7 ms·
I think that what contributes to this view is that new construction always seems to be at the high end of the market. This makes sense, it doesn't cost the buil
by SoftTalker 1y ago
I think that what contributes to this view is that new construction always seems to be at the high end of the market. This makes sense, it doesn't cost the builder a lot more to build a $500k house than to build a $250k house, and building two $250k houses will take twice the time and close to twice the costs. So builders/developers are going to build what is most profitable, which is the most expensive houses that they think they can sell in the local market.
What is less obvious is that this still increase housing supply. It's not new affordable housing, but the people moving in to the new expensive houses are leaving their old houses, and the people who buy those are leaving their old houses, so eventually the price drops happen on the older, smaller homes at the bottom end of the market.
- entropicdrifter 1y agoThis makes sense in a world where the market adjusts rationally and there's an unbroken chain of people from different levels of wealth who can afford to buy houses. Unfortunately in the US right now, that is not reflective of the present scenario due to the immense generational wealth gap and housing bubble.
- pwarner 1y agoBut that's a supply problem. Create the supply, prices will drop and that bubble and generational wealth challenge begins to heal.
- entropicdrifter 1y agoThe US has 28 empty homes for every homeless person. It's a market manipulation problem that's not going to go away for as long as we maintain the perverse incentive of using real estate as an investment vehicle. Japan has never had this problem and likely never will because housing depreciates in value there like cars. A 30-year-old house is often worthless or near-worthless in Japan.
- morkalork 1y agoAnd in Canada there is a huge amount of backlogged demand. There are areas where rental listings for roommates show two beds to a room and 10 people crammed into a house. Unwinding that is going to take a long time.
- TulliusCicero 1y agoAlso, they can only address the luxury market so much. If you're only legally or practically able to build and sell so many cars, then you're gonna focus on Lexuses more than Toyotas. But if you can build and sell as much as you want, that's when you start seriously addressing the mainstream market.
- SoftTalker 1y agoYes, but you'll only do this once the luxury market is saturated. As long as you can sell more luxury homes that is what you are going to build.
- TulliusCicero 1y agoRight, but there's only so many people in that market. The reason it never seems to be saturated is that building more homes in expensive areas is typically very restricted and difficult and time consuming to do, mostly due to local/state regulations.
- jeremyjh 1y agoThen it isn’t saturated.
- TulliusCicero 1y agoRight. The real problem is regulations that prevent saturation.
- dwaltrip 1y agoHousing regulation should be dramatically improved and streamlined, but we also have a deep cultural problem of nimbyism. Humanity needs to learn how the cooperate much more effectively, or we are going to fuck everything up.
- 1y ago
- loeg 1y ago> the people moving in to the new expensive houses are leaving their old houses, and the people who buy those are leaving their old houses, so eventually the price drops happen on the older, smaller homes at the bottom end of the market. This effect, in this context, is called "filtering."
- greenie_beans 1y agoso you are suggesting that one house is better than two to alleviate supply? this is exactly why market incentives isn't the cure. we would have more housing if we built more housing. if we built double the housing, then we would be in an even better place. this logic makes zero sense to me.
- SoftTalker 1y agoIt's better than none, which is what you'll get if you start mandating what developers can build. They'll just go somewhere else where they can make more money.
- greenie_beans 1y agolove this debate! the market built a ton of houses leading up the the GFC until the market decided it was too risky: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/HOUST https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/HOUST this was in a similar regulatory environment we face today. so if you take the market logic, then the market caused the problem as much as regulations.
- tempestn 1y agoAs your sibling comment says, there is only so much market for luxury housing. If the land, permitting, etc. exists to build two houses, then two will get built. And if there's only sufficient demand for one of them to be high-end, then only one will be. (In aggregate on larger scales of course, not literally any given two houses.) It's not necessary to force a given developer to build two houses instead of one; if the economics make sense, and are predictable, the developers will come.
