deviation from the question at hand
- rafaelmn 1y agoNot really - there is no right shift, Croatia is very catholic and right leaning since the civil war. But at the same time the I would say it's mostly performative and not really that extreme as painted in the article.
- silisili 1y agoIn fairness, you could make the same glum joke in most if not all of the developed world over the last 5 years.
- hopelite 1y agoIt is something that is not well understood about the Euro, it is a deal with the devil, with all the hallmarks of looking like a wonderful idea where wishes and imagination blind one to the details and the tricks one opens oneself up to. It immensely benefits the ruling class and the upper class, and even foreigners at the expense of the working and middle class and the indigenous. It was also that way for the Germans who are accused of having benefited at the expense of others, when that was really more an effect of national scale, not all Germans individually. The Euro has had an odd distorting and perverting effect all across Europe; but it has always generally been excellent for the ruling and upper class that have gained access to an overflowing trough of other people’s money at the EU. The Euro has been a kind of wealth transfer mechanism to the ruling, upper, and even foreign classes, just as it has been a tool to restore the aristocracy just as it had in the USA; the aristocracy gets the money, the people get the inflation and debt that fuels the fraud. We shall see if it all goes off the rails and the people establish legitimate democratic rule, or if the authoritarian aristocracy can fully entrench itself again.
- yread 1y agoFWIW Warsaw or Prague also got ridiculously expensive (esp. housing) without a Euro
- FirmwareBurner 1y agoYou ain't seen nothing yet. Wait till they join the Euro. Housing is gonna get even more expensive. But hey at least imported knickknacks are gonna get cheaper.
- brna-2 1y agoStill not to bad, don't scare people off. Here are some comparisons of cost of living - to Vienna, but you can choose what to compare. For example living in Split is cca 26% cheaper than Vienna. https://www.numbeo.com/cost-of-living/compare_cities.jsp?country1=Croatia&country2=Austria&city1=Pula&city2=Vienna https://www.numbeo.com/cost-of-living/compare_cities.jsp?cou... https://www.numbeo.com/cost-of-living/compare_cities.jsp?country1=Croatia&country2=Austria&city1=Zagreb&city2=Vienna https://www.numbeo.com/cost-of-living/compare_cities.jsp?cou... https://www.numbeo.com/cost-of-living/compare_cities.jsp?country1=Croatia&country2=Austria&city1=Split&city2=Vienna https://www.numbeo.com/cost-of-living/compare_cities.jsp?cou...
- closewith 1y agoAnd much cheaper in real terms, as the Croatian digital nomad residence permit provides an exemption from income tax on earned income.
- techcode 1y agoThere are other tax exemptions in Croatia that might still make it worth it - especially in FIRE setting. While say The Netherlands taxes your investments such as Stocks/ETFs (not their earnings/capital-gain/etc but literally just owning stocks/ETFs/etc) - in Croatia those are not taxed after you've held them for 1 or 2 years (don't recall if 1 or 2). Similar (owning stocks/ETFs not taxed) in Serbia, Malta, Cyprus ...etc.
- rafaelmn 1y agoYeah but you can't compare living in Vienna and Split - Vienna is a top tier city - huge regional capital with so many things going on and offerings. Split is a C tier city dead outside of tourist season, like the rest of the coast. 26% is kind of ridiculous when you compare the standard of living. Again depends on what you value, some might find it worth, just saying the equation was much more in Croatia favor 5 years ago.
- keiferski 1y ago
- pjmlp 1y agoAs Portuguese, I can relate as I have seen what the euro has brought, positive and negatively as well. For example 1 euro = 200.482 escudos, and when euro came we had stuff happening like 50 cents escudos becoming 50 cents in euro, I bet something similar has happened in Croatia. Those 50 cents across coins are naturally not the same value, especially when the income wasn't suffered the same valuation across monetary systems.
- rafaelmn 1y agoYes I believe Portugals and Croatias stories are very similar, your capital being a coastal city probably makes it even worse with regards to tourist inflation.
- pjmlp 1y agoUnfortunally tourist inflation, digital nomads, and foreign pensionists have driven house prices sky high, prevented the usual system of house renting for university students and people unable to buy houses, with crazy rents, as landlords rather profit from foreigners, thus that is how we end with a mostly right goverment, the far right having a large majority, with my parents and many others having fought the dictatorship for nothing.
- FirmwareBurner 1y agoZagreb isn't a coastal city.
- rafaelmn 1y agoBut Lisbon is, which is why Portugal situation is likely even worse (that was what I was trying to say). I can only imagine Zagreb prices if it was on the coast.
- raverbashing 1y agoThis happened even in Germany though the DM/E rate was 2 Marks = 1 Euro but some things magically went from 2 DM to 2 Euro
- cyrillite 1y agoThis appears to coincide with the rapid rise of my wealthier friends taking extended holidays in Croatia. It wasn’t the cool thing to do, now suddenly it’s a must-see place. I didn’t get the memo about that, apparently. I wonder if it’s having an impact or if it’s just a local phenomena that feels far larger to me
- techcode 1y agoNot sure it's just those EU funds. As Serbian/Dutch with wife from Croatia - I can definitely say that prices didn't rise only in Croatia. Basically same % rise in (non-EU) Serbia, and The Netherlands. Possibly elsewhere too - but NL/CRO/SRB is where were have family and spend enough time to really know.