- greenie_beans 1y agothe market logic just proves my point. logging off now bc i'm about to get flamed by YIMBYs and georgists! you can go read my comment history for my argument: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44555384 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44555384
- 1y ago
- starkparker 1y ago> It's not new affordable housing, but the people moving in to the new expensive houses are leaving their old houses, and the people who buy those are leaving their old houses, so eventually the price drops happen on the older, smaller homes at the bottom end of the market. I keep seeing this, but if the housing being vacated is in a different, less-desirable market, it's a bit tree-falling-in-the-woods for locals. If a $450,000 house in a Chicago suburb is freed up by its owners moving to a $700,000 condo in Seattle, the people who can't afford a house in Seattle don't see the benefit of the condo building and aren't going to buy the house in Chicago, and the people who can't afford a house in Chicago don't recognize the Seattle development as the cause of the house hitting the market.
- whall6 1y agoThere doesn’t need to be a connection between the purchase and sale events. Any marginal unit of inventory added to a market will place downward pressure on the price of that inventory (i.e., make it more affordable). The reverse is true for a marginal bid for inventory. The effect is so minimal when you zoom into a single sale of one home and purchase of one condo, but in aggregate this causes real noticeable price movement.
- ASinclair 1y ago> If a $450,000 house in a Chicago suburb is freed up by its owners moving to a $700,000 condo in Seattle, the people who can't afford a house in Seattle don't see the benefit of the condo building and aren't going to buy the house in Chicago Is the existence of the $700,000 condo the limiting factor for those people moving? If it isn't built would they instead bid up an existing unit in Seattle and put it more out of reach of existing Seattle residents?
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- mediaman 1y agoThis analogy seems confused. If someone in Chicago moves to Seattle, then our policy options are (1) no new condo in Seattle or (2) new condo in Seattle. Under policy 1, the new buyer from Chicago must outbid locals for the fixed housing supply; they will wind up buying older housing stock, which otherwise would have gone to existing local residents. Prices go up. With policy 2, the new entrant buys the new condo and does not compete for pre-existing housing stock. In this scenario, whatever house is freed up in Chicago is irrelevant to the housing stock in Seattle. I'm not sure why you included it. The entire question can be contained by the assumption that "there is someone new coming to Seattle" and whether it would be better to have a new condo unit to sell to them or have them compete for existing fixed stock. The whole bit about the Chicago housing market is a distractor, because it stays the same under either policy.
- DevX101 1y agoIncreasing the supply of the high end market often occurs while simultaneously reducing the supply of the low end market. This happens when landlords renovate their buildings. So it's very possible that adding supply can limit price inflation on the high end, while increasing costs on the low end.
- bondarchuk 1y agoI wouldn't count renovation as "adding supply", though.
- supertrope 1y agoYes that’s gentrification of a neighborhood. Neighborhoods evolve over time. Displacement is bad but measures to fight it can be even worse. If no new construction can be approved over it being a gentrification signal, rents will zoom up even more. In the most competitive metro areas there are no cheap rent areas left within an hour commute.
- lcnPylGDnU4H9OF 1y ago> people who buy those are leaving their old houses I do not believe this is accurate, at least not in the last ~10 years or so. The houses are purchased by hedge funds and other smaller investors.
- SoftTalker 1y agoOnly because they are scarce enough to be worth doing that. With greater supply, there comes a point where you can make better investments than buying up empty houses. And so they will stop buying them.
- lcnPylGDnU4H9OF 1y agoI don't see how that really matters. If you keep making homes and investment buyers keep buying them then the price will keep going up and regular folk will still be priced out. If you make so many homes via this strategy that institutional buyers are no longer interested, I think it's because the homes have somehow become genuinely worthless, at least to the investors. I don't see how to do that without legislation that makes the investment unattractive (unprofitable) to them. Policies such as rent control, "you can't buy that house because you're not living in it", etc., are the proper solution.
- BobaFloutist 1y agoInvestors have finite capital, and it's easier to corner a tight, pinched market than a large market with lots of liquidity. You don't see PE making huge investments in gas stations, because you can always easily just go to another gas station, and there's way too many of them to easily corner the market. We could pretty easily make housing similarly unattractive.
- epistasis 1y agoWhy would the price keep going up if more and more houses are being added? Prices go up when there is a shortage. Everywhere that has been building adequate housing sees prices falling.
- 1y ago
- stego-tech 1y ago> It's not new affordable housing, but the people moving in to the new expensive houses are leaving their old houses, and the people who buy those are leaving their old houses, so eventually the price drops happen on the older, smaller homes at the bottom end of the market. As I commented elsewhere, that’s the paper math version that doesn’t resemble reality for those of us living in it. Buyers of new luxury stock are increasingly just leveraging prior housing equity to fund the new purchase and renting out old stock at “market rates”, which doesn’t actually increase supply or decrease pricing. Laws have made short-term rentals and long-term landlording immensely profitable for those who got into the game early, especially in major metros that lack regulations on rent control or have preferential property taxation schemes. When actually affordable housing is built (i.e. starter homes), they’re frequently snapped up by PE firms and investors rather than being sold to first-time homebuyers. The “property cycle” you mention does not exist anymore, and that’s by design. It’s why meaningful legislation and taxation policies are needed to deter landlording of SFH properties and prevent exploitation of renters by implementing rent controls.
- bryanlarsen 1y agohow does renting out old stock not increase supply? Renting and buying are relatively fungible. People buy fewer houses when renting is cheaper.
- WarOnPrivacy 1y ago> how does renting out old stock not increase supply? Raw and overall housing numbers can be misleading by their nature. That is, they can be technically true while being false for many/most people. Declaration: Housing supply is increased! Actuality: Increase is only in homes for >$100k income earners. The declaration is true for >$100k. It is not true for most <$100k earners. (of those <$100k earners) There could be a very slight increase in supply for $80k. It'll be less, if any, for $60k earners. There is no increase in supply for <$40k (25% of US households). Past that, there is a challenge in tossing around $250k and $500k houses as examples of anything. Those numbers are 4x & 8x over what typical-wage households can afford. Generally, there is no affordable, reasonable housing for typical income earners.
- dkarl 1y agoNIMBYs actively target this misconception. "New housing is luxury housing." > eventually the price drops happen on the older, smaller homes at the bottom end of the market I'd be interested in how long "eventually" takes for single-family homes. I think for rental units it happens very quickly.
- bluGill 1y agodepends, it takes decades and often people remodle their old houst thus bringing up the value.
- majormajor 1y agoThe land value gives a strong floor. And nearby development increases the land value even if it makes the state of the house itself look worse and worse.
- Ekaros 1y agoIn such market fixation on inefficient single-family homes is very weird. In desirable and growing markets those might not ever go down. Population in such market should just accept more dense configurations.
- bilsbie 1y agoI think we should start using hermit crab analogies. Everyone understands that you need more of the biggest shells to free up shells for the little guys.
- seanmcdirmid 1y ago> What is less obvious is that this still increase housing supply. It's not new affordable housing, but the people moving in to the new expensive houses are leaving their old houses, and the people who buy those are leaving their old houses, so eventually the price drops happen on the older, smaller homes at the bottom end of the market. Two things to think about when making this argument: * Older housing could have been torn down to build new housing. So before, you had a rooming house with 10 or so low cost tenants, and now you have three town homes with three very rich families moving in. Life just became a lot harder for people in the lower end of the market. Gentrification of entire neighborhoods is an extreme example of this: a blighted neighborhood is great for cheap housing options, but then people start coming in and redeveloping it and...it is no longer blighted, the neighborhood is better, and the cheap housing is gone replaced by much more expensive housing. * Demand is induced by new supply. We accept this as a fact for highway construction, but it is somewhat also true for housing in a hot market where everyone wants to live. So building a bunch of new housing in Seattle could attract new resident, causing the population to grow, rather than adding supply to deal with fixed demand. Yes, adding housing in Buffalo isn't going to run into that, and yes, overall the situation becomes better for the country (or world if you are inducing demand from other countries), but locally you feel like you are going nowhere with the problem. A more extreme example of this is handing out housing to your unhoused population (you'll almost certainly wind up with more unhoused than when you started even though you've given some housing).