- rafaelmn 1y agoCroatian price increases are topping the EU stats for years now and it accumulates, especially in real-estate. There are some comparable situations in EU, but overall I would say comparable countries like Italy, Spain, Greece did not have nearly as much price growth in the same period. For example - personal opinion disclaimer - if Spain had better tax scheme for small business (not really sure on the nomad status there, but I am more interested in long term) I would probably move because the coastal cities in Spain are much better for similar prices, I would rather live in Valencia than Split/Rijeka/Zadar/Dubrovnik/Pula.
- techcode 1y agoOur house in The Netherlands is now 3x more expensive than 13 years ago - from ~€200k to ~€600k. We got lucky to move to NL and then buy house just around the time when post 2008 crisis was at the lowest point. Some houses are only 2x more expensive than back then. Meanwhile apartments in Belgrade Serbia are now similar to price of apartments in Amsterdam/Amstelveen/etc from 10-15 years ago. From what I've heard from friends and family - more of the same across France, Germany ...etc.
- kristoff200512 1y agoI believe digital nomadism is the trend of the future, and AI is making solo businesses increasingly complete and efficient.
- closewith 1y agoNo, it's a transitionary step before Governments introduce more comprehensive taxation regimes. You already can't work even a single day in many developed countries with becoming liable to the local taxation regime and as desirable locations developer, they inevitably have to restrict access due to overcrowding and taxation (along with visa availability) is the key lever available. What AI is doing very effectively is allowing tax authorities to identify digital nomads illegally working in jurisdictions without registering for tax.
- oytis 1y agoI think the purpose of digital nomad visa is exactly to get their taxes. As opposed to say Germany where it's close to impossible to work for a overseas company even as a citizen, not to say get a visa for that
- closewith 1y agoNo, that's not the case for the most part. For example, the Croatian digital nomad residence permit that this article is about provides an exemption to income tax for earned income while working for a foreign company and living in Croatia. This means that most digital nomads can work tax-free in Croatia. This contrasts with, for example, Ireland, where not only does a digital nomad's income become subject to local tax on day 1, so does their company (if they are the beneficial owner). Croatia's approach is excellent if you want many wealthy (compared to local standards) people to bring an influx of hard currency into your economy, at the cost of inflation. Eventually the benefits outweigh the costs and the government begins to subject digital nomads to local taxation and stricter visa rules.
- oytis 1y ago
- bluecalm 1y agoCroatia is beautiful, well connected and has low taxes. Capital gain tax is 12%. It's a very important consideration although some other countries in the area are even more attractive tax wise but then there are trade-offs (more remote, worse infrastructure, not as beautiful).
- nixass 1y agoCGT is applicable only if held <2 years, otherwise no CGT
- bluecalm 1y agoWow, that's fantastic. I may consider Croatia as the base for retirement in the future if that stays. Nothing annoys me more about EU countries' tax system as giving all the tax breaks to real estate investors and punishing stock investors with heavy CGT.
- techcode 1y agoFor FIRE - maybe check out Serbia (IIRC >1 year no CGT) as well as Greece, Malta, Cyprus ...etc.
- egorfine 1y agoCroatia is beautiful. Yesterday I have returned to Warsaw from a week-long vacation in Croatia. There is this one thing I can't seem to grasp: Croatia and Poland have almost the same GDP per capita, but why are the prices in Croatia roughly 2x compared to Poland while the infrastructure and quality of life are visibly way lower than those in Poland? What is the proposition? Like, just the sea and the weather?
- techcode 1y agoCan you share more specific place(s) in Poland and Croatia for your "infrastructure and quality of life" being 2x different? And what infra and what are you looking at for QOL? And the weather - well personally I haven't been in Croatia around New Years. But last few weeks (it's same every year) it was 37-40°C - too hot. While in May you still need to turn on heating (or light a fire). And from the rest of family that grew up in the Croatian coast (Dalmatia) - winters sound pretty crappy due to winds. Also because it's mostly still above 0°C snow is rare. My wife said that as kid, they had to drive her to other part of then Yugoslavia for her to finally see real snow.
- egorfine 1y agoIn Poland - basically almost every large city, from Warsaw to Torun. In Croatia I have been in Split and in Dubrovnik. I'm looking at things like pavement construction, overnight leftover trash on the streets, quality of business signs, cleanliness of buildings, bike parking spots and infrastructure on them, % of restaurants trying to scam you, etc. That sort of things.
- techcode 1y agoIMHO it's not really good comparison? What would be ultra touristic places in Poland? Both Split and Dubrovnik are ultra touristic, and say Amsterdam is similar. Also the part of really old streets/buildings that are UNESCO and such protected and not supposed to be renovated. And to me - Krakow seemed very similar to Belgrade (Serbia) and Zagreb (Croatia).
- betaby 1y agoThat ... doesn't matter? Croatia approves under 1k nomad visas per year. I don't know why people are concerned that nomads will anyhow affect housing supply given that today Croatia has 500k fewer people than it had 20 years ago.
- kelipso 1y agoThe stat you should compare the 1k nomad visas to is the number of houses on sale or rent each year in the locations that the nomads go to. The 500k people, it should also be restricted to the locations that the nomads go to. The nomads aren’t going to buy or rent some abandoned farmland in rural Croatia.
- ETH_start 1y ago[dead]
- toomuchtodo 1y agohttps://mup.gov.hr/aliens-281621/stay-and-work/temporary-stay-of-digital-nomads/286833 https://mup.gov.hr/aliens-281621/stay-and-work/temporary-sta...