- wahern 1y ago> Demand is induced by new supply. We accept this as a fact for highway construction. Induced demand is only a thing with highways because use of the highways is free; there's no counterveiling cost pressure unless and until traffic jams start forming. By definition induced demand doesn't exist where the market can set prices for using newly created resources. Closer to your point (if we stretch really hard) would be something like lowering crime. If Seattle successfully lowers crime without, say, increasing taxes, then Seattle becomes a nicer place to live, and people can (and will) move there to enjoy lower crime without having to directly incur the cost of lowering that crime. One of the externalities of that "induced demand" would be an increase in housing prices. So obviously Seattleites who oppose residential development should just promote more crime. The fundamental issue here is that people don't like being subject to market forces and the insecurity that engenders, particularly when it comes to housing and labor. That's understandable. They do like market forces when they get to enjoy lower prices, though. But the feeling of insecurity is particularly acute when it comes to housing and the issue of new development. That's also understandable, notwithstanding that it's simply irrational and empirically disproven that NIMBYism makes for lower prices than the alternative of allowing market development. You get higher prices with NIMBYism than YIMBYism, period; though there's simply no guaranteeing that absolute prices will come down, especially for a city that permits development where others don't. That's a collective action/free-rider problem, where the positive externalities of good public policies of one community are captured in part by other, cheating groups.
- Dig1t 1y ago>and building two $250k houses will take twice the time and close to twice the costs Building densely is actually more profitable, there’s already incentive to build as densely as possible for developers. Adding an extra story and creating a duplex, triplex, etc doesn’t cost much more and means you can sell multiple more units. Building as tall as possible and getting more units into the same footprint is almost always more profitable than just building one single family house. The problem is that zoning limits what type of building is allowed to be built on a site. Who controls zoning? Existing homeowners that already live in the area, so of course they are going to make sure that new builds are low-density, as it impacts them less (parking, traffic) and keeps their home values high. Source: I tried to build dense housing myself and was stymied by zoning.
- PaulHoule 1y agoMy take on it as a small landlord (have two houses on my farm, one has two rental units) is: I don’t think a lot about the pricing of my rental units and I’m not quick to raise them but when some new development comes into town and puts up billboards with their eye-popping prices and runs ads in the paper and on web sites and on the radio I think “Gee…. I must be leaving money on the table because I could raise my rates 50% and it would still undercut what they’re advertising a lot” Of course the money they are spending on advertising indicates that their pricing is aspirational and they may very well next year be telling the city that they can’t afford their property taxes because they can’t fill the units and might be telling their lenders the same in a few years. In Ithaca we got “luxury housing for seniors” that was nuclear reactor late and they can’t fill https://ithacavoice.org/2025/03/library-place-to-sell-at-a-loss-to-rochester-firm/ https://ithacavoice.org/2025/03/library-place-to-sell-at-a-l... (Don’t seniors with money go to Florida?) A few market rate projects had an affordable component which has been part of a surge which has taken a bite out of our homeless colony but it is now like that talking heads song where they’re “burning down the house” https://ithacavoice.org/2025/08/inside-asteri/ https://ithacavoice.org/2025/08/inside-asteri/ My understanding is many “luxury” developments are shoddily built and not a good place to live https://www.nytimes.com/2022/04/15/realestate/condo-defects-new-development.html https://www.nytimes.com/2022/04/15/realestate/condo-defects-...
- m463 1y agoI think you might be right, and I think people who buy new care less about price.
- appreciatorBus 1y agoThere is also the recursive nature of a shortage 1. housing becomes a bit scarce for any reason, even a temporarily transient reason 2. prices go up 3. people point to high prices a reason new housing is bad, enact laws to limit it 4. housing becomes more scarce 5. goto 2
- supportengineer 1y agoIn other words, housing capacity is created and "trickles down" to the bottom. If there was such as thing as a $250k house within a few hours drive, I would buy all of them and just sit on them, maybe rent them out.
- crooked-v 1y agoWhat you're missing here is that housing is only a good investment because it's in such short supply. If plenty of $250K houses were available, they wouldn't be doubling in price every few years, and "sitting on them" and eating the maintenance costs would just lose money compared to other investments.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- amelius 1y agoWhat if a Chinese real estate investor buys US property just for the sake of it? Just one of many scenarios this doesn't take into account.
- WalterBright 1y agoWhy would he leave it vacant?
- glial 1y agoBecause the value always goes up and managing renters and repairs is a PITA.
- WalterBright 1y ago> value always goes up History shows us that there are many bear markets in housing. There's also Detroit. I sold my previous home in 2000. It recently sold for 4x what I sold it for. A great ROI, eh? If I'd invested in the S&P 500 in 2000, it went up 6.61x. And I didn't have to pay property taxes, insurance, real estate commissions, maintenance, repair vandalism, clean up after teen hookup parties, evict squatters, or any of my time.
- gottorf 1y ago> And I didn't have to pay property taxes, insurance, real estate commissions, maintenance, repair vandalism, clean up after teen hookup parties, evict squatters, or any of my time. And of course, had you let it sit empty the whole time, you still would have had to pay commissions, taxes, insurance, and maintenance (because an empty home goes bad very quickly). There are very few scenarios where the appreciation at the end would be big enough to leave you with a profit after all those expenses, especially considering financing and/or opportunity costs.
- Straw 1y agoIf you don't include rent, real estate has significantly underperformed equities as an investment: https://www.frbsf.org/wp-content/uploads/wp2017-25.pdf https://www.frbsf.org/wp-content/uploads/wp2017-25.pdf
- rayiner 1y agoSupply and demand requires thinking about equilibria and intersecting curves and is out of the reach of a largely innumerate population. Most Americans don’t even really have a strong grasp on millions versus billions versus trillions. Americans also think in terms of stories with actors, and supply and demand doesn’t have any obvious actors. “Prices are high because bad people are choosing to keep them high” is an easy narrative for people to understand. There’s an obvious villain, and the success simply requires the hero to defeat the villain. This leads to a funny meme: https://www.reddit.com/r/neoliberal/comments/13l1lmn/presenting_recent_findings_by_fucking_magnets/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=mweb3x&utm_name=mweb3xcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=share_button https://www.reddit.com/r/neoliberal/comments/13l1lmn/present...
- supertrope 1y agoPeople prefer a teleological explanation. It has the allure of a simplistic solution. Having a direct and complete solution out there is emotionally satisfying. Just like how subduing the villain saves the day, why not tax/ban landlords/immigrants/Wall Street/your favorite outgroup here? If there’s no simple solution available that’s not nearly as hopeful of a message. Politicians and marketers peddle simplistic “solutions” to a willing audience.
- jillesvangurp 1y agoNew construction is kept expensive mostly through complex rules that often exist to protect the interests of those doing the construction work, those owning existing houses and property, etc. It's a form of artificial scarcity. This scarcity is crucial to justifying real estate prices, propping up mortgages and the banks that provide them, etc. There's no technical reason why building some shelter that keeps the rain out and the heat/cold where it should be is not something that could not be done cheaply at large scale using affordable materials. People have been building shelter for tens of thousands of years and it's easier than ever with modern materials. It's not rocket science to keep people dry and comfortable. People routinely buy recreational vehicles that, because they have wheels, are not considered houses. So, suddenly there are much less rules and you can just produce those efficiently in factories. Except getting permission to park those and live in them is really hard to come by in many places. It's OK for recreational use. But not for living permanently. Which of course some people do anyway. But it's highly stigmatized. Recreational vehicles come out of factories. Houses are built artisanally at great cost. The only functional difference that matters is mobility and wheels. Why should people not be able to get a nice second hand RV for a few thousand dollars and park it in a nice spot and live there? Answer: it would immediately devalue the notion of owning brick and mortar.
- nine_k 1y agoDoesn't the price of land play a role? If the developer pays $100k for a parcel of land and builds a $500k house on it, they may have their margin on the $400k, but if they build a $250k house, it's only $150k, a more dramatic drop. The minimum lot size requirements don't help the situation either. It likely would be more efficient and profitable to build a townhouse, or even a mid-rise, and let more people live on the same parcel of land, but zoning restrictions often prevent that.
- ncruces 1y agoNot just land, but all the bureaucratic costs, licensing, etc. Developers will always build the most high margin house the market will bear. It still increases supply, though. And if there's no market for expensive houses, eventually they'll make cheaper houses. Also, the people on the market who can afford the expensive houses, would still outbid you for a shittier house.
- BrenBarn 1y agoMaybe, but for people currently living who need housing, all that is academic. It's another case of "the market can remain irrational longer than you can remain solvent